Tungsten has been increasing in demand for use in manufacturing and recently, medical devices, as it imparts flexibility, strength, and conductance of metal alloys. Given the surge in tungsten use, our population may be subjected to elevated exposures. For instance, embolism coils made of tungsten have been shown to degrade in some patients. In a cohort of breast cancer patients who received tungsten-based shielding for intraoperative radiotherapy, urinary tungsten levels remained over tenfold higher 20 months post-surgery. In vivo models have demonstrated that tungsten exposure increases tumor metastasis and enhances the adipogenesis of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells while inhibiting osteogenesis. We recently determined that when mice are exposed to tungsten [15 ppm] in their drinking water, it bioaccumulates in the intervertebral disc tissue and vertebrae. This study was performed to determine the toxicity of tungsten on intervertebral disc.

Bovine nucleus pulposus (bNP) and annulus fibrosus (bAF) cells were isolated from bovine caudal tails. Cells were expanded in flasks then prepared for 3D culturing in alginate beads at a density of 1×10^∧6 cells/mL. Beads were cultured in medium supplemented with increasing tungsten concentrations in the form of sodium tungstate [0, 0.5, 5, 15 ug/mL] for 12 days. A modified GAG assay was performed on the beads to determine proteoglycan content and Western blotting for type II collagen (Col II) synthesis. Cell viability was determined by counting live and dead cells in the beads following incubation with the Live/Dead Viability Assay kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific). Cell numbers in beads at the end of the incubation period was determined using Quant-iT dsDNA Assay Kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific)

Tungsten dose-dependently decreased the synthesis of proteoglycan in IVD cells, however, the effect was significant at the highest dose of 15 ug/mL. (n=3). Furthermore, although tungsten decreased the synthesis of Col II in IVD cells, it significantly increased the synthesis of Col I. Upregulation of catabolic enzymes ADAMTS4 and −5 were also observed in IVD cells treated with tungsten (n=3). Upon histological examination of spines from mice treated with tungsten [15 ug/mL] in their drinking water for 30 days, disc heights were diminished and Col I upregulation was observed (n=4). Cell viability was not markedly affected by tungsten in both bNP and bAF cells, but proliferation of bNP cells decreased at higher concentration. Surprisingly, histological examination of IVDs and gene expression analysis demonstrated upregulation of NGF expression in both NP and AF cells. In addition, endplate capillaries showed increases in CGRP and PGP9.5 expression as determined on histological sections of mouse IVDs, suggesting the development of sensory neuron invasion of the disc.

We provide evidence that prolonged tungsten exposure can induce disc fibrosis and increase the expression of markers associated with pain. Tungsten toxicity may play a role in disc degeneration disease.