Strategy regarding patella resurfacing in total knee replacement (TKR) remains controversial. TKR revision rates are reportedly influenced by surgeon procedure volume. The study aim was to compare revision outcomes of TKR with and without patella resurfacing in different surgeon volume groups using data from the AOANJRR. The study population included 571,149 primary TKRs for osteoarthritis. Surgeons were classified as low, medium, or high-volume based on the quartiles of mean primary TKR volume between 2011 and 2020. Cumulative percent revision (CPR) using Kaplan-Meier estimates of survivorship were calculated for the three surgeon volume groups with and without patella resurfacing. Cox proportional hazards models, adjusted for age and sex, were used to compare revision risks. High-volume surgeons who did not resurface the patella had the highest all-cause CPR (20-year CPR 10.9%, 95% CI [10.0%, 12.0%]). When the patella was resurfaced, high-volume surgeons had the lowest revision rate (7.3%, 95% CI [6.4%, 8.4%]). When the high-volume groups were compared there was a higher rate of revision for the non-resurfaced group after 6 months. When the medium-volume surgeon groups were compared, not resurfacing the patella also was associated with a higher rate of revision after 3 months. The low-volume comparisons showed an initial higher rate of revision with patella resurfacing, but there was no difference after 3 months. When only patella revisions were considered, there were higher rates of revision in all three volume groups where the patella was not resurfaced. TKR performed by high and medium-volume surgeons without patella resurfacing had higher revision rates compared to when the patella was resurfaced. Resurfacing the patella in the primary procedure protected against revision for patella reasons in all surgeon volume groups. Level of evidence: III (National registry analysis)

Glenoid baseplate orientation in reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) influences clinical outcomes, complications, and failure rates. Novel technologies have been produced to decrease performance heterogeneity of low and high-volume surgeons. This study aimed to determine novice and experienced shoulder surgeon's ability to accurately characterise glenoid component orientation in an intra-operative scenario. Glenoid baseplates were implanted in eight fresh frozen cadavers by novice surgical trainees. Glenoid baseplate version, inclination, augment rotation, and superior-inferior centre of rotation (COR) offset were then measured using in-person visual assessments by novice and experienced shoulder surgeons immediately after implantation. Glenoid orientation parameters were then measured using 3D CT scans with digitally reconstructed radiographs (DRRs) by two independent observers. Bland-Altman plots were produced to determine the accuracy of glenoid orientation using standard intraoperative assessment compared to postoperative 3D CT scan results. Visual assessment of glenoid baseplate orientation showed “poor” to “fair” correlation to 3D CT DRR measurements for both novice and experienced surgeon groups for all measured parameters. There was a clinically relevant, large discrepancy between intra-operative visual assessments and 3D CT DRR measurements for all parameters. Errors in visual assessment of up to 19.2 degrees of inclination and 8mm supero-inferior COR offset occurred. Experienced surgeons had greater measurement error than novices for all measured parameters. Intra-operative measurement errors in glenoid placement may reach unacceptable clinical limits. Kinesthetic input during implantation likely improves orientation understanding and has implications for hands-on learning

Introduction. Hip resurfacing arthroplasty (HRA) is an alternative to traditional total hip arthroplasty (THA) in young active patients. While comparative implant survival rates are well documented, there is a paucity of studies reporting the patient mortality rates associated with these procedures. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the mortality rates in patients age 55 years and younger who underwent HRA versus THA and to assess whether the type of operation was independently associated with mortality. Patients and Methods. The database of a single high-volume surgeon was reviewed for all consecutive patients age 55 years and younger who underwent hip arthroplasty between 2002 and 2010. HRA became available in the United States in 2006. This yielded 504 patients who had undergone HRA from 2006 to 2010 and 124 patients who had undergone a THA. Patient characteristics were collected from the electronic medical record including age, gender, body mass index, Charleston comorbidity index, smoking status, and primary diagnosis. Mortality was determined through a combination of electronic chart reviews, patient phone calls, and online obituary searches. Univariate analysis was performed to identify a survival difference between the two cohorts. Multivariable Cox-Regression analyses were used to determine whether the type of operation was independently associated with mortality. Results. The mean follow up for consecutive patients was 7 years (up to 11 years) in the HRA group and 8 years (up to 16 years) in the THA group. A total of 467 HRA patients (92%) and 105 THA patients (85%) were followed for a minimum of 5-years. 92% of the THA procedures were performed prior to the availability of HRA. There were 8 mortalities (1.6%) in the HRA cohort and 11 (8.9%) in the THA cohort, a statistically significant difference (p<0.001) on univariate analysis. Low mortality rates produced underpowered multivariate models. Conclusion. We have demonstrated that patients under age 55 who undergo HRA have a significantly lower mortality rate than those undergoing THA at mid-term follow-up. This is consistent with previously published large database studies. Such studies typically analyze large heterogeneous populations of patients and surgeons. Our study uniquely examined only patients age 55 or younger from a single high-volume surgeon, and we primarily reviewed THA performed prior to the availability of HRA as a surgical option. Thus, surgeon selection bias was largely eliminated. To our knowledge, this is the first single surgeon study comparing HRA and THA in terms of mortality

