Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 20 of 22
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_10 | Pages 124 - 124
1 May 2016
Thornton-Bott P Fung S Walter W Walter W Zicat B
Full Access

Introduction. Osteloysis following metal-on-UHMW polyethylene Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) is well reported, as is lack of osteolysis following Ceramic-on-Ceramic (CoC)THA. Early ceramic failures did report some osteolysis, but in flawed implants. As 3rd and now 4th generation ceramic THAs come into mid- and long-term use, the orthopaedic community has begun to see reports of high survival rates and very low incidence of osteolysis in these bearings. Osteolysis reported after 3rd generation CoC THA often included metallosis due to neck rim impingement. In our department we have revised only 2 hips in over 6000 CoC THAs for osteolysis. Both had evidence of metallosis as well as ceramic wear. The technique used by Radiologists for identifying the nature of lesions on CT is the Hounsfield score which will identify the density of the tissue within the lucent area. It is common for radiologist to have no access to previous imaging, especially pre-operative imaging if a long time has elapsed. With such a low incidence of osteolysis in this patient group, what, then, should a surgeon do on receiving a CT report on a ceramic-on-ceramic THA which states there is osteolysis? Revision of such implants in elderly patients has a high risk of morbidity and mortality. Objectives. This retrospective review aims to determine the accuracy of CT in identifying true osteolysis in a cohort of long-term third generation ceramic-on-ceramic uncemented hip arthroplasties in our department. Methods. Pelvic CT scans were performed on the first 27 patients from a cohort of 301 patients undergoing 15 year review with 3rd generation alumina-alumina cementless THAs. The average follow-up was 15 years (15–17). The CT scans were reviewed against pre-operative and post-operative radiographs and reviewed by a second musculoskeletal specialist radiologist. Results. Eleven of the CTscans were reported to show acetabular osteolysis, two reported osteolysis or possible pre-existing cyst and one reported a definitive pre-existing cyst. After review of previous imaging including pre-operative radiographs, eleven of the thirteen patients initially reported to have osteolysis were found to have pre-existing cysts or geodes in the same size and position as the reported osteolysis, and a further patient had spot-welds with stress-shielding. One patient with evidence of true osteolysis awaits aspiration or biopsy to determine if he has evidence of ceramic wear or metallosis. Conclusions. Reports of osteolysis on CT should be interpreted with care in modern ceramic-on-ceramic THA to prevent unnecessary revision. Further imaging and investigations may be necessary to exclude other conditions such as geodes, or stress shielding which are frequently confused with osteolysis on CT scans


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 104-B, Issue SUPP_12 | Pages 82 - 82
1 Dec 2022
Hitchon S Milner J Holdsworth D Willing R
Full Access

Revision surgeries for orthopaedic infections are done in two stages – one surgery to implant an antibiotic spacer to clear the infection and another to install a permanent implant. A permanent porous implant, that can be loaded with antibiotics and allow for single-stage revision surgery, will benefit patients and save healthcare resources. Gyroid structures can be constructed with high porosity, without stress concentrations that can develop in other period porous structures [1] [2]. The purpose of this research is to compare the resulting bone and prosthesis stress distributions when porous versus solid stems are implanted into three proximal humeri with varying bone densities, using finite element models (FEM). Porous humeral stems were constructed in a gyroid structure at porosities of 60%, 70%, and 80% using computer-aided design (CAD) software. These CAD models were analyzed using FEM (Abaqus) to look at the stress distributions within the proximal humerus and the stem components with loads and boundary conditions representing the arm actively maintained at 120˚ of flexion. The stem was assumed to be made of titanium (Ti6Al4V). Three different bone densities were investigated, representing a healthy, an osteopenic, and an osteoporotic humerus, with an average bone shape created using a statistical shape and density model (SSDM) based on 75 cadaveric shoulders (57 males and 18 females, 73 12 years) [3]. The Young's moduli (E) of the cortical and trabecular bones were defined on an element-by-element basis, with a minimum allowable E of 15 MPa. The Von Mises stress distributions in the bone and the stems were compared between different stem scenarios for each bone density model. A preliminary analysis shows an increase in stress values at the proximal-lateral region of the humerus when using the porous stems compared to the solid stem, which becomes more prominent as bone density decreases. With the exception of a few mesh dependent singularities, all three porous stems show stress distributions below the fatigue strength of Ti-6Al-4V (410 MPa) for this loading scenario when employed in the osteopenic and osteoporotic humeri [4]. The 80% porosity stem had a single strut exceeding the fatigue strength when employed in the healthy bone. The results of this study indicate that the more compliant nature of the porous stem geometries may allow for better load transmission through the proximal humeral bone, better matching the stress distributions of the intact bone and possibly mitigating stress-shielding effects. Importantly, this study also indicates that these porous stems have adequate strength for long-term use, as none were predicted to have catastrophic failure under the physiologically-relevant loads. Although these results are limited to a single boney geometry, it is based on the average shape of 75 shoulders and different bone densities are considered. Future work could leverage the shape model for probabilistic models that could explore the effect of stem porosity across a broader population. The development of these models are instrumental in determining if these structures are a viable solution to combatting orthopaedic implant infections


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 104-B, Issue SUPP_12 | Pages 80 - 80
1 Dec 2022
Reeves J Spangenberg G Elwell J Stewart B Vanasse T Roche C Langohr GD Faber KJ
Full Access

