Total knee replacement (TKR) design aims to restore normal kinematics with emphasis on flexion range. The survivorship of a TKR is dependent on the kinematics in six-degrees-of-freedom (6-DoF). Stepping up, such as stair ascent is a kinematically demanding activity after TKR. The debate about design choice has not yet been informed by 6-DoF in vivo kinematics. This prospective randomised controlled trial (RCT) compared kneeling kinematics in three TKR designs. 68 participants were randomised to receive either cruciate retaining (CR-FB), rotating platform (CR-RP) or posterior stabilised (PS-FB) prostheses. Image quality was sufficient for 49 of these patients to be included in the final analysis following a minimum 1-year follow-up. Patients completed a step-up task while being imaged using single-plane fluoroscopy. Femoral and tibial computer-aided design (CAD) models for each of the TKR designs were registered to the fluoroscopic images using bespoke software OrthoVis to generate six-degree-of-freedom kinematics. Differences in kinematics between designs were compared as a function of flexion. There were no differences in terminal extension between the groups. The CR-FB was further posterior and the CR-RP was more externally rotated at terminal extension compared to the other designs. Furthermore, the CR-FB designs was more posteriorly positioned at each flexion angle compared to both other designs. Additionally, the CR-RP design had more external femoral rotation throughout flexion when compared with both fixed bearing designs. However, there were no differences in total rotation for either step-up or down. Visually, it appears there was substantial variability between participants in each group, indicating unique patient-specific movement patterns. While use of a specific implant design does influence some kinematic parameters, the overall patterns are similar. Furthermore, there is high variability indicating patient-specific kinematic patterns. At a group level, none of these designs appear to provide markedly different step-up kinematic patterns. This is important for patient
There is controversy regarding the effect of different approaches on recovery after THR. Collecting detailed relevant data with satisfactory compliance is difficult. Our retrospective observational multi-center study aimed to find out if the data collected via a remote coaching app can be used to monitor the speed of recovery after THR using the anterolateral (ALA), posterior (PA) and the direct anterior approach (DAA). 771 patients undergoing THR from 13 centers using the moveUP platform were identified. 239 had ALA, 345 DAA and 42 PA. There was no significant difference between the groups in the sex of patients or in preoperative HOOS Scores. There was however a significantly lower age in the DAA (64,1y) compared to ALA (66,9y), and a significantly lower Oxford Hip Score in the DAA (23,9) compared to PA(27,7). Step count measured by an activity tracker, pain killer and NSAID use was monitored via the app. We recorded when patients started driving following surgery, stopped using crutches, and their HOOS and Oxford hip scores at 6 weeks. Overall compliance with data request was 80%. Patients achieved their preoperative activity level after 25.8, 17,7 and 23.3 days, started driving a car after 33.6, 30.3 and 31.7 days, stopped painkillers after 27.5, 20.2 and 22.5 days, NSAID after 30.3, 25.7, and 24.7 days for ALA, DAA and PA respectively. Painkillers were stopped and preoperative activity levels were achieved significantly earlier favoring DAA over ALA. Similarly, crutches were abandoned significantly earlier (39.9, 29.7 and 24.4 days for ALA, DAA and PA respectively) favoring DAA and PA over ALA. HOOS scores and Oxford Hip scores improved significantly in all 3 groups at 6 weeks, without any statistically significant difference between groups in either Oxford Hip or HOOS subscores. No final conclusion can be drawn as to the superiority of either approach in this study but the remote coaching platform allowed the collection of detailed data which can be used to advise patients individually, manage
Obesity is associated with poor outcomes and increased risk of failure after rotator cuff (RC) repair surgery. The effect of diet-induced obesity (DIO) on enthesis healing has not been well characterised and whether its effects can be reversed with dietary intervention is unknown. We hypothesised that DIO would result in inferior enthesis healing in a rat model of RC repair and that dietary intervention in the peri-operative period would improve enthesis healing. A total of 78 male Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into three weight-matched groups from weaning and fed either: control diet (CD), high-fat diet (HFD), or HFD until surgery, then CD thereafter (HF-CD). After 12 weeks the left supraspinatus tendon was detached, followed by immediate surgical repair. At 2 and 12 weeks post-surgery, animals were cullers and RCs harvested for biomechanical and histological evaluation. Body composition and metabolic markers were assessed via DEXA and plasma analyses, respectively. DIO was established in the HFD and HF-CD groups prior to surgery, and subsequently reversed in the HF-CD group after surgery. At 12 weeks post-surgery, plasma leptin concentrations were higher in the HFD group compared to the CD group (5.28 vs. 2.91ng/ml, P=0.003). Histologically, the appearance of the repaired entheses was poorer in both the HFD and HF-CD compared to the CD group at 12 weeks (overall histological score 6.20 (P=0.008), 4.98 (P=0.001) and 8.68 out of 15, respectively). The repaired entheses in the HF-CD group had significantly lower (26.4 N, P=0.028) load-at-failure 12 weeks post-surgery compared to the CD group (34.4 N); while the HFD group was low, but not significantly different (28.1 N, P=0.096). Body mass at the time of surgery, plasma leptin and body fat percentage were negatively correlated with histological scores and plasma leptin with load-at-failure 12 weeks post-surgery. DIO impaired enthesis healing in this rat RC repair model, with inferior biomechanical and histological outcomes. Restoring normal weight with dietary change after surgery did not improve healing outcomes. Exploring interventions that improve the metabolic state of obese patients and counselling patients appropriately about their modest
