Suture anchor have been used in surgical procedure of tendon or ligament repair. Recently, there has been developed an all suture anchor (soft anchor) which can be used even when the insertion area is narrow. But, the stability of soft anchors due to narrow zone has not been elucidated. This purpose of this study was to investigate stability of soft anchors with respect to their fixation intervals. Polyurethane foams with two different bone densities (10 pcf; 0.16g / cm³, 20 pcf; 0.32g / cm³) were used. All suture anchors and conventional suture anchors were fixed at 10mm, 5mm, and 2.5mm intervals. The failure load was measured using a mechanical testing machine. The average load to failure of conventional suture anchor were 200.4N, 200.2N, 184.7N in the 10mm, 5mm and 2.5mm interval with 10pcf foam bones and 200.4 N, 200.2 N and 184.7 N with the 20 pcf foam bone respectively. Average load to failure load of soft anchor was 97.3N, 93.9N and 76.9N with 10pcf foam bones and 200.4 N, 200.2 N and 184.7 N with 20 pcf foam bone. Suture screw spacing and bone density are important factors in anchor pullout strength. In osteoporotic bone density, insertion of the suture screw interval of 5 mm might be necessary

Introduction. Suture anchor have been used in surgical procedure of tendon or ligament repair. Recently, there has been developed an all suture anchor (soft anchor) which can be used even when the insertion area is narrow. But, the stability of soft anchors due to narrow zone has not been elucidated. This purpose of this study was to investigate stability of soft anchors with respect to their fixation intervals. Methods. Polyurethane foams with two different bone densities (10 pcf; 0.16g / cm³, 20 pcf; 0.32g / cm) were used. All suture anchors and conventional suture anchors were fixed at 10mm, 5mm, and 2.5mm intervals. The failure load was measured using a mechanical testing machine. Results. The average load to failure of conventional suture anchor were 97.3N, 93.9N, and 76.9N in the 10mm, 5mm and 2.5mm interval with 10pcf foam bones and 200.4 N, 200.2 N and 184.7 N with the 20 pcf foam bone respectively. Average load to failure load of soft anchor was 97.3N, 93.9N and 76.9N with 10pcf foam bones and 200.4 N, 200.2 N and 184.7 N with 20 pcf foam bone. Conclusion. Suture screw spacing and bone density are important factors in anchor pullout strength. In osteoporotic bone density, insertion of the suture screw interval of 5 mm might be necessary

We compared time-dependent changes in the biomechanical properties of single-and double-row repair of a simulated acute tear of the rotator cuff in rabbits to determine the effect of the fixation techniques on the healing process. A tear of the supraspinatus tendon was created in 80 rabbits which were separated into two equal groups. A single-row repair with two suture anchors was conducted in group 1 and a double-row repair with four suture anchors in group 2. A total of ten intact contralateral shoulder joints was used as a control group. Biomechanical testing was performed immediately post-operatively and at four and eight weeks, and histological analysis at four and eight weeks. The mean load to failure in group 2 animals was greater than in group 1, but both groups remained lower than the control group at all intervals. Histological analysis showed similar healing properties at four and eight weeks in both groups, but a significantly larger number of healed tendon-bone interfaces were identified in group 2 than in group 1 at eight weeks (p < 0.012). The ultimate load to failure increased with the number of suture anchors used immediately post-operatively, and at four and eight weeks. The increased load to failure at eight weeks seemed to be related to the increase in the surface area of healed tendon-to-bone in the double-row repair group

