Aims. Early large treatment effects can arise in small studies, which lessen as more data accumulate. This study aimed to retrospectively examine whether early treatment effects occurred for two multicentre orthopaedic randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and explore biases related to this. Methods. Included RCTs were ProFHER (PROximal Fracture of the Humerus: Evaluation by Randomisation), a two-arm study of surgery versus non-surgical treatment for proximal humerus fractures, and UK FROST (United Kingdom Frozen Shoulder Trial), a three-arm study of two surgical and one non-surgical treatment for frozen shoulder. To determine whether early treatment effects were present, the primary outcome of Oxford Shoulder Score (OSS) was compared on forest plots for: the chief investigator’s (CI) site to the remaining sites, the first five sites opened to the other sites, and patients grouped in quintiles by randomization date. Potential for bias was assessed by comparing mean age and proportion of patients with indicators of poor outcome between included and excluded/non-consenting participants. Results. No bias in treatment effect was observed overall for the CI site, or the first five sites, compared with the remaining sites in either trial. An early treatment effect on the OSS was observed for the first quintile of participants recruited to ProFHER only (clinically relevant difference of seven points). Selection bias for age was observed in the ProFHER trial only, with slightly younger patients being recruited into the study. Both trials showed some selection bias for markers of poor
Background. Recently, a larger number of elderly individuals with osteoporosis has undergone total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Intuitively, such vulnerable bone condition should deteriorate post-TKA functional recovery compared to a non-osteoporotic condition, but this hypothesis has not been directly examined. Methods. To address this issue, we analysed
Radial head fractures are common and mainly require a functional conservative treatment. About 20% of patients will present an unsatisfactory final functional result. There is, however, little data allowing us to predict which patients are at risk of bad evolve. This makes it difficult to optimize our therapeutic strategies in these patients. The aim of this study is to determine the personal and environmental factors that influence the functional
The aim of this study is to determine evidence-based guidelines on functional outcomes following common thoracolumbar injuries using a synthesis of systematic literature reviews and consensus expert opinion. A questionnaire was created comprising five cases representative of common thoracolumbar injuries (a thoracic compression fracture, a flexion distraction injury and burst fractures each with varied location, patient demographics and treatment strategies). For each scenario five questions about expected functional outcomes were posed. Questionnaires were distributed to the Spine Trauma Study Group. Responses were combined with available data from a systematic review of the same injuries and outcomes to create consensus evidence based guidelines. The survey was completed by 31 (57%) of 53 surgeons representing 20 centres across North America. The systematic reviews identified 49 appropriate studies. One year following a L1 burst fracture, a heavy laborer, treated with protective mobilization (cast or brace) has a 40% chance of being pain free, 70% chance of regaining pre-injury range of motion, can expect to be re-employed within 4–6 months and be able to participate in high impact exercise and contact sport with no or minimal limitation. Length of inpatient stay averages 4–5 days. One year following posterior short segment stabilization of a L1 bust fracture in a college football player, there is an expected 45% chance of being pain free and 55% chance of regaining pre-injury ROM. While an ultimate return to high impact exercise and contact sports is anticipated, 32% of experts expect the injury to end a college football career. Results for the other trauma scenarios are included. This combination of literature and expert opinion represents the best available evidence on functional
Of those foot and ankle injuries requiring radiographs based on the Ottawa Foot and Ankle Rules only approximately 22% will have a fracture. This diagnostic cohort study examined if ultrasound could detect acute non-bony foot and ankle injuries. Ottawa Rules positive patients over 16 years were eligible. An ED member performed scans for injury of tendons and ligaments blind to radiograph findings. Patients without fracture were re-scanned at 2 weeks. The Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS), a validated, patient-reported outcome measure, was completed at baseline (based on pre-injury status), 2 and 6 weeks. 110 subjects participated. 99 did not have significant radiological fractures. FAOS scores were significantly different at 2 weeks compared with baseline across all subscales (p< 0.000). At 6 weeks a significant difference persisted between scores for the ‘Pain’, ‘Sport’ and ‘QOL’ subscales (p<0.043, p<0.000, p<0.000 respectively) compared with baseline. Initial post-injury USS Anterior Talofibular Ligament (ATFL) findings were significantly predictive of FAOS Subscale results for ‘Symptoms’, ‘Sport’ and ‘QOL’ - respective p values being p<0.004 95% CI (−20.184, −4.402), p<0.029 95% CI (−31.857, −1.896) and p<0.008 95% CI (−32.118, −5.561). ATFL ultrasound status at the time of injury predicts patient perceived sporting function at 6 weeks.
