The risk of AVN is high in Unstable Slipped Capital Femoral
Purpose of Study:. In situ fixation with cannulated screws, is the most common surgical management of Slipped Capital Femoral
Slipped Capital Femoral
Despite recent advances in the management of slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE), controversy remains about the treatment of choice for unstable slips. Surgical dislocation and open reduction has the advantage of identifying and preserving the blood supply of femoral head thereby potentially reducing the risk of avascular necrosis, (AVN). There is large variation in the literature from several small series about reported AVN rates ranging from two to 66% for unstable SCFE treated with surgical dislocation. The aim of our study was to analyze our experience with acute open reduction and internal fixation of unstable acute and unstable acute on chronic slips using the technique of surgical dislocation described by Professor Reinhold Ganz. A retrospective review of 11 patients (12 hips) treated by surgical dislocation, reduction and pinning as the primary procedure for unstable acute and unstable acute on chronic SCFE in a tertiary referral children's hospital was undertaken. This represents the entire series treated in this manner from September 2007 to January 2018. These procedures were performed by a team of Orthopaedic surgeons with significant experience performing surgical dislocation of the hip including patients with chronic SCFE, Perthes' disease, impingement and acetabular fractures. Demographic data, intraoperative records, postoperative notes and radiographs including details of subsequent surgery were reviewed. There were seven boys and four girls with mean age of 13.4 years, range 11 to 15 years at the time of surgical dislocation. Out of 12 hips, two had acute unstable slip while the remaining 10 had acute on chronic unstable slip. Six patients had good or excellent results. The remaining six patients developed AVN of which three patients had total hip replacement at six months, 17 months and 18 months following primary procedure. Seven patients required more than one operation. Three patients lost their correction and required re fixation despite surgical dislocation, reduction and fixation being their primary procedure. This series demonstrates a high percentage of AVN (50%) in severe unstable SCFE treated with surgical dislocation despite careful attention to retinacular flap development and intra operative doppler studies. This is in direct contrast to our experience with subcapital reorientation with surgical dislocation in stable slips where excellent results were achieved with a low rate of AVN. Pre-operative imaging with MRI and perfusion studies may identify where ischemia has occurred and might influence operative treatment. Based on our results, we do not recommend routine use of surgical dislocation in unstable SCFE. This technique requires further scrutiny to define the operative indications in unstable SCFE.
Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) is traditionally treated with in situ fixation using a threaded screw, leading to physeal arrest while stabilizing the femoral head. Recently, there has been interest in alternative methods of fixation for SCFE, aiming to allow growth and remodelling of the femoral neck postoperatively. One such option is the Free Gliding SCFE Screw (Pega Medical), which employs a telescopic design intended to avoid physeal compression. The objective of this study is to evaluate radiographic changes of the proximal femur following in situ fixation using the Free Gliding SCFE Screw. This study retrospectively evaluated 28 hips in 14 consecutive patients who underwent in situ hip fixation using the Free Gliding SCFE Screw between 2014 and 2018. Initial postoperative radiographs were compared to last available follow-up imaging. Radiographic assessment included screw length, articulotrochanteric distance (ATD), posterior sloping angle (PSA), alpha angle, head-neck offset (HNO) and head-shaft angle (HSA). Of the 28 hips reviewed, 17 were treated for SCFE and an additional 11 treated prophylactically. Average age at surgery was 11.7 years, with an average follow-up of 1.44 years. Screw length increased by 2.3 mm (p < 0.001). ATD decreased from 25.4 to 22.2 mm (p < 0.001). Alpha angle decreased from 68.7 to 59.8 degrees (p = 0.004). There was a trend towards an increase in HNO (p = 0.07). There was no significant change in PSA or HAS. There were three complications (two patients with retained broken guide wires, and one patient requiring screw removal for hip pain). With use of the Free Gliding SCFE Screw, there was evidence of screw expansion and femoral neck remodelling with short-term follow-up. More research is required to determine the long-term impact of these changes on hip function, and to aid in patient selection for this technology.
