Objectives. The treatment of osteoporotic fractures is a major challenge, and the enhancement of healing is critical as a major goal in modern fracture management. Most osteoporotic fractures occur at the metaphyseal bone region but few models exist and the healing is still poorly understood. A systematic review was conducted to identify and analyse the appropriateness of current osteoporotic metaphyseal fracture animal models. Materials and Methods. A literature search was performed on the Pubmed, Embase, and Web of Science databases, and relevant articles were selected. A total of 19 studies were included. Information on the animal, induction of osteoporosis, fracture technique, site and fixation, healing results, and utility of the model were extracted. Results. Fracture techniques included drill hole defects (3 of 19), bone defects (3 of 19), partial osteotomy (1 of 19), and complete osteotomies (12 of 19). Drill hole models and incomplete osteotomy models are easy to perform and allow the study of therapeutic agents but do not represent the usual clinical setting. Additionally, biomaterials can be filled into drill hole defects for analysis. Complete osteotomy models are most commonly used and are best suited for the investigation of therapeutic drugs or noninvasive interventions. The metaphyseal defect models allow the study of biomaterials, which are associated with complex and comminuted osteoporotic fractures. Conclusion. For a clinically relevant model, we propose that an animal model should satisfy the following criteria to study osteoporotic fracture healing: 1) induction of osteoporosis, 2) complete osteotomy or defect at the metaphysis unilaterally, and 3) internal fixation. Cite this article: R. M. Y. Wong, M. H. V. Choy, M. C. M. Li, K-S. Leung, S. K-H. Chow, W-H. Cheung, J. C. Y. Cheng. A systematic review of current osteoporotic metaphyseal fracture animal models. Bone Joint Res 2018;7:6–11. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.71.BJR-2016-0334.R2

The management of comminuted metaphyseal fractures is a technical challenge and satisfactory outcomes of such fixations often remain elusive. The small articular fragments and bone loss often make it difficult for standard fixation implants for proper fixation. We developed a novel technique to achieve anatomical reduction in multiple cases of comminuted metaphyseal fractures at different sites by employing the cantilever mechanism with the help of multiple thin Kirschner wires augmented by standard fixation implants. We performed a retrospective study of 10 patients with different metaphyseal fractures complicated by comminution and loss of bone stock. All patients were treated with the help of cantilever mechanism using multiple Kirschner wires augmented by compression plates. All the patients were operated by the same surgeon between November 2020 to March 2021 and followed up till March 2023. Surgical outcomes were evaluated according to the clinical and radiological criteria. A total of 10 patients were included in the study. Since we only included patients with highly unstable and comminuted fractures which were difficult to fix with traditional methods, the number of patients in the study were less. All 10 patients showed satisfactory clinical and radiological union at the end of the study with good range of motion. One of the patient in the study had post-operative wound complication which was managed conservatively with regular dressings and oral antibiotics. Comminuted metaphyseal fractures might differ in pattern and presentation with every patient and there can be no standard treatment for all. The cantilever technique of fracture fixation is based on the principle of cantilever mechanism used in bridges and helps achieve good anatomical reduction and fixation. It provides a decent alternative when standard modes of fixation don't give desired result owing to comminuted nature of fractures and deficiency of bone stock

Intramedullary nails (IMNs) are the current gold standard for treatment of long bone diaphyseal and selected metaphyseal fractures. Their design has undergone many revisions to improve fixation techniques, conform to the bone shape with appropriate anatomic fit, reduce operative time and radiation exposure, and extend the indication of the same implant for treatment of different fracture types with minimal soft tissue irritation. The IMNs are made or either titanium alloy or stainless steel and work as load-sharing internal splints along the long bone, usually accommodating locking elements – screws and blades, often featuring angular stability and offering different configurations for multiplanar fixation – to secure secondary fracture healing with callus formation in a relative-stability environment. Bone cement augmentation of the locking elements can modulate the construct stiffness, increase the surface area at the bone-implant interface, and prevent cut-through of the locking elements. The functional requirements of IMNs are related to maintaining fracture reduction in terms of length, alignment and rotation to enhance fracture healing. The load distribution during patient's activities is along the entire bone-nail interface, with nail length and anatomic fit being important factors to avoid stress risers

