Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 20 of 103
Results per page:
The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery British Volume
Vol. 93-B, Issue 6 | Pages 755 - 759
1 Jun 2011
Brennan SA Brabazon D O’Byrne JM

We developed a method of applying vibration to the impaction bone grafting process and assessed its effect on the mechanical properties of the impacted graft. Washed morsellised bovine femoral heads were impacted into shear test rings. A range of frequencies of vibration was tested, as measured using an accelerometer housed in a vibration chamber. Each shear test was repeated at four different normal loads to generate stress-strain curves. The Mohr-Coulomb failure envelope from which shear strength and interlocking values are derived was plotted for each test. The experiments were repeated with the addition of blood in order to replicate a saturated environment. Graft impacted with the addition of vibration at all frequencies showed improved shear strength when compared with impaction without vibration, with 60 Hz giving the largest effect. Under saturated conditions the addition of vibration was detrimental to the shear strength of the aggregate. The civil-engineering principles of particulate settlement and interlocking also apply to impaction bone grafting. Although previous studies have shown that vibration may be beneficial in impaction bone grafting on the femoral side, our study suggests that the same is not true in acetabular revision


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXI | Pages 23 - 23
1 May 2012
S. B K. R D. B J. O
Full Access

Studies on soil mechanics have established that when vibration is applied to an aggregate, it results in more efficient alignment of particles and reduces the energy required to impact the aggregate. Our aim was to develop a method of applying vibration to the bone impaction process and assess its effect on the mechanical properties of the impacted graft. Phase 1. Eighty bovine femoral heads were milled using the Noviomagus bone mill. The graft was then washed using a pulsed lavage normal saline system over a sieve tower. A vibration impaction device was developed which housed two 15V DC motors with eccentric weights attached inside a metal cylinder. A weight was dropped onto this from a set height 72 times so as to replicate the bone impaction process. A range of frequencies of vibration were tested, as measured using an accelerometer housed in the vibration chamber. Each shear test was then repeated at four different normal loads so as to generate a family of stress-strain curves. The Mohr-Coulomb failure envelope from which the shear strength and interlocking values are derived was plotted for each test. Phase 2. Experiments were repeated with the addition of blood so as to replicate a saturated environment as is encountered during operative conditions. Relatively dry graft impacted with the addition of vibration showed improved shear strength at all frequencies of vibration when compared to impaction without vibration. In our system the optimal frequency of vibration was 60 Hz. Under saturated conditions the addition of vibration is detrimental the shear strength of the aggregate. This is secondary to decreased interlocking between particles and may be explained by the process of liquefaction


The Bone & Joint Journal
Vol. 101-B, Issue 6_Supple_B | Pages 62 - 67
1 Jun 2019
Tanzer M Chuang PJ Ngo CG Song L TenHuisen KS

Aims. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the biological fixation of a 3D printed porous implant, with and without different hydroxyapatite (HA) coatings, in a canine model. Materials and Methods. A canine transcortical model was used to evaluate the characteristics of bone ingrowth of Ti6Al4V cylindrical implants fabricated using laser rapid manufacturing (LRM). At four and 12 weeks post-implantation, we performed histological analysis and mechanical push-out testing on three groups of implants: a HA-free control (LRM), LRM with precipitated HA (LRM-PA), and LRM with plasma-sprayed HA (LRM-PSHA). Results. Substantial bone ingrowth was observed in all LRM implants, with and without HA, at both time periods. Bone ingrowth increased from 42% to 52% at four weeks, to 60% to 65% at 12 weeks. Mechanical tests indicated a minimum shear fixation strength of 20 MPa to 24 MPa at four weeks, and 34 MPa to 40 MPa at 12 weeks. There was no significant difference in the amount of bone ingrowth or in the shear strength between the three implant types at either time period. Conclusion. At four and 12 weeks, the 3D printed porous implants exhibited consistent bone ingrowth and high mechanical shear strength. Based on the results of this study, we confirmed the suitability of this novel new additive manufacturing porous material for biological fixation by bone ingrowth. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2019;101-B(6 Supple B):62–67


Bone & Joint Research
Vol. 8, Issue 6 | Pages 246 - 252
1 Jun 2019
Liddle A Webb M Clement N Green S Liddle J German M Holland J