Shoulder arthroplasty is effective at restoring function and relieving pain in patients suffering from glenohumeral arthritis; however, cortex thinning has been significantly associated with larger press-fit stems (fill ratio = 0.57 vs 0.48; P = 0.013)1. Additionally, excessively stiff implant-bone constructs are considered undesirable, as high initial stiffness of rigid fracture fixation implants has been related to premature loosening and an ultimate failure of the implant-bone interface2. Consequently, one objective which has driven the evolution of humeral stem design has been the reduction of stress-shielding induced bone resorption; this in-part has led to the introduction of short stems, which rely on metaphyseal fixation. However, the selection of short stem diametral (i.e., thickness) sizing remains subjective, and its impact on the resulting stem-bone construct stiffness has yet to be quantified. Eight paired cadaveric humeri (age = 75±15 years) were reconstructed with surgeon selected ‘standard’ sized and 2mm ‘oversized’ short-stemmed implants. Standard stem sizing was based on a haptic assessment of stem and broach stability per typical surgical practice. Anteroposterior radiographs were taken, and the metaphyseal and diaphyseal fill ratios were quantified. Each humerus was then potted in polymethyl methacrylate bone cement and subjected to 2000 cycles of compressive loading representing 90º forward flexion to simulate postoperative seating. Following this, a custom 3D printed metal implant adapter was affixed to the stem, which allowed for compressive loading in-line with the stem axis (Fig.1). Each stem was then forced to subside by 5mm at a rate of 1mm/min, from which the compressive stiffness of the stem-bone construct was assessed. The bone-implant construct stiffness was quantified as the slope of the linear portion of the resulting force-displacement curves. The metaphyseal and diaphyseal fill ratios were 0.50±0.10 and 0.45±0.07 for the standard sized stems and 0.50±0.06 and 0.52±0.06 for the oversized stems, respectively. Neither was found to correlate significantly with the stem-bone construct stiffness measure (metaphysis: P = 0.259, diaphysis: P = 0.529); however, the diaphyseal fill ratio was significantly different between standard and oversized stems (P < 0.001, Power = 1.0). Increasing the stem size by 2mm had a significant impact on the stiffness of the stem-bone construct (P = 0.003, Power = 0.971; Fig.2). Stem oversizing yielded a construct stiffness of −741±243N/mm; more than double that of the standard stems, which was −334±120N/mm. The fill ratios reported in the present investigation match well with those of a finite element assessment of oversizing short humeral stems3. This work complements that investigation's conclusion, that small reductions in diaphyseal fill ratio may reduce the likelihood of stress shielding, by also demonstrating that oversizing stems by 2mm dramatically increases the stiffness of the resulting implant-bone construct, as stiffer implants have been associated with decreased bone stimulus4 and premature loosening2. The present findings suggest that even a small, 2mm, variation in the thickness of short stem humeral components can have a marked influence on the resulting stiffness of the implant-bone construct. This highlights the need for more objective intraoperative methods for selecting stem size to provide guidelines for appropriate diametral sizing. For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_5 | Pages 94 - 94
1 Apr 2018
Vogel D Dempwolf H Schulze C Kluess D Bader R
Full Access

Introduction. In total hip arthroplasty, press-fit anchorage is one of the most common fixation methods for acetabular cups and mostly ensures sufficient primary stability. Nevertheless, implants may fail due to aseptic loosening over time, especially when the surrounding bone is affected by stress-shielding. The use of acetabular cups made of isoelastic materials might help to avoid stress-shielding and osteolysis. The aim of the present numerical study was to determine whether a modular acetabular cup with a shell made of polyetheretherketone (PEEK) may be an alternative to conventional titanium shells (Ti6Al4V). For this purpose, a 3D finite element analysis was performed, in which the implantation of modular acetabular cups into an artificial bone stock using shells made of either PEEK or Ti6Al4V, was simulated with respect to stresses and deformations within the implants. Methods. The implantation of a modular cup, consisting of a shell made of PEEK or Ti6Al4V and an insert made of either ceramic or polyethylene (PE), into a bone cavity made of polyurethane foam (20 pcf), was analysed by 3D finite element simulation. A two-point clamping cavity was chosen to represent a worst-case situation in terms of shell deformation. Five materials were considered; with Ti6Al4V and ceramic being defined as linear elastic and PE and PEEK as plastic materials. The artificial bone stock was simulated as a crushable foam. Contacts were generated between the cavity and shell (μ = 0.5) and between the shell and insert (μ = 0.16). In total, the FE models consisted of 45,282 linear hexahedron elements and the implantation process was simulated in four steps: 1. Displacement driven insertion of the cup; 2. Relief of the cup; 3. Displacement driven placement of the insert; 4. Load driven insertion of the insert (maximum push-in force of 500 N). The FE model was evaluated with respect to the radial deformations of the shell and insert as well as the principal stresses in case of the ceramic inserts. The model was experimentally validated via comparison of nominal strains of the titanium shells. Results. The maximum radial deformation of the shell made of PEEK was 581 μm (insertion) and 470 μm (relief) and therefore multiple times higher compared to the Ti6Al4V shell (42 μm and 21 μm). As a result, larger deformations occurred at the PE and ceramic inserts in combination with the PEEK shell. Partially, the deformations were above an usual clearance of 100 μm. When the ceramic insert was combined with the shell made of PEEK, maximum principal stresses in the ceramic insert amounted to 30 MPa and were clearly lower than approved bending strength of the ceramic material (948 MPa). Conclusion. The examined acetabular shell made of PEEK was intensively deformed during insertion compared to the geometrically identical Ti6Al4V shell and is therefore not suitable for modular acetabular cups. In future studies it should be clarified to what extent acetabular cups with shells made of carbon fiber reinforced PEEK materials with higher stiffness lead to reduced deformations during the insertion procedure


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 111 - 111
1 Jan 2016
De Martino I D'Apolito R De Santis V Gasparini G
Full Access

