Aim.
Background. The advent of EOS imaging has offered clinicians the opportunity to image the whole skeleton in the anatomical standing position with a smaller radiation dose than standard spine roentgenograms. It is known as the fifth modality of imaging. Current NICE guidelines do not recommend EOS scans over x-rays citing: “The evidence indicated insufficient patient benefit in terms of radiation dose reduction and increased throughput to justify its cost”. Methods. We retrospectively reviewed 103 adult and 103 paediatric EOS scans of standing whole spines including shoulders and pelvis for those undergoing investigation for spinal deformity in a tertiary spinal centre in the UK. We matched this against a retrospective control group of 103 adults and 103 children who underwent traditional roentgenograms whole spine imaging at the same centre during the same timeframe. We aimed to compare the average radiation dose of AP and lateral images between the two modalities. We utilised a validated lifetime risk of cancer calculator (. www.xrayrisk.com. ) to estimate the additional mean risk per study. Results. In the Adult EOS Group (AEG) the mean estimated effective dose of AP was 0.08 mSv (0.04–0.15) and Lateral 0.06 mSv (0.03–0.14). Conversely in the Adult Roentgenograms Group (ARG) the mean AP was 0.49 mSv (0.15–1.88) and Lateral was 0.29 mSv (0.07–1.20). In the Paediatric EOS Group (PEG): the mean dose of AP was 0.07 mSv (0.02–0.21) and Lateral 0.04 mSv (0.02–0.11). Conversely Paediatric Roentgenograms Group (PRG) had a mean dose in AP of 0.37 mSv (0.03–5.92) and in lateral of 0.17 mSv (0.03–0.44). The percentage differences were: ARG:AES AP 613%, ARG:AES Lat 483%, PPG:PEG AP 529%, PRG:PEG Lat 425%. Mean difference 513%. The additional lifetime cancer risk for AEG was 1 in 176056 for males and 1 in 138696 for females, compared to ARG 1 in 31596 for males and 1 in 24894 for females. In PEG that was 1 in 58207 for boys and 1 in 33367 for girls, compared to PRG 1 in 11860 for boys and 1 in 6797 in girls. Differences in additional lifetime risk of cancer per scan: ARG:AES Male 557%, Female 557%, PRG:PEG Male 491%, Females 491%. Conclusion. Standard plain film imaging of the whole spine requires approximately five-times higher doses of radiation compared to dual planar EOS scans. This carries a significant impact when considering the need for repeat imaging on additional lifetime malignancy risk in both children and adults. There is approximately 5-fold increase in risk of cancer for all groups with roentgenograms over EOS. We directly challenge the
Background.
Background and purpose of the study. Axial Spondyloarthritis (axSpA) is commonly mistaken as chronic mechanical back pain. Delayed diagnosis averages 5- 8 years with impacts on effective and timely management, outcomes and quality of life.
The use of serial casting in the management of early onset scoliosis (EOS) has been well described. Our aim was to evaluate outcomes of plaster jacket therapy in patients with EOS from a tertiary referral centre. A retrospective review of hospital records and PACS images of 27 patients to identify patients treated with serial casting over a five year period. The primary outcome measure was the need for surgical intervention, with change in Cobb angle used as a secondary outcome measure. Mean age at presentation was 14 months (range 10 – 42), including 14 male and 13 female patients, with an average follow-up of 34 months. Curves were categorised according to aetiology: 16 idiopathic, 6 syndromic, 3 congenital and 2 neuromuscular curves. The mean Cobb angle at diagnosis was 43.7° (range 22 – 115) and mean rib vertebral angle difference (RVAD) was 22.2° (8 – 70). Duration of treatment was 9.9 months (range 3 – 27), with an average of two plaster jacket changes per child. At the time of review, patients fell into one of three groups. Group one (10 patients) failed conservative treatment due no improvement in Cobb angle (mean 48.4° compared with pre-op 53.9°, p value 0.55) and either had insertion of growing rods or had been listed for this procedure, at a mean age of 51.8 months. Group two (12 patients) had a mean Cobb angle of 38.9° pre-treatment which improved to 23.5° (p value <0.05) and were either treated in a brace or had discontinued treatment. The mean RVAD at initial diagnosis was 36.6° in group 1 compared with 13.8° in group 2 (p<0.05). All patients in group one requiring surgical treatment had an RVAD of greater than 20°. Serial casting is on-going for five patients (group three). Complications occurred in 30% of patients including pressure sores, chest infection and respiratory compromise requiring intubation. Current