Chronic low back pain (cLBP) is a complex, multifaceted disorder where biological, psychological, and social factors affect its onset and trajectory. Consequently, cLBP encompasses many different disease variants, with multiple patient-specific mechanisms. The goal of NIH Back Pain Consortium (BACPAC) Research Program is to develop understanding of cLBP mechanisms and to develop algorithms that optimally match specific treatments to individual patients. To accomplish this, one research activity of BACPAC is to develop theoretical models for chronic low back pain based on the current state of knowledge in the scientific community, and to interrogate the relationships implied by the theoretical models using data generated by or available to BACPAC. The models consider biopsychosocial perspectives, and encompass both peripheral (i.e. low back) and central (i.e. spinal and supra-spinal) factors as well as proposed mechanisms of action of cLBP treatments. However, absent explanations, models/algorithms may fall short of regulatory requirements and clinician
Patient reported outcome measures (PROMs) are important for assessing the results of lower limb arthroplasty. Unrealistic or uneducated
Increasing incidence of osteoporosis, obesity and an aging population have led to an increase in low energy hip fractures in the elderly. Perceived lower blood loss and lower surgical time, media coverage of minimal invasive surgery and patient
In the UK and USA in 2016 more than 263,000 primary knee replacements were performed. Around 20% of patients report chronic post-surgical pain (CPSP) at three or more months after total knee replacement (TKR). A large proportion of adults with all types of chronic musculoskeletal pain do not use services for a number of reasons, despite being in constant or daily pain. Given the high prevalence of CPSP, there is potentially a large hidden population with an unexpressed need for care, experiencing ongoing pain and disability; understanding why they do not use health services may herald further insight into why many remain dissatisfied with knee replacement surgery. The aim of this study is to understand why some people with CPSP after TKR do not access services or make little use of healthcare. We conducted face-to-face in-depth interviews with 34 patients from 2 high-volume orthopaedic hospitals in England, to investigate their experience of long-term pain after knee replacement; their knowledge and understanding of CPSP; and their decisions about consulting for CPSP. The sample size was based on achievement of saturation and participants provided written informed consent. Interviews were transcribed and analysed using an inductive thematic approach with double coding for rigor. Ethical approval for the study was granted by the West Midlands Solihull Research Ethics Committee (15/WM/0469). A core theme within the analysis suggests that participants do not seek healthcare because they believe that nothing further can be done, either by themselves or by healthcare professionals. Surgeons' satisfaction with the knee surgery and reassurances that pain would improve, left patients feeling uncertain about whether to re-consult, and some assumed that further consultation could lead to further surgery or medication, which they wish to avoid. Some participants' comorbidities took precedence over their knee pain when seeking healthcare. Others felt they had received their “share” of healthcare resources and that others were more deserving of treatment. People's descriptions of pain varied, from dull, or aching to shooting pains. Many described their pain as “discomfort” rather than pain. The majority described pain that was better than their pre-surgical pain, though others described pain that was worse, which they believed to be nerve damage. Many expressed disappointment in the outcome of their TKR.
Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is one of the most successful surgery. However, patients'
Cell-based therapies have taken the emerging field in many clinical directions. Among them, orthopaedic surgery is one of the most promising directions – due to the clinical needs, and because of the availability of the advanced cell-based constructs dedicated to bone and cartilage regeneration. The current practical clinical input is, however, below
This edition of the Cochrane Corner looks at the three reviews that were published in the second half of 2023: surgical versus non-surgical interventions for displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures; cryotherapy following total knee arthroplasty; and physical activity and education about physical activity for chronic musculoskeletal pain in children and adolescents.