Objectives. Previous studies have evidenced cement-in-cement techniques as reliable in revision arthroplasty. Commonly, the original cement mantle is reshaped, aiding accurate placement of the new stem. Ultrasonic devices selectively remove cement, preserve host bone, and have lower cortical perforation rates than other techniques. As far as the authors are aware, the impact of ultrasonic devices on final cement-in-cement bonds has not been investigated. This study assessed the impact of cement removal using the Orthosonics System for Cemented Arthroplasty Revision (OSCAR; Orthosonics) on final cement-in-cement bonds. Methods. A total of 24 specimens were manufactured by pouring cement (Simplex P Bone Cement; Stryker) into stainless steel moulds, with a central rod polished to Stryker Exeter V40 specifications. After cement curing, the rods were removed and eight specimens were allocated to each of three internal surface preparation groups: 1) burr; 2) OSCAR; and 3) no treatment. Internal holes were recemented, and each specimen was cut into 5 mm discs. Shear testing of discs was completed by a technician blinded to the original grouping, recording ultimate shear strengths. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was completed, inspecting surfaces of shear-tested specimens. Results. The mean shear strength for OSCAR-prepared specimens (33.6 MPa) was significantly lower than for the control (46.3 MPa) and burr (45.8 MPa) groups (p < 0.001; one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Tukey’s post hoc analysis). There was no significant difference in shear strengths between control and burr groups (p = 0.57). Scanning electron microscopy of OSCAR specimens revealed evidence of porosity undiscovered in previous studies. Conclusion. Results show that the cement removal technique impacts on final cement-in-cement bonds. This in vitro study demonstrates significantly weaker bonds when using OSCAR prior to recementation into an old cement mantle compared with cement prepared with a burr or no treatment. This infers that care must be taken in surgical decision-making regarding cement removal techniques used during cement-in-cement revision arthroplasty, suggesting that the risks and benefits of ultrasonic cement removal need consideration. Cite this article: A. Liddle, M. Webb, N. Clement, S. Green, J. Liddle, M. German, J. Holland. Ultrasonic cement removal in cement-in-cement revision total hip arthroplasty: What is the effect on the final cement-in-cement bond? Bone Joint Res 2019;8:246–252. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.86.BJR-2018-0313.R1


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 102-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 105 - 105
1 Feb 2020
Friedrich C Wang S Francis A Baker E
Full Access

Prior work in the setting of MRSA (clinical isolate), showed that enhancement of Ti6Al4V with anodized nanotubes apparently disrupts the formation and adhesion of MRSA biofilm. The greater amount of cultured MRSA using effluent released from in vitro nanotube surfaces by sonication, compared with thermal plasma sprayed (TPS), indicated probable disruption of biofilm formation and adhesion. The use of nanosilver nanotubes in vivo in a rabbit model showed that after 1 week of infection followed by 1 week of vancomycin treatment, the nanotube MRSA level was 30% that of TPS, and the nanosilver nanotube MRSA level was only 5% of TPS. The implementation of the technology will enhance the remodeled bone locking ability of rough TPS, with surface nanotubes that provide antibacterial properties and increased bone adhesion. Lap shear tests of the nanotubes were performed according to ASTM F1044. In multiple tests, circular adhesive films bonded Ti6Al4V bars containing nanotubes with plain Ti6Al4V. The assemblies were suitably arranged in a tensile tester and pulled to shear failure. There were three modes of failure; shear failure within the adhesive, failure of the adhesive from the plain titanium, and shear failure of the nanotubes from the bar. Tests determined the shear strength of the adhesive and its bonding strength to bare titanium. ImageJ software determined the area of each of the three failure modes. From this analysis, the shear strength of the nanotubes of each sample was calculated. The analyses showed the shear strength of the nanotubes to be as high as 65MPa (9,500psi) with a more typical shear strength of 55MPa (8,000 psi), and several surfaces with 45MPa (6,000 psi). The literature presents models predicting the shear stress in bonded hip stems. Assuming the TPS with nanotubes performs similar to a bonded hip stem, owing to the locking of the bone with the TPS, a typical shear stress prediction for physiological loads is approximately 10 MPa. The nanotube shear strengths were 4–6 times higher than the expected stress during use. For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_13 | Pages 7 - 7
1 Oct 2018
Tanzer M
Full Access