Radiation induced sarcoma of bone is a rare but challenging disease process associated with a poor
Medical Genetics is a transversal discipline with the potential to impact on every specialty and subspecialty in medicine and the allied health sciences. The completion of the human genome project resulted in technical advancements in genomics, genomic testing and our understanding of genetic disorders in general. These advancements have greatly enhanced our understanding of the role of genetics in Orthopaedic practice, with respect to both monogenic and complex disorders. Tygerberg Hospital is currently the only state hospital in South Africa to support genetic testing in the form of gene panels as part of routine care. This is complemented by more comprehensive research testing in the form of exome and genome sequencing as part of the Undiagnosed Disease Programme. We audit the genetic and genomic testing done on patients referred from the Orthopaedic clinic over a period of 3 years (2020–2022) and review diagnostic rates and interesting results. The largest group of patients referred (n=50) had a clinical diagnosis of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). A 100% diagnostic yield was achieved for these patients with the identification of recurring variants (FKBP10, COL1A2). Further families (n=20) with much rarer conditions are presented with important implications on the orthopaedic and medical management,
Shoulder septic arthritis is uncommon and frequently misdiagnosed, resulting in severe consequences. This study evaluated the demographics, bacteriological profile, antibiotic susceptibility, treatment regimens, and clinical outcomes. This is a 10-year retrospective observational analysis of 30 patients (20 males and 10 females) who were treated for septic arthritis of the shoulder. The data collecting process utilised clinical records, laboratory archives, and x-ray archives. We gathered demographic information, pre- and post-intervention clinical data, serum biochemical markers, and the results of imaging examinations. All patients had a surgical arthrotomy and joint debridement in the operating room, and specimens were taken for culture and sensitivity testing. The specimens were cultivated for at least seventy-two hours. Shoulder joint ranges of motion, comorbidities, and the presence of osteomyelitis were assessed clinically to determine the outcome. All statistical analyses were conducted using the STATA 17 statistical software. Analysis of correlation between categorical variables was performed using the chi-squared test. The majority of the study patients were black Africans (97%). The age range of the group was from 8 days to 17 years. At presentation, 33% of patients had a low-grade fever, whereas the majority (60%) had normal body temperature. The average length of symptoms was 3.9 days (ranged from 1 day to 15 days), and the majority of patients had an increased white cell count (83%) and C-reactive protein (98%). There was accumulation of fluid in the joint of all individuals who received shoulder ultrasound imaging. We noted a significant incidence of gram-positive cocci, which were mostly susceptible to first-line antibiotics. Shoulder stiffness affected 63% of patients and chronic osteomyelitis affected 50% of individuals. Neither the severity nor the duration of the symptoms was related to an increased risk of osteomyelitis. The results of this study revealed that the clinical characteristics and bacterial profile of septic arthritis of the shoulder conform to typical patterns. The likelihood of osteomyelitis and an unfavourable
Aim. To describe the impact of a failed DAIR in the further
The Lisfranc fracture dislocation of the tarsometatarsal joint (TMTJ) is a complex injury with a reported incidence of 9.2 to 14/100,000 person-years. Lisfranc fixation involves dorsal bridge plating, transarticular screws, combination or primary arthrodesis. We aimed to identify predictors of poor patient reported outcome measures at long term follow up after operative intervention. 127 patients underwent Lisfranc fixation at our Level One Trauma Centre between November 2007 and July 2013. At mean follow-up of 10.7 years (8.0-13.9), 85 patients (66.92%) were successfully contacted. Epidemiological data including age, gender and mechanism of injury and fracture characteristics such as number of columns injured, direction of subluxation/dislocation and classification based on those proposed by Hardcastle and Lau were recorded. Descriptive analysis was performed to compare our primary outcomes (AOFAS and FFI scores). Univariate analysis and multivariate regression analysis was done adjusted for age and sex to compare the entirety of our data set. P<0.05 was considered significant. The primary outcomes were the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) Midfoot Score and the Foot Function Index (FFI). The number of columns involved in the injury best predicts functional outcomes (FFI, P <0.05, AOFAS, P<0.05) with more columns involved resulting in poorer outcomes. Functional outcomes were not significantly associated with any of the fixation groups (FFI, P = 0.21, AOFAS, P = 0.14). Injury type by Myerson classification systems (FFI, P = 0.17, AOFAS, P = 0.58) or open versus closed status (FFI, P = 0.29, AOFAS, P = 0.20) was also not significantly associated with any fixation group. We concluded that 10 years post-surgery, patients generally had a good functional outcome with minimal complications.