Background. Tapered cementless femoral components have been used in total hip arthroplasty (THA) constructs for more than 20 years. The Synergy femoral component was introduced in 1996 as a second generation titanium proximally porous-coated tapered stem with dual offsets to better restore femoral offset at THA (Figure 1). The purpose of this study was to evaluate the outcome of the authors' experience using the Synergy stem at minimum 15 years of follow-up. Material and methods. We retrospectively reviewed a consecutive series of 102 patients (112 hips) who underwent surgery between November 1996 and October 1998 for primary THA using cementless Synergy stem with a minimum 15-years follow-up. The mean age at the time of surgery was 61 years, and the mean duration of follow-up was 16.3 years. Seventeen patients were lost at FU (8 died before the 15 years mark, 8 changed residency, 1 not willing to be seen) with no problems related to the replaced hip. Ninety-four hips in 85 patients were available for clinical and radiologic analysis. Clinical results of the 94 THAs with more than 15 years of follow-up were assessed preoperatively and postoperatively at 5, 10 and 15 years by means of standard evaluation tools: SF12, WOMAC and Harris Hip Score. Thigh pain frequency and intensity were also recorded. Radiographic analysis (Figure 2) was focused on stem alignment, bone ingrowth, radiolucent lines presence, width and progression, stress-shielding and heterotopic ossification (HTO). Student paired test and Kaplan-Meier survival analysis were used for statistical analysis. Results. All clinical evaluation tools showed at 5-year FU, 10-year FU and at latest FU (15–17 years) a statistically significant improvement compared to the preoperative scores. We observed a not constant thigh pain in 5 hips (4.75%). Nine stems were revised due to polyethylene wear (3 cases), late periprosthetic fracture (2 cases), infection (2 cases), subsidence (1 case) and instability (1 case). Stem related revision was a case of subsidence, related to occult intraoperative calcar crack and early revised (within 1 year); cumulative stem-related survival rate at 15 years was 99%. Alignment was varus in 5 cases and valgus in 1. Bone in-growth was observed in 93 hips (98%). Radiolucent lines were uncommon, non progressive, less than 2 mm, in Gruen zones 2 and 6. Stress-shielding was present as cortical reaction in 5 femurs in Gruen zones 3 and 5. Fifteen cases of HTO (grade I and II in 12 case and grade III in 3 cases) were observed. Conclusions. The Synergy stem demonstrated excellent clinical and radiographic results at 15–17 years FU in 85 patients. Survivorship (with stem revision as end point) was 99% at 15 years. Thigh pain was uncommon and the level of activity and autonomy is excellent. Radiographically bone ingrowth is evident in all stems and radiolucent lines are “benign” with no aseptic loosening


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 102-B, Issue SUPP_6 | Pages 86 - 86
1 Jul 2020
Ashjaee N Johnston G Johnston J
Full Access

Distal radius fractures are the most common osteoporotic fractures among women. The treatment of these fractures has been shifting from a traditional non-operative approach to surgery, using volar locking plate (VLP) technology. Surgery, however, is not without risk, complications including failure to restore an anatomic reduction, fracture re-displacement, and tendon rupture. The VLP implant is also marked by bone loss due to stress-shielding related to its high stiffness relative to adjacent bone. Recently, a novel internal, composite-based implant, with a stiffness less than the VLP, was designed to eradicate the shortcomings associated with the VLP implant. It is unclear, however, what effect this less-stiff implant will have upon adjacent bone density distributions long-term. The objective of this study was to evaluate the long-term effects of the two implants (the novel surgical implant and the gold-standard VLP) by using subject-specific finite element (FE) models integrated with an adaptive bone formation/resorption algorithm. Specimen: One fresh-frozen human forearm specimen (female, age = 84 years old) was imaged using CT and was used to create a subject-specific FE model of the radius. Finite element modeling: In order to simulate a clinically relevant (unstable) fracture of the distal radius, a wedge of bone was removed from the model, which was approximately 10 mm wide and centered 20 mm proximal to the tip of the radial styloid. Bone remodeling algorithm: A strain-energy density (SED) based bone remodeling theory was used to account for bone remodeling. With this approach, bone density decreased linearly when SED per bone density was less than 67.5 µJ/g and increased when it was more than 232.5 µJ/g. When it was in the lazy zone (67.5 to 232.5 µJ/g), no changes in density occurred. Boundary conditions: A 180 N quasi-static force representing the scaphoid, and a 120 N quasi-static force representing the lunate was applied to the radius. The midshaft of the radius was constrained. FE outcomes: To examine the effects of stress shielding associated with each implant, the long-term changes of bone density within proximal transverse cross-sections of radius were inspected. The regional density analysis focused on three transverse cross-sections. The transverse cross-sections were positioned proximal to the subchondral plate, and were distanced 50 (cross-section A), 57 (cross-section B), and 64 mm (cross-section C) from the subchondral endplate. For both implants in all three cross-sections, cortical bone was reserved completely at the volar side. On the dorsal side, the cortical bone was completely resorbed in the VLP model. In all cross-sections, the averaged resultant density was higher for the “novel implant”. The difference ranged from 33% (cross-section A) to 36% (cross-section C) in favor of the “novel implant”. On average, the density values of the novel implant were 34% higher in transverse cross-sections (A, B, and C). This study showed that the novel implant offered higher density distributions compared to the VLP, which suggests that the novel implant may be superior to the VLP in terms of avoiding stress shielding


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXV | Pages 220 - 220
1 Jun 2012
Sochart D Chaudhary N
Full Access

Negative remodelling of the femoral cortex in the form of calcar resorption due to stress-shielding, and femoral cortical hypertrophy at the level of the tip of the implant due to distal load transfer, is frequenly noted following cemented total hip replacement, most commonly with composite beam implants, but also with polished double tapered components. The C-stem polished femoral component was designed with a third taper running from lateral to medial across and along the entire length of the implant, with the aim of achieving more proximal and therefore more natural loading of the femur. The implant is designed to subside within the femoral cement mantle utilising the cement property of creep, generating hoop stresses, which are transferred more proximally to the femoral bone, starting at the level of the medial calcar. The intention is to load the proximal femur minimising stress-shielding and calcar resorption, as well as reducing distal load transfer as signified by the lack of distal femoral cortical hypertrophy. We present the results of a consecutive series of 500 total hip replacements using C-stem femoral components, performed between March 2000 and December 2005 at a single institution. Data was collected prospectively and all patients remain under annual follow-up by a Specialist Arthroplasty Practitioner. The operations were performed using a standard surgical technique with third generation cementing using Palacos-R antibiotic loaded cement. 500 arthroplasties were performed on 455 patients with an average age at the time of surgery of 68.3 years (23-92). There were 282 (62%) female and 173 (38%) male patients with osteoarthritis being the predominant diagnosis. 77 patients have died (73 hips) and the average duration of follow-up for the entire series is 81 months (52-124). Only 2 femoral implants have been revised - one for deep sepsis and the other as part of a revision procedure for a loose acetabulum, although the femoral component itself was not loose. One implant is currently loose following a periprosthetic fracture treated by internal fixation, but none of the remaining implants demonstrates any progressive radiolucencies in any Gruen zones or any features suggestive of current or future loosening. Calcar rounding has been observed, but there have been no cases with obvious loss of calcar height and no cases of distal femoral cortical hypertrophy. The C-stem femoral component has therefore performed well in clinical practice and the objective of eradicating negative bone remodelling has been achieved. The study is ongoing


