Metabolic bone diseases, such as osteoporosis and osteopetrosis, result from an imbalanced bone remodeling process. In vitro bone models are often used to investigate either bone formation or resorption independently, while in vivo, these processes are coupled. Combining these processes in a co-culture is challenging as it requires finding the right medium components to stimulate each cell type involved without interfering with the other cell type's differentiation. Furthermore, differentiation stimulating factors often comprise growth factors in supraphysiological concentrations, which can overshadow the cell-mediated crosstalk and coupling. To address these challenges, we aimed to recreate the physiological bone remodeling process, which follows a specific sequence of events starting with cell activation and bone resorption by osteoclasts, reversal, followed by bone formation by osteoblasts. We used a mineralized silk fibroin scaffold as a bone-mimetic template, inspired by bone's extracellular matrix composition and organization. Our model supported osteoclastic resorption and osteoblastic mineralization in the specific sequence that represents physiological bone remodeling. We also demonstrated how culture variables, such as different cell ratios, base media, and the use of osteogenic/osteoclast supplements, and the application of mechanical load, can be adjusted to represent either a high bone turnover system or a self-regulating system. The latter system did not require the addition of osteoclastic and osteogenic differentiation factors for remodeling, therefore avoiding growth factor use. Our in vitro model for bone remodeling has the potential to reduce animal experiments and advance in vitro drug development for bone remodeling pathologies like osteoporosis. By recreating the physiological bone remodeling cycle, we can investigate cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions, which are essential for understanding bone physiology and pathology. Furthermore, by tuning the culture variables, we can investigate bone remodeling under various conditions, potentially providing insights into the mechanisms underlying different bone disorders.
Young patients receiving metallic bone implants after surgical resection of bone cancer require implants that last into adulthood, and ideally life-long. Porous implants with similar stiffness to bone can promote bone ingrowth and thus beneficial clinical outcomes. A mechanical remodelling stimulus, strain energy density (SED), is thought to be the primary control variable of the process of bone growth into porous implants. The sequential process of bone growth needs to be taken into account to develop an accurate and validated bone remodelling algorithm, which can be employed to improve porous implant design and achieve better clinical outcomes. A bone remodelling algorithm was developed, incorporating the concept of bone connectivity (sequential growth of bone from existing bone) to make the algorithm more physiologically relevant. The algorithm includes adaptive elastic modulus based on apparent bone density, using a node-based model to simulate local remodelling variations while alleviating numerical checkerboard problems. Strain energy density (SED) incorporating stress and strain effects in all directions was used as the primary stimulus for bone remodelling. The simulations were developed to run in MATLAB interfacing with the commercial FEA software ABAQUS and Python. The algorithm was applied to predict bone ingrowth into a porous implant for comparison against data from a sheep model.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
Bone remodelling is a continuous process whereby osteocytes regulate the activity of osteoblasts and osteoclasts to repair loading-induced microdamage. While many in vitro studies have established the role of paracrine factors (e.g., RANKL/OPG) and cellular pathways involved in bone homeostasis, these techniques are generally limited to two-dimensional cell culture, which neglects the role of the native extracellular matrix in maintaining the phenotype of osteocyte. Recently, ex vivo models have been used to understand cell physiology and mechanobiology in the presence of the native matrix. Such approaches could be applicable to study the mechanisms of bone repair, whilst also enabling exploration of biomechanical cues. However, to date an ex vivo model of bone remodelling in cortical bone has not been developed. In this study, the objective was to develop an ex vivo model where cortical bone was subjected to cyclic strains to study the remodelling of bone. Ex vivo model of bone remodelling induced by cyclic loading: At the day of