Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 2 of 2
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 104-B, Issue SUPP_13 | Pages 102 - 102
1 Dec 2022
Gundavda M Lazarides A Burke Z Griffin A Tsoi K Ferguson P Wunder JS
Full Access

Cartilage lesions vary in the spectrum from benign enchondromas to highly malignant dedifferentiated chondrosarcomas. From the treatment perspective, enchondromas are observed, Grade 1 chondrosarcomas are curetted like aggressive benign tumors, and rest are resected like other sarcomas. Although biopsy for tissue diagnosis is the gold standard for diagnosis and grade determination in chondrosarcoma, tumor heterogeneity limits the grading in patients following a biopsy. In the absence of definite pre-treatment grading, a surgeon is therefore often in a dilemma when deciding the best treatment option. Radiology has identified aggressive features and aggressiveness scores have been used to try and grade these tumors based on the imaging characteristics but there have been very few published reports with a uniform group and large number of cases to derive a consistent scoring and correlation. The authors asked these study questions :(1) Does Radiology Aggressiveness and its Score correlate with the grade of chondrosarcoma? (2) Can a cut off Radiology Agressiveness Score value be used to guide the clinician and add value to needle biopsy information in offering histological grade dependent management?. A retrospective analysis of patients with long bone extremity intraosseous primary chondrosarcomas were correlated with the final histology grade for the operated patients and Radiological parameters with 9 parameters identified a priori and from published literature (radiology aggressiveness scores - RAS) were evaluated and tabulated. 137 patients were identified and 2 patients were eliminated for prior surgical intervention. All patients had tissue diagnosis available and pre-treatment local radiology investigations (radiographs and/or CT scans and MRI scans) to define the RAS parameters. Spearman correlation has indicated that there was a significant positive association between RAS and final histology grading of long bone primary intraosseous chondrosarcomas. We expect higher RAS values will provide grading information in patients with inconclusive pre-surgery biopsy to tumor grades and aid in correct grade dependant surgical management of the lesion. Prediction of dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma from higher RAS will be attempted and a correlation to obtain a RAS cut off, although this may be challenging to achieve due to the overlap of features across the intermediate grade, high grade and dedifferentiated grades. Radiology Aggressiveness correlates with the histologic grade in long bone extremity primary chondrosarcomas and the correlation of radiology and biopsy can aid in treatment planning by guiding us towards a low-grade neoplasm which may be dealt with intralesional extended curettage or high-grade lesion which need to be resected. Standalone RAS may not solve the grading dilemma of primary long bone intraosseous chondrosarcomas as the need for tissue diagnosis for confirming atypical cartilaginous neoplasm cannot be eliminated, however in the event of a needle biopsy grade or inconclusive open biopsy it may guide us towards a correlational diagnosis along with radiology and pathology for grade based management of the chondrosarcoma


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 93 - 93
1 Feb 2012
Grimer R
Full Access

Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma is a rare but highly malignant manifestation that can occasionally arise in patients with cartilage tumours. There remains uncertainty as to the best treatment for this condition and in particular whether chemotherapy may have a role in improving prognosis. Members of EMSOS were invited to contribute data on patients, tumours, treatment and outcomes of patients with dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma. Eight centres contributed data on 317 patients from 7 countries. The mean age was 59 (range 15 to 89) and the most common site was the femur (46%) followed by the pelvis (28%). 25% of patients presented with a pathological fracture and the most common high grade component identified was MFH. 23% had metastases at diagnosis and these patients had a median survival of 5 months. 30% of patients received chemotherapy, with 47% under 60 having chemotherapy compared with 10% over 60. One third of this group had neoadjuvant chemotherapy and the rest had adjuvant reatment. 88% had surgery with limb salvage in 80% of this group. The overall survival was 38% at 2 years and 24% at 5 years but in patients without metastases at diagnosis these figures were 44% and 28% respectively. Poor prognostic factors for survival were: metastases at diagnosis, amputation or no operation, local recurrence, age over 60 and pathological fracture at presentation. We were unable to identify any group in whom chemotherapy appeared to have a survival benefit. Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma carries a dismal prognosis. Although 30% of patients received chemotherapy in this study we were not able to prove that it improved survival. Early diagnosis and complete surgical excision still offer the best prognosis for this condition