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 102-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 94 - 94
1 Feb 2020
Hagio K Akiyama K Aikawa K Saito M
Full Access

Introduction. In our institution, we started to perform THA with SuperPATH approach, including preservation of soft tissue around the hip (James Chow et al. Musculoskelet Med 2011) since July 2014, aiming for fast recovery and prevention of hip dislocation. For minimally-invasive approaches, however, there have been a few reports on malalignment of the implants related to shortage of operative field. The purpose of this study is to examine the short-term results of THA using SuperPATH, especially implant alignment. Materials and methods. We performed a study of 45 patients (45 hips) with osteoarthritis of the hip joint who had a THA with SuperPATH approach. There were 8 men and 37 women with an average age of 73 years, which were minimally 24 months followed. Dynasty Bioform cup and Profemur Z stem (Microport Orthopaedics) were used for all cases. Patients were clinically assessed with Merle d'Aubigne score and complications. Implant alignment and stability were radiologically evaluated by annual X-ray and CT acquired two months after surgery. Results. Merle d'Aubigne score was 10.2 (pain:2.8, mobility:4.4 walking ability:3.0) preoperatively and 16.6(pain:5.8, mobility:5.8, walking ability:5.0) at the latest follow-up. There were no dislocation and infection, but intraoperative proximal femoral fracture was found for two cases, which was managed to treat with additional circulating wire intraoperatively. Latest follow-up X-ray image showed 95% of the stem A-P alignment to be within 2 degrees and 5% to be more than 2 degrees and less than 5 degrees, while 44% of the stem lateral alignment to be within 2 degrees, 47% to be more than 2 degrees and less than 5 degrees, and 8% to be more than 5 degrees. From CT images averaged cup position found to be 40±5 degrees for inclination, and 19±5 degrees for anatomic anteversion, averaged stem anteversion to be 33±9 degrees. Annual X-ray evaluation showed no radiolucent line and less than Grade 2 stress-shielding (Engh classification) around the implants for all cases. One case had more than 5mm subsidence of the stem in early postoperative period, but not progressively subsided. No loosening of components was evident. Discussion and Conclusion. Many minimally-invasive approaches have developed, there have been many reports on fast recovery and low incidence of postoperative hip dislocation, however, the risk of complications or malalignment related to shortage of operative field has been pointed out. In this study, intraoperative proximal femoral fracture occurred for two cases. Also, though there were no loosening and the components position seemed excellent but lateral view of the X-ray showed 8% to be more than 5 degrees tilting alignment, resulting from femoral broaching required before femoral neck resection. SuperPATH approach, including pass way from between the Gluteus Medius and the piriformis tendon, can preserve the whole short external rotators and capsule of the hip joint, leading to fast recovery and low incidence of postoperative dislocation. Moreover, this approach may be friendly to the surgeons familiar with the posterior approach because of easily conversion to the conventional posterior approach


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_4 | Pages 9 - 9
1 Feb 2017
Harada Y Miyasaka T Miyagi J Kitahara S
Full Access

Introduction. Dysplastic hip has not only deficiency of acetabulum but also femoral deformity. Therefore, selection of stem is important in cementless THA for dysplasia. Especially using of short stem should be challenge for deformed femur. We studied clinical performance and radiological findings after THA with triple tapered short stem (Optimys hip) for dysplastic hip. Materials and method. From May 2013, we performed cementless THA for osteoarthritis with dysplasia. Seventy-one hips of 67 patients were examined including four males and 63 females. Age at surgery was from 36 to 88 years old (61.7 in average). Surgical approach was used modified Watson-Jones in all hips. Clinical evaluation was used modified Harris hip score (MHSS), incidence of complications and thig pain. Radiological findings were evaluated according Engh's classification and grade of stress shielding. Follow-up period was minimum one year and was 21.3 months in average. Results. MHHS before surgery was 41 points and that at follow-up was 88 points in average and pain score was significantly improved. Calcar fracture during surgery occurred in two hips and circular wiring was performed. Deep infection, DVT and dislocation were not observed. Incidence of thigh pain was 1.4% of one hip. Radiological findings were assessed as bone in-grown in all of the hips and grade of stress-shielding was very low. There were no aseptic loosening and no revision for any reasons. Conclusions. Cementless THA with triple tapered short stem was useful for treatment of dysplastic hips. Radiological findings of all hip were assessed as bone in-grown


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_10 | Pages 4 - 4
1 Jun 2018
Walter W
Full Access