Introduction. Porous surfaces developed over the past decades have been shown to promote tissue ingrowth. Hydroxyapatite (HA) coatings have been added to these porous coatings in an attempt to further augment bone ingrowth. The development of additive manufacturing techniques has allowed for precision in building these complex porous structures. The effect of supplemental HA coatings on these new surfaces is unclear. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the biological fixation of a novel 3D printed porous implant in a canine model. In addition, we evaluated the effect of different HA coatings on this 3D printed implant. Methods. A canine transcortical model was used to evaluate the performance of three different laser rapid manufacturing (LRM) Ti6Al4V cylindrical implants (5.2 mm diameter, 10mm length): LRM with precipitated hydroxyapatite (P-HA), LRM with plasma sprayed hydroxyapatite (PS-HA), and a hydroxyapatite-free control (No-HA). The implants were 50–60% porous with a mean pore size of 450 μm and have a random interconnected architecture with irregular pore sizes and shapes that are designed based on the structure of cancellous bone. A lateral approach to the femoral diaphysis was used to prepare 5 mm unicortical, perpendicular drill holes in 12 canines. One of each implant type was press-fit into each femur. The femora were harvested at both 4 and 12 weeks post implantation, radiographed and prepared for either mechanical push-out testing to assess the shear strength of the bone-implant interface (left femora, N=6) or for histological processing (right femora, N=6). An un-paired Student's t-test was used to compare statistical significance between the 4 and 12-week results, as well as differences due to implant type; p<0.05 was considered significant. Results. The post-mortem contact radiographs demonstrated substantial condensation of bone around the implants at both 4 and 12 weeks. Bone ingrowth in the canine femora was observed in all implants, with and without HA, at both time periods under backscattered SEM. The mean extent of bone ingrowth at 4 weeks for no-HA, P-HA, and PS-HA implants was 41.5% (95% CI 32.5 to 50.6), 51.0% (95% CI 45.2 to 56.8) and 53.2% (95% CI 41.6 to 64.7), respectively. The mean extent of bone ingrowth at 12 weeks for no-HA, P-HA, and PS-HA implants was 64.4% (95% CI 61.5 to 67.3), 59.9% (95% CI 51.9 to 67.8) and 64.9% (95% CI 58.2 to 71.6), respectively. There was no significant difference in the amount of bone ingrowth between the HA and non-HA coated implants at any of the time points. All the implants were successfully pushed out after 4 weeks of implantation. The mean shear strength from the push-out test at 4 weeks for the no-HA, P-HA, and PS-HA implants was calculated to be 21.6 MPa (95% CI 17.2 to 26.0), 20.7 MPa (95% CI 18.9 to 22.4), and 20.2 MPa (95% CI 16.3 to 24.2), respectively. At week 12, in two femora all three implant types had compressive failure before rupture of the bone-implant interface with a load of over 2000N. This suggests that the values of shear strength were higher than those calculated from the successful tests at 12 weeks. The mean shear strength for the remaining no-HA, P-HA and PS-HA implants at 12 weeks was calculated to be 39.9 MPa (95% CI 29.8 to 50.9), 33.7 MPa (95% CI 26.3 to 41.2), and 36.0 MPa (95% CI 29.53 to 42.4), respectively. For all implants, the mean shear strength at 12 weeks was statistically significantly greater than at 4 weeks (p<0.05). There was no significant difference in the shear strength between HA coated and non-HA coated implants at 4 or 12 weeks. Conclusion. At 4 and 12 weeks, all non-HA coated LRM Ti6Al4V implants consistently exhibited very high bone ingrowth and mechanical shear strength in the canine model. These results demonstrate that this novel additive manufactured porous implant promoted biological fixation in a canine model. There was no significant improvement in the extent of bone ingrowth with the addition of HA. This is in agreement with the literature indicating that topography is the dominant factor governing bone apposition to hydroxyapatite-coated implants. It is likely that in this model, the morphologic features and roughness of the surface of the LRM implants stimulated osteoblastic activity, so that the addition of HA had a non-significant effect


The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery British Volume
Vol. 87-B, Issue 9 | Pages 1298 - 1302
1 Sep 2005
Iesaka K Jaffe WL Jones CM Kummer FJ

We have investigated the role of the penetration of saline on the shear strength of the cement-stem interface for stems inserted at room temperature and those preheated to 37°C using a variety of commercial bone cements. Immersion in saline for two weeks at 37°C reduced interfacial strength by 56% to 88% after insertion at room temperature and by 28% to 49% after preheating of the stem. The reduction in porosity as a result of preheating ranged from 71% to 100%. Increased porosity correlated with a reduction in shear strength after immersion in saline (r = 0.839, p < 0.01) indicating that interfacial porosity may act as a fluid conduit


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 102-B, Issue SUPP_6 | Pages 5 - 5
1 Jul 2020
Tanzer M Chuang P Ngo C Aponte C Song L TenHuisen K
Full Access

Porous surfaces on orthopaedic implants have been shown to promote tissue ingrowth. This study evaluated biological fixation of novel additively manufactured porous implants with and without hydroxyapatite coatings in a canine transcortical model. Laser rapid manufacturing (LRM) Ti6Al4V cylindrical implants were built with a random interconnected architecture mimicking cancellous bone (5.2 mm diameter, 10mm length, 50–60% porous, mean pore size 450μm). Three groups were investigated in this study: as-built with no coating (LRM), as-built coated with solution precipitated hydroxyapatite (LRM-PA), and as-built coated with a plasma sprayed hydroxyapatite (LRM-PSHA). Implants were press-fit into a 5mm unicortical, perpendicular drill hole in the femoral diaphysis of the left and right femurs in 12 canines. Right femora were harvested for histology (SEM, bone ingrowth into implant within cortical region) and left femora for mechanical push-out testing (shear strength of bone-implant interface) at 4 and 12 weeks (N=6, un-paired Student's t-test, p=0.05). For mean bone ingrowth, there was no significant difference between groups at 4 weeks (LRM, LRM-PA, LRM-PSHA: 41.5+8.6%, 51+5.5% and 53.2+11%, respectively) or 12 weeks (LRM, LRM-PA, LRM-PSHA: 64.4+2.8%, 59.9+7.6%, 64.9+6.4%, respectively). LRM and LRM-PA implants had more bone ingrowth at 12 weeks than 4 weeks (p < 0 .05). Mean shear strength of all implants at 12 weeks (LRM, LRM-PA, LRM-PSHA: 39.9+3.6MPa, 33.7+4.6MPa, 36+4.1MPa respectively) were greater than at 4 weeks (LRM, LRM-PA, LRM-PSHA: 21.6+2.8MPa, 20.7+1.1MPa, 20.2+2.5MPa respectively) (p < 0 .05). No significant difference was observed between all groups at 4 or 12 weeks. Overall, this canine study confirmed the suitability of this novel additive manufacturing porous material for biological fixation by bone ingrowth. All implants exhibited high bone ingrowth and mechanical shear strength in this canine model. No difference was observed between uncoated and hydroxyapatite coated implants