Summary. Our results prove that Demineralised Cortical Bone (DCB) can be used as biological tendon graft substitute, combined with correct surgical technique and the use of suture bone anchor early mobilisation can be achieved. Introduction. Surgical repair of tendon injuries aims to restore length, mechanical strength and function. In severe injuries with loss of tendon substance a tendon graft or a substitute is usually used to restore functional length. This is usually associated with donor site morbidity, host tissue reactions and lack of remodelling of the synthetic substitutes which may result in suboptimal outcome. In this study we hypothesise that DCB present in biological tendon environment with early mobilisation and appropriate tension will result in remodelling of the DCB into ligament tissue rather that ossification of the DCB at traditional expected. Our preparatory cadaveric study (abstract submitted to CORS 2013) showed that the repair model used in this animal study has sufficient mechanical strength needed for this animal study. Methods. 6 mature female sheep undergone surgical resection of the distal 1 cm of the right patellar tendon and osteotomy of patellar tendon attachment at the tibial tuberosity under general anaesthesia. Repair was done using DCB with 2 suture bone anchor. Animals were allowed immediate mobilisation after surgery and were sacrificed at 12 weeks. The force passing through the operated and non-operated legs was assessed preoperatively and at week 3, week 6, week 9 and week 12 bay walking the animals over a force plate. Radiographs were taken immediately after euthanasia, the Patella-Tendon-tibia constructs were retrieved and pQCT scan was done. Histological analysis included tenocytes and chondrocytes cell counts, semi-quantitative scoring of the neo-enthesis and polarised microscopy. Result. In this study, none of the retrieved specimens showed any evidence of ossification of the DCB as proved by the pQCT analysis. One animal failed to show satisfactory progress after week 3, X-rays showed patella alta, on specimen retrieval no damage to the DCB was found, sutures and stitches were intact and no evidence of anchor pullout was found. Force plate analysis of the other 5 animals showed satisfactory progression over time with 44% functional weight bearing at week 3 progressing to 79% at week 12. There was full range of movement of the stifle joint after 12 weeks. Histological analysis proved formation of neo-enthesis with evidence of cellulisation, vascularisation and remodelling of the collagen leading to ligamentisation of the DCB. Discussion. Surgical reconstruction of damaged tendons is technically challenging, patellar tendon injuries presents even more challenging situation as it involves weight bearing joint. It is generally accepted that a period of immobilisation with passive range of movement exercises and protected weight bearing for up to 6 weeks post operatively is usually advised. Some surgeons use offloading metal wire to protect the repair for 6 weeks involving second surgical procedure to remove the wire. Demineralised bone is usually used in orthopaedics to utilise its osteogenic properties as bone graft substitute and to enhance osteogenesis in load bearing situations. In our study we explored a potential new use of the demineralised bone as tendon graft substitute, it acts as collagen scaffold allowing host cells to remodel its fibres into ligament like structure

This study aims to compare the biomechanical properties of the “Double Lasso-Loop” suture anchor (DLSA) technique with the commonly performed interference screw (IS) technique in an ex vivo ovine model. Fourteen fresh sheep shoulder specimens were used in this study. Dissection was performed leaving only the biceps muscle attached to the humerus and proximal radius before sharply incised to simulate long head of biceps tendon (LHBT) tear. Repair of the LHBT tear was performed on all specimens using either DSLA or IS technique. Cyclical loading of 500 cycles followed by load to failure was performed on all specimens. Tendon displacement due to the cyclical loading at every 100 cycles as well as the maximum load at failure were recorded and analysed. Stiffness was also calculated from the load displacement graph during load to failure testing. No statistically significant difference in tendon displacement was observed from 200 to 500 cycles. Statistically significant higher stiffness was observed in IS when compared with DSLA (P = .005). Similarly, IS demonstrated significantly higher ultimate failure load as compared with DSLA (P = .001). Modes of failure observed for DSLA was mostly due to suture failure (7/8) and anchor pull-out (1/8) while IS resulted in mostly LHBT (4/6) or biceps (2/6) tears. DSLA failure load were compared with previous studies and similar results were noted. After cyclical loading, tendon displacement in DLSA technique was not significantly different from IS technique. Despite the higher failure loads associated with IS techniques in the present study, absolute peak load characteristics of DLSA were similar to previous studies. Hence, DLSA technique can be considered as a suitable alternative to IS fixation for biceps tenodesis