Numerous prediction tools are available for estimating postoperative risk following spine surgery. External validation studies have shown mixed results. We present the development, validation, and comparative evaluation of novel tool (NZSpine) for modelling risk of complications within 30 days of spine surgery. Data was gathered retrospectively from medical records of patients who underwent spine surgery at Waikato Hospital between January 2019 and December 2020 (n = 488). Variables were selected a priori based on previous evidence and clinical judgement. Postoperative adverse events were classified objectively using the Comprehensive Complication Index. Models were constructed for the occurrence of any complication and significant complications (based on CCI >26). Performance and clinical utility of the novel model was compared against SpineSage (. https://depts.washington.edu/spinersk/. ), an extant online tool which we have shown in unpublished work to be valid in our local population. Overall complication rate was 34%. In the multivariate model, higher age, increased surgical invasiveness and the presence of preoperative anemia were most strongly predictive of any postoperative complication (OR = 1.03, 1.09, 2.1 respectively, p <0.001), whereas the occurrence of a major postoperative complication (CCI >26) was most strongly associated with the presence of respiratory disease (OR = 2.82, p <0.001). Internal validation using the bootstrapped models showed the model was robust, with an AUC of 0.73. Using sensitivity analysis, 80% of the model's predictions were correct. By comparison SpineSage had an AUC of 0.71, and in decision curve analysis the novel model showed greater expected benefit at all thresholds of risk. NZSpine is a novel risk assessment tool for patients undergoing acute and elective spine surgery and may help inform clinicians and patients of their
Aim. Prosthetic joint infection (PJI) due to Candida spp. is a severe complication of arthroplasty but is little reported. This study describes Candida PJI epidemiology, management, and outcome. Method. We performed a retrospective, observational multinational study with support of the European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases (ESCMID). Patients diagnosed with PJI due to Candida spp. between 1990 and 2021 were included. Demographic, clinical, laboratory, imaging, medical/surgical treatment, and outcome data were collected within a standardized database. Treatment failure was defined either as a Candida infection recurrence, superinfection, or death due to infection. Results. Data from 151 patients across 18 centers were analyzed. Mean age was 69.5 ± 13.1yo, 78 (51.7%) patients were male, and 21 (13.9%) were immunosuppressed. Site of infection included hip (55.0%), knee (41.7%), shoulder (2.6%), and femur (0.7%). Twenty-five (16.6%) patients were febrile, and 58 (38.4%) had fistula. Mean number of previous surgeries on the same anatomical site was 3.3±2.3. Surgeries were DAIR (33.8%), one-stage exchange (19.9%), two-stage exchange (39.1%), and implant removal (6.0%). Candida species identified were C. albicans (60.3%), C. parapsilosis (26.5%), C. glabrata (7.3%), and C. tropicalis (5.3%). Co-infection with bacteria was found in 69 (45.7%) cases. Fluconazole (62.9%) and caspofungin (14.6%) were the main antifungal agents prescribed for 148.6 ± 167.5 days. Favorable outcome was found in 54/144 (37.5%) cases. Failure was associated with the number of previous surgeries (OR 1.249, 95%CI 1.061–1.469; p-value=0.007), while treatment by fluconazole was associated with cure (OR 0.336, 95%CI 0.160–0.707; p-value=0.004). Conclusions. This study provides epidemiologic and outcome data on Candida PJIs. Although poor overall, the
Aim. Our aim was to evaluate the prevalence and impact of unexpected intraoperative cultures on the outcome of total presumed aseptic knee and hip revision surgery. Method. Data regarding patients prospectively recruited in our center, who had undergone elective complete hip and knee revision surgery from January 2003 to July 2017 with a preoperative diagnosis of aseptic loosening was retrospectively reviewed. Partial revisions and patients with follow up below 60 months were excluded from the study. The protocol of revision included at least 3 intraoperative cultures. Failure was defined as the need for re-revision due to any-cause at 5 years and/or the need for antibiotic suppressive therapy. Results. A total of 608 cases were initially included in the study, 53 patients were excluded. 