Abstract

Age is the most accurate surrogate for bone density and poor bone density is the reason for many fracture repairs to fail. Hemiarthroplasty has demonstrated consistently inconsistent results in terms for restoration of function. Most recently, with the evolution of reverse prostheses, prospective studies which are, in many cases, randomised and Level 2, have clearly shown reverse prostheses to be the most consistently reliable treatment in the patient noted above. It is with a high degree of certainty that we can inform such a patient that their function will be restored and their pain minimal with such treatment.

Management of 4-part fractures of the proximal humerus continues to challenge orthopaedic surgeons, shoulder surgeons, and trauma surgeons. Truly displaced 4-part fractures typically require surgery if the patient is medically able to undergo a surgical procedure. However, outcomes following surgery are not always as predictable as we would like. Results following hemiarthroplasty have led to more predictable pain relief than predictable functional recovery relying exclusively on the fate of tuberosity healing. Tuberosity healing failure leads to nearly universal catastrophic results with pain, dysfunction, and pseudoparalysis. Furthermore, conversion of failed hemiarthroplasty to reverse total shoulder arthroplasty leads to the highest incidence of complications and poorest outcomes of all groups of patients undergoing reverse total shoulder replacement. This is countered by the knowledge that if tuberosity healing occurs the outcome can be reliable with regard to pain relief and functional restoration.

Reverse total shoulder arthroplasty, on the other hand, has emerged as a preferred surgical option for many surgeons due to the issues following hemiarthroplasty. The increased prevalence of RTSA for the management of 4-part fractures has come without overwhelming evidence that outcomes are superior especially in light of the increased cost, life-time weight bearing restrictions, and uncertain long-term durability. Long-term follow-up of patients treated with RTSA for 4-part fracture has shown concerning degradation of function and outcomes and remains a valid concern about the long-term durability. We must remain diligent therefore in continuing to better understand which fractures should be treated non-operatively and those that may be amenable to anatomic hemiarthroplasty and finally those which may be better served by using a reverse total shoulder replacement.

Abstract. Reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) is being increasingly used for complex, displaced fractures of the proximal humerus. The main goal of the current study was to evaluate the functional and radiographic results after primary RSA of three or four-part fractures of the proximal humerus in elderly patients. Between 2012 and 2020, 70 consecutive patients with a recent three- or four-part fracture of the proximal humerus were treated with an RSA. There were 41 women and 29 men, with a mean age of 76 years. The dominant arm was involved in 42 patients (60%). All surgeries were carried out within 21 days. Displaced three-part fracture sustained in 16 patients, 24 had fracture dislocation and 30 sustained a four-part fracture of the proximal humerus. Patients were followed up for a mean of 26 months. The mean postoperative OSS at the end of the follow-up period was 32.4. The mean DASH score was 44.3. Tuberosity non-union occurred in 18 patients (12.6%), malunion in 7 patients (4.9%), heterotopic ossification in 4 patients (2.8%) and scapular notching in one patient. Anatomical reconstruction was achieved in 25 patients (17.5%), the influence of greater tuberosity healing on shoulder function could not be demonstrated. Heterotopic ossification seems to affect OSS and QDASH, we found statistically significant relation between HO and clinical outcomes. Patients with heterotopic ossification had significantly lower postoperative scores on DASH and OSS (P = .0527). Despite expecting good functional outcome with low complication rate after RSA, the functional outcome was irrespective of healing of the tuberosities

