Biphasic calcium phosphate (BCP) with a characteristic needle-shaped submicron surface topography (MagnetOs) has attracted much attention due to its unique bone-forming ability which is essential for repairing critical-size bone defects such as those found in the posterolateral spine. Previous in vitro and ex-vivo data performed by van Dijk LA and Yuan H demonstrated that these specific surface characteristics drive a favorable response from the innate immune system. This study aimed to evaluate and compare the in vivo performance of three commercially-available synthetic bone grafts, (1) i-FACTOR Putty. ®. , (2) OssDsign. ®. Catalyst Putty and (3) FIBERGRAFT. ®. BG Matrix, with that of a novel synthetic bone graft in a clinically-relevant instrumented sheep posterolateral lumbar spine fusion (PLF) model. The novel synthetic bone graft comprised of BCP granules with a needle-shaped submicron surface topography (MagnetOs) embedded in a highly porous and fibrillar collagen matrix (MagnetOs Flex Matrix). Four synthetic bone grafts were implanted as standalone in an instrumented sheep PLF model for 12 weeks (n=3 bilateral levels per group; levels L2/3 & L4/5), after which spinal fusion was determined by manual palpation, radiograph and µCT imaging (based on the Lenke scale), range-of-motion mechanical testing, and histological and histomorphological evaluation. Radiographic fusion assessment determined bilateral robust bone bridging (Lenke scale A) in 3/3 levels for MagnetOs Flex Matrix compared to 1/3 for all other groups. For µCT, bilateral fusion (Lenke scale A) was found in 2/3 levels for MagnetOs Flex Matrix, compared to 0/3 for i-FACTOR Putty. ®. , 1/3 for OssDsign. ®. Catalyst Putty and 0/3 for FIBERGRAFT. ®. BG Matrix. Fusion assessment for MagnetOs Flex Matrix was further substantiated by histology which revealed significant graft resorption complemented by abundant bone tissue and continuous bony bridging between vertebral transverse processes resulting in bilateral spinal fusion in 3/3 implants. These results show that MagnetOs Flex Matrix achieved better fusion rates compared to three commercially-available synthetic bone grafts when used as a standalone in a clinically-relevant instrumented sheep PLF model

Our objective was to conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis, comparing differences in clinical outcomes between either autologous or synthetic bone grafts in the operative management of tibial plateau fractures: a traumatic pattern of injury, associated with poor long-term functional prognosis. A structured search of MEDLINE, EMBASE, The Bone & Joint and CENTRAL databases from inception until 07/28/2021 was performed. Randomised, controlled, clinical trials that compared autologous and synthetic bone grafts in tibial plateau fractures were included. Preclinical studies, clinical studies in paediatric patients, pathological fractures, fracture non-union or chondral defects were excluded. Outcome data was assessed using the Risk of Bias 2 (ROB2) framework and synthesised in random-effect meta-analysis. Preferred Reported Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis guidance was followed throughout. Six comparable studies involving 352 patients were identified from 3,078 records. Following ROB2 assessment, five studies (337 patients) were eligible for meta-analysis. Within these studies, more complex tibia plateau fracture patterns (Schatzker IV-VI) were predominant. Primary outcomes showed non-significant reductions in articular depression at immediate postoperative (mean difference −0.45mm, p=0.25, 95% confidence interval (95%CI): −1.21-0.31mm, I. 2. =0%) and long-term (>6 months, standard mean difference −0.56, p=0.09, 95%CI: −1.20-0.08, I. 2. =73%) follow-up in synthetic bone grafts. Secondary outcomes included mechanical alignment, limb functionality, defect site pain, occurrence of surgical site infections, secondary surgery, perioperative blood loss, and duration of surgery. Blood loss was lower (90.08ml, p<0.001, 95%CI: 41.49-138.67ml, I. 2. =0%) and surgery was shorter (16.17minutes, p=0.04, 95%CI: 0.39-31.94minutes, I. 2. =63%) in synthetic treatment groups. All other secondary measures were statistically comparable. Our findings supersede previous literature, demonstrating that synthetic bone grafts are non-inferior to autologous bone grafts, despite their perceived disadvantages (e.g. being biologically inert). In conclusion, surgeons should consider synthetic bone grafts when optimising peri-operative patient morbidity, particularly in complex tibial plateau fractures, where this work is most applicable

