We evaluated the impact of stereo-visualisation of three-dimensional volume-rendering CT datasets on the inter- and intraobserver reliability assessed by kappa values on the AO/OTA and Neer classifications in the assessment of proximal humeral fractures. Four independent observers classified 40 fractures according to the AO/OTA and Neer classifications using plain radiographs, two-dimensional CT scans and with stereo-visualised three-dimensional volume-rendering reconstructions. Both classification systems showed moderate interobserver reliability with plain radiographs and two-dimensional CT scans. Three-dimensional volume-rendered CT scans improved the interobserver reliability of both systems to good. Intraobserver reliability was moderate for both classifications when assessed by plain radiographs. Stereo visualisation of three-dimensional volume rendering improved intraobserver reliability to good for the AO/OTA method and to excellent for the Neer classification. These data support our opinion that stereo visualisation of three-dimensional volume-rendering datasets is of value when analysing and classifying complex fractures of the proximal humerus

The lateral pillar classification (LPC) is a widely used tool in determining prognosis and planning treatment in patients who are in the fragmentation stage of Perthes disease. The original classification has been modified to help increase the accuracy of the classification system by the Herring group. The purpose of our study was to independently assess this modified Herring classification. 35 standardized true antero-posterior radiographs of children in various stages of fragmentation were independently assessed by 6 senior observers on 2 separate occasions (6 weeks apart). Kappa analysis was used to assess the inter and intraobserver agreement between observations made. The degrees of agreement were as follows: poor, fair, moderate, good and very good. Intraobserver analysis revealed at best only moderate agreement for two observers. 3 observers showed fair consistency, whilst 1 remaining observer showed poor consistency between repeated observations (p<0.01). The highest scores for interobserver agreement varying between moderate to good could only be established between 2 observers. For the remaining observers results were just fair (p<0.01). This study highlights the lack of agreement between senior clinicians when applying the modified LPC. This has clinical implications when applying the classification to the decision making process in treating patients at risk of developing adverse outcomes from the disease. To our knowledge, this is the first time the modified LPC has been independently tested for its reproducibility by another specialist paediatric orthopaedic unit

We assessed the inter- and intraobserver variation in classification systems for fractures of the distal humerus. Three orthopaedic trauma consultants, three trauma registrars and three consultant musculoskeletal radiologists independently classified 33 sets of radiographs of such fractures on two occasions, each using three separate systems. For interobserver variation, the Riseborough and Radin system produced ‘moderate’ agreement (kappa = 0.513), but half of the fractures were not classifiable by this system. For the complete AO system, agreement was ‘fair’ (kappa = 0.343), but if only AO type and group or AO type alone was used, agreement improved to ‘moderate’ and ‘substantial’, respectively (kappa = 0.52 and 0.66). Agreement for the system of Jupiter and Mehne was ‘fair’ (kappa = 0.295). Similar levels of intraobserver variation were found. Systems of classification are useful in decision-making and evaluation of outcome only if there is agreement and consistency among observers. Our study casts doubt on these aspects of the systems currently available for fractures of the distal humerus

The reliability of the radiological assessment of the healing of tibial fractures remains undetermined. We examined the inter- and intraobserver agreement of the healing of such fractures among four orthopaedic trauma surgeons who, on two separate occasions eight weeks apart, independently assessed the radiographs of 30 patients with fractures of the tibial shaft which had been treated by intramedullary fixation. The radiographs were selected from a database to represent fractures at various stages of healing. For each radiograph, the surgeon scored the degree of union, quantified the number of cortices bridged by callus or with a visible fracture line, described the extent and quality of the callus, and provided an overall rating of healing. The interobserver chance-corrected agreement using a quadratically weighted kappa (κ) statistic in which values of 0.61 to 0.80 represented substantial agreement were as follows: radiological union scale (κ = 0.60); number of cortices bridged by callus (κ = 0.75); number of cortices with a visible fracture line (κ = 0.70); the extent of the callus (κ = 0.57); and general impression of fracture healing (κ = 0.67). The intraobserver agreement of the overall impression of healing (κ = 0.89) and the number of cortices bridged by callus (κ = 0.82) or with a visible fracture line (κ = 0.83) was almost perfect. There are no validated scales which allow surgeons to grade fracture healing radiologically. Among those examined, the number of cortices bridged by bone appears to be a reliable, and easily measured radiological variable to assess the healing of fractures after intramedullary fixation