culling, beam-shape bovine bone samples were cut and preserved in PBS + 5% Pen/Strep + 2 mM L-Glut overnight at 37°C. Cyclic strains were applied with a three-point bend system to induce damage with a regime at 16.66 mm/min for 5,000 cycles in sterile PBS in Evolve® bags (maximum strain 6%). A control group was cultured under static conditions. Metabolic activity: Alamar Blue assays were performed after 1 and 7 days of ex vivo culture for each group (Static, Loaded) and normalized to weight. Bone remodelling: ALP activity was assessed in the media at day 1 and 7. After 24 hours cell culture conditioned media (CM) was collected from each group and stored at −80°C. RAW264.7 cells were cultured with CM for 6 days, after which the samples were stained for TRAP, to determine osteoclastogenesis, and imaged. Histomorphometry: Samples were cultured with calcein for 3 days to label bone formation between day 4 and 7. Fluorescent images were captured at day 7. μCT scanning was performed at 3 μm resolution after labelling samples with BaSO4 precipitate to quantify bone damage.Introduction and Objective
Materials and Methods
The effect of high-fat diet and testosterone replacement therapy upon bone remodelling was investigated in orchiectomised male APOE-/- mice. Mice were split in to three groups: sham surgery + placebo treatment (control, n=9), orchiectomy plus placebo treatment (n=8) and orchiectomy plus testosterone treatment (n=10). Treatments were administered via intramuscular injection once a fortnight for 17 weeks before sacrifice at 25 weeks of age. Tibiae were scanned ex-vivo using µCT followed by post-analysis histology and immunohistochemistry. Previously presented µCT data demonstrated orchiectomised, placebo treated mice exhibited significantly reduced trabecular bone volume, number, thickness and BMD compared to control mice despite no significant differences in body weight. Trabecular parameters were rescued back to control levels in orchiectomised mice treated with testosterone. No significant differences were observed in the cortical bone. Assessment of TRAP stained FFPE sections revealed no significant differences in osteoclast or osteoblast number along the endocortical surface. IHC assessment of osteoprotegerin (OPG) expression in osteoblasts is to be quantified alongside markers of osteoclastogenesis including RANK and RANKL. Results support morphological analysis of cortical bone where no change in cortical bone volume or density between groups is in line with no significant change in osteoblast or osteoclast number and percentage across all three groups. Future work will include further IHC assessment of bone remodelling and adiposity, as well as utilisation of mechanical testing to establish the effects of observed morphological differences in bone upon mechanical properties. Additionally, the effects of hormone treatments upon murine-derived bone cells will be investigated to provide mechanistic insights.
Global prevalence of obesity has risen almost three-fold between 1975 and 2016. Alongside the more well-known health implications of obesity such as cardiovascular disease, cancer and type II diabetes, is the effect of male obesity on testosterone depletion and hypogonadism. Hypogonadism is a well-known contributor to the acceleration of bone loss during aging, and obesity is the single biggest risk factor for testosterone deficiency in men. Understanding the micro and macro structural changes to bone in response to testosterone depletion in combination with a high fat ‘Western’ diet, will advance our understanding of the relationship between obesity and bone metabolism. This study investigated the impact of surgically induced testosterone depletion and subsequent testosterone treatment upon bone remodelling in mice fed a high fat diet. Male ApoE−/− mice were split into 3 groups at 7 weeks of age and fed a high fat diet: Sham surgery with placebo treatment, orchiectomy surgery with placebo treatment, and orchiectomy surgery with testosterone treatment. Surgeries were performed at 8 weeks of age, followed by fortnightly testosterone treatment via injection. Mice were sacrificed at 25 weeks of age. Tibiae were collected and scanned ex-vivo at 4.3μm on a SkyScan 1272 Micro-CT scanner (Bruker). Left tibiae were used for assessment of trabecular and cortical Volumes of Interest (VOIs) 0.2mm and 1.0mm respectively from the growth-plate bridge break. Tibiae were subsequently paraffin embedded and sectioned at 4μm prior to immunohistochemical evaluation of alkaline phosphatase.Introduction and Objective
Materials and Methods