The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery British Volume
Vol. 75-B, Issue 3 | Pages 459 - 463
1 May 1993
Majkowski R Miles A Bannister G Perkins J Taylor G

We studied the effects of nine techniques of bone surface preparation on cement penetration and shear strength at the cement-bone interface in a standard model of bovine cancellous bone. In unprepared bone the mean penetration was 0.2 mm and the mean shear strength of the interface was 1.9 MPa, less than that of the underlying bone. Brushing with surface irrigation gave mean penetrations of 0.6 to 1.4 mm and mean shear strengths of 1.5 to 9.9 MPa. In 50% of specimens the interface was weaker than the underlying bone. The use of pressurised lavage resulted in mean penetrations of 4.8 to 7.9 mm and mean shear strengths of 26.5 to 36.1 MPa, which were greater than those of the cancellous bone in all specimens. Pressurised lavage was equally effective alone or in combination with brushing, and its efficacy was not altered by using pulsed or continuous jets, or by changing the temperature of the solution from 21 degrees C to 37 degrees C


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 95-B, Issue SUPP_15 | Pages 360 - 360
1 Mar 2013
Wang T Pelletier M Bertollo N Crosky A Walsh W
Full Access

Introduction. Implant contamination prior to cement application has the potential to affect the cement-implant bond. the consequences of implant contamination were investigated in vitro using static shear loading with bone cement and titanium dowels of differing surface roughness both with, and without contamination by substances that are likely to be present during surgery. Namely; saline, fat, blood and oil, as a negative control. Methods. Fifty Titanium alloy (Ti-6Al-4V) dowels were prepared with two surface finishes comparable to existing stems. The roughness (Ra and Rq) of the dowel surface was measured before and after the pushout test. Four contaminants (Phosphate Buffered Saline (PBS), ovine marrow, ovine blood, olive oil) were prepared and heated to 37°C. Each contaminant was smeared on the dowel surface completely and uniformly approximately 4 minutes prior to implantation. Samples were separated into ten groups (n=5 per group) based on surface roughness and contaminant. Titanium alloy dowels was placed in the center of Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) tubes with bone cement, and equilibrated at 37°C in PBS for 7 days prior to mechanical testing. The push out test was performed at 1 mm per minute. The dowel surface and cement mantel were analyzed using a Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) to determine the distribution and composition of any debris and contaminates on the surface. Results. All contaminants decreased stem-bone cement interfacial shear strength. Saline produced the greatest decrease, followed by blood. The effect of fat was less pronounced and similar to that of oil likely due to the strong lipid solvent properties of the methacrylate monomer. For rough dowels, there were differences in ultimate shear strength between control and contaminated groups (p<0.001). Blood and saline groups had lower ultimate shear strength compared to fat and oil (p<0.05) (fig. 1). The ultimate shear strength for smooth samples was not significantly affected by contamination. Increasing surface roughness increased the interfacial bonding strength, even in the presence of contaminants. In control, fat and oil groups, the effect of roughness are significant (p<0.001, p<0.05 and p<0.001 respectively) (fig. 1). Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) showed that contaminants influence the interfacial bond by different mechanisms. Although rough surfaces were associated with higher bond strength, they also generated more debris, which could negatively affect the longevity of the implant bond (fig. 2 and fig. 3). Conclusion. The results of this study underscores the importance of keeping an implant free from contamination, and that if contamination does occur, a saline rinse may further decrease the stability of an implant. Contaminants did not significantly affect the bond strength between bone cement and smooth Ti stem, although a trend of improved properties was seen in the presence of lipid based contaminants. Therefore, the influence of contaminants is more important to the shape-closed type stem. Increasing surface roughness dramatically improved the load carrying capability of the implant-cement interface even with contaminants


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 101-B, Issue SUPP_5 | Pages 97 - 97
1 Apr 2019
Justin D Nguyen YS Walsh W Pelletier M Friedrich CR Baker E Jin SH Pratt C
Full Access