Repair of the rotator cuff requires secure reattachment, but large chronic defects cause osteoporosis of the greater tuberosity which may then have insufficient strength to allow proper fixation of the tendon. Recently, suture anchors have been introduced, but have not been fully evaluated. We have investigated the strength of suture-to-anchor attachment, and the use of suture anchors in repairs of the rotator cuff either to the greater tuberosity or the lateral cortex of the humerus. The second method gave a significant increase in the strength of the repair (p = 0.014). The repairs were loaded cyclically and failed at low loads by cutting into bone and tendon, casting doubt on the integrity of the repair in early mobilisation after surgery. Repairs with suture anchors did not perform better than those with conventional transosseous attachment

Repair of tendon injuries aims to restore length, mechanical strength and function. We hypothesise that Demineralised Cortical Bone (DCB) present in biological tendon environment will result in remodelling of the DCB into ligament tissue. A cadaveric study was carried out to optimize the technique. The distal 1cm of the patellar tendon was excised and DCB was used to bridge the defect. 4 models were examined, Model-1: one anchor, Model-2: 2 anchors, Model-3: 2 anchors with double looped off-loading thread, Model-4: 2 anchors with 3 threads off-loading loop. 6 mature sheep undergone surgical resection of the distal 1cm of the right patellar tendon. Repair was done using DCB with 2 anchors. Immediate mobilisation was allowed, animals were sacrificed at 12 weeks. Force plate assessments were done at weeks 3, 6, 9 and 12. Radiographs were taken and pQCT scan was done prior to histological analysis. In the cadaveric study, the median failure force for the 4 models; 250N, 290N, 767N and 934N respectively. In the animal study, none of the specimens showed evidence of ossification of the DCB. One animal failed to show satisfactory progress, X-rays showed patella alta, on specimen retrieval there was no damage to the DCB and sutures and no evidence of anchor pullout. Functional weight bearing was 79% at week12. Histological analysis proved remodelling of the collagen leading to ligamentisation of the DCB. Results prove that DCB can be used as biological tendon substitute, combined with the use of suture bone anchor early mobilisation can be achieved

Objectives. All-suture anchors are increasingly used in rotator cuff repair procedures. Potential benefits include decreased bone damage. However, there is limited published evidence for the relative strength of fixation for all-suture anchors compared with traditional anchors. Materials and Methods. A total of four commercially available all-suture anchors, the ‘Y-Knot’ (ConMed), Q-FIX (Smith & Nephew), ICONIX (Stryker) and JuggerKnot (Zimmer Biomet) and a traditional anchor control TWINFIX Ultra PK Suture Anchor (Smith & Nephew) were tested in cadaveric human humeral head rotator cuff repair models (n = 24). This construct underwent cyclic loading applied by a mechanical testing rig (Zwick/Roell). Ultimate load to failure, gap formation at 50, 100, 150 and 200 cycles, and failure mechanism were recorded. Significance was set at p < 0.05. Results. Overall, mean maximum tensile strength values were significantly higher for the traditional anchor (181.0 N, standard error (. se). 17.6) compared with the all-suture anchors (mean 133.1 N . se. 16.7) (p = 0.04). The JuggerKnot anchor had greatest displacement at 50, 100 and 150 cycles, and at failure, reaching statistical significance over the control at 100 and 150 cycles (22.6 mm . se. 2.5 versus 12.5 mm . se. 0.3; and 29.6 mm . se. 4.8 versus 17.0 mm . se. 0.7). Every all-suture anchor tested showed substantial (> 5 mm) displacement between 50 and 100 cycles (6.2 to 14.3). All-suture anchors predominantly failed due to anchor pull-out (95% versus 25% of traditional anchors), whereas a higher proportion of traditional anchors failed secondary to suture breakage. Conclusion. We demonstrate decreased failure load, increased total displacement, and variable failure mechanisms in all-suture anchors, compared with traditional anchors designed for rotator cuff repair. These findings will aid the surgeon’s choice of implant, in the context of the clinical scenario. Cite this article: N. S. Nagra, N. Zargar, R. D. J. Smith, A. J. Carr. Mechanical properties of all-suture anchors for rotator cuff repair. Bone Joint Res 2017;6:82–89. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.62.BJR-2016-0225.R1

