A large body of the orthopaedic literature clearly indicates that the cement mantle surrounding the femoral component of a cemented total hip arthroplasty should be at least 2 mm thick. In the early 1970s, another concept was introduced and is still in use in France consisting of implanting a canal filling femoral component line-to-line associated with a thin cement mantle. This principle has been named the “French paradox”. An explanation to this phenomenon has been provided by in-vitro studies demonstrating that a thin cement mantle in conjunction with a canal filling stem was supported mainly by cortical bone and was subjected to low stresses. We carried out a study to evaluate the in-vivo migration patterns of 164 primary consecutive Charnley-Kerboull total hip replacements. All prosthesis in the current series combined an all-polyethylene socket and a 22.2 mm stainless steel femoral head. The monobloc double tapered (5.9 degrees) femoral component was made of 316L stainless steel with a highly polished surface (Ra = 0.04 μm), a quadrangular section, and a neck-stem angle of 130 degrees. The stem was available in six sizes with a stem length (shoulder to tip) ranging from 110 mm to 160 mm, and a neck length ranging from 24 mm to 56 mm. For each size, the femoral component was available in two to four different diameters to adapt the implant to the medullary canal. Hence the whole range comprised a total of 18 standard femoral components. The femoral preparation included removal of diaphyseal cancellous bone to obtain primary rotational and varus/valgus stability of the stem prior to the line-to-line cementation. We used the Ein Bild Roentgen Analyse Femoral Component (EBRA-FCA) method to assess the subsidence of the femoral component. At the minimum 15-year follow-up, 73 patients were still alive and had not been revised at a mean of 17.3 years, 8 patients had been revised, 66 patients were deceased, and 8 patients were lost to follow-up. The mean subsidence of the entire series was 0.63 ± 0.49 mm (0 – 1.94 mm). When using a 1.5 mm threshold, only four stems were considered to have subsided. With revision of either component for any reason as the endpoint, the cumulative survival rate at 17 years was 90.5 ± 3.2% (95% CI, 84.2% to 96.8%). With radiological loosening of the femoral component as the endpoint, the cumulative survival rate at 17 years was 96.8 ± 3.1% (95% CI, 93.2% to 100%). This study demonstrated that, in most cases, a highly polished double tapered stem cemented line-to-line does not subside up to 18-year follow-up.

The use of endoprosthesis implants is frequent for tumours involving the proximal third of the femur and not amenable to primary arthroplasty or internal fixation. In this population, these implants are preferentially cemented given poor bone quality associated with systemic diseases and treatments. Loosening is a common complication of these implants that have been linked to poor bone quality, type of implants and importantly cementing technique. Thus, these techniques vary between different surgeons and based mainly on previous experience. One of the most successful cementing techniques in the arthroplasty literature is the French paradox. This technique involves removing the cancellous bone of the proximal femoral metaphysis and selects the largest stem to tightly fit the created cavity delineated by cortical bone. Cementing the implant results in a very thin cement layer that fills the inconsistent gaps between the metal and the bone. To our knowledge, no previous report exists in the literature assessing loosening in proximal femur replacement using the French paradox cementing technique. In this study, we sought to examine (1) rates of loosening in proximal femur replacement, and (2) the oncological outcomes including tumour recurrence and implant related complications. A retrospective study of 42 patients underwent proximal femur replacement between 1990 and 2018 at our institution. Of these, 30 patients met our inclusion criteria. Two independent reviewers have evaluated the preoperative and the most recent postoperative radiographs using the International Society of Limb Salvage (ISOLS) radiographic scoring system and Gruen classification for femoral stem loosening. Additionally, the acetabulum was evaluated for erosion according to the criteria of Baker et al. The mean age of this cohort was 60.5 (19–80), with 60% being males. The primary origin was metastatic in 17 (56.7%) patients, bone sarcoma in 10 (33.3%) patients and soft tissue sarcoma in 3 (10%) patients. Pathological fractures were present in 11 (36.7%) patients. Seven (23.3%) patients had prior intramedullary nailing. Preoperative radiotherapy was used in 8 (26.7%) and postoperative radiotherapy in 17 (56.7%) patients. The mean clinical follow-up was 25.2±26.3 months and the mean radiographical follow-up was 24.8±26 months. The mean ISOLS score for both reviewers was found to be 89±6.5% and 86.5±6.1%, respectively. Additionally, the first reviewer found two patients to be possibly loos (6.7%) compared to one (3.3%) patient for the second reviewer. No components scored as probably or definitely loose and non-required revision for either loosening or metal failure. Furthermore, both reviewers showed no acetabular erosion in 25 (83.3%) and 24 (80%) patients, respectively. On the other hand, the overall rate of complications was 36.6% with 11 complications reported in 30 patients. Local recurrence occurred in five (16.6%) patients. Prosthetic Dislocation was the most frequent complications with eight dislocations in four patients. Despite complications, our results showed no radiographic evidence of stem loosening. Cementing proximal femur prosthesis with a tight canal fit and with a thin cement mantle appears to be a viable option at short and medium term

Introduction. The French paradox regarding cemented femoral components has not been resolved, so we compared the mechanical behavior of a French stem, the CMK stem (Biomet, Warsaw, IN, USA), with a collarless, polished, tapered stem (CPT, Zimmer, Warsaw, IN, USA) using an original biomechanical instrument. Materials and Methods. Two size-3 CPT stems and two size-302 CMK stems stems were fixed with bone cement into a composite femur soaked in vegetable oil to simulate wet condition. The composite femur was attached to a biomechanical testing instrument after stem implantation, and a 1-Hz dynamic sine wave load (3000 N) was applied to the stems for a total of 1 million cycles. An 8-hour unload period was set after every 16 hours of load. Femur temperature was maintained at 37°C during testing. The femoral canal was prepared for the CPT stems by standard rasping; for the CMK stems, however, the French method was used, in which cancellous bone was removed with a reamer. One CMK stem (CMK-1) was inserted into a femur without collar contact (>2 mm above the calcar), and the other (CMK-2) was inserted into a femur with collar contact. Stem subsidence was measured at the stem shoulder. Compressive force and horizontal cement movement were measured via rods set at the cement–bone interface on the medial, lateral, anterior, and posterior sides of the proximal and distal portions of the composite femurs. Results. Subsidence was as follows: 0.521 mm and 0.629 mm for the CPT stems, 0.46 mm for CMK-1, and 0.36 mm for CMK-2. Compressive force at the cement–bone interface was at the maximum level at the proximomedial portion of all stems. These forces increased gradually until the one-millionth loading. Maximum compressive forces were 183 N and 107 N for the CPT stems, 180 N for CMK-1, and 215 N for CMK-2. There was a strong positive correlation between stem subsidence and compressive force in all stems. Radial cement creep at the proximomedial portion was 90 μ for one of the CPT stems, 184 μ for CMK-1, and −636 μ for CMK-2. Discussion. We previously reported our findings of a positive correlation between stem subsidence and compressive force in CPT stems. In the current study, CMK stems also subsided even when there was stem collar contact with bone. Subsidence was less in CMK stems than in CPT stems, but the values were close. In addition, compressive force and radial cement creep in CMK stems were also similar to or greater than in CPT stems. Conclusion. The two different concept stems demonstrated similar behavior in relation to bone cement, a finding that may present a solution to the French paradox