To identify the incidence of sequential slip of the unaffected hips in patients presenting with unilateral SCFE managed with prophylactic fixation or observation. A retrospective review of all unilateral SCFE treated during 1998 to 2012 was undertaken. The study compares the incidence of sequential slip of the initially unaffected hip in patients managed with prophylactic fixation or observation. The study also reports the incidence avascular necrosis, chondrolysis, and metal-work related problem in this group of patients. All patients included in this current work have at least 12 months of follow-up from the index slip. A total of 44 cases had prophylactic fixation of the unaffected hip (mean age 12.6 years,) and 36 patients managed with regular observation (mean age 13.4 years). Sequential slip of the unaffected hip was noted in a total of 10 patients (28 %) managed with regular observation and only in 1 patient (2%) managed with prophylactic fixation. A Fishers exact test showed significantly high incidence of sequential slip in unaffected hips when managed by regular observation (p-value-0.002). There is no evidence of avascular necrosis or chondrolysis in the unaffected hip in both groups, 3 patients had metalwork related problem and one had superficial wound infection in prophylactic fixation group. Simultaneous prophylactic fixation of the unaffected hips significantly reduces the incidence of sequential slip. This is a relatively safe procedure and should be advocated in all cases of unilateral SCFE to avoid potential complications and preserve function of the unaffected hip.
In situ pinning for classic slipped capital femoral epiphysis(SLIP) is evolving to a more direct and anatomic realignment of proximal femoral epiphysis; but in no study the result of such a treatment in Valgus Slip, an uncommon type of slipped capital femoral epiphysis, has been reported. Three hips in three patients (one male, two female) with valgus SCFE were treated by sub-capital realignment (two hips) or femoral neck osteotomy (one hip) for anatomic realignment of proximal femoral epiphysis. Extended retinacular flap technique performed through surgical hip dislocation in all hips. They followed clinically by Merle d'Aubigne Scale and visual analog scale for pain and radiographically for AVN, recurrence of SLIP, chondrolysis and osteoarthritisIntroduction
Material and methods
The consequences of the complications associated with the management of slipped upper femoral epiphysis are a major source of disability in young adults. Whilst the management of chondrolysis, avascular necrosis or malunion of the femoral neck is usually undertaken by paediatric orthopaedic surgeons the initial management of SUFE in many regions is as part of an adult trauma service. This retrospective audit assessed the outcome of the management of SUFE in one such health region in which treatment occurred at three sites by a number of surgeons of varying experience, during the period July 1994 to June 2004. The aim was to compare our outcomes with those published and to identify whether our service should be altered as a consequence. The case notes and x-rays as recorded in theatre records were retrieved. Of the 64 cases that were treated during this period adequate records for 60 patients were available. Of these 60 patients there were 7 bilateral cases. Fixation in all 67 cases was by a single cannulated screw. In the 53 unilateral cases 17 underwent prophylactic pinning, the remaining 36 remained under observation. Of these nine patients presented with subsequent slips, eight of which were unstable and two had slip angles greater than 60° in which one developed avascular necrosis. Four other cases of avascular necrosis were observed (incidence 6%). Chondrolysis occurred in one patient with persistent pin penetration. In the remaining 73 cannulated screws used for stabilisation and 17 for prophylactic fixation no complications were observed. The complication rates observed in this series are within those accepted in the literature. The high incidence of subsequent slips and the attendant severity of these when compared with the relative safety of contemporary cannulated screw fixation has led us to recommend prophylactic pinning in our region.