Optimal surgical management of proximal humeral fractures remains controversial. We report our experience and the study on our surgical technique for proximal humeral fractures and fracture-dislocations using locking plates in conjunction with calcium sulphate augmentation and tuberosity repair using high strength sutures. We used the extended deltoid-splitting approach for fracture patterns involving displacement of both lesser and greater tuberosities and for fracture-dislocations. We retrospectively analysed 22 proximal humeral fractures in 21 patients. 10 were male and 11 female with an average age of 64.6 years (Range 37 to 77). Average follow-up was 24 months. Fractures were classified according to Neer and Hertel systems. Pre-operative radiographs and CT scans in three and four-part fractures were done to assess the displacement and medial calcar length for predicting the humeral head vascularity. According to the Neer classification, there were 5 two-part, 6 three-part, 5 four-part fractures and 6 fracture-dislocations (2 anterior and 4 posterior). Results were assessed clinically with DASH scores, modified Constant & Murley scores and serial post-operative radiographs. The mean DASH score was 16.18 and modified Constant & Murley score was 64.04 at the last follow-up. 18 out of 22 cases achieved good clinical outcome. All the fractures united with no evidence of infection, failure of fixation, malunion, tuberosity failure, avascular necrosis or adverse reaction to calcium sulphate bone substitute. There was no evidence of axillary nerve injury. The CaSO4 bone substitute was replaced by normal appearing trabecular bone texture at an average of 6 months in all patients

A reverse shoulder arthroplasty has become increasingly common for the treatment of proximal humerus fractures. A reverse shoulder arthroplasty is indicated especially in older and osteopenic individuals in whom the osteopenia, fracture type or comminution precludes fixation. However, there are many other ways to treat proximal humerus fractures and many of these are appropriate for different indications. Percutaneous pinning remains an option in certain surgical neck or valgus impacted proximal humerus fractures with minimal or no comminution at the medial calcar. In general, a fracture that is amenable to open reduction and fixation should be fixed. Open reduction and internal fixation should be the gold standard treatment for three-part fractures in younger and middle-aged patients. Four-part fractures should also be fixed in younger patients. Hemiarthroplasty results are less predictable as they are very dependent on tuberosity healing. While a reverse shoulder replacement may be considered in patients with severe comorbidities, patients always have better outcomes in the setting of an appropriately reduced and stably fixed proximal humerus fracture

Displaced two- to four-part fractures of the proximal humerus pose a difficult therapeutic challenge. We report the results of internal fixation of these fractures in a case series of 50 patients with a locking plate system. All fractures united with no failure of fixation. The mean constant score was 79. One patient developed avascular necrosis. Internal fixation with locking plate system in healthy active patients, disregarding their age, is a reliable method of treating displaced proximal humerus fractures. The tuberosities should be restored anatomically prior to plate application. Surgical expertise in treating shoulder conditions is essential for good functional outcome

Michael Robinson has been a Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon and Senior Lecturer in the Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology in Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom for 10 years. His special interests include the treatment of proximal humeral and clavicle fractures, and shoulder instability. The majority of proximal humerus fractures can be managed non-operatively with surgery reserved for approximately 10–20% of patients. The choice of surgical treatment is usually between a humeral head head-conserving fracture reduction and internal fixation and humeral head sacrifice hemiarthroplasty. Current indications for primary hemiarthroplasty include a displaced four-part fracture (with or without associated dislocation of the humeral head) and a head-splitting fracture (with involvement of >40% of the articular surface), due to the high associated risk of avascular necrosis. However, the indications for internal fixation of proximal humerus fractures have expanded over the last decade, and many fractures which have previously been considered unsalvageable and treated either non-operatively or with hemiarthroplasty are now deemed reconstructable. This is partially as a result of improved appreciation of sub-groups of fractures which have a better prognosis from head-salvage, the possibility that subsequent development of osteonecrosis may be relatively asymptomatic and the realisation that functional results after hemiarthroplasty are often sub-optimal. The purpose of this talk is to discuss the current concepts in fracture classification and the indications for operative treatment for these fractures. The novel surgical approaches, techniques and implants which have renewed interest in their treatment are also highlighted. None of the authors have received any payment or consideration from any source for the conduct of this study

