Operative treatment of osteoporotic vertebral fractures seems to result in higher primary costs compared to conservative treatment. However it is still unclear whether the inpatient related follow-up costs don’t result in a different outcome. The aim of this analysis was a nationwide comparison of spine related inpatient treatments after balloon kyphoplasty versus conservative treatment of balloon kyphoplasty patients.
Data from the Austrian DRG-system, which includes all inpatients treated in Austria have been used to identify admission of the target population between 2002 and 2006. Because no unique patient identifier is available in the data set, a matching according to data of birth, gender and postal code was used. Outpatient visits are not included. From these data the number of admissions, the length of stay and the scores can be determined. Furthermore each admission was classified as spine related or not. To calculate the exact follow up times the data were matched against the Austrian death registry. If a patient has died this data was used to calculate the follow up time otherwise December 31st 2006 was used. The mean age of the conservative group was 75.49 and of the kyphoplasty group 71.16 years. The total follow up time was 324.55 years(mean +standard deviation 2.92+−1.40) for the conservative and 354.25 (2.53+−0.96) for the kyphoplasty group. The shorter mean follow up interval for the kyphoplasty group is due to the fact that in the years 2004 and 2005 more patients have been treated by kyphoplasty.
We demonstrate a long term superiority of balloon kyphoplasty compared to non-surgical treatment regarding inpatient treatments.
A recurrent fracture rate after vertebroplasty and balloon kyphoplasty is as high as 20%. Biomechanically, it has not been proven that refracture rate is due to the cement stiffness alone. This finite-element study investigated effects of cement-stiffness, bone-quality, cement-volume and height-restoration in treatment of vertebral compression fractures using balloon kyphoplasty. A finite-element model of the lumbar spine was generated from CT-scans. The model comprised of two functional spinal-units, consisting of L2-L4 vertebral bodies, intervertebral-discs, and spinal ligaments. Cement volumes modelled were in the order of 15% and 30% of total vertebral body (VB) volume. Spinal fracture was modelled as being reduced and height of VB was restored. Kyphoplasty was performed. Three different bone qualities were modelled: healthy, osteopenic, osteoporotic. A compressive load was applied to the proximal endplate of L2. An anterior shift of the centre-of-gravity of upper body was simulated by increasing the moment arm of the applied load. All results of the analysis were compared back to an intact spinal model of the same region under the same loading regime. All parameters affected the mechanical behaviour of the spine model, although changing the bone quality from normal to osteoporotic resulted in the least change. The cement stiffness was initially modelled with an elastic modulus between 0.5GPa and 2GPa. The results showed small differences relative to intact case in the lower modulus cement. A much higher cement stiffness of 8GPa resulted in larger changes in the stresses. The most significant parameter in this study was found to be the changed load path as a result of partial height restoration. This induced a moment in the construct and increased the stresses and strains in the anterior compartments of each vertebra as well as marked in the adjacent (upper and lower) vertebrae. The factor of safety calculation showed the centre of the L3 vertebra to be the most failure prone in all cases, with the osteoporotic bone models showing higher fracture tendencies. This study indicates that healthier bone has a better chance of survival. Cement properties with lower cement elastic moduli induce stresses/strains which are more similar to the intact model. The best way to reduce the likelihood of failure is to restore the vertebral height.
During the last decades numerous studies have reported the critical impact of physical activity on bone repair. While most studies have evaluated the tissue response to the local mechanical environment within the fracture gap, there is a lack of information on the systemic role of physical activity during fracture healing. Therefore, the aim of this study was to standardize the mechanical environment in the fracture gap by developing a rotationally and axially stable murine fracture model, and thereby to analyze the systemic influence of physical activity on early bone repair. After stable fixation of a closed femoral fracture, mice (n=18) were housed in cages supplied with running wheels (running distance >
500m/d). At 2 weeks animals were sacrificed and bones were prepared for histomorphometric (n=7), biomechanical (n=7), and protein biochemical analyses (n=4). Additional mice (n=22), which were housed in standard cages, served as controls. Histomorphometric evaluation showed no influence of increased physical activity on bone repair in terms of callus size and tissue composition. Accordingly, also biomechanical testing of the callus revealed no differences between both groups in rotational stiffness, peak rotation angle, and load at failure. Western blot analyses demonstrated no alterations in callus expression of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) after daily running when compared to controls. We conclude that increased physical activity under standardized mechanical conditions in the fracture gap does not affect early bone repair in mice.
Kyphoplasty is an efficient tool in the treatment of primary tumours (plasmocytoma) and osteolytic metastasis. Especially in plasmocytoma the current chemotherapy has increased life expectancy significantly. Therefore minimal-invasive stabilisation is not only a palliative treatment but really increases quality of life in those cases. Kyphoplasty offers several special tools and techniques to lower the leakage rate which is especially high with other cementoplasty techniques in the osteolytic spine.
Recurrent fracture risk after kyphoplasty is inferior to vertebroplasty, but the risk is still eminent. The reduction of kyphosis is strongly related to the age of the fracture, therefore the reduction and the correction of the kyphosis varies. We investigated the indication of a prophylactic kyphoplasty of adjacent levels to the fracture site in order to decrease the postoperative refracture risk.
In 2 cases cement leakage was seen as direct cause of the refracture. Group 2: prophylactic stabilisation (28 pat. 4 male, 24 female, 63 levels, 29 prophylactic levels). 8 refractures, all adjacent to kyphoplasty. In 3 cases cement leakage as cause of recurrent fracture.