Ceramic-on-ceramic bearings provide a solution to the osteolysis seen with traditional metal-on-polyethylene bearings. Sporadic reports of ceramic breakage and squeaking concern some surgeons and this bearing combination can show in vivo signs of edge loading wear which was not predicted from in vitro studies. Taper damage or debris in the taper between the ceramic and metal may lead to breakage of either a ceramic head or insert. Fastidious surgical technique may help to minimise the risk of ceramic breakage. Squeaking is usually a benign complication, most frequently occurring when the hip is fully flexed. Rarely, it can occur with each step of walking when it can be sufficiently troublesome to require revision surgery. The etiology of squeaking is multifactorial in origin. Taller, heavier and younger patients with higher activity levels are more prone to hips that squeak. Cup version and inclination are also relevant factors. Osteolysis following metal-on-UHMW polyethylene Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) is well reported. Earlier generation ceramic-on-ceramic bearings did produce some osteolysis, but in flawed implants. As third and now fourth generation ceramic THAs come into mid- and long-term service, the orthopaedic community has begun to see reports of high survival rates and very low incidence of osteolysis in these bearings. The technique used by radiologists for identifying the nature of lesions on Computed Tomography (CT) scan is the Hounsfield score which will identify the density of the tissue within the lucent area. Commonly the radiologist will have no access to previous imaging, especially pre-operative imaging if a long time has elapsed. With such a low incidence of osteolysis in this patient group, what, then, should a surgeon do on receiving a CT report on a ceramic-on-ceramic THA, which states there is osteolysis? This retrospective review aims to determine the accuracy of CT in identifying true osteolysis in a cohort of long-term third generation ceramic-on-ceramic uncemented hip arthroplasties in our department. Pelvic CT scans were performed on the first 27 patients from a cohort of 301 patients undergoing 15-year review with third generation alumina-alumina cementless THAs. The average follow-up was 15 years (15–17). The CT scans were reviewed against pre-operative and post-operative radiographs and reviewed by a second musculoskeletal specialist radiologist. Eleven of the CT scans were reported to show acetabular osteolysis, two reported osteolysis or a possible pre-existing cyst and one reported a definitive pre-existing cyst. After review of previous imaging including pre-operative radiographs, eleven of the thirteen patients initially reported to have osteolysis were found to have pre-existing cysts or geodes in the same size and position as the reported osteolysis, and a further patient had spot-welds with stress-shielding. One patient with evidence of true osteolysis awaits aspiration or biopsy to determine if he has evidence of ceramic wear or metallosis. Reports of osteolysis on CT should be interpreted with care in modern ceramic-on-ceramic THA to prevent unnecessary revision. Further imaging and investigations may be necessary to exclude other conditions such as geodes, or stress shielding which are frequently confused with osteolysis on CT scans


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_5 | Pages 11 - 11
1 Apr 2018
Sas A Kolk S Pellikaan P Scheerlinck T Van Lenthe H
Full Access

Introduction. Although total hip arthroplasty is a very successful operation, complications such as: dislocation, aseptic loosening, and periprosthetic fracture do occur. These aspects have been studied in large populations for traditional stem designs, but not for more recent short stems. The design rationale of short stems is to preserve bone stock, without compromising stability. However, due to their smaller bone contact area, high peak stresses and areas of stress shielding could appear in the proximal femur, especially in the presence of atypical bone geometries. In order to evaluate this aspect, we quantified the stress distribution in atypical proximal femurs implanted with a commercially available calcar guided short stem. Methods. Geometrical shape variations in neck-shaft angle (NSA), neck-length (NL) and anteversion (AV), were determined three-dimensionally in the Mimics Innovation Suite (Materialise N.V., Leuven, Belgium) from a CT dataset of 96 segmented femurs. For each shape variation, the femurs that had the two lowest, two average and two highest values were included (18 femurs). Using scripting functionality in Mimics, CAD design files of the calcar guided Optimys short stem (Mathys, Bettlach, Switzerland) were automatically sized and aligned to restore the anatomical hip rotation center. Stem size and position were manually corrected by an orthopedic surgeon before finite element (FE) models were constructed using a non-manifold assembly approach (Figure 1). Material properties were estimated from the CT dataset and loads representing walking and stair climbing were applied [1]. Stress-shielding was evaluated by the change in average strain energy density pre- and post-operatively in three different regions (calcar, midstem, tip) each being subdivided in four quarters (medial, lateral, anterior, posterior) (Figure 2). Results. Stress shielding in the proximal femur was seen in all models, especially in the calcar-medial region. In that region, the largest variation in stress shielding was observed for the models with an atypical NSA, ranging from 57% to 96%. The lowest amount was found in a patient with an average NSA (124°), and the highest amount was found in a patient with a small NSA (109°) (Figure 2). In the models selected for their varying neck lengths, calcar-medial stress shielding increased from 69% (NL 53 mm) to 97% (NL 66 mm). Stress shielding was least sensitive to variations in AV, ranging from 79% to 92%. Similar patterns were observed for walking and stair climbing loads. Discussion. Stress shielding was smallest in femurs where the load-transfer between implant and bone was located more proximally, while higher levels of stress shielding occurred when the load transfer was more pronounced at the tip of the stem (Figure 3). Two femurs with an average NSA and NL showed substantially lower stress shielding than the 16 other femurs. This may suggest that the calcar guided Optimys short stem prevents stress shielding especially in average femurs, but less so in atypical femurs. Hence, a larger study population should be investigated to support this hypothesis. For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 96-B, Issue SUPP_12 | Pages 95 - 95
1 Jul 2014
Rodriguez J
Full Access

The use of tapered, fluted, modular, distally fixing stems has increased in femoral revision surgery. The goal of this retrospective study was to assess mid- to long-term outcomes of this implant in femoral revision with bone loss. Seventy-one hips in 70 patients with a mean age of 68.5 years were followed for an average of 10 years. Pre-operative HHS averaged 50 and improved to an average of 87 post-operatively. Seventy-nine percent hips had Paprosky type 3A, 3B or 4 bone-loss and 44% had an associated proximal femoral osteotomy. All stems osseointegrated distally (100%). Two hips subsided >5mm (mean 8mm) but achieved secondary stability. Sixty-eight percent hips had evidence of bony reconstitution and 21% demonstrated diaphyseal stress-shielding. One stem fractured at its modular junction and was revised with a mechanical failure rate of 1.4%. Distal fixation and clinical improvement were reproducibly achieved with this stem design


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_9 | Pages 83 - 83
1 May 2016
Christiansen J Nielsen P Laursen M Blunn G
Full Access