Study purpose and background. There is growing concern that current outcome measures of back pain trials do not comprehensively capture what is important to patients. Some researchers believe we need to incorporate patients in the development of ‘next-generation’ outcomes. As a preliminary step to patient-interviews, we aimed to articulate ‘important change’ from the patients' perspective, as represented in reports of qualitative investigations inadvertently or directly exploring this. Summary of methods used and results. We adopted a multi-strand search of electronic databases, and citation and reference tracking. Two researchers identified qualitative investigations relating to low back pain. Data were abstracted and synthesised using meta-ethnographic processes. Provisional results, based on 41 studies, indicate few studies have directly addressed this issue, but that data regarding experience and
Summary Statement. Service industry metrics (the net promoter score) are being introduced as a measure of UK healthcare satisfaction. Lower limb arthroplasty, as a ‘service’, scores comparably with the most successful commercial organisations. Background. Satisfaction with care is important to both the patient and the payer. The Net Promoter Score, widely used in the service industry, has been recently introduced to the UK National Health Service as an overarching metric of patient satisfaction and to monitor performance. This questionnaire asks ‘customers’ if they would recommend a service or products to others. Scores range from −100 (everyone is a detractor) to +100 (everyone is a promoter). In industry, a positive score is well regarded, with those over 50 regarded as excellent. Our aims were to assess net promoter scores for joint arthroplasty, to compare these scores with direct measures of patient satisfaction, and to evaluate which factors contributed to net promoter response. Methods. 6912 individuals undergoing primary lower limb joint replacement over a five year period (Jan 2007 – Dec 2011) took part in a prospective cohort study at a single NHS University hospital. Net promoter score, clinical outcomes as measured by PROMS (Oxford Hip or Knee Score and SF-12 score), multi-faceted patient satisfaction questionnaire, demographic data and length of hospital stay were recorded. Data was collected preoperatively and at 1 year post-surgery. Multivariate regression was performed to determine which factors could predict an outcome of ‘promoter’ and ‘detractor’ at 1 year post-surgery. Significance was accepted at p = 0.1 to accommodate the confounding effect of other variables. Results. Net promoter scores for knee and hip replacements were 49 and 71 respectively. Strong correlation was seen between overall satisfaction and whether the patient would recommend the operation to another (r = 0.637), though regression of these factors was modest (R. 2. = 0.406). Only 4 factors were relevant to the net promoter response: pain relief (OR 2.13, CI 1.83 – 2.49), meeting
Introduction. Today TKR is considered one of the most successful operative procedures in orthopedic surgery. Nevertheless, failure rates of 2 – 10% depending on the length of the study and the design are still reported. This provides evidence for further development in knee arthroplasty. Particularly the oxide ceramics used now in THA show major advantages due to their excellent tribological properties, their significantly reduced third-body wear as well as their high corrosion resistance. A further advantage of ceramic materials is their potential use in patients with metal allergy. Metallic wear induces immunological reactions resulting in hypersensitivity, pain, osteolysis and implant loosening. The purpose of our study was to examine the safety of the tibial component of a novel all-ceramic TKR. Materials and Methods. We tested the tibial components of the primary knee implant BPK-S Integration Ceramic. Both the tibial and the femoral component consist of BIOLOX®delta ceramic The standards ISO 14879-1 and ASTM F1800-07 describe the test set-up for the experimental fatigue strength testing of tibial components from knee implants. We conducted the testing with a significantly increased maximum load of 5,300 N (900 N are required). A final burst strength test was carried out after the fatigue load testing in the same embedding and with the same test set-up. Results. No specimen failed during fatigue load testing. The subsequent post-fatigue burst strength testing showed a maximum strength against fracture of at least 9.7 kN for size 3 and at least 12.1 kN for size 6. Discussion. The good results of the strength testing of the tibial component of the BPK-S Integration Ceramic tibial plateau supported the good initial clinical outcome without any implant specific complications of this knee design. Further clinical studies have to show if this design fulfills the high