Cervical and lumbar spine fusion procedures are increasing every year. Nonetheless, these procedures are associated with high infection rates, resulting in additional cost burden. The conundrum of achieving efficient spinal fusions with minimum complications requires an ideal bone graft with osteoconductive, osteoinductive, osteogenic and structural characteristics. Synthetic bone graft substitutes with or without autograft, allograft or synthetic bone substitutes have been commonly used for fusion procedures. We carried out a meta-analysis of comparative studies and prospective case series (n = 29) with cervical and lumbar fusion procedures using synthetic bone graft substitutes, autograft or allograft and other biologics. Synthetic bone graft substitutes analysed included HA (Hydroxyapatite), β-TPC (Tri Calcium Phosphate), β-TSC (Tri Calcium Sulfate), PMMA (Polymethylmetacrylate), Surgibone, BOP (Biocompatible Osteoconductive Polymer). The analysis revealed suboptimal evidence for the efficacy and safety of synthetic products used in spinal fusion procedures. Further studies are needed to determine beneficial effects of synthetic substitutes. However, the infection rate could be highly decreased with surface and composition modification of widely used polyether ether ketone (PEEK) implants. Laser modification of surface characteristics and collagen fleeces with micro and nano pore structures can prove to be excellent surface for increased osteoblasts cell proliferation and vitality

Over the last decades, biodegradable metals emerged as promising materials for various biomedical implant applications, aiming to reduce the use of permanent metallic implants and, therefore, to avoid additional surgeries for implant removal. However, among the important issue to be solved is their fast corrosion - too high to match the healing rate of the bone tissue. The most effective way to improve this characteristic is to coat biodegradable metals with substituted calcium phosphates. Tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) is a resorbable bioceramic widely used as synthetic bone graft. In order to modulate and enhance its biological performance, the substitution of Ca2+ by various metal ions, such as strontium (Sr2+), magnesium (Mg2+), iron (Fe2+) etc., can be carried out. Among them, copper (Cu2+), manganese (Mn2+), zinc (Zn2+) etc. could add antimicrobial properties against implant-related infections. Double substitutions of TCP containing couples of Cu2+/Sr2+ or Mn2+/Sr2+ ions are considered to be the most perspective based on the results of our study. We established that single phase Ca3−2x(MˊMˊˊ)x(PO4)2 solid solutions are formed only at x ≤ 0.286, where Mˊ and Mˊˊ—divalent metal ions, such as Zn2+, Mg2+, Cu2+, Mn2+, and that in case of double substitutions, the incorporation of Sr2+ ions allows one to extend the limit of solid solution due to the enlargement of the unit cell structure. We also reported that antimicrobial properties depend on the substitution ion occupation of Ca2+ crystal sites in the β-TCP structure. The combination of two different ions in the Ca5 position, on one side, and in the Ca1, Ca2, Ca3, and Ca4 positions, on another side, significantly boosts antimicrobial properties. In the present work, zinc-lithium (Zn-Li) biodegradable alloys were coated with double substituted Mn2+/Sr2+ β-TCP and double substituted Cu2+/ Sr2+ β-TCP, with the scope to promote osteoinductive effect (due to the Sr2+ presence) and to impart antimicrobial properties (thanks to Cu2+ or Mn2+ ions). The Pulsed Laser Deposition (PLD) method was applied as the coating's preparation technique. It was shown that films deposited using PLD present good adhesion strength and hardness and are characterized by a nanostructured background with random microparticles on the surface. For coatings characterization, Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy, X-ray Diffraction, and Scanning Electron Microscopy coupled with Energy Dispersive X-ray and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy were applied. The microbiology tests on the prepared coated Zn-Li alloys were performed with the Gram-positive (Staphylococcus aureus, Enterococcus faecalis) and Gram-negative (Salmonella typhimurium, Escherichia coli) bacteria strains and Candida albicans fungus. The antimicrobial activity tests showed that Mn2+/Sr2+ β-TCP -coated and Cu2+/Sr2+ β-TCP coated Zn-Li alloys were able to inhibit the growth of all five microorganisms. The prepared coatings are promising in improving the degradation behavior and biological properties of Zn-Li alloys, and further studies are necessary before a possible clinical translation