Recent clinical data suggest improvement in the fixation of tibia trays for total knee arthroplasty when the trays are additive manufactured with highly porous bone ingrowth structures. Currently, press-fit TKA is less common than press-fit THA. This is partly because the loads on the relatively flat, porous, bony apposition area of a tibial tray are more demanding than those same porous materials surrounding a hip stem. Even the most advanced additive manufactured (AM) highly porous structures have bone ingrowth limitations clinically as aseptic loosening still remains more common in press-fit TKA vs. THA implants. Osseointegration and antibacterial properties have been shown in vitro and in vivo to improve when implants have modified surfaces that have biomimetic nanostructures designed to mimic and interact with biological structures on the nano-scale. Pre-clinical evaluations show that TiO. 2. nanotubes (TNT), produced by anodization, on Ti6Al4V surfaces positively enhance the rate at which osseointegration occurs and TNT nano-texturization enhances the antibacterial properties of the implant surface. 2. In this in vivo sheep study, identical Direct Metal laser Sintered (DMLS) highly porous Ti6Al4V specimens with and without TNT surface treatment are compared to sintered bead specimens with plasma sprayed hydroxyapatite-coated surface treatment. Identical DMLS specimens made from CoCrMo were also implanted in sheep tibia bi-cortically (3 per tibia) and in the cancellous bone of the distal femur and proximal tibia (1 per site). Animals were injected with fluorochrome labels at weeks 1, 2 and 3 after surgery to assess the rate of bone integration. The cortical specimens were mechanically tested and processed for PMMA histology and histomorphometry after 4 or 12 weeks. The cancellous samples were also processed for PMMA histology and histomorphometry. The three types of bone labels were visualized under UV light to examine the rate of new bony integration. At 4 weeks, a 42% increase in average pull-out shear strength between nanotube treated specimens and non-nanotube treated specimens was shown. A 21% increase in average pull-out shear strength between nanotube treated specimens and hydroxyapatite-coated specimens was shown. At 12 weeks, all specimens had statistically similar pull-out values. Bone labels demonstrated new bone formation into the porous domains on the materials as early as 2 weeks. A separate in vivo study on 8 rabbits infected with methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus showed bacterial colonization reduction on the surface of the implants treated with TNT. In vitro and in vivo evidence suggests that nanoscale surfaces have an antibacterial effect due to surface energy changes that reduce the ability of bacteria to adhere. These in vivo studies show that TNT on highly porous AM specimens made from Ti6Al4V enhances new bone integration and also reduce microbial attachment


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXXVI | Pages 100 - 100
1 Aug 2012
Coathup M Shawcross J Scarsbrook C Korda M Hanoun A Pickford M Agg P Blunn G
Full Access

Introduction. A modified anodisation technique where a titanium surface releases bactericidal concentrations of silver was developed and called Agluna. Our hypothesis was that silver incorporation was bactericidal and had no effects on the viability of fibroblasts and osteoblasts, would have no negative effect on interfacial shear strength and bone contact in an in vivo trans-cortical implant ovine model. Methods. In vitro: Titanium alloy discs were either polished (Ti), anodised (Ano), anodised or Agluna treated (Ag) or anodised and Agluna treated followed by a conditioning step (Ag C). Conditioning was achieved by incubating discs in culture fluid for 48 hrs. The bactericidal effect of these discs was tested by measuring the zone of inhibition of different bacteria grown on agar. Live/dead staining was carried out and silver levels measured using atomic emission spectroscopy. 8 implants were inserted into each sheep (60 in total (n=5)). Grit blasted Titanium alloy (Gb) and Agluna treated grit blasted titanium alloy (Ag) at a silver concentration of 4-6 micrograms/cm2 were compared at 6 weeks. Gb implants, Ag (at 4-6micrograms/cm2), high dose Agluna implants with silver concentrations at 15-20micrograms/cm2 (HdAg) and a grit blasted anodised titanium alloy (Ano) were compared at 12 weeks. Pullout strength and bone-implant contact was quantified. Results. On Ti, Ano and Ag C surfaces the number of live fibroblasts was significantly greater than on Ag (non-conditioned) surfaces. Data from pull out tests at 6 weeks showed a lower but significant interfacial shear strength in the Ag group (310.4N) when compared with the Gb group (561.2N) (p=0.01). At 12 weeks, there were no significant differences between each of the 4 treatment groups. Histological analysis showed no significant differences in bone-implant contact between groups at 6 and 12 weeks. Discussion. The initial non-conditioned Agluna surface is bactericidal and cytotoxic but on conditioning, osteoblasts and fibroblasts attached and remained viable. The condition Agluna surface remains bactericidal. Silver incorporation at a concentration up to 20 micrograms/cm2 has no adverse toxic effect on osteointegration and the interfacial shear strength of implants. This coating has been used clinically in situations where the infection rate is high


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_12 | Pages 4 - 4
1 Jun 2017
Liddle A German M Green S Townsend A Webb M Holland J
Full Access

Numerous studies have evidenced cement-in-cement techniques as reliable in revision arthroplasty. The original cement mantle is commonly reshaped to aid accurate placement of the new stem. Ultrasonic devices selectively remove cement, preserve host bone and have lower cortical perforation rates than other techniques. As far as the authors are aware, their impact on final cement-cement bonds has not been investigated. This study assessed the impact of cement removal using OSCAR (Orthosonics System for Cemented Arthroplasty Revision, ORTHOSONICS) on final cement-cement bonds. Twenty-four specimens were manufactured by pouring cement (Simplex P Bone Cement, Stryker) into stainless-steel moulds with a central rod polished to Stryker Exeter V40 specifications. After cement curing, rods were removed and eight specimens allocated to each of three internal surface preparation groups: 1) burr; 2) OSCAR; or 3) no treatment. Internal holes were re-cemented, then each specimen was cut into 5mm discs. Shear testing of discs was completed by a technician blinded to original grouping (Instron 5567, UK), recording ultimate shear strengths. The mean shear strength for OSCAR-prepared specimens (17 MPa, 99% CI 14.9 to 18.6, SD=4.0) was significantly lower than that measured for the control (23 MPa, 99% CI 22.5 to 23.7, SD=1.4) and burr (23 MPa, 99% CI 22.1 to 23.7, SD=1.9) groups (P<0.001, one-way ANOVA with Tukey's post-hoc analysis). There was no significant difference between control and burr groups (P>0.05). Results show that cement removal technique impacts on final cement-cement bonds. This in vitro study shows a significantly weaker bond when using OSCAR prior to re-cementation into an old cement mantle, compared to cement prepared with a burr or no treatment. These results have implications for surgical practice and decision-making about specific cement removal techniques used during cement-in-cement revision arthroplasty, suggesting that the risks and benefits of ultrasonic cement removal need careful consideration