Introduction. Sustained loading on the intervertebral disc leads to loss of disc height. The generally accepted explanation for this is that the disc loses height due to an unbalance between the external load on the disc and the osmotic pressure in the disc. Consequently, water is expelled from the disc until the osmotic attraction reaches an equilibrium with the pressure applied. In this study, we compared the time course of loss of disc height with loss of pressure in the nucleus. We expected to see a similar time course of disc height and intra-discal pressure. Methods. Fifteen caprine lumbar discs were tested in a saline bath. Of each motion segment both vertebral bodies were cut-off close to the endplate. After a preload of 6 hours at 10N, an axial compressive load of 150N was applied to the discs for 18 hours by an Instron testing device. An 1.33mm pressure needle was inserted in the nucleus to measure hydrostatic pressure. Both change of disc height and change of nucleus pressure were measured at 2 samples/s. A double Kelvin–Voigt model was fitted to estimate the time constants of both hydrostatic pressure and disc height loss. The model comprises two time constants: the first modelling a fast change, the second a slow change. A paired t-test was used to compare the time constants of both the pressure and the disc height. Results. The slow time constant of the change of disc height (3.4 hours, sd=0.8) was larger (p=0.0006) than the slow time constant of the change of nucleus pressure (2.4 hours, sd=0.8). The difference between the time constants of the fast regime (0.33 hours resp 0.27 hours) was not significant (p=0.27). Discussion. In contrast to our
Achilles tendon (AT) rupture may lead to complaints of heel pain. In forefoot ulcer patients AT lengthening is used to transfer pressure from forefoot to the heel. The primary aim was to investigate if AT was longer or associated with changes in pedobaric measurements, in particular heel pressure, on the injured leg 4–5 years after the injury. Methods. We invited all participants from an RCT (n=56) of conservatively treated AT Rupture (ATR) with or without early weight-bearing (early-WB, non-WB). 37 patients participated, 19 from early-WB (1 re-rupture (RR)), and 18 from non-WB (2 RR). Time from injury to follow up was 4,5 years (4,1 to 5,1). AT length was measured using ultrasound with a validated protocol. Foot pressure mapping (FPM) was measured barefoot, using an EMED platform (novel, Germany), with 5 trials for each foot. Statistics. T-test for limb to limb comparisons and linear regression for correlations was applied. Results. We found no differences in any of the variables between the early-WB and non-WB groups. Compared to the uninjured limb, the Achilles tendon was an average of 1.8 (1.2–2.3) cm longer on the injured limb (p<0.001). When comparing the ratio of the medial (1–2 ray) to lateral (3–5 ray) forefoot mean peak pressure, we found no difference between the injured and healthy limb (p=0.26). Mean heel peak pressure was not different from the injured to the healthy leg (difference was 3,9 (−1,7 – 9,45) p=0,17). Heel lift-off was delayed in the injured limb by 2% (0.4%–4.4%) of the total roll over process (ROP) (p= 0.02). Achilles tendon length could not be linked to either heels lift-off or mean peak pressure of the heel using linear regression (p 0.27 to 0.78). Conclusion. Conservatively treated Achilles tendon ruptures were approximately 1.8 cm longer. A subtle change in the time of heel rise could be detected on the injured limb, but contrary to our
Background. Metal-on-metal hip implants can produce adverse tissue reactions to wear debris. Increased metal ion concentrations in the blood are measured as a proxy to wear and the complications it can trigger. Many studies have examined various factors influencing the metal ion concentrations. This is the first study to investigate the effect of physical activity level, as objectively measured in daily life, on blood ion levels, expecting higher concentrations for higher patient activity. Methods. Thirty-three patients (13F/20M, 55.8 ± 6.2 years at surgery) with a unilateral resurfacing hip prosthesis were included. At last follow-up (6.8 ± 1.5 years) cobalt and chromium concentrations in the blood were determined by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Physical activity was measured during 4 successive days using a 3D-acceleration-based activity monitor. Data was analysed using validated algorithms, producing quantitative and qualitative parameters. Acetabular cup position was measured radiographically. Correlations were tested with Pearson's r'. Results. Wide ranges in cobalt (10-833nmol/l) and chromium (16-592nmol/l) concentrations were measured. No correlations were found between metal ion concentrations and patient characteristics. The mean time of walking per day of was 5475 ± 2730 seconds (≈ 91 minutes) per day, with 6953 ± 3104 steps made during the day. The cadence, the number of steps per minute, was 99.5 ± 7.4. The subjects performed 41 ± 13 sit-stand transfers per day. The number of peak intensity declines when peaks where more intense. No correlations were found between quantitative or qualitative parameters and metal ion concentrations. Conclusions. Higher metal ion concentrations were not correlated with higher activity levels contrary to original
Background. After surgical correction of thoracic scoliosis, an improvement in the cardio-respiratory adaptation to exercise would be expected because of the correction of the rib cage associated with the spinal deformity. This work intended to evaluate the physiologic responses to incremental exercise in patients undergoing surgical correction of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS). The hypothesis of this study was that the exercise limitations described in patients with AIS could be related with the physical deconditioning instead of being linked to the severity of the vertebral deformity. Methods. Cross-sectional study of the exercise tolerance in a series of patients with AIS type Lenke 1A, before and 2 years after surgical correction. Twenty patients with AIS and 10 healthy adolescents aged between 12 and 17 years old were evaluated. The average magnitude of the curves was 60.3±12.9 Cobb. Cardio-respiratory function was assessed before surgery and at 2-year follow-up by maximal exercise tolerance test on treadmill following a Bruce standard protocol. Maximal oxygen uptake (VO2), VCO2, expiratory volume (VE), and VE/VO2 ratio were registered. Results. Before surgery, AIS patients showed lower values than healthy controls in all cardio-respiratory parameters. The most important restrictions were the VO2max in ml/kg/min. (30.3±5.4 vs 49.9±7.5), VE (43.2±10.3 vs 82.3±10.7) and VE/CO2 ratio (25.0±3.9 vs 29.6±4.2). Contrary to