Implant stability and is an important factor for adequate bone remodelling and both are crucial in the long-term clinical survival of total hip arthroplasty (THA). Assessment of early bone remodelling on X-rays during the first 2 years post-operatively is mandatory when stepwise introduction of a new implant is performed. Regardless of fixation type (cemented or cementless), early acetabular component migration is usually the weakest link in THA, eventually leading to loosening. Over the past years, a shift towards uncemented cup designs has occurred. Besides the established hydroxyapatite (HA) coated uncemented cups which provide ongrowth of bone, new uncemented implant designs stimulating ingrowth of bone have increased in popularity. These cups initiate ingrowth of bone into the implant by their open metallic structure with peripheral pores, to obtain a mechanical interlock with the surrounding bone, thereby stabilising the prosthesis in an early stage after implantation. This retrospective study assessed bone remodelling, osseointegration and occurrence of radiolucency around a new ingrowth philosophy acetabular implant. In a retrospectively, single centre cohort study all patients whom underwent primary THA with a Tritanium acetabular component in 2011 were included. Bone remodelling, osseointegration and occurrence of radiolucency were determined by two reviewers from X-ray images that were made at 6 weeks, 3–6-12 and 24 months post-operatively. Bone contact % was calculated based on the original Charnley and DeLee zones. According to Charnley and DeLee the outer surface of an acetabular cup is divided into 3 zones (1-2-3). For our analysis the original 3 zones were further divided into 2 producing 6 zones 1A to 3B. Each of these 6 zones were then further divided into 4 equal sections. We attributed 25 points per section in which complete bone contact without lucency was observed. If lucency was observed no points were attributed to the section. A fully osteointegrated cup in all 24 sections could therefore attain 600 points. The total of each section and zone was subsequently tallied and recalculated to produce the percentage of bone contact on a 1–100% score.Background
Methods
Children suffering from primary bone cancer necessitating resection of growth plates, may suffer progressive leg length discrepancy, which can be attenuated with extendable prostheses. A serious complication is catastrophic implant failure. Over time, bone will remodel, altering the stress pattern in the implant. By using finite element analysis we can model different bone remodeling conditions to ascertain the effect that this will have on stress distribution and magnitude. A finite element analysis was performed. Simplified computer generated models were designed of a cemented femoral Stanmore growing massive endoprosthesis. Three scenarios were designed, modelled on post-operative radiographs. Scenario 1 had a gap between the end of the femur and the implant collar, scenario 2 had no gap, but with no bone attachment into the collar, and scenario 3 had growth of the bone over the length of the collar with attachment. Physiological loading conditions were applied. The resultant stress in the implant for each scenario was measured, and compared to the strength of the material. Peak stresses were recorded at the stem-collar junction. The maximum stress recorded in the implant in scenario 1 was 3104.2Mpa, compared to 1054.4Mpa in scenario 2, and 321.2Mpa in scenario 3. Both accurate reduction and bone growth with attachment to the stem of a massive endoprosthesis will greatly reduce the resultant stress in the implant under loading conditions. The load is redistributed throughout the length of the bone. This may help to prevent catastrophic failure in the implant under loading conditions. Further investigations of patient findings are needed to ensure the model findings are verified.Background
Conclusions
In a prospective study of 14 patients undergoing total hip replacement we have used dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) to investigate remodelling of the bone around two different designs of cementless femoral prosthesis. The bone mineral density (BMD) was measured at 12-weekly intervals for a year. Eight patients (group A) had a stiff, collarless implant and six (group B) a flexible isoelastic implant. Patients in group A showed a decrease in BMD from 14 weeks after operation. By 12 months, the mean loss in BMD was 27%, both medially and laterally to the proximal part of the implant. Those in group B showed an overall increase in BMD which reached a mean of 12.6% on the lateral side of the distal portion of the implant. Our results support the current concepts of the effects of stem stiffness and flexibility on periprosthetic remodelling.