Objectives

Current studies on the additional benefit of using computed tomography (CT) in order to evaluate the surgeons’ agreement on treatment plans for fracture are inconsistent. This inconsistency can be explained by a methodological phenomenon called ‘spectrum bias’, defined as the bias inherent when investigators choose a population lacking therapeutic uncertainty for evaluation. The aim of the study is to determine the influence of spectrum bias on the intra-observer agreement of treatment plans for fractures of the distal radius.

To develop a reliable and effective radiological score to assess the healing of isolated ulnar shaft fractures (IUSF), the Radiographic Union Score for Ulna fractures (RUSU). Initially, 20 patients with radiographs six weeks following a non-operatively managed ulnar shaft fracture were selected and scored by three blinded observers. After intraclass correlation (ICC) analysis, a second group of 54 patients with radiographs six weeks after injury (18 who developed a nonunion and 36 who united) were scored by the same observers. In the initial study, interobserver and intraobserver ICC were 0.89 and 0.93, respectively. In the validation study the interobserver ICC was 0.85. The median score for patients who united was significantly higher than those who developed a nonunion (11 vs 7, p<0.001). A ROC curve demonstrated that a RUSU ≤8 had a sensitivity of 88.9% and specificity of 86.1% in identifying patients at risk of nonunion. Patients with a RUSU ≤8 (n = 21) were more likely to develop a nonunion (n = 16/21) than those with a RUSU ≥9 (n = 2/33; OR 49.6, 95% CI 8.6–284.7). Based on a PPV of 76%, if all patients with a RUSU ≤8 underwent fixation at 6-weeks, the number of procedures needed to avoid one nonunion would be 1.3. The RUSU shows good interobserver and intraobserver reliability and is effective in identifying patients at risk of nonunion six weeks after fracture. This tool requires external validation but may enhance the management of patients with isolated ulnar shaft fractures

Mirels’ score predicts the likelihood of sustaining pathological fractures using pain, lesion site, size and morphology. The aim is to investigate its reproducibility, reliability and accuracy in upper limb bony metastases and validate its use in pathological fracture prediction. A retrospective cohort study of patients with upper limb metastases, referred to an Orthopaedic Trauma Centre (2013–18). Mirels’ was calculated in 32 patients; plain radiographs at presentation scored by 6 raters. Radiological aspects were scored twice by each rater, 2-weeks apart. Inter- and intra-observer reliability were calculated (Fleiss’ kappa test). Bland-Altman plots compared variances of individual score components &total Mirels’ score. Mirels’ score of ≥9 did not accurately predict lesions that would fracture (11% 5/46 vs 65.2% Mirels’ score ≤8, p<0.0001). Sensitivity was 14.3% &specificity was 72.7%. When Mirels’ cut-off was lowered to ≥7, patients were more likely to fracture (48% 22/46 versus 28% 13/46, p=0.045). Sensitivity rose to 62.9%, specificity fell to 54.6%. Kappa values for interobserver variability were 0.358 (fair, 0.288–0.429) for lesion size, 0.107 (poor, 0.02–0.193) for radiological appearance and 0.274 (fair, 0.229–0.318) for total Mirels’ score. Values for intraobserver variability were 0.716 (good, 95% CI 0.432–0.999) for lesion size, 0.427 (moderate, 95% CI 0.195–0.768) for radiological appearance and 0.580 (moderate, 0.395–0.765) for total Mirels’ score. We showed moderate to substantial agreement between &within raters using Mirels’ score on upper limb radiographs. Mirels’ has poor sensitivity &specificity predicting upper limb fractures - we recommend the cut-off score for prophylactic surgery should be lower than for lower limb lesions

Aims

To investigate if preoperative CT improves detection of unstable trochanteric hip fractures.