Slipped upper femoral epiphysis (SUFE) is an uncommon condition with potentially severe complications including avascular necrosis (AVN) and chondrolysis. Children with a ‘slip’ are at a significantly higher risk of a contralateral slip. Controversy remains as to when to undertake prophylactic pinning. The primary aim of this study was to assess the Posterior Sloping Angle (PSA, as described by Barrios et al in 2005) as a predictor for contralateral slip in a large, multi ethnic cohort. All consecutive patients treated for SUFE presenting to Waikato Hospital between January 2000 and December 2009 were identified via medical coding. Patients without radiographs and those with bilateral slips on presentation were excluded. Clinical records were reviewed to document demographic data, slip characteristics and follow up outcomes. Radiographic analysis of the PSA in the unaffected hip was performed by a single author. Statistical analysis was performed using a student's t-test with Microsoft Excel 2003. 182 patients were identified, 50 were excluded [26 bilateral slips, 24 no radiograph available] to total a study population of 132 patients. 93 patients were male [72%]. Mean age was 11.8 years [6.2–15.6 years]. 72% were of Maori ethnicity and 26% were of New Zealand European descent. 90 patients [69%] had a unilateral slip, 42 [32%] had a contralateral slip. 48% were not followed until physeal closure and 50% did not attend at least one scheduled appointment Mean PSA of those with a unilateral slip was 10.8° [2–21°]. Patients who subsequently developed a contralateral slip had a statistically significantly higher mean PSA of 17.2° [6–36°] [p<0.0001]. Children with a contralateral slip were significantly younger 11.1 years than those with a unilateral slip 12.2 years (p<0.0001). No significant differences in PSA were found between Maori and NZ European children. If a PSA of 14° was used as an indication for prophylactic fixation in this population 35/42 [83.3%] of contralateral slips would have been prevented. 19/90 hips would have been pinned unnecessarily. The number needed to treat demonstrates that 1.79 hips are prophylactically pinned to prevent one slip in this population. This large retrospective cohort study demonstrates that a PSA of 14° in an unaffected hip after one sided SUFE could warrant prophylactic pinning in an unaffected hip to prevent subsequent slip and the complications associated with this, potentially protecting a population that can be difficult to follow up.
A group of UK paediatric surgeons (the UK SCFE Study Group) convened to design pertinent trials in slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE), twelve centres across the UK reviewed the demographics and management of children with SCFE. At all contributing centres with digital PACS records, a search for terms relating to SCFE were performed. From the results, radiographs and electronically stored clinic letters were assessed to confirm the diagnosis and ascertain age at presentation, incidence of bilaterality, chronicity, stability, management and complications. A total of 601 SCFEs presented between 2007 and 2012 to the twelve units. The mean age at presentation was 12.5 years. The left hip was nearly twice as commonly involved compared to the right (R: L = 3.3: 5.1), with bilateral presentation in 22% of patients. The most common mode of presentation was acute-on-chronic. Stable slips were over twice as common as unstable. The most common intervention was percutaneous pinning in situ. Open reduction was required in 24% of cases. The commonest complication was osteonecrosis (10.5%). This data concurs with earlier smaller audits and highlights current demographics and contemporary management of SCFE throughout the UK and informs the subject and content of potential future randomized control trials.
We report our early experience with distracting external fixation used to offload the hip after avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head secondary to severe slipped upper femoral epiphysis (SUFE). A case series of five patients treated in a tertiary centre is reported. Electronic case records and radiographs were reviewed. Data recorded included demographics, initial presentation, timing of head collapse, timing and duration of distraction and outcome including referral to adult arthoplasty services. Mean age at presentation was 12 years (range 12–15). 4 were females. Initial treatment in 4 cases was a delayed cuneiform osteotomy and pinning, one patient underwent serendipitous reduction and percutaneous pinning. Mean duration to initial surgery was 10 days (range 5–16). All patients had femoral head collapse at a mean of 148 days from time of presentation. 2 patients required backing out of screws due to intra-articular protrusion. All patients underwent distraction at a mean 193 days from presentation. Average distraction achieved was 10 mm and duration of application was 125 days (range 91–139) All patients experienced improvement or resolution of pain but persistence of poor function, characterised by fixed adduction and limb length discrepancy. 3 patients were referred to adult arthroplasty services. This may be an effective treatment option for pain associated with AVN post SUFE. However, in our experience normal anatomy and function of the hip is not restored if performed after collapse of the femoral head. Consideration should be given to application of the distractor either at the time of initial fixation or prior to femoral head collapse. Authors believe that timing of the application of the distractor is critical for a successful outcome and recommend a prospective study with large numbers.