BACKGROUND. High-volume surgeons and hospital systems have been shown to deliver higher value care in several studies. However, no evidence-based volume thresholds for cost currently exist in total hip arthroplasty (THA). The objective of this study was to establish clinically meaningful volume thresholds based on cost for surgeons and hospitals performing THA. A secondary objective was to analyze the relative market share of THAs among the newly defined surgeon and hospital volume strata. METHODS. Using 136,501 patients from the New York State Department of Health's SPARCS database undergoing total hip arthroplasty, we used stratum-specific likelihood ratio (SSLR) analysis of a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve to generate volume thresholds predictive of increased costs for both surgeons and hospitals. Additionally, we examined the relative proportion of annual THA cases performed by each of these surgeon and hospital volume strata we had established. RESULTS. SSLR analysis of cost by annual surgeon THA volume produced stratifications at: 0–73 (low), 74–123 (medium), and 124 or more (high) (Figure 1). Analysis by annual hospital THA volume produced stratifications at: 0–121 (low), 122–309 (medium), and 310 or more (high) (Figure 2). Hospital costs decreased significantly (P < .05) in progressively higher volume stratifications. The largest proportion of THA cases are performed at high-volume hospitals (48.6%); however, low-volume surgeons perform the greatest share of these cases (44.6%) (Figure 3). CONCLUSIONS. Our study establishes economies of scale in total hip arthroplasty by demonstrating a direct relationship between volume and cost reduction. High volume hospitals are performing the greatest proportion of total hip arthroplasties; however, low volume, surgeons perform the largest share of these cases, which highlights a potential area for enhanced value in the care of patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty

INTRODUCTION. The direct anterior approach (DAA) for total hip arthroplasty has become a popular technique. Proponents of the anterior approach cite advantages such as less muscle damage, lower dislocation risk, faster recovery, and more accurate implant placement for the approach. However, there is a steep, complex learning curve associated with the technique. The present study seeks to define the learning curve based on individual surgical and outcome variables for a high-volume surgeon. METHODS. 300 consecutive patients were retrospectively analyzed. Intraoperative outcomes measured include surgery time and estimated blood loss (EBL). Complications include intraoperative fracture, post-operative fracture, infection, dislocation, leg length discrepancy, loosening, and medical complications such as deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary embolism (PE). Segmented regression models were used to elucidate the presence of a learning curve and mastery of the procedure with regard to each individual variable. RESULTS. The mean operative time was 77.1 minutes (range 40–213). Operative time improved at a rate of 6.6 minutes per case for the first 15 cases then by an average of 5 seconds per subsequent case. The mean EBL for the series was 288.6 mL. Segmented regression shows EBL decreased at a rapid rate until case 52, followed by a more gradual decline. Complications were higher in the first 7 surgeries, with a 48% decrease in the likelihood of complication with each subsequent surgery. The improvement continued through the rest of the series with a 0.5% decrease in likelihood with each surgery. DISCUSSION. Our data contributes to the current body of literature by defining the learning curve with what we consider the most pertinent outcomes. First, we show that operative efficiency can be gained quite quickly (15 cases) while the slower improvement in EBL demonstrates continued learning about the anatomy. Our data is consistent with previous published reports regarding complication improvement. The present study will provide surgeons considering DAA useful information regarding what to expect during their learning curve. Furthermore, the data can be useful for surgeons charged with teaching the technique to critically evaluate what learning curve variables can be improved to hasten the learning curve