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 90-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 368 - 368
1 Jul 2008
Bolland B Partridge K New A Dunlop D Oreffo R
Full Access

The use of fresh morsellised allograft in impaction bone grafting for revision hip surgery remains the gold standard. Bone marrow contains osteogenic progenitor cells that arise from multipotent mesenchymal stem cells and we propose that in combination with allograft will produce a living composite with biological and mechanical potential. This study aimed to determine if human bone marrow stromal cells (HBMSC) seeded onto highly washed morsellised allograft could survive the impaction process, differentiate and proliferate along the osteogenic lineage and confer biomechanical advantage in comparison to impacted allograft alone. Future work into the development of a bioreactor is planned for the potential safe translation of such a technique into clinical practice. Methods: HBMSC were isolated and culture expanded in vitro under osteogenic conditions. Cells were seeded onto prepared morsellised allograft and impacted with a force equivalent to a standard femoral impaction (474J/m2). Samples were incubated for either two or four week periods under osteogenic conditions and analysed for cell viability, histology, immunocytochemistry, and biochemical analysis of cell number and osteogenic enzyme activity. Mechanical shear testing, using a Cam shear tester was performed, under three physiological compressive stresses (50N, 150N, 250N) from which the shear strength, internal friction angle and particle interlocking values were derived. Results: HBMSC survival post impaction, as evidenced by cell tracker green staining, was seen throughout the samples. There was a significant increase in DNA content (P< 0.05) and specific alkaline phosphatase activity (P< 0.05) compared to impacted seeded allograft samples. Immunocytochemistry staining for type I collagen confirmed cell differentiation along the osteogenic lineage. There was no statistical difference in the shear strength, internal friction angle and particulate cohesion between the two groups at 2 and 4 weeks. Conclusion: HBMSC seeded onto allograft resulted in the formation of a living composite capable of withstanding the forces equivalent to a standard femoral impaction and, under osteogenic conditions, differentiate and proliferate along the osteogenic lineage. In addition, there was no reduction in aggregate shear strength and longer term studies are warranted to examine the biomechanical advantage of a living composite. The therapeutic implications of such composites auger well for orthopaedic applications


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 69 - 69
1 Jan 2011
Jones A Foong T Bolland B New A Dunlop D Oreffo R
Full Access

Introduction: Impaction bone grafting (IBG) using fresh frozen morsellised allograft is considered by many as the method of choice for replacing lost bone stock encountered during revision hip surgery. Bone marrow contains multipotent skeletal stem cells which have the potential to differentiate down a number of different cell lineages including osteoblasts, chondrocytes and adipocytes. In IBG it is desirable for as many as possible to go on to form bone rather than fibrous tissue to form a solid osseous construct. Whilst it is possible to push cells down the osteogenic lineage in vitro, some of these methods (e.g. the addition of Dexamethasone) are not translatable to clinical practice due to undesirable side effects. In this study we test the hypothesis that by coating the allograft with type 1 Collagen prior to seeding with human bone marrow stromal cells (hBMSC), the cellular adhesion and proliferation down an osteogenic lineage can be increased, leading to improved mechanical and biological properties of the IBG composite. Methods: A control group of plain allograft and three experimental groups where used to determine the effects that collagen and hBMSC have on IBG (both individually and in combination). The samples where impacted in standardised fashion previously validated to replicate Femoral IBG, and cultured in vitro for 2 weeks. The samples then underwent mechanical shear testing giving a family of stress strain curves for each group, from which a Mohr coulomb failure curve can be plotted. Using the Mohr Coulomb failure equation τ = σ tanΦ + c, the shear strength (τ), Internal friction angle (tanΦ) and inter particulate cohesion (c) can then be calculated. Biochemical analysis was also performed for DNA content and Osteogenic activity. Results: Mechanical shear testing demonstrated a significant improvement (p=0.002) in the grafts ability to resist shear with the coating of Collagen and seeding with hBMSC (245 vs 299 kPa) as well as improved cohesion between the bone graft particles (46 vs 144 kPa). Regression analysis of the shear strength showed a linear increase with compressive stress (R2 > 0.98) for all groups, indicating that the grafts satisfied the Mohr Coulomb failure law. In the two groups seeded with cells, the collagen coated group also showed increased osteogenic cell activity compared to the plain allograft. Conclusion: This study has shown a role in the improvement of the mechanical and biological properties of IBG coated with type 1 Collagen and seeded with hBMSC. Collagen coating of IBG is a facile process and translation of the technique into the theatre setting feasible. The improvement in shear strength and cohesion could lead to earlier weight bearing for the patients and allow quicker recovery. The therapeutic implications of such composites auger well for orthopaedic applications. We are currently strengthening the above findings with an in vivo study