123 hip and 432 knee revision surgeries were included. 420 cases (75.7%) had all cultures negative, 114 (20.5%) a single positive culture or two of different microorganisms and 21 (3.8%) had at least 2 positive cultures for the same microorganism. Early failure was found in 4.8% (1/21) of the patients with missed low grade infection. The presence of positive cultures during total exchange was not associated with a higher failure rate than in those with negative cultures (44 of 420, 10.5%). In contrast, patients revised before 24 months had a significant higher rate of re-revision, 18% (15/83) vs. 8.4%. Conclusions. Total hip and knee revisions with unexpected positive cultures were not significantly associated with a higher re-revision risk at 5 years of follow-up. Representing an overall good
As the field of hip arthroscopy continues to develop, functional measures and testing become increasingly important in patient selection, managing patient expectations prior to surgery, and physical readiness for return to athletic participation. The Hip Sport Test (HST) was developed to assess strength, coordination, agility, and range of motion prior to and following hip arthroscopy as a functional assessment. However, the relationship between HST and hip strength, range of motion, and hip-specific patient reported outcome (PRO) measures have not been investigated. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the correlation between the HST scores and measurements of hip strength and range of motion prior to undergoing hip arthroscopy. Between September 2009 and January 2017, patients aged 18-40 who underwent primary hip arthroscopy for the treatment of femoroacetabular impingement with available pre-operative HST, dynamometry, range of motion, and functional scores (mHHS, WOMAC, HOS-SSS) were identified. Patients were excluded if they were 40 years old, had a Tegner activity score < 7, or did not have HST and dynamometry evaluations within one week of each other. Muscle strength scores were compared between affected and unaffected side to establish a percent difference with a positive score indicating a weaker affected limb and a negative score indicating a stronger affected limb. Correlations were made between HST and strength testing, range of motion, and PROs. A total of 350 patients met inclusion criteria. The average age was 26.9 ± 6.5 years, with 34% females and 36% professional athletes. Total and component HST scores were significantly associated with measure of strength most strongly for flexion (rs = −0.20, p < 0 .001), extension (rs = −0.24, p<.001) and external rotation (rs = −0.20, p < 0 .001). Lateral and diagonal agility, components of HST, were also significantly associated with muscle strength imbalances between internal rotation versus external rotation (rs = −0.18, p=0.01) and flexion versus extension (rs = 0.12, p=0.03). In terms of range of motion, a significant correlation was detected between HST and internal rotation (rs = −0.19, p < 0 .001). Both the total and component HST scores were positively correlated with pre-operative mHHS, WOMAC, and HOS-SSS (p<.001 for all rs). The Hip Sport Test correlates with strength, range of motion, and PROs in the preoperative setting of hip arthroscopy. This test alone and in combination with other diagnostic examinations can provide valuable information about initial hip function and patient
Aim. This study seeks to outline the clinical, laboratory, and imaging features of patients with pyogenic spondylitis. It aims to define a novel imaging sign that could indicate the severity of suppurative spondylitis, aiding in its early diagnosis and treatment. Method. This retrospective study included 137 patients from 2013 to 2023. Through the analysis and summary of imaging characteristics among all patients, we identified a distinct MRI sign known as ‘the Disc Penetration sign’ (DP). This sign is defined as an image finding on sagittal MRI depicting the anterior and posterior penetration of an abscess through the intervertebral disc space, affecting both the anterior margin of the vertebrae and the structures within the spinal canal. Observational parameters included WBC, ESR, CRP, hemoglobin, and albumin levels. Documentation of the study included location and segment of the lesion, presence or absence of spinal cord compression, and paravertebral abscesses. Results. 