Introduction. The Primoris® femoral stem was designed to preserve bone and maintain normal stress to the proximal femur, thereby minimizing stress-shielding. The implant is anchored in the femoral neck and metaphysis without diaphysial involvement and differs from other neck prothesis by: a) Elliptical shape to fit the inner neck dimensions. b) On top of Ti– porous-coating electrochemically deposited hydroxy apatite (Bonemaster®) c) The surgical technique aims to enhance initial implant stability by compaction of neck and metaphyseal cancellous bone. Objectives. As part of stepwise introduction to monitor bone remodeling, RSA data and clinical results. Methods. A prospective cohort study of 52 patients (Female = 55 years or younger, Male = 65 years or younger) with end stage non inflammatory osteoarthritis and no anatomical abnormality was carried out. Clinical data (HHS score, UCLA, and verbal satisfaction score) were collected regularly and compared with patients who in a previous study had a conventional femoral stem (Bimetric®). Furthermore serial DXA scans and RSA analysis were performed. Results. Two patients were excluded during surgery (one major neck deformity, one insufficient bony support). One neck fracture (not compromising implant stability). One was revised in the follow period (aseptic loosening). The mean HHS score increased from 54 (median) preoperatively to 95 at one year and 95 at two years. These results favourably compared with the Bimetric group. DXA scans revealed no bone loss in femoral diaphysis and minimum bone loss at the area of calcar. RSA revealed stable bone implant bond. Conclusions. The early clinical results are encouraging and favourably comparable to the clinical results with a conventional uncemented femoral implant. As part of the stepwise introduction process this clinical step I study justifies further clinical evaluation before the implant is introduced in a wider population


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_15 | Pages 74 - 74
1 Aug 2017
Walter W
Full Access

Ceramic-on-ceramic bearings provide a solution to the osteolysis seen with traditional metal-on-polyethylene bearings. Sporadic reports of ceramic breakage and squeaking concern some surgeons and this bearing combination can show in vivo signs of edge loading wear which was not predicted from in vitro studies. Taper damage or debris in the taper between the ceramic and metal may lead to breakage of either a ceramic head or insert. Fastidious surgical technique may help to minimise the risk of ceramic breakage. Squeaking is usually a benign complication, most frequently occurring when the hip is fully flexed. Rarely, it can occur with each step of walking when it can be sufficiently troublesome to require revision surgery. The etiology of squeaking is multifactorial origin. Taller, heavier and younger patients with higher activity levels are more prone to hips that squeak. Cup version and inclination are also relevant factors. Fifty-five ceramic bearings revised at our center were collected over 12 years. Median time to revision was 2.7 years. Forty-six (84%) cases had edge loading wear. The median femoral head wear volume overall was 0.2mm. 3. /yr, for anterosuperior edge loading was 2.0mm. 3. /yr, and the median volumetric wear rate for posterior edge loading was 0.15mm. 3. /yr (p=0.005). Osteolysis following metal-on-polyethylene total hip arthroplasty (THA) is well reported. Earlier generation ceramic-on-ceramic bearings did produce some osteolysis, but in flawed implants. As 3rd and now 4th generation ceramic THAs come into mid- and long-term service, the orthopaedic community has begun to see reports of high survival rates and very low incidence of osteolysis in these bearings. The technique used by radiologists for identifying the nature of lesions on Computed Tomography (CT) scan is the Hounsfield score which will identify the density of the tissue within the lucent area. Commonly the radiologist will have no access to previous imaging, especially pre-operative imaging if a long time has elapsed. With such a low incidence of osteolysis in this patient group, what, then, should a surgeon do on receiving a CT report on a ceramic-on-ceramic THA, which states there is osteolysis? This retrospective review aims to determine the accuracy of CT in identifying true osteolysis in a cohort of long-term 3rd generation ceramic-on-ceramic uncemented hip arthroplasties in our department. Methods. Pelvic CT scans were performed on the first 27 patients from a cohort of 301 patients undergoing 15-year review with 3rd generation alumina-alumina cementless THAs. The average follow-up was 15 years (15–17). The CT scans were reviewed against pre-operative and post-operative radiographs and reviewed by a second musculoskeletal specialist radiologist. Results. Eleven of the CT scans were reported to show acetabular osteolysis, two reported osteolysis or possible pre-existing cyst and one reported a definitive pre-existing cyst. After review of previous imaging including pre-operative radiographs, eleven of the thirteen patients initially reported to have osteolysis were found to have pre-existing cysts or geodes in the same size and position as the reported osteolysis, and a further patient had spot-welds with stress-shielding. One patient with evidence of true osteolysis awaits aspiration or biopsy to determine if he has evidence of ceramic wear or metallosis. Conclusions. Reports of osteolysis on CT should be interpreted with care in modern ceramic-on-ceramic THA to prevent unnecessary revision. Further imaging and investigations may be necessary to exclude other conditions such as geodes, or stress shielding which are frequently confused with osteolysis on CT scans


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_3 | Pages 136 - 136
1 Feb 2017
Ghouse S van Arkel R Babu S Nai K Hooper P Jeffers J
Full Access