Operative fixation is the treatment of choice for a rupture of the distal tendon of biceps. A variety of techniques have been described including transosseous sutures and suture anchors. The poor quality of the bone of the radial tuberosity might affect the load to failure of the tendon repair in early rehabilitation. The aim of this study was to determine the loads to failure of different techniques of fixation and to investigate their association with the bone mineral density of the radial tuberosity. Peripheral quantitative computed tomography was carried out to measure the trabecular and cortical bone mineral density of the radial tuberosity in 40 cadaver specimens. The loads to failure in four different techniques of fixation were determined. The Endobutton-based method showed the highest failure load at 270 N (. sd. 22) (p < 0.05). The mean failure load of the transosseous suture technique was 210 N (. sd. 66) and that of the TwinFix-QuickT 5.0 mm was 57 N (. sd. 22), significantly lower than those of all other repairs (p < 0.05). No significant correlation was seen between bone mineral density and loads to failure. The transosseous technique is an easy and cost-saving procedure for fixation of the distal biceps tendon. TwinFix-QuickT 5.0 mm had significantly lower failure loads, which might affect early rehabilitation, particularly in older patients

Summary Statement. Demineralised bone matrix augmented tendon-bone fixations in the animal model show less scar tissue and an enthesis morphology closer to the physiologic one which may lead to a more resistant repair construct. Introduction. Rotator cuff repair is one of the most common operative procedures in the shoulder. Yet despite its prevalence recurrent tear rates of up to 94% have been reported in the literature. High failure rates have been associated with tendon detachment from bone at the tendon – bone interface. Exogenous agents as biological strategies to augment tendon – bone healing in the shoulder represent a new area of focus to improve patient outcomes. Demineralised bone matrix (DBM) contains matrix bound proteins, exposed through acid demineralization step of DBM manufacture, and has long been recognised for its osteoinductive and osteoconductive properties. We hypothesised that DBM administered to the bone bed prior to the reattachment of the tendon, will upregulate healing and result in enhanced tissue morphology that more closely resembles that of a normal enthesis. An established ovine transosseous equivalent rotator cuff model was used. Methods. Following ethics approval, 10 adult wethers (18 months) were randomly allocated to control, n=4 (without DBM) or DBM, n=6 (DBM administered to bone bed) groups. The infraspinatus tendon was detached from its insertion and repaired in a transosseous equivalent fashion using PEEK suture anchors. In treatment animals 0.25cc of ovine DBM, previously prepared using a modified Urist protocol, was injected into two drill holes within the bony tendon footprint. Animals were culled at 4 weeks following surgery and processed for tissue histology and microcomputed tomography (μCT) endpoints. Results. No infection or tendon detachment following repair was noted in either group. 3D reconstructed images of μCT scans verified correct DBM and suture anchor placement. Histological images demonstrated distinct differences in tissue morphology between the two groups; however there was no evidence of the four – zoned structure characteristic of a healthy tendon bone insertion, in any specimens. In the control group specimens, the tendon midsubstance was highly disorganised with randomly arranged collagen fibres and diminutive areas of fibrocartilage. In the treatment group, large regions between tendon and bone were occupied by fibrocartilage. Within the fibrocartilage region, insertional collagen fibres appeared organised and chondrocytes were orientated in the direction of the insertional collagen fibres. Organised collagen fibre orientation within the tendon midsubstance was observed, though this was not consistent throughout all the specimens. DBM particles were resorbed and trabecular bone occupied the DBM holes. The PEEK anchors were all in direct contact with the ongrowing bone indicating good quality integration and fixation. Discussion. This study showed that DBM augmented tendon to bone repair leads to an upregulated cellular activity resulting in increased amounts of fibrocartilage between the repaired tendon and underlying bone. The upshot of this is an improved tissue organization which more closely resembles the morphology of the normal enthesis. Introduction of osteoinductive DBM at the tendon – bone interface during surgery may reduce failure rates associated with rotator cuff repair and improve clinical outcomes