Osteoporotic fracture has become a major problem in ageing population and often requires prolonged healing time. Low Intensity Pulsed Ultrasound (LIPUS) can significantly enhance fracture healing through alteration of osteocyte lacuno-canalicular network (LCN). DMP1 in osteocytes is responsible for maintaining LCN and mineralisation. This study aims to investigate osteocyte-specific DMP1's role in enhanced osteoporotic fracture healing in response to mechanical stimulation. Bilateral ovariectomy was performed in 6-month-old female SD rats to induce osteoporosis. Metaphyseal fracture was created at left distal femur using oscillating micro-saw. Rats were randomised to groups: (1) DMP1 KD, (2) DMP1 KD + LIPUS, (3) Control, or (4) Control + LIPUS, where KD stands for knockdown by injection of shRNA into marrow cavity 2 weeks before surgery. Assessments included weekly radiography, microCT and immunohistochemistry on DMP1, E11, FGF23 and sclerostin. DMP1 KD significantly impaired LIPUS-accelerated fracture healing when comparing KD + LIPUS group to Control + LIPUS group. The X-ray relative opacity showed less tissue growth at all timepoints (Week 1, 3 & 6; p=0.000, 0.001 and 0.003 respectively) and the bone volume fraction was decreased after DMP1 KD at Week 3 (p=0.006). DMP1 KD also significantly altered the expression levels of osteocyte-specific DMP1, E11, FGF23 and sclerostin during healing process. The lower relative opacity and bone volume fraction in DMP1 KD groups indicated that knockdown of DMP1 was associated with poorer fracture healing process compared to non-knockdown groups. The similar results between knockdown group with and without LIPUS showed that blockage of DMP1 would negate LIPUS-induced enhancement on fracture healing. Acknowledgment: General Research Fund (Ref: 14113018)

The ideal treatment method regarding various defect sizes after local aggressive tumor resection is unknown. We investigated the biomechanical properties of metaphyseal defect filling regarding different defect sizes and fixation methods. Ninety-one sheep tibias were divided into five groups as 21 tibias per four study groups and 7 tibias in the control group. Study groups were further divided into three subgroups according to 25%, 50% and 75% metaphyseal defect size. Control group tibias were left intact. In study group 1, a metaphyseal defect was created and no further process was applied. Metaphyseal defects were filled with cement without fixation in group 2. Cement filling and fixation with 2 screws were performed in group 3. In addition to cement filling, plate-screw fixation was performed in group 4. Axial loading test was applied to all tibias and the results were compared between study subgroups and control group. Plate-screw fixation was found to have the best biomechanical properties in all defect sizes. Load to failure for screw fixation was found to be significantly decreased between 25% and 50% defect size (P<0.05). However, load to failure for isolated cement filling was not affected from defect size (p>0.05). In conclusion, size of the defect predicts the fixation method in addition to filling with cement. Filling with cement in metaphyseal defects was found to be biomechanically insufficient. In addition to filling with cement, additional screw fixation in less than 25% defects and plate-screw fixation in more than 25% defects may decrease tibial plateau fracture or metaphyseal fracture risk after local aggressive tumor resection