Orthopaedic reconstruction procedures to combat osteoarthritis, inflammatory arthritis, metabolic bone disease and other musculoskeletal disorders have increased dramatically, resulting in high demand on the advancement of bone implant technology. In the past, joint replacement operations were commonly performed primarily on elderly patients, in view of the prosthesis survivorship. With the advances in surgical techniques and prosthesis technology, younger patients are undergoing surgeries for both local tissue defects and joint replacements. This patient group is now more active and functionally more demanding after surgery. Today, implanted prostheses need to be more durable (load-bearing), they need to better match the patient's original biomechanics and be able to survive longer. Additive manufacturing (AM) provides new possibilities to further combat the problem of stress-shielding and promote better bone remodelling/ingrowth and thus long term fixation. This can be accomplished by matching the varying strain response (stiffness) of trabecular or subchondral bone locally at joints. The purpose of this research is therefore to determine whether a porous structure can be produced that can match the required behaviour and properties of trabecular bone regardless of skeletal location and can it be incorporated into a long-term implant. A stochastic structure visually similar to trabecular bone was designed and optimised for AM (Figure 1) and produced over a range of porosities in multiple materials, Stainless Steel 316, Titanium (Grade 23 – Ti6Al4V ELI) and Commercially Pure Titanium (Grade 2) using a Renishaw AM250 metal additive manufacturing system. Over 150 cylindrical specimens were produced per material and subjected to a compression test to determine the specimens' Elastic Modulus (Stiffness) and Compressive Yield Strength. Micro-CT scans and gravimetric analysis were also performed to determine and validate the specimens' porosity. Results were then graphed on a Strength vs. Stiffness Ashby plot (Figure 2) comparing the values to those of trabecular bone in the tibia and femur. It was found that AM can produce porous structures with an elastic modulus as low as 100 MPa up to 2.7 GPa (the highest stiffness investigated in this study). Titanium structures with a stiffness <500MPa had compressive strengths towards the bottom range of similar stiffness trabecular bone. Between 500 MPa − 1 GPa Titanium AM porous structures match the compressive strength of equivalent stiffness trabecular bone and from 1 GPa − 2 GPa the Ti structures exceed the strength of equivalent stiffness trabecular bone up to ∼2.5 times and consequently increase by a power law. These results show that AM can produce structures with similar stiffness to trabecular bone over a range of skeletal locations whilst matching or exceeding the compressive strength of bone. The results have not yet taken into account fatigue life with the fatigue life of these types of structures tending to be between 0.1 – 0.4 of their compressive strength. This means that a titanium porous structure would need to be 2.5 – 10 times stiffer or stronger than the portion of trabecular bone it is replacing. This data is highly encouraging for AM manufactured, bone stiffness matched implant technology


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXV | Pages 245 - 245
1 Jun 2012
Deshmukh A Rodriguez J Klauser W Rasquinha V Lubinus P Ranawat C Thakur R
Full Access

Introduction. Studies have documented encouraging results with the use of fluted, tapered, modular, titanium stems in revision hip arthroplasty with bone loss. However, radiographic signs of osseointegration and patterns of reconstitution have not been previously categorized. Materials and Methods. 64 consecutive hips with index femoral revision using a particular stem of this design formed the study cohort. Serial radiographs were retrospectively reviewed by an independent observer. Bone loss was determined by Paprosky's classification. Osseointegration was assessed by a slight modification of the criteria of Engh et al. Femoral restoration was classified according to Kolstad et al. Pain and function was documented using Harris Hip Score (HHS). Results. Mean patient age was 68.3 years and radiographic follow-up 6.2 years. 74% femora had type 3 or 4 bone loss. All distal segments were radiographically osseointegrated. Proximal segment radiolucent lines were frequent (40%). Early minor subsidence occured in 4 (6.2%) hips. Definite bony regeneration was documented in 73% femora and stress-shielding in 26%. HHS improved from a pre-operative mean of 50.1 points to 86.2 at most recent follow-up. Discussion. A consistent pattern of bony remodeling and osseointegration occurred which could be applied for assessment of fixation and stability of this stem. The well established criteria of osseointegration for cylindrical cobalt-chrome stems may have to be altered for application to these stems as the mechanism of load transfer is entirely different. Stems with diameter of 18mm or greater are clearly predisposed to stress shielding, predominantly at the mid-shaft region


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 62 - 62
1 Jan 2016
Burns S Soler JA Cuffolo G Sharma A Kalairajah Y
Full Access

Introduction. Acetabular revision for cavitary defects in failed total hip replacement remains a challenge for the orthopaedic surgeon. Bone graft with cemented or uncemented revision is the primary solution; however, there are cases where structural defects are too large. Cup cage constructs have been successful in treating these defects but they do have their problems with early loosening and metalwork failure. Recently, highly porous cups that incorporate metal augments have been developed to achieve greater intra-operative stability showing encouraging results. Methods. Retrospective analysis of twenty-six consecutive acetabular revisions with Trabecular Titanium cups. Inclusion criteria included aseptic cases, adult patients, end-stage disease with signs of loosening, no trauma nor peri-prosthetic fractures. Data was obtained for patient demographics, Paprosky classification, use of bone graft, use of acetabular augment, and Moore index of osseointegration. Results. Twenty-six subjects were included in the study. Four patients were lost to follow up due to death. The average age was 73 (range 50–91) with 16 females and 10 males. The Paprosky classification was as follows: type I=7 (26.9%), type IIa=7 (26.9%), type IIb=4 (15.4%), type IIc=2 (7.7%), type IIIa=6 (23%). The Moore index at 6 months was as follows: type I=2 (7.7%), type II=4 (15.4%), type III=8 (30.1%), type IV= 6 (23%), type V=3 (11.5%), no data =3 (11.5). At 12 months: type I=0, type II=2 (7.7%), type III=5 (19.2%), type IV=7 (26.9%), type V=4 (15.4%), no data = 8 (4 no radiographs and 4 deceased). Augments were used in 8 patients. All cups implanted had supplemented screw fixation. Discussion. Revision acetabular surgery for aseptic loosening remains a challenge, particularly with cavitary defects. Success of surgery depends on solid fixation at the time of implantation and good, rapid osseointegration. With cavitary defects, stability of the implant becomes an issue, needing implants capable of filling the defects, with good porosity and enough surface roughness to achieve early stability. We found the Trabecular Titanium cup to have very high porosity and surface roughness allowing very good and stable fixation. The use of augments did not affect the initial stability of the implant. The Moore index of osseointegration reliably detects bony ingrowth of the cup of radiographic analysis by assessing (1) absence of radiolucent lines; (2) presence of a superolateral buttress; (3) medial stress-shielding; (4) radial trabeculae; and (5) an inferomedial buttress. Each sign had a high PPV for the presence of bone ingrowth. Ninety-seven percent of cups with three to five signs were ingrown, whereas 83% of cups with one or no signs were unstable. With three or more signs present, the PPV was 96.9%, the sensitivity was 89.6%, and specificity was 76.9%. In our study, 61.5% of patients had 3 signs or more and 69.2% of patients had 2 signs or more at 12 months. Conclusion. The Trabecular Titanium. TM. cup demonstrates good initial stability at implantation, and at twelve-months excellent osseointegration. These results are comparable to published results for similar trabecular cup designs. Further long-term studies are welcome and we continue to monitor this group of patients