Introduction:. Tuberosity healing is strongly correlated with functional results in all series of three- and four-part fractures of the proximal humerus treated by hemiarthroplasty. We formed a working group to improve position of the implant and fixation of the tuberosities on an implant specifically intended for traumatology. Material and Methods:. An anatomic study on 11 cadavers and a prospective multicentre clinical study of 32 cases were performed to validate extrapolable original solutions at the patient scale: placement of the stem at a height indicated in relation to the insertion of the clavicular bundle of the pectoralis major, locking of the stem, placement (based on bone quality) of a variable volume metaphyseal frame (offset modular system® OMS®), avoiding medialisation of the tuberosities, and fixation of the tuberosities using strong looped sutures, brightly coloured so that they can be located more easily. Evaluation by Dash score and Constant score was correlated with positioning of the tuberosities using radiographs. Results:. The clinical study enabled a distance of the top of the head to pectoralis major of 5.5 cm +/− 5 mm to be determined, confirming the results of the anatomic study and data from the literature. The distal double-locking ancillary device and the suturing technique for the tuberosities using looped sutures was judged to be effective by all of the surgeons. 23 patients (5 males, 9 CT4 and 8 CT3) with an mean age 69,6 (33–90) were operated on by 3 senior surgeons and reviewed at a mean follow-up of 17,3 months (6–24). All patients were seen again at 3 months and 6 months and the average motion at last follow was abduction of 90,7° (140–40), active anterior elevation of 113,25° (160–60), and external rotation of 43,2°(55–30). One complication was noted: inadequate position of a locking screw. In the 17 patients operated without oms® 50% had adequate initial positioning of the tuberosities and 10% secondary displacement. In comparison the 6 patients operated with the oms® 100% had adequate initial positioning of the tuberosities and no secondary displacement occurred. Discussion:. The series from Sofcot, Boileau, and more recently Reuther yielded results of 40 to 66% malposition or nonunion of the tuberosities. The initial clinical results from our series are encouraging and demonstrate that using a variable volume metaphyseal frame in synthesis of the tuberosities with control of the height of the implant is reliable. This multicentre study should be extended by a more long-term analysis

The aim of this retrospective study is to expose results and complications of the reverse concept in trauma. We therefore ask whether clinically the patients recover a pre-broken state, whether the radiological follow-up show worrisome images and whether the rate of complications is important. We reviewed thirty-seven consecutive patients with 26 three- and four-part fractures and 11 fracture-dislocations, mean age 75 (range, 58–92 years) with a minimum follow-up of one year (mean, 7.3 years; range, 1–17 years). Eight complications occurred: 2 complex sympathetic dystrophies, 3 dislocations, 2 deep infections and one aseptic loosening of the base-plate leading to 3 re-operations and 2 prosthesis revisions. The mean Constant score dropped from 55 at one year to 52 (20 to 84) at last revision which represented 67% of the mean score for the injured side. Mean adjusted Constant score was 68. 42% of the patients considered the results to be unsatisfactory because of poor rotations avoiding nourishment with utensils, dressing and personal hygiene when the dominant extremity was involved. We observed two complete borders between the base plate and the glenoid, fourteen stable inferior spurs which did not affect function and twenty-one inferior scapular notches including ten of them with medial proximal humeral bone loss or radio lucent lines between the cement border and the humerus. Notching increased in size with longer follow-up. Notching, accompanied by changes in proximal humerus, was associated with the weakest mean Constant score (41). The functional results were not equal to the pre-injury state. When the dominant arm was affected, the patients lost frequently their autonomy. 60% of the radiological images found were worrying. 22% of the patients had a severe complication. New developments in design, bearing surfaces and surgical technique and long term studies may support the role of the reverse concept for fracture