Anterior-posterior (AP) x-rays are routinely taken following total hip replacement to assess placement and orientation of implanted components. Pelvic orientation at the time of an AP x-ray can influence projected implant orientation. 1. However, the extent of pelvic orientation varies between patients. 2. Without compensation for patient specific pelvic orientation, misleading measurements for implant orientation may be obtained. These measurements are used as indicators for post-operative dislocation stability and range of motion. Errors in which could result in differences between
Patients report similar or better pain and function before revision hip arthroplasty than before primary arthroplasty but poorer outcomes after revision surgery. The trajectory of post-operative recovery during the first 12 months and any differences by type of surgery have received little attention. We explored the trajectories of change in pain and function after revision hip arthroplasty to 12-months post-operatively and compared them with those observed after primary hip arthroplasty. We conducted a single-centre UK cohort study of patients undergoing primary (n = 80) or revision (n = 43) hip arthroplasty. WOMAC pain and function scores and 20-metres walking time were collected pre-operatively, at 3 and 12-months post-operatively. Multilevel regression models were used to chart and compare the trajectories of post-operative change (0–3 months and 3–12 months) between the types of surgery. Patients undergoing primary arthroplasty had a total hip replacement (n=74) or hip resurfacing (n=6). Osteoarthritis was the indication for surgery in 92% of primary cases. Patients undergoing revision arthroplasty had revision of a total hip arthroplasty (n=37), hemiarthroplasty (n=2) or hip resurfacing (n=4). The most common indication for revision arthroplasty was aseptic loosening (n=29); the remaining indications were pain (n=4), aseptic lymphocyte-dominated vasculitis-associated lesion (n=4) or other reasons (n=6). Primary (87%) and revision arthroplasties (98%) were mostly commonly performed via a posterior surgical approach. The improvements in pain and function following revision arthroplasty occurred within the first 3-months following operation (WOMAC-pain, p<0.0001; WOMAC-function, p<0.0001; timed 20-metres walk, p<0.0001) with no evidence of further change beyond this initial period (p>0.05). While the pattern of recovery after revision arthroplasty was similar to that observed after primary arthroplasty, improvements in the first 3-months were smaller after revision compared to primary arthroplasty (p<0.0001). Patients listed for revision surgery reported lower pre-operative pain levels (p=0.03) but similar post-operative levels (p=0.268) compared to those undergoing primary surgery. At 12-months post-operation patients who underwent a revision arthroplasty had not reached the same level of function achieved by those who underwent primary arthroplasty (WOMAC-function p=0.015; Time walk p=0.004). Patients undergoing revision hip arthroplasty should be informed that the majority of their improvement will occur in the first 3-months following surgery and that the expected improvement will be less marked than that experienced following primary surgery. More research is now required to 1.) identify whether specific in-patient and post-discharge rehabilitation tailored towards patients undergoing revision arthroplasty would improve or achieve equivalent outcomes to primary surgery and 2.) whether patients who are achieving limited improvements at 3-months post-operative would benefit from more intensive rehabilitation. This will become all the more important with the increasing volume of revision surgery and the high
Staged bilateral total knee arthroplasty is performed increasingly frequently but no data has been published comparing the specific outcome for the first knee replacement to that of the second. Pre-operative and post-operative Oxford Knee Scores (/ 48) were reviewed for each knee in a series of 91 patients undergoing staged bilateral total knee arthroplasty over a 5-year period. Pre-operative scores for the first total knee arthroplasty were significantly worse with a mean of 14.9 in comparison to 17.0 for the second knee (P=0.0083). While there was no significant difference between the mean post-operative scores for the first knee (37.4) and the second knee (36.6) (P=0.195), the mean improvement was significantly less for the second knee (22.6 points versus 19.6 points) (P=0.0045). Our results demonstrate that in patients undergoing staged bilateral knee arthroplasty, the second knee replacement is commonly performed at a lower threshold and functional improvement is less than for the first knee. This data will be important to inform the