Aims

Periprosthetic fractures (PPFs) following hip arthroplasty are complex injuries. This study evaluates patient demographic characteristics, management, outcomes, and risk factors associated with PPF subtypes over a decade.

Introduction. Dislocation following total hip arthroplasty THA is a major short term complication not infrequently resulting in revision arthroplasty. Malposition of the acetabular component in THA results in a higher rate of dislocation as well as increased wear and osteolysis. The aim of this study was to assess the effect of mode of fixation on positioning of the acetabular component. Patients, materials and methods. For all THAs performed at our hospital in 2008, angle of acetabular inclination was measured using PACS by two independent observers. Interobserver and intraobserver reliability were assessed (Pearson's correlation coefficient, r). We determined whether the number of acetabular components outside the target angle range (eg:45±5°) was significantly different between cemented and cementless THA (chi squared test). An enquiry was made to the National Joint Registry (NJR) in respect to incidence of revision for dislocation of THA using cemented and cementless acetabular components, 2004–2009. Results. During 2008 126 THA were performed, 80 cemented and 46 cementless. There was good reliability of angle measurement (interobserver: r=0.89; intraobserver: r=0.87 and 0.97). More cemented acetabular components were within target angle range compared to cementless (cemented 32/80, cementless 29/46; chi squared=6.39, p<0.05). Using data from NJR comparing the number of primary hip replacement operations with number of revisions due to dislocation found a higher rate for cementless THA, 0.381% (266/69,822) than for cemented, 0.282% (262/92,928) (Odds ratio: 1.35 (95% CI 1.14–1.60; P<0.05). Conclusion. Positioning of the acetabular component is more difficult when using cementless systems as implant position is determined by orientation of reaming whereas with cement there is potential for fine implant position adjustment on insertion. The choice of a cementless acetabular component significantly increases the incidence of dislocation post THA. Acetabular component malposition is likely to be a factor in this increased incidence

Introduction. Regenerative medicine is a rapidly expanding discipline. However due to a lack of validated outcome measures, clinical trials have been far few. This study aims to assess the validity, inter-observer reliability and intra-observer reproducibility of experimental fracture healing assessment on plain radiographies. This technique involves implantation of mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) seeded constructs on only one side of the fracture after randomisation. Methods. We examined inter/intraobserver agreement on the area and “bridging length” of callus formed on opposite sides of the fracture. Among 16 orthopaedic surgeons with trauma commitments (8 consultants, 8 registrars) on two separate occasions (average 52 days apart). They independently assessed the radiographs (AP or lateral) of 28 patients with fractures of the tibial or femoral shaft. The fractures chosen included non-unions treated with MSC/constructs and fresh fractures at 4–9 months. For each radiograph the assessor assigned which side (medial or lateral) is there more callus. Chase-corrected agreement using Fleiss kappa was used to compare opinions. Digital analysis software (Image-J) was used to quantify extent/bridging callus and correlate it with surgeons opinion. Results. Inter-observer variation showed a substantial overall agreement (k = 0.716) on the fracture side containing a larger “area” of callus but moderate agreement (k = 0.489) on side with more “bridging length”. These results were reproducible with a substantial overall intraobserver agreement. MSC/construct treated non-union showed a larger amount of agreement than fresh fractures for area (k = 0.754 vs 0.613) and bridging (0.550 vs 0.406). Utilizing digital analysis, non-unions showed a significant larger quantifiable difference between sides than fresh fractures (p = 0.009) for area but not bridging length (p = 0.269). Digital analysis quantification and surgeons opinion showed an almost perfect agreement for area (k = 0.867) and bridging (k = 0.846). Discussion. In this study we aimed to validate a novel method at studying the efficacy and effect of regenerative techniques on fracture healing. In particular, plain radiographs for comparing a treatment/internal control side. In this study we showed this method assessing area of callus is valid, reliable and reproducible. This is particularly so for MSC/construct treated non-union where the difference in both sides is higher as quantified in digital analysis. This is a novel method of experimental fracture healing using an internal control which decreases the variation between groups and sample size needed. This makes regenerative medicine clinical trials easier