Unstable slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) has an increased incidence of avascular necrosis (AVN). The purpose of this study was to determine if early identification and intervention for AVN may help preserve the femoral head. We retrospectively reviewed 48 patients (50 hips) with unstable SCFE managed between 2000 and 2014. Based on two different protocols during the same time period, 17 patients (17 hips) had a scheduled MRI between 1 and 6 months from initial surgery, with closed bone graft epiphysiodesis (CBGE) or free vascularised fibular graft (FVFG) if AVN was diagnosed. Thirty-one patients (33 hips) were evaluated by plain radiographs. Outcomes analysed were Steinberg classification and subsequent surgical intervention. We defined Steinberg class IVC as failure in treatment because all of the patients referred for osteotomy, arthoplasty, or arthrodesis in our study were grade IVC or higher. Overall, 13 hips (26%) with unstable SCFE developed AVN. MRI revealed AVN in 7 of 17 hips (41%) at a mean of 2.5 months postoperatively (range, 1.0 to 5.2 months). Six hips diagnosed by MRI received surgical intervention (4 CBGE, 1 FVFG, and 1 repinning due to screw cutout) at a mean of 4.1 months (range, 1.3 to 7.2 months) postoperatively. None of the 4 patients treated with CBGE within two months postoperatively progressed to stage IVC AVN. The two patients treated after four months postoperatively both progressed to stage VC AVN. Radiographically diagnosed AVN occurred in 6 of 33 hips (18%) at a mean of 6.8 months postoperatively (range, 2.1 to 21.1 months). One patient diagnosed with stage IVB AVN at 2.4 months had screw cutout and received CBGE at 2.5 months from initial pinning. The remaining 5 were not offered surgical intervention. Five of the 6 radiographically diagnosed AVN, including the one treated with CBGE, progressed to stage IVC AVN or greater. None of the 4 patients with unstable SCFE treated with CBGE within 2 months post pinning developed grade IVC AVN, while all patients treated with other procedures after 2 months developed IVC or greater AVN. Early detection and treatment of AVN after SCFE may alter the clinical and radiographic progression.
In 2000, Reinhold Ganz developed a surgical technique for treating slipped capital femoral epiphysis using his surgical hip dislocation approach to facilitate anatomical reconstruction of the slipped epiphysis—reportedly, without risk of avascular necrosis. This technique is now being adopted cautiously in paediatric orthopaedic centres internationally. The technique will be described and early results presented. Complications and their treatments will also be discussed. Early experience suggests morbidity following the procedure is not insignificant and until more corroborating safety data is available, the author suggests this technically demanding surgery should only be offered to children whose significant deformity would otherwise result in childhood disability.
Hips following in-situ pinning for slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) have an altered morphology of the proximal femur with cam type deformity. This deformity can result in femoroacetabular impingement and early joint degeneration. The modified Dunn procedure allows to reorientate the slipped epiphysis to restore hip morphology and function. To evaluate (1) hip pain and function, (2) 10-year survival rate and (3) subsequent surgeries and complications in hips undergoing modified Dunn procedure for SCFE.Introduction
Objectives
The childhood hip conditions of Developmental Dysplasia, Legg-Calve-Perthes Disease and Slipped Capital Femoral
Introduction. Patients presenting with osteoarthritis as late sequelae following pediatric hip trauma have few options aside from standard Total Hip Replacement (THR). For younger more active patients, Hip Resurfacing Arthroplasty (HRA) can be offered as an alternative. HRA has been performed in the United States over the past decade and allows increased bone preservation, decreased hip dislocation rates versus THR, and potential to return to full activities. Patients presenting with end-stage hip arthritis as following prior pediatric trauma or disease often have altered hip morphology making HRA more complicated. Often Legg-Calve-Perthes (LCP) patients present with short, wide femoral necks, and femoral head distortion including coxa magna or coxa plana. There often can be acetabular dysplasia in conjunction with the proximal femoral abnormalities. Slipped Capital Femoral
Through the paediatric LCP Hip plating system (Synthes GmBH Eimattstrasse 3 CH- 4436 Oberdorff), the highly successful technique of the locking compression plate used in adult surgery, has been incorporated in a system dedicated to pediatrics. We are presenting the outcome of the paediatric LCP hip plating system used for a variety of indications in our institution. We retrospectively reviewed the notes and radiographs of all those children who have had Paediatric LCP Plate for the fixation of proximal femoral osteotomy and proximal femur fractures in our institution, between October 2007 and July 2010, for their clinical progress, mobilization status, radiological healing and any complications. Forty-three Paediatric LCP hip plates were used in forty patients (24 males and 13 females) for the fixation of proximal femoral osteotomies (n=40) and proximal femur fractures (n=3). The osteotomies were performed for a variety of indications including Perthes disease, developmental dysplasia of hip, Cerebral Palsy, Down's syndrome, coxa vara, Leg length discrepancy and previous failed treatment of Slipped Upper Femoral