Introduction. Symptomatic neglected and displaced three- and four-part proximal humeral fractures are often difficult to reconstruct. Replacement has been reported to give poor functional outcome and hence is not the ideal treatment option. We report our results of secondary reconstruction of these difficult fractures with a locking plate system. Material and methods. Between 2003 and 2005, 15 healthy active patients with displaced three- to four-part fractures underwent revision/secondary open reduction and internal fixation with a locking plate system (Philos, Stratec UK Ltd). Ten patients had delayed presentation. Three patients had failed previous internal fixation. One patient had non-union and one had malunited fracture. Their average age was 63 years. Objective assessment was measured by the Constant score, subjective assessment by the Oxford questionnaire. The mean follow-up was 14 months. Surgical technique. In revision cases, the fracture was approached through the same incision. All metal work was removed. Careful attention was given to restore the normal anatomy of the humeral head with correct placement of the tuberosities. Reduction was held with Ticron sutures through the rotator cuff followed by fixation with the locking plate. Two patients required arthroscopic repair of their labral tears. The shoulder was immobilised in a sling for four weeks followed by a gradual mobilisation programme. Results. All fractures united. No failure of fixation was observed. The mean Constant score was 73. The pain component improved from 3 pre-operatively to 14 at follow-up. The average range of flexion was 1100, abduction of 950 and external rotation of 350. All patients had good to excellent subjective outcome. We encountered poor rotator cuff function in one patient. Conclusion. Successful reconstruction of three- and four-part proximal humeral fractrures is possible. Anatomical restoration of humeral head and tuberosities prior to plate fixation is essential for good outcome

The aim of this retrospective and mono centric study is to expose results and complications of the reverse concept in the elderly in case of trauma. We therefore ask whether clinically the patients recover a pre-broken state, whether the radiological follow-up shows critical images and whether the rate of complications is important. We reviewed the outcome of forty-two patients operated consecutively by the same surgeon at a mean follow-up of 9.1 years (range, 1–19 years). There were four men and thirty-eight females, mean age 75 (range, 58–92 years), with 28 complex four-part fractures and 14 fracture-dislocations. There was no re-fixation of the tubercles because of a poor bone quality. Six complications occurred: 2 complex sympathetic dystrophies treated by medication, 2 early dislocations (one superior because of an impingement in adduction between the humeral stem and the remnants of the tubercles solved by their ablation without further problems and one anterior caused by the voluntary 10° ante-version of the humeral component to improve internal rotation leading to the reorientation of the stem), 1 deep infection solved by debridement and drainage for an early postoperative Acinetobacter infection without further problems and one aseptic loosening of the base-plate with a broken screw and no wear at 12-year follow-up leading to implant a classic base-plate because of a fair bone stock and efficient primary grip after impaction. The mean Constant score dropped from 55 at one year to 52 (20 to 84) at last revision which represented 67% of the mean score for the injured side. Mean adjusted Constant score was 68. Only 58% of the patients were satisfied or very satisfied because of poor rotations avoiding nourishment with utensils, dressing andpersonal hygiene. When the dominant arm was affected, the patients lost frequently their autonomy. Two patients with 42-mm glenospheres had complete 2-mm radiolucent lines at four- and eight-year follow-up. Inferior spurs were seen in 15 cases (35%). They were stable after emergence without functional impact or radiographic evolution. They appeared at a mean of 2.5 years (range, 1–6 years). Scapular notching was seen in 23 cases (55% of the patients), all appeared before two-year follow-up. Eleven notches were stable with a sclerotic border and without critical humeral images. Twelve were progressive with a proximal humeral bone loss (n = 7) or a radiolucent line (n = 5). In these cases, there was a negative effect on the Constant score: 41 points instead of 57 for notches without critical images. Our experience reported in the present study has somewhat weakened our enthusiasm for this procedure. 42% of the patients were unsatisfied because of poor rotations and the functional results were never equal to the pre-injury state. 33% of the radiological images found were critical. 14% of the patients had a severe complication. Such results do not allow us to validate in the long-term the concept of RSA in recent trauma of proximal humerus. So nowadays, our elective indication is a woman for a non-dominant arm, over seventy years old with poor physiology and important osteoporosis