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 95-B, Issue SUPP_19 | Pages 16 - 16
1 Apr 2013
Shah A Badge R Joshi Y Choudhary N Sochart D
Full Access

Introduction. Negative remodelling of the femoral cortex in the form of calcar resorption due to stress shielding and cortical hypertrophy at the level of the tip of the implant, due to distal load transfer, is frequently noted following cemented total hip replacement, most commonly with composite beam implants, but also with polished double tapers. The C-stem polished femoral component was designed with a third taper running from lateral to medial across and along the entire length of the implant, with the aim of achieving more proximal and therefore more natural loading of the femur. The hoop stresses generated in the cement mantle are transferred to the proximal bone starting at the calcar, which should theoretically minimise stress-shielding and calcar resorption, as well as reducing distal load transfer, as signified by the development of distal femoral cortical hypertrophy. Materials/Methods. We present the results of a consecutive series of 500 total hip replacements performed between March 2000 and December 2005 at a single institution, using a standard surgical technique and third generation cementing with Palacos-R antibiotic loaded cement. Data was collected prospectively and the patients remain under annual follow-up. 500 arthroplasties were performed on 455 patients with an average age of 68.3 years (23–92). 77 patients have died (73 arthroplasties) and the average duration of follow-up for the entire series is 81 months (52–124). Results. Only 2 femoral implants have been revised - one for deep sepsis and the other as part of a revision procedure for a loose acetabulum, although the femoral component itself was not loose. One implant is currently loose following a periprosthetic fracture treated by internal fixation, but none of the other remaining implants demonstrates any progressive radiolucencies in any Gruen zones, or any features suggestive of current or future loosening. Rounding of the calcar has been observed, but there have been no cases with obvious loss of calcar height and no cases of distal femoral cortical hypertrophy. Conclusion. The C-stem femoral component has therefore performed well in clinical practice and the objective of eradicating negative bone remodelling has been achieved. The study is ongoing


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 95-B, Issue SUPP_34 | Pages 304 - 304
1 Dec 2013
Arno S Fetto J Bell C Papadopoulos K Walker P
Full Access

INTRODUCTION:. The purpose of this study was to determine if a short femoral stem (Lima Corporate, Udine, Italy) would result in a strain distribution which mimicked the intact bone better than a traditional length stem, thereby eliminating the potential for stress-shielding. METHODS:. A 2 mm thick moldable plastic (PL-1, Vishay Micromeasurements, Raleigh, NC) was contoured to six fourth-generation composite femoral bones (Pacific Research Laboratories, Vashon, WA). The intact femurs were then loaded (82 kg) in a rig which simulated mid-stance single limb support phase of gait (Figure 1). During testing, the femurs were viewed and video recorded through a model 031 reflection polariscope. Observing the photoelastic coating through the polariscope, a series of fringes could be seen, which represented the difference in principal strain along the femur. The fringes were quantified using Fringe Order, N, as per the manufacturers technical notes. In order to analyze the strain distribution, the femur was separated into 6 zones, 3 lateral and 3 medial, and the maximum fringe order determined. Upon completion of testing of the intact femur, the short length femoral stem was inserted and tested, and finally the traditional length femoral stem was inserted and tested. Anterior and lateral radiographs were obtained of the femur with each femoral stem in order to confirm proper alignment. RESULTS:. Fringes formed in a similar pattern for all femurs, intact and with stems. The fringes first occurred medially and laterally in a proximal-distal direction and radiated outward, decreasing in fringe order, toward the neutral axis of bending (anterior and posterior). The magnitude of the fringe order, N, remained the same or increased in the proximal to distal direction. This became more prominent, particularly on the lateral side, with the traditional length femoral stem, when a distal migration of the fringes was seen compared to the intact femur (Figures 2 and 3). Medially, with the traditional length femoral stem, the fringes remained but were of a lower magnitude than the intact femur. The femoral strain pattern, resulting from implantation of the short length femoral stem, was found to closely match the intact femur. X-rays confirmed proper alignment of all implants. CONCLUSIONS:. The distal migration of strain seen with the traditional length femoral stem was indicative of potential stress shielding. As an alternative, this study suggests that the short length femoral stem most closely replicates the strain distribution of the intact femur and may limit this type of failure


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 77 - 77
1 Mar 2012
Vidalain J
Full Access

Introduction. Bio-active fixation has increasingly gained acceptance over the last two decades. However extent of the coating is still a subject of debate. We introduced in 1986, the concept of total osteointegration of a tapered stem with the hope that we could achieve durable biological fixation while preserving normal periprosthetic bone trophicity. Material and methods. Patients from our first clinical series using this stem are now eligible for 18-year follow up. Between July 1986 and December 1990, we performed 615 THA using the Corail stem (DePuy). Corail is a straight tapered stem totally coated with a 150 μ thick layer of HA following an atmospheric plasma-spray process. The mean age at surgery was 64.5 (range 16 to 95). 242 patients are now deceased (39%), 62 patients (10%) are lost to follow-up. The mean follow-up for 243 living patients on file is 17.7 years. Results. 89 THAs required component revisions: 72 cups, 9 stems, 8 “cups and stems”. 8 cups and 4 stems have been revised for aseptic loosening. Owing to the high incidence of wear-related revision, Kaplan-Meïer survivorship at 18-year follow-up, using component revision for any reason as an endpoint, was 80.7 ± 3.3 (95% confidence intervals). In contrast, Corail stem survivorship, using stem removal for any reason as an endpoint, was 95.0% ± 3.0 at 18-year follow-up, and considering aseptic loosening only, the survival probability of the stem is 98.9% ± 1.1 at 18 years. Discussion and conclusions. Therefore, despite wear and proximal osteolysis, the fixation achieved with this totally HA-coated stem remained durable through 18-year follow-up. Regarding the periprosthetic remodelling during this period, modifications of the bone pattern have been strictly limited: slight resorption at the calcar level, absence of cortical hypertrophy, anecdotic significant stress-shielding. The radiological silence is one of the paramount facts demonstrated by this prospective study