Background. Re-attachment of tendon to bone is challenging with surgical repair failing in up to 90% of cases. Poor biological healing is common and characterised by the formation of weak scar tissue. Previous work has demonstrated that decellularised allogenic demineralised bone matrix (DBM) regenerates a physiologic enthesis. Xenografts offer a more cost-effective option but concerns over their immunogenicity have been raised. We hypothesised that augmentation of a healing tendon-bone interface with DBM incorporated with autologous mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) would result in improved function, and restoration of the native enthesis, with no difference between xenogenic and allogenic scaffolds. Methods. Using an ovine model of tendon-bone retraction the patellar tendon was detached and a complete distal tendon defect measuring 1 cm was created. Suture anchors were used to reattach the shortened tendon and xenogenic DBM + MSCs (n=5) and allogenic DBM + MSCs (n=5) were used to bridge the defect. Functional recovery was assessed every 3 weeks and DBM incorporation into the tendon and its effect on enthesis regeneration was measured using histomorphometry. Results. By 12 weeks, DBM augmentation resulted in significantly improved functional weight bearing with no failures in either group. Compared to xenogenic DBM, allogenic DBM was associated with significantly higher functional weight bearing at 6 (P=0.047), 9 (P=0.028) and 12 weeks (P=0.009). This was accompanied by a more direct type of enthesis characterised by significantly more fibrocartilage and mineralised fibrocartilage. Xenograft was also associated with an immunogenic reaction despite preoperative decellularisation. Conclusion. This study shows that DBM enhances tendon-bone healing and may reduce the high failure rates associated with surgery. An immunogenic reaction, and inferior biomechanical and histological results were also associated with the use of xenograft. Allogenic DBM with autologous MSCs may be a suitable scaffold for the enhancement of tendon-bone healing in the clinical setting. Disclosures. Funded by IKC PoC grant awarded by the University of Leeds. Ethical approval. Granted by the study institution (University College London)

Treatment of massive rotator cuff tears can be challenging. Previous studies with irreparable rotator cuff tears showed good clinical results of tendon healing with the arthroscopic insertion of a protective biodegradable spacer balloon filled with saline solution between the repaired tendon and the acromion [1,2], but so far no scientific evidence has showed how the device alters pressures over the repaired tendon. This biomechanical study investigated the effects of a spacer inserted in the subacromial space on pressures over the repaired rotator cuff tendon in passive motion cycles typical for post-operative rehabilitation routines. Six human cadaveric shoulders were prepared with the humerus cut 15cm below the joint and embedded in a pot, while the scapula fixed at three points on a plate. A rotator cuff tear was simulated and repaired using a suture anchor and a Mason-Allen suture. The specimens were then mounted on a custom-made pneumatic testing rig to induce passive motion cycles of adduction-abduction (90–0°) and flexion-extension (0–40°) with constant glenohumeral and superior loads and tension is exerted on the supraspinatus tendon with weights. A pressure sensor was placed between the supraspinatus tendon and the acromion. After pressure measurements for 15 cycles of each motion type, the InSpace balloon (OrthoSpace, Inc, Israel) was inserted and the specimens tested and pressure measured again for 15 cycles. Statistically significant changes in peak pressures were then measured before and after balloon. Peak pressures were measured near 90 degrees abduction. No statistical differences were observed for internal-external rotation before and after balloon-shaped subacromial spacer was inserted. Mean pressures in abduction-adduction were significantly reduced from 121.7 ± 9.5 MPa to 51.5 ± 1.2 MPa. Peak pressures after repair were 1171.3 ± 99.5 MPa and 1749.6 ± 80.7 MPa in flexion-extension and abduction-adduction motion, respectively, and significantly decreased to 468.7 ± 16.0 MPa and 535.1 ± 27.6 MPa after spacer insertion (p<0.0001). The use of the spacer above the repaired tendon reduced peak pressures and distributed them more widely over the sensor during both abduction-adduction and flexion-extension motions and therefore can reduce the stress on the rotator cuff repair. The InSpace system may reduce the pressure on the repaired tendon, thus potentially protecting the repair. Further studies to investigate this phenomenon are warranted, in particular relating these changes to shoulder kinematics following tear repair and spacer insertion