Successful reconstruction of bone defects requires an adequate filling material that supports regeneration and formation of new bone within the treated defect in an optimal fashion. Currently available synthetic bone graft substitutes cannot fulfill all requirements of the highly complex biological processes involved in physiological bone healing. Due their unphysiologically asynchronous biodegradation properties, their specific foreign material-mediated side effects and complications and their relatively modest overall osteogenic potential, their overall clinical performance typically lags behind conventional bone grafts of human origin. However, defect- and pathology specific combination of synthetic bone graft substitutes exhibiting appropriate carrier properties with therapeutic agents and/or conventional bone graft materials allows creation of biologically enhanced composite constructs that can surpass the biological and therapeutic limits even of autologous bone grafts. This presentation introduces a bone defect reconstruction concept based on biological enhancement of optimal therapeutic agent-carrier composites and provides a rationale for an individual, requirement-specific adaptation of a truly patient-specific reconstruction of bone defects. It represents the pinnacle of the bone defect reconstruction pyramid, founded on the basic principles and prerequisites of complete elimination of the underlying pathology, preservation, augmentation or restoration of mechanical stability of the treated bone segment and creation of a biodegradable scaffold with adequate mechanical integrity. It summarises the current body of relevant experimental and clinical research, presents clinical case examples illustrating the various aspects of the proposed concept as well as early clinical results. The author hopes that the theoretical and conceptual framework provided, will help guide future research as well as clinical decision making with respect to this particular field

Background context. Fusion is a fundamental procedure in spine surgery. Although autogenous grafts have ideal bone graft characteristics, their use may remain limited due to various morbidities. Even though ceramic based synthetic bone grafts are used commonly at present, in order to enhance their efficacy, their combined use with other materials has been investigated. The use of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) together with synthetic bone grafts such as hydroxyapatite (HA) has contributed to positive developments in bone tissue engineering. Purpose. The aim of the present study was to investigate the effect of CNTs/ HA- tricalcium phosphate (TCP) composite prepared in posterolateral spinal fusion model. Study Design/Setting. Experimental animal study. Methods. At first, CNTs and CNTs/HA-TCP composites were prepared. Twenty adult male Spraque Dawley rats were randomized into four groups with five rats in each group. Decortication was carried out in standard manner in all animals. Group 1 (only decortication), group 2 (CNTs), group 3 (HA-TCP) and group 4 (CNTs/HA-TCP) were formed. Eight weeks later all animals were sacrificed and obtained fusion segments were evaluated by manual palpation, histomorphometry and micro computed tomography (mCT). Results. In all evaluations, highest fusion values were obtained in Group 4. In mCT investigations, bone volume/ tissue volume (BV/TV) ratio was found to be significantly higher in composite group (group 4) only compared to ceramic group (group 3). Although in Group 2, in which only CNTs were used, the ratio was found to be significantly higher than group 1, the difference was not considered significant in terms of fusion and in addition in group 2, CNTs were completely surrounded by fibrous tissue, i.e. no bone formation was observed. Conclusions. The combined use of carbon nanotubes with ceramic based bone grafts enhances spinal fusion markedly. Although CNTs are inadequate in producing spinal fusion when they are used by themselves, due to especially their high biocompatibillity and unique bicomechanic characteristics compatible with bone tissue, they increase fusion rates significantly, particularly together with ceramic based synthetic grafts. Keywords. Spinal fusion; Rat; Carbon nanotube(s); Ceramic(s); Bone graft subsitutes; Hydroxyapatite