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 103-B, Issue SUPP_13 | Pages 11 - 11
1 Nov 2021
Imwinkelried T Heuberger R Eggli S
Full Access

Introduction and Objective. Local cartilage defects in the knee are painful and mostly followed by arthritis. In order to avoid impaired mobility, the osteochondral defect might be bridged by a synthetic compound material: An osteoconductive titanium foam as an anchoring material in the subchondral bone and an infiltrated polymer as gliding material in contact with the surrounding natural cartilage. Materials and Methods. Titanium foam cylinders (Ø38 mm) with porosities ranging from 57% to 77% were produced by powder metallurgy with two different grain sizes of the space holder (fine: 340 ± 110 μm, coarse: 530 ± 160 μm). The sintered titanium foam cylinders were infiltrated with UHMWPE powder on one end and UHMWPE bulk at the other end, at two different temperatures (160 °C, 200 °C), using a pressure of 20 MPa for 15 minutes. Smaller cylinders (Ø16 mm) were retrieved from the compound material by water jet cutting. The infiltration depths were determined by optical microscopy. The anchoring of the UHMWPE was measured by a shear test and the mechanical properties of the titanium foam were verified by a subsequent compression test. The tribological behaviour was investigated in protein containing liquid using fresh cartilage pins (Ø5 mm) sliding against a UHMWPE disc with or without a notch to simulate the gap between the implant and the surrounding cartilage. Friction coefficients were determined in a rotation tribometer and the cartilage wear in a multidirectional six-station tribometer from AMTI (load 10 – 50 N, sliding speed 20 mm/s, 37 °C). Results. UHMWPE could be infiltrated into titanium foam by 1.1 – 1.3 mm with fine pores and by 1.5 – 1.8 mm with coarse pores. The infiltration was neither dependent on the type of UHMWPE (powder or bulk) nor on the temperature. The polymer was so well anchored inside the titanium foam pores that the shear forces for the compounds exceeded the shear strength obtained for a UHMWPE-cylinder. This effect was due to the increased stiffness of the compound plug. Uniaxial compression of the titanium foams after the shear-off of the polymer revealed yield strengths ranging from 50 – 88 MPa for porosities of 62 – 73%. The Ø16 mm samples yielded beyond physiological loads in the knee (≥ 10x body weight) and behaved in a strain hardening and fully ductile manner, reaching deformations of at least 50 % of their initial height without the appearance of macroscopically visible cracks. For smaller plug diameters down to Ø8 mm, however, the lower porosity / higher strength foam should be used to limit elastic deformation of the compound to < 0.1 mm. Pore size did not significantly influence the strength and stiffness values. The elevated coefficient of friction between cartilage and UHMWPE of about 1 was not negatively affected by the presence of the gap. The height loss of the cartilage pin after 1 hour (respectively after 3600 reciproque wear cycles) was 0.2 ± 0.1 mm using a flat disc. For discs with a 1 mm wide V-notch, the wear increased to 0.9 ± 0.3 mm. Conclusions. The tested titanium foams are well suited to act as an anchoring material in the subchondral bone as mechanical properties can be tailored by choosing the adequate porosity and as bone ingrowth has previously been demonstrated for the used pore sizes. UHMWPE is not an ideal gliding partner against cartilage because the friction coefficients of frictions were high. The presence of a V-notched gap was detrimental for cartilage wear. More hydrophilic polymers like PCU should be tested as potential gliding materials


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 135 - 135
1 Jan 2016
Kwon S Kim Y Lim YW Jo WL
Full Access

The plasma spray(TPS) has come to be accepted as one of the more reliable methods of porous coating of prosthesis, it is not without some technical limitations, especially with regard to precise modulation of pore size, porosity, and roughness. However, the plasma spray(TPS) not often but seriously faces problems such as bead detachment related poor osteointegration, weakness of metal strength and high manufacturing costs in addition to its various technical limitations. Currently, there has been much research into developing a more economical and effective method for porous coating of the prosthesis. In light of such demand, 3D Printing with DMT Technology has been introduced into the field of surface treatment of prosthesis with promising expectations. DMT technology -an additive fabrication process that uses high-power laser and various metal powders in order to produce fully dense and geometrically complex metal components, molds, and dies directly from digital CAD model data of 3D subjects aims to help overcome many of the problems associated with plasma spray and thereby open a new chapter of endless possibilities for coating technology. In this study, the porous coating specimen using 3-D DMT metal printing was characterized morphologically as well as biomechanically, in terms of 1) pore size 2) porosity 3) tensile strength 4) shear strength 5) roughness respectively. The biological cyto-compatibility was evaluated by culturing human osteoblast-like cells(Saos-2: ATCC HTB85) on the surface of round discs with porous coating to demonstrate the biological influence on the porosity of the specimens with different surface treatment for comparative analysis. The evaluation was accompanied by assessment of cell proliferation and morphology with arrangement of actin filament and expression of adhesion molecule with α. v. β. 3. integrin. While 3-D DMT coating specimen showed relatively regular porosity in the range of 150–500µm with the increase of porosity about 83%, the mechanical behavior remarkably improved, compared to TPS: shear strength 13%, fatigue failure 30%, roughness 16%, respectively. Also worth noting, the tensile strength was unable to be measured because the glue for test had fallen off. (Fig. 1) There is no transitional zone underneath the porous coating layer.(Fig. 2) From the aspect of biocompatibility, 3-D coating showed better cell attachment, spreading of cytoskeleton, cell proliferation, and expression of osteogenic markers than TPS, even if not significantly.(Fig. 3) Additionally, cell migration assay was performed with double chamber study, and gene expression was evaluated by measuring alkaline phosphatase(ALP) levels and analyzing mRNA expression for ostepontin(OPG) and osteocalcin(OC). In conclusion, the study reinforces the popular stance that the implementation of 3-D DMT could open up new possibilities for coating technology and form a new chapter in the history of prosthesis development