We examined cultured osteoblasts derived from paired samples from the greater tuberosity and acromion from eight patients with large chronic tears of the rotator cuff.

We found that osteoblasts from the tuberosity had no apparent response to mechanical stimulation, whereas those derived from the acromion showed an increase in alkaline phosphatase activity and nitric oxide release which is normally a response of bone cells to mechanical strain. By contrast, we found that cells from both regions were able to respond to dexamethasone, a well-established promoter of osteoblastic differentiation, with the expected increase in alkaline phosphatase activity.

Our findings indicate that the failure of repair of the rotator cuff may be due, at least in part, to a compromised capacity for mechanoadaptation within the greater tuberosity. It remains to be seen whether this apparent decrease in the sensitivity of bone cells to mechanical stimulation is the specific consequence of the reduced load-bearing history of the greater tuberosity in these patients.

This study was undertaken to elucidate the mechanism of biological repair at the tendon-bone junction in a rat model. The stump of the toe flexor tendon was sutured to a drilled hole in the tibia (tendon suture group, n = 23) to investigate healing of the tendon-bone junction both radiologically and histologically. Radiological and histological findings were compared with those observed in a sham control group where the bone alone was drilled (n = 19). The biomechanical strength of the repaired junction was confirmed by pull-out testing six weeks after surgery in four rats in the tendon suture group. Callus formation was observed at the site of repair in the tendon suture group, whereas in the sham group callus formation was minimal. During the pull-out test, the repaired tendon-bone junction did not fail because the musculotendinous junction always disrupted first.

In order to understand the factors that influenced callus formation at the site of repair, four further groups were evaluated. The nature of the sutured tendon itself was investigated by analysing healing of a tendon stump after necrosis had been induced with liquid nitrogen in 16 cases. A proximal suture group (n = 16) and a partial tenotomy group (n = 16) were prepared to investigate the effects of biomechanical loading on the site of repair. Finally, a group where the periosteum had been excised at the site of repair (n = 16) was examined to study the role of the periosteum. These four groups showed less callus formation radiologically and histologically than did the tendon suture group.

In conclusion, the sutured tendon-bone junction healed and achieved mechanical strength at six weeks after suturing, showing good local callus formation. The viability of the tendon stump, mechanical loading and intact periosteum were all found to be important factors for better callus formation at a repaired tendon-bone junction.

Despite worldwide clinical use of bio-absorbable devices for internal fixation in orthopaedic surgery, the degradation behaviour and tissue replacement of these implants are not fully understood.

In a long-term experimental study, we have determined the patterns of tissue restoration 36 and 54 months after implantation of polyglycolic acid and poly-laevo-lactic acid screws in the distal femur of the rabbit.

After 36 months in the polyglycolic acid group the specimens showed no remaining polymer and loose connective tissue occupied 80% of the screw track. Tissue restoration remained poor at 54 months, the amounts of trabecular bone and haematopoietic elements being significantly lower than those in the intact control group. The amount of trabecular bone within the screw track at 54 months in the polyglycolic acid group was less than in the empty drill holes (p = 0.04). In the poly-laevo-lactic acid group, polymeric material was present in abundance after 54 months, occupying 60% of the cross-section of the core area of the screw track.

When using absorbable internal fixation implants we should recognise that the degradation of the devices will probably not be accompanied by the restoration of normal trabecular bone.