Most of researches related to osteoporosis emphasized on trabecular bone loss. However, cortical bone has a prominent role on bone strength determined by bone quality, such as 2D or 3D geometry and microstructure of bone, not only density.[1] The focal thinning of cortical bone associated with aging in post-menopausal osteoporotic bone in the proximal femur may predispose a hip to fracture.[2, 3] As the trabecular bone is lost with progression of osteoporosis, the remaining cortical bone take more predominant role on bone strength.[4] To date, no effective osteoporotic agent was demonstrated to enhance both cortical geometric change and bone strength. Herein, we investigate the effect of Teriparatide (rhPTH(1–34)) on cortical bone at femoral diaphysis in OVX rat model. Twenty 12-week-old, female Sprague Dawley rats were used in this study. Bilateral ovariectomies were performed in 16 animals and randomly divided to three groups as control (N=6), OVX (N=6) and treatment group after OVX (OVX+F) by teriparatide (N=8). After twelve weeks of intervention, all rats were euthanized and right femurs and L5 vertebrae were extracted for further tests. All bone specimens were subjected to dual-energy X-ray absorptiometer (DXA) to evaluate areal bone mineral density (aBMD) of L5 vertebrae and femurs, micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) to analyze cortical bone parameters of femoral diaphysis, including cortical cross section area (CSA), cortical thickness and cross-sectional moment of inertia (CSMI). A three-point bending test was applied to determine fracture load of each femurs. Compare to OVX group, increase of aBMD by 14.6 % at L5 vertebrae and 13.3% at femoral diahpysis in treatment group. The cortical parameters of femoral diaphysis, CSA and cortical thickness, analyzed by micro-CT were significantly increased but the increasing tendency of CSMI did not have significant changes statistically after teriparatide intervention for 3 months duration. The increase of cortical bone strength (OVX vs OVX+F group, 120.72±2.72 vs 137.93±5.02, p < 0.05) at femoral diaphysis after treatment were also noticed. This study has point out a deeper look at geometric change of cortical bone after teriparatide treatment. This finding imply teirparatide has the ability to change the geometry of cortical bone and increase bone strength at femoral diaphysis.
Recent studies have shown that random disorder nanotopography increases osteoblast differentiation and bone formation. This has great potential merit in producing surfaces where osteointegration is required such as spinal fusion surgery and arthroplasty. However, the long-term failure of orthopaedic implants is often related to osteoclast mediated osteolysis and loosening. It is vitally important that we understand the effect of nanotopography on osteoclast formation and bone remodeling. We developed an unique osteoblast/osteoclast co-culture system derived from human mesenchymal and haematopoetic stem cells. This was co-cultured on both nanopatterned and unpatterned polycarbonate substrates. We assessed the co-culture using electron microscopy (SEM), protein expression using immunofluorescence and histochemical staining and gene expression using polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Co-culture of both osteoclasts and osteoblasts was confirmed with mature bone nodules and resorption pits identified on both surfaces. Significantly increased osteoblast differentiation and bone formation was noted on disordered nanotopography. Antagonistic genes controlling osteoclast activity were both upregulated with no significant difference in osteoclast marker gene expression. Our results confirm successful co-culture of osteoblasts and osteoclasts using an unique method closely resembling the
Long term, secondary implant fixation of Total Disc Replacements (TDR) can be enhanced by hydroxyapatite or similar osseo-conductive coatings. These coatings are routinely applied to metal substrates. The objective of this in vivo study was to investigate the early stability and subsequent bone response adjacent to an all polymer TDR implant over a period of six months in an animal model. Six skeletally mature male baboons (Papio annubis) were followed for a period of 6 months. Using a transperitoneal exposure, a custom-sized Cadisc L device was implanted into the disc space one level above the lumbo-sacral junction in all subjects. Radiographs of the lumbar spine were acquired prior to surgery, and post-operatively at intervals up to 6 months to assess implant stability. Flourochrome markers (which contain molecules that bind to mineralization fronts) were injected at specified intervals in order to investigate bone remodeling with time. Animals were humanely euthanized six months after index surgery. Test and control specimens were retrieved, fixed and subjected to histological processing to assess the bone-implant-bone interface. Fluorescence microscopy and confocal scanning laser microscopy were utilized with BioQuant image analysis to determine the bone mineral apposition rates and gross morphology. Radiographic evaluation revealed no loss of disc height at the operative level or adjacent levels. No evidence of subsidence or significant migration of the implant up to 6 months. Heterotopic ossification was observed to varying degrees at the operated level. Histology revealed the implant primary fixation features embedded within the adjacent vertebral endplates. Flourochrome distribution revealed active bone remodeling occurring adjacent to the polymeric end-plate with no evidence of adverse biological responses. Mineral apposition rates of between 0.7 and 1.7 microns / day are in keeping with literature values for hydroxyapatite coated implants in cancellous sites of various species. Radiographic assessment demonstrates that the Cadisc L implant remains stable in vivo with no evidence of subsidence or significant migration. Histological analysis suggests the primary fixation features are engaged, and in close apposition with the adjacent vertebral bone. Flourochrome markers provide evidence of a positive bone remodelling response in the presence of the implant.