The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery British Volume
Vol. 32-B, Issue 1 | Pages 5 - 11
1 Feb 1950
Harris WR

1. An apparatus was designed to determine the shearing strength of the upper tibial epiphysis in the rat. Observations were made with this instrumenton normal animals, on animals receiving growth-hormone, and on animals receiving oestrogen. 2. When the epiphysis separates from the diaphysis, the plane of cleavage is constant, passing through the third layer of the epiphysial plate. 3. Growth-hormone decreases and sex-hormone increases the shearing strength of the epiphysial plate. These changes are due to alterations produced by these two hormones in the thickness of the third layer of the epiphysial plate. 4. It is suggested that these findings may be of significance in providing an anatomical basis for slipping of the upper femoral epiphysis in man, especially when it is associated with the adiposo-genital syndrome or with rapid adolescent growth


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXXVII | Pages 145 - 145
1 Sep 2012
Tayton E Kalra S Briscoe A Aarvold A Smith J Lanham S Fahmy S Howdle S Shakesheff K Dunlop D Oreffo R
Full Access

Background. Impaction bone grafting with milled human allograft is the gold standard for replacing lost bone stock during revision hip surgery. Problems surrounding the use of allograft include cost, availability, disease transmission and stem subsidence (usually due to shear failure of the surrounding allograft). Aims. To investigate various polymers for use as substitute allograft. The ideal graft would be a composite with similar mechanical characteristics as allograft, and with the ability to form de novo bone. Methods. High and low molecular weight (MW) forms of three different polymers (polylactic acid (PLA), poly (lactic-co-glycolic) acid (PLGA) and polycaprolactone (PCL)) were milled, impacted into discs, and then tested in a custom built shear testing rig, and compared to allograft. A second stage of the experiment involved the addition of skeletal stem cells (SSC) to each of the milled polymers, impaction, 8 days incubation, and then tests for cell viability and number, via fluorostaining and biochemical (WST-1, DNA) assays. Results. The shear strengths of both high/ low MW PLA, and high/low MW PLGA were significantly higher than those of milled allograft but high and low MW PCL was poor to impact, and had significantly lower shear strengths. Fluorostaining showed good cell survival on high MW PLA, high MW PCL and both high and low MW PLGA. These findings were confirmed on both DNA and WST-1 assays. Conclusions. High MW PLA as well as high and low MW PLGA performed well both in mechanical testing and cell compatibility studies. These three polymers are good contenders to produce a living composite for use as substitute human allograft in impaction bone grafting


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXIX | Pages 65 - 65
1 Jul 2012
Dahabreh Z Stewart T Stone M
Full Access

Purpose of the Study. This study aims at investigating the effect of application time of bone cement on the cement-bone interface strength in two types of commercially available bone cements, Cement-A and Cement-B. Materials and methods. Cement-A and Cement-B were applied to cancellous bone specimens at two different times; 2 and 4 minutes (min). The bone specimens were formulated from bovine bone. Specimens were loaded to failure and the force at which the cement-bone interface failed was recorded. The shear strength of the cement-bone interface was calculated by dividing the force at failure by the cross-sectional surface area of the cement-bone interface. Results. The mean (± standard deviation) and median (inter-quartile range) shear strength of the cement-bone interface was 2.79 ± 1.29 MPa and 2.29 (2.34) MPa for Cement-A applied at 2 min; 1.35 ± 0.89 MPa and 1.35 (1.74) MPa for Cement-A applied at 4 min; 2.93 ± 1.21 MPa and 3.01 (2.61) MPa for Cement-B applied at 2 min; and 3.00 ± 1.11 MPa and 2.92 (1.61) MPa for Cement-B applied at 4 min. Compared to all other groups, the cement-bone interface strength was significantly lower when Cement-A was applied to the bone specimens at 4 min (p < 0.05). There was no significant difference in the cement-bone interface strength when Cement-B was applied to bone at 2 and at 4 min. Conclusions. Under these testing conditions, the cement-bone interface strength did not seem to be affected by the time of application of Cement-B to bone. However, it was significantly lower when Cement-A was applied to bone at 4 min