56 patients presented with the Disc Penetration sign(DP) and 81 did not. In both groups, there were no significant differences in gender ratio or age (P > 0.05). However, significant differences were observed in the presence of comorbid diabetes and chronic kidney disease (p < 0.05). The DP group had a significantly greater ESR level (74.30±33.79 mm/h vs. 51.46±30.46 mm/h, P < 0.001) and CRP level (47.28 mg/L vs. 26.18 mg/L, P = 0.003). Additionally, the DP group had a significantly lower Hb (100.66±19.82 g/L vs. 116.99±19.99g/L,P < 0.001) and the serum albumin level (28.81±6.59 g/L vs. 34.09±6.17 g/L,P < 0.001). Imaging results showed no significant differences in affected spinal segments or parts (p>0.05). Patients in the DP group showed a higher likelihood of developing paravertebral abscesses compared to those in the non-DP group (n = 54 [96.4%] vs. n = 33 [40.7%], P < 0.001), and also exhibited a higher incidence of spinal cord compression(n = 32 [57.1%] vs. n = 17 [21.0%], P < 0.001). Conclusions. The study suggests that the Disc Penetration sign in pyogenic spondylitis patients correlates with more severe inflammation and higher incidence of paraspinal abscess, pointing to worse stability of the spine, longer bone restructuring time, and potentially poorer
The poor
Background. Acromegaly, which stems from high level of serum growth hormone secreted by a benign tumour in the anterior pituitary gland, is likely to cause severe peripheral joint pains due to hypertrophic changes in such joints. Recently, the life expectancy of such patients has been improved and more patients with acromegaly have undergone joint surgeries to mitigate joint pain and malfunctions. However, little is known about to what extent surgical procedures can improve the joint functions of acromegalic patients compared to non-acromegalic cases. Methods. First, we qualitatively analysed
Aim. A significant number of patients undergoing shoulder arthroplasty surgery have C acnes contamination at the end of the primary surgery. The objective of this study is to determine whether patients with C acnes contamination at the end of their primary shoulder surgery have a worse
Introduction. Despite all modern advances the indications and possibilities of treatment in Legg-Calvé-Perthes Disease (LCPD) are still controversial. In the past 15 years we started using arthrodiastasis of the hip creating negative pressure over the avascular femoral head in some selected cases of LCPD in the active phasis of the disease. Now we present our experience with distraction in LCPD using the original Ilizarov circular frame for the hip. Materials and Methods. From 2015 to 2021, eight patients with LCPD were submoitted to hip distraction; all male ranging from six to 12 years (avg 8.2 years). All patients with bad
Introduction. Fibrous dysplasia is a pathological condition, where normal medullary bone is replaced by fibrous tissue and small, woven specules of bone. Fibrous dysplasia can occur in epiphysis, metaphysis or diaphysis. Occationally, biopsy is necessary to establish the diagnosis. We present a review of operative treatment using the Ilizarov technique. The management of tibial fibrous dysplasia in children are curettage or subperiosteal resection to extra periosteal wide resection followed by bone transport. Materials and Methods. A total of 18 patients were treated between 2010 – 2020; 12 patients came with pain and 6 with pain and deformity. All patients were treated by Ilizarov technique. Age ranges from 4–14 years. 12 patients by enbloc excision and bone transportation and 6 patients were treated by osteotomy at the true apex of the deformity by introducing the k/wires in the medullary cavity with stable fixation by Ilizarov device. The longest duration for bone transport was 16 weeks (14–20 weeks) for application, after deformity correction was 20 weeks. We have never used any kind of bone grafts. Results. All the 18 patients were treated successfully by Ilizarov compression distraction device. The patients with localized tibial pathology with deformity had the shortest period on the Ilizarov apparatus, 14 weeks. Conclusions. Preservation and bone regeneration by distraction histogenesis constitutes a highly conservative limb saving surgery. Patients with bone defects of <10 cm, a great deal of preserved healthy tissue and good