We developed a 3D vascularized bone remodeling model embedding human osteoblast and osteoclast precursors and endothelial cells in a mineralized matrix. All the cells included in the model exerted their function, resulting in a vascularized system undergoing mineralized matrix remodeling. Bone remodeling is a dynamic process relying on the balance between the activity of osteoblasts and osteoclasts which are responsible for bone formation and resorption, respectively. This process is also characterized by a tight coupling between osteogenesis and angiogenesis, indicating the existence of a complex cross-talk between endothelial cells and bone cells. We have recently developed microscale in vitro hydrogel-based models, namely the 3D MiniTissue models, to obtain bone-mimicking microenvironments including a 3D microvascular network formed by endothelial cell self-assembly [1–2]. Here, we generated a vascularized 3D MiniTissue bone remodeling model through the coculture of primary human cells in a 3D collagen/fibrin (Col/Fib) matrix enriched with CaP nanoparticles (CaPn) to mimic bone mineralized matrix. Human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs), bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs), osteoblast (OBs) and osteoclast (OCs) precursors were cocultured in plain and CaPn-enriched Col/Fib according to the following experimental conditions: a) HUVECs-BMSCs; b) OBs-OCs; c) HUVECs-BMSCs-OBs-OCs. Undifferentiated BMSCs were used to support HUVECs in microvascular network formation. BMSCs and peripheral blood mononuclear cells were respectively pre-differentiated into OB and OC precursors through 7 days of culture in osteogenic or osteoclastogenic medium. Needle-shaped CaPn (Ø ∼20 nm, length ∼80 nm) were added to a collagen/fibrinogen solution. Cells were resuspended in a thrombin solution and then mixed with plain or CaPn-enriched collagen/fibrinogen. The cell-laden mix was injected in U-shaped PMMA masks and let to polymerize to generate constructs of 2×2×5 mm3. Samples were cultured for 10 days. Microvascular network formation was evaluated by confocal microscopy. OB differentiation was analyzed by quantification of Alkaline Phosphatase (ALP) and cell-mediated mineralization. OC differentiation was assessed by Tartrate-Resistant Acid Phosphatase (TRAP) and cell-mediated phosphate release quantification. HUVECs developed a robust 3D microvascular network and BMSCs differentiated into mural cells supporting vasculogenesis. The presence of CaPn enhanced OB and OC differentiation, as demonstrated by the significantly higher ALP and TRAP levels and by the superior cell-mediated mineralization and phosphate release measured in CaPn-enriched than in plain Col/Fib. The coculture of OBs and OCs with HUVECs and BMSCs further enhanced ALP and TRAP levels, indicating that the presence of HUVECs and BMSCs positively contributed to OB and OC differentiation. Remarkably, higher values of ALP and TRAP activity were measured in the tetraculture in CaPn-enriched Col/Fib compared to plain Col/Fib, indicating that also in the tetraculture the mineralized matrix stimulated OB and OC differentiation. The 3D MiniTissue bone remodeling model developed in this study is a promising platform to investigate bone cell and endothelial cell cross-talk. This system allows to minimize the use of cells and reagents and is characterized by a superior ease of use compared to other microscale systems, such as microfluidic models. Finally, it represents a suitable platform to test drugs for bone diseases and can be easily personalized with patient-derived cells further increasing its relevance as drug screening platform.