Summary Statement. The present study demonstrates the beneficial effects of strontium (Sr) modified calcium phosphate cement to improve new bone formation in a metaphyseal osteoporotic fracture defects in rats compared to calcium phosphate cement and empty defects. Keywords: strontium, fracture, calcium phosphate, bone formation. Introduction. Impaired fracture healing with subsequent implant failure is a dramatic problem in osteoporotic fractures. Biomaterials are of interest to stimulate fracture healing in osteoporotic defects and the objective of the current study is to investigate the effects of Strontium modified calcium phosphate cement (SrCPC) in a critical-size metaphyseal fracture defect of osteoporotic rats compared to calcium phosphate (CPC) and empty defect control group. Methods. 45 female Sprague-Dawley rats were randomized into 3 groups: SrCPC, CPC and empty defect (n=15 for each). A combinatorial approach of multi-deficiency diet for 3 months after bilateral ovariectomy was used for induction of osteoporosis. Left femur of all animals underwent a 4mm wedge-shaped metaphyseal osteotomy that was internally fixed with a T-shaped plate. The defect was then either filled with CPC or SrCPC and internally stabilised with a T shaped mini-plate. Empty defect served as a control. After 6 weeks femora were harvested followed by histological, histomorphometrical, immunohistochemical (bone-morphogenic protein 2, osteocalcin and osteoprotegerin), and molecular biology analysis (alkaline phosphatase, collagen10a1 and osteocalcin) to demonstrate the effects of the biomaterials on new bone formation. Time of flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) technology was used to assess the distribution of released strontium ions and calcium appearance of newly formed bone. Results. Histomorphometric analysis showed a statistically significant increase in the bone formation at the tissue-implant interface in the SrCPC group (p<0.001). A statistically significantly more cartilage and unmineralised bone formation was also seen in the SrCPC group in comparision to the CPC group alone (p<0.05) and also to the empty defect (p<0.05) in the former fracture defect zone. These data were confirmed by the immunohistochemistry results which revealed an increase in bone-morphogenic protein 2, osteocalcin and osteoprotegerin and an increase in expression of genes responsible for bone formation viz. alkaline phosphatase, collagen10a1 and osteocalcin. TOF-SIMs analysis showed a higher release of Sr from the SrCPC into the interface region and related to a higher calcium content in this area compared to CPC. Discussion/Conclusion. SrCPC treatment showed enhanced new bone formation in a metaphyseal osteoporotic fracture defect of rats after 6 weeks compared to CPC-filled and empty defects in histomorphometry, immunochemistry and gene expression analysis. Strontium ranelate is a well-known anti-osteoporotic drug increasing bone formation and reducing bone resorption. As revealed by TOF-SIMS release of Sr out of the the SrCPC cement is most likely attributable for new bone formation. Therefore, Sr seems to be a good candidate not only for systemic treatment in osteoporosis but also in Sr-modification of biomaterials for local stimulation of new bone formation in osteoporotic fracture defects

Objectives

Healing in cancellous metaphyseal bone might be different from midshaft fracture healing due to different access to mesenchymal stem cells, and because metaphyseal bone often heals without a cartilaginous phase. Inflammation plays an important role in the healing of a shaft fracture, but if metaphyseal injury is different, it is important to clarify if the role of inflammation is also different. The biology of fracture healing is also influenced by the degree of mechanical stability. It is unclear if inflammation interacts with stability-related factors.

External fixation of distal tibial fractures is often associated with delayed union. We have investigated whether union can be enhanced by using recombinant bone morphogenetic protein-7 (rhBMP-7).

Osteoinduction with rhBMP-7 and bovine collagen was used in 20 patients with distal tibial fractures which had been treated by external fixation (BMP group). Healing of the fracture was compared with that of 20 matched patients in whom treatment was similar except that rhBMP-7 was not used.

Significantly more fractures had healed by 16 (p = 0.039) and 20 weeks (p = 0.022) in the BMP group compared with the matched group. The mean time to union (p = 0.002), the duration of absence from work (p = 0.018) and the time for which external fixation was required (p = 0.037) were significantly shorter in the BMP group than in the matched group. Secondary intervention due to delayed healing was required in two patients in the BMP group and seven in the matched group.

RhBMP-7 can enhance the union of distal tibial fractures treated by external fixation.