Introduction. Proper rotational alignment of the tibial component in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) could be achieved using several techniques. The self adjustment methodology allows the alignment of the tibial component under the femoral component after several flexion-extension movements. Our hypothesis was that this technique allowed a posterior tibial component alignment parallel to the femoral component posterior bicondylar axis. The aim of this study was to access this hypothesis using a post-operative CT-scan study. Materials and Methods. This prospective CT-scan study involved 94 TKA. Theses TKA were divided in two groups: group1: 50 knees with a pre-operative genu varum deformity (mean HKA: 172.2°), operated using a medial parapatellar approach, and group 2: 44 knees with a preoperative valgus deformity (mean HKA: 188.7°), operated using a lateral parapatellar approach. Four measures were done on each post-operative CT-scan: angle between anatomical transepicondylar axis and femoral component posterior bicondylar axis (FCPCA), angle between FCPCA and tibial component marginal posterior axis, angle between tibial component marginal posterior axis and bony tibial plateau marginal posterior axis (BTPMPA), angle between transepicondylar axis and tibial component marginal posterior axis. Each measure was repeated, after one month by the same independent observer. Statistical evaluation used non-parametric Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney test to compare each group of measures, and intraobserver reproducibility was assessed using ANOVA test, with an error rate of 5%. Results. Intraobserver measurements were reproducible. Mean FCPCA was to 3,1° (SD:1,91) in group 1 and 4,7° (DS: 2,96) in group 2. Tibial component was positioned in external rotation in both groups, in relation to FCPCA: (group 1: mean angle: 0,7° (SD:4,45), group 2: mean angle: 0,9° (SD:4,53)) and in relation to BTPMPA: (group1: mean angle: 6,1° (SD: 5,85); group2: mean angle: 12,5° (SD: 8,6)). There was no statistical difference between these two groups. Tibial component was positioned in internal rotation in relation to anatomical transepicondylar axis: (Group1: mean angle: 1,9° (SD: 4,93); group 2: mean angle: 3° (SD: 4.38)). Discussion. By using the self adjustment technique, tibial component is aligned parallel to the femoral component regardless of the initial frontal deformity and the surgical approach. However, there was a difference in tibial component axis and BTPMPA, between the two groups. This difference should be explained by the difference in morphology of the tibial plateau bone in knee with genu valgum deformity. The self adjustment technique is a reliable method to obtain a proper rotational alignment of the tibial component in TKA

Aims

Heterotopic ossification (HO) is a common complication after elbow trauma and can cause severe upper limb disability. Although multiple prognostic factors have been reported to be associated with the development of post-traumatic HO, no model has yet been able to combine these predictors more succinctly to convey prognostic information and medical measures to patients. Therefore, this study aimed to identify prognostic factors leading to the formation of HO after surgery for elbow trauma, and to establish and validate a nomogram to predict the probability of HO formation in such particular injuries.

Aims

The incidence of atypical femoral fractures (AFFs) continues to increase. However, there are currently few long-term studies on the complications of AFFs and factors affecting them. Therefore, we attempted to investigate the outcomes, complications, and risk factors for complication through mid-term follow-up of more than three years.

Aims

The aim of this study was to investigate if there are differences in outcome between sliding hip screws (SHSs) and intramedullary nails (IMNs) with regard to fracture stability.

Aims

Malreduction of the syndesmosis has been reported in up to 52% of patients after fixation of ankle fractures. Multiple radiological parameters are used to define malreduction; there has been limited investigation of the accuracy of these measurements in differentiating malreduction from inherent anatomical asymmetry. The purpose of this study was to identify the prevalence of positive malreduction standards within the syndesmosis of native, uninjured ankles.