Synthetic bone grafts are used in several major dental and orthopaedic procedures. Strontium, in the form of strontium ranelate, has been shown to reduce fracture risk when used to treat osteoporosis. The aim of the study was to compare bone repair in femoral condyle defects filled with either a 10% strontium substituted bioactive glass (StronBoneTM) or a TCP-CaSO4 graft. We hypothesise that strontium substituted bioactive glass increases the rate of bone ingrowth into a bone defect when compared to a TCP-CaSO4 ceramic graft. A critical size defect was created in the medial femoral condyle of 24 sheep; half were treated with a Sr-bioactive glass (StronBoneTM), and in the other animals defects were filled TCP-CaSO4. Two time points of 90 and 180 days were selected. The samples were examined with regard to: bone mineral density (BMD) from peripheral quantitative CT (pQCT), mechanical properties through indentation testing, and bony ingrowth and graft resorption through histomorphometry. The radiological density of Sr-bioactive glass in the defect is significantly higher than that of the TCP-CaSO4-filled defect at 90 and 180 days, (p=0.035 and p=0.000). At 90 days, the stiffness of the defect containing Sr-bioactive glass and is higher than that of the TCP-CaSO4 filled defect, (p=0.023). At 6 months there is no significant difference between the two materials. Histomorphometry showed no significant difference in bone ingrowth at any time point, however significantly more of the graft is retained for the StronBoneTM treatment group than the TCP-CaSO4 group at both 0 days (p=0.004) and 180 days (p=0.000). The amount of soft tissue within the defect was significantly less in the StronBoneTM group than for the TCP-CaSO4 group at 90 days (p=0.006) and 180 days (p=0.000). The data shows the mechanical stability of the defect site is regained at a faster rate with the strontium substituted bioglass than the TCP-CaSO4 alternative. Histomorphmetry shows this is not due to increased bone ingrowth but may be due to the incorporation of stiff graft particles into the trabeculae. Sr-bioactive glass produces a stronger repair of a femoral condyle defect at 3 months compared with TCP-CaSO4

Background, Context and Motivation. “Increases in reconstructive orthopaedic surgery, resulting from advances in surgical practice and the ageing population, have lead to a demand for bone graft that far exceeds supply.”…Traditional bone grafting methods have been linked with a number of negative issues including increased morbidity due to secondary operation site and action as a vector for spread of disease. (Hing 2004). A solution to these insufficiencies would be the creation of a synthetic osteoinductive bone graft material. This would vastly improve bone graft surgery success rates and expedite post-op recovery times. The aim of this study was to classify then explore the dissolution rates of three experimental hydroxyapatite/silicate apatite synthetic bonegrafts in physiological solutions, (phosphate buffered saline, (PBS) +/− serum proteins, (PBS +FCS). The overall objective being to identify whether there is an explainable significant difference in ion exchange that could be behind the osteoinductive phenomena. Methods Used. Classification of the apatite samples, (HA, SA1 and SA2), was conducted via X-Ray diffraction, FTIR-PAS Spectroscopy and SEM with EDS analysis. A dissolution experiment of the experimental apatites was conducted in PBS and PBS + FCS solutions, over time periods of 1, 2 and 4 hours, and at 1, 2, 4 and 8 days, with repeat measures. Results and Conclusions. Silicon both free in solution and at the apatite surface was found to be key for osteoinduction and its presence at both these sites increases the rates of bone apposition around a synthetic graft. Experimental Samples HA, SA1 and SA2 share the same crystalline structure as Hydroxyapatite and are phase pure. Sample SA1 showed a %wt of silicon of 0.9%wt and SA2 showed a %wt of silicon of 0.6% wt. Review of the literature indicates that samples SA1 and SA2 are within an osteoinductive range for %wt of silicon. All three samples exhibit porosity within the most bioactive levels (150-500μm). Dissolution reactions for silicon are present and faster than experienced in the literature, this leads us to hypothesise that bone apposition rates would be high in all samples as silicon is available both free in solution and at the apatite surface, indicating all experimental samples possess an osteoinductive effect. Further work would involve exposing these samples to solutions containing osteoblast like cells and comparing the levels of activity found to those of traditional bone grafts currently used

Objectives

This systematic review aimed to assess the in vivo and clinical effect of strontium (Sr)-enriched biomaterials in bone formation and/or remodelling.

Objectives

We have observed clinical cases where bone is formed in the overlaying muscle covering surgically created bone defects treated with a hydroxyapatite/calcium sulphate biomaterial. Our objective was to investigate the osteoinductive potential of the biomaterial and to determine if growth factors secreted from local bone cells induce osteoblastic differentiation of muscle cells.

This study investigates the use of porous biphasic ceramics as graft extenders in impaction grafting of the femur during revision hip surgery.

Impaction grafting of the femur was performed in four groups of sheep. Group one received pure allograft, group two 50% allograft and 50% BoneSave, group three 50% allograft and 50% BoneSave type 2 and group four 10% allograft and 90% BoneSave as the graft material. Function was assessed using an index of pre- and post-operative peak vertical ground reaction force ratios. Changes in bone mineral density were measured by dual energy X ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scanning. Loosening and subsidence were assessed radiographically and by histological examination of the explanted specimens.

There was no statistically significant difference between the four groups after 18 months of unrestricted functional loading for all outcome measures.