Introduction. A longer operative time will lead to the development of any postoperative complications in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). According to previous reports, a significant increase in TKA procedure time done by novice surgeons was observed compared to high-volume surgeons. Our purpose was to investigate and to clarify the important maneuver necessary for novice surgeons to minimize a surgical time in TKA. Methods. A total of 300 knees in 248 patients, averaged 74.6 ± 8.7 years, were enrolled. All primary TKAs were done using same instruments (Balanced Knee System®, PS design, Ortho Development, Draper, UT) and same measured resection technique at 14 facilities by 25 orthopedic surgeons. Surgeons were divided into three surgeon groups (4 experts, 9 medium volume surgeons, 12 novices). All methods were approved by our institution's ethics committee. We divided the operative technique into 5 steps to make comparisons of step-by-step surgical time among surgeon groups of different levels. We defined Phase 1 as performing surgical exposure from skin incision to insertion of the intramedullary rod into the femur. Thereafter, the distal and AP surface of the femur, proximal tibia, the chamfer and PS box of the femur, and patella were resected in Phase 2. In Phase 3, a setup the trial component and a keel of the tibia were done after a confirmation of appropriate ligament balance using the spacer block. Then, a bone surface was irrigated with 2000ml of saline after the removal of the trial component. Subsequently, permanent components were fixed with use of bone cement in Phase 4. Finally, the final irrigation using 2000ml saline and wound closure were done in Phase 5. Every phase of the surgical time was recorded in each TKA. As a statistical analysis, operation data including length of skin incision, component size, operation time in each phase, and ratio of surgical time in each phase to whole surgical time, were compared using non-repeated measures of ANOVA and a post hoc Bonferroni correction. The threshold for statistical significance was set at a p value of less than 0.05. Results. A total of 62 TKAs were done by novice surgeons. On the other hand, medium volume surgeons and experts performed 119 and 119 TKAs, respectively. Gradually, differences among three groups became large phase by phase. Significant differences were detected among groups in each phase (Fig.1). Novice surgeons and medium volume surgeons took much time even in a basic technique including the exposure and wound closure (Fig.2). Regarding the ratio, no significant differences were detected among groups in Phase 2, 3, and 5. Experts and medium volume surgeons seemed to take caution in fixation of the permanent component. Interestingly, the ratio was still notably different among groups in Phase 1 (Fig.3). Conclusions. Significant differences among groups were seen in bone resection and implant fixation as well as in a basic technique including exposure and wound closure. Ratio was also notably different among groups in surgical exposure. Therefore, a basic technique would be important to reduce surgical time in novice surgeons in primary TKA

Introduction. Optimized tibial tray rotation during a total knee replacement (TKR) is critical for tibiofemoral congruency through full range of motion, as it affects soft tissue tension, stability and patellar tracking. Surgeons commonly reference the tibial tubercle, or the “floating tibial tray,” while testing the knee in flexion and extension. Utilization of embedded sensors may enable the surgeon to more accurately assess tibiofemoral contact points during surgery. Methods. The malrotation of the tibiofemoral congruency when utilizing the mid to medial 1/3 of the tibial tubercle for tibial rotation was evaluated in 50 posterior cruciate ligament-retaining TKRs performed by an experienced, high-volume surgeon. Sensors were embedded in the tibial trials; the rotation of the tibial tray was defined, and the femoral contact points in each compartment were captured. The surgical procedure was performed to size and then appropriately rotate the tibial tray. The anterior medial tray was pinned to control anterior-posterior and medio-lateral displacement, and allow internal and external rotation of the tray. With the capsule closed and patella reduced, the knee was reduced with trial implants. The femoral contact points and medial-lateral soft tissue tension were documented. Patellar tracking and changes in soft tissue tension were also documented. Results. In 60% (n = 30/50) of cases, further external rotation (average 5 degrees) was required. No further rotation was required in 10% (n = 5/50), and 30% (n = 15/50) required further internal rotation for optimized congruency. Patellar tracking and changes in soft tissue tension based on rotation showed parallel center of load in medio-lateral compartments and equalized intercompartment pressures resulting in optimized balance of the knee. Conclusions. Utilizing the tibial tubercle for optimized tibial tray rotation and femoral congruency was only adequate in 10% of cases. The use of sensors to define the femoral contact points on the tibia enabled the surgeon to adjust the tibial tray to optimize tibiofemoral congruency. Mal-rotated trays negatively affected soft tissue tension and patellar tracking

Direct anterior approach (DAA) using the Hueter interval for total hip replacement (THA) provides an inter-nervous and inter-muscular access to the hip joint. Although it is technically demanding, the learning curve has been shown to be around 40 cases and 6 months in a high-volume joint surgeon's practice. A level-one study has demonstrated that DAA provides equal or better results and an equivalent rate of complications when compared to the highly utilized direct lateral approach. Using the available evidence to perform a multi-criteria decision analysis we demonstrated that DAA can be the most efficient approach to perform THA. From our standpoint, there is no reason to speculate a surgical approach with such advantages will be abandoned in the future. The DAA is here to stay, and may become the gold standard for THA