Accurate measurement of the alignment of the tibia is important both clinically and in research. The conventional method of measuring the angle of malunion after a fracture of the shaft of the tibia is potentially inaccurate because the mechanical axis of the normal bone may not pass down the centre of the medullary canal. An alternative method is described in which a radiograph of the opposite tibia is used as a template. A sample of 56 sets of standard radiographs of healed fractures of the shaft of the tibia was evaluated. The 95% limits of agreement between this and the conventional method were wide, being −6.2° to +5.5° for coronal angulation and −6.7° to +8.1° for sagittal angulation. These results suggest that the conventional method is inaccurate. The new method has good inter- and intraobserver reliability

The bare area of the humeral head is limited in front by the cartilage and backwards by the insertion of the Infra Spinatus tendon. There are few references in the current literature. The aim of this work was to precise the anatomic description of the bare area and to compare the size of this area in patients with anterior shoulder instability and patients without anterior shoulder instability. Material and method. We have proceeded first to an anatomic study to precise the limit of the bare area. The second part of this study was a retrospective and prospective comparative arthro CT-scan study in two groups of patients. The first group (group 1) had 48 patients, going to have anterior instability surgery. The second group (group 2) had 38 patients, without shoulder instability. Mean age was respectively 28.2 years (range: 19–48) in group 1; and 39.3 years (16–69) in group 2. The size of the bare area was measured on the axial injected CT cut passing by the larger diameter of the humeral head, The size of the bare area was definite by the angle between the line connecting the centre of the head to the posterior limit of the cartilage and the line connecting the centre of the head to the anterior point of the Infra Spinatus tendon. The reproducibility of the measure has been evaluated by a Bland and Altman test and an intra class correlation test. The measures were realised by two independent surgeons in a blind manner. The results where compared by a Student test with a threshold at 5%. Results. In the anatomic part of this study, the average angle of the bare area was 32.7° equal to 13.7mm wide. Mean intraobserver variability was 4° (range: 0 to 20°) (NS) and mean interobserver variability was 4° also (range: 0 to 20°) (NS). Mean size of the bare area was 49.6° eaqual to 19.8mm wide [range 25° to 70°] in group 1 and 33.2° equal to 13.5mm wide [range 21° to 60°] in group 2 (p< 0,05). Discussion. Our measures were reproducible. This study confirms our hypothesis: the bare area is significantly larger in shoulders suffering of anterior instability, but we cannot yet tell if this result is a consequence or a risk factor of anterior shoulder instability

From 1988 to 1994 a consecutive series of 1000 fractures of the adult clavicle was treated in the Orthopaedic Trauma Clinic of the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh. In males, the annual incidence was highest under 20 years of age, decreasing in each subsequent cohort until the seventh decade. In females, the incidence was more constant, but relatively frequent in teenagers and the elderly. In young patients, fractures usually resulted from road-traffic accidents or sport and most were diaphyseal. Fractures in the outer fifth were produced by simple domestic falls and were more common in the elderly. A new classification was developed based on radiological review of the anatomical site and the extent of displacement, comminution and articular extension. There were satisfactory levels of inter- and intraobserver variation for reliability and reproducibility. Fractures of the medial fifth (type 1), undisplaced diaphyseal fractures (type 2A) and fractures of the outer fifth (type 3A) usually had a benign prognosis. The incidence of complications of union was higher in displaced diaphyseal (type 2B) and displaced outer-fifth (type 3B) fractures. In addition to displacement, the extent of comminution in type-2B fractures was a risk factor for delayed and nonunion

Aims

The primary aim of this study was to develop a reliable, effective radiological score to assess the healing of humeral shaft fractures, the Radiographic Union Score for HUmeral fractures (RUSHU). The secondary aim was to assess whether the six-week RUSHU was predictive of nonunion at six months after the injury.