Clinical researchers use Pfirrmann classification for grading intervertebral disc degeneration radiologically. Basic researchers have access to morphology and instead use the Thompson score. The aim of this study was to assess the inter-observer reliability of both classifications, along with their correlation. We obtained T2-weighted MR images of 80 human lumbar intervertebral discs with various stages of degeneration to assess the Pfirrmann-score. Then the discs were dissected midsagittally to obtain the Thompson-score. The observers were typical users of both grading systems: a spine surgeon, radiology resident, orthopaedic resident, and a basic scientist, all experts on intervertebral disc degeneration. Cohen's kappa (CK) was used to determine inter-observer reliability, and intra-class correlation (ICC) as a measure for the variation between the outcomes. For the Thompson score, the average CK was 0.366 and ICC score 0.873. The average inter-observer reliability for the Pfirrmann score was 0.214 (CK) and 0.790 (ICC). Comparing the grading systems, the intra-observer agreement was 0.240 (CK) and 0.685 (ICC).Purpose of study and background
Methods and Results
From 1990 to 1993 we treated 22 consecutive patients who had progressive spinal kyphosis due to ankylosing spondylitis by a closing-wedge posterior vertebral osteotomy with partial corporectomy of L4 and transpedicular fixation. The average correction was 32 degrees (24 to 52) with a mean loss of correction after operation of 2.7 degrees (0 to 13). The average operating time was 185 minutes (135 to 240) and blood loss was 2500 ml (1200 to 5000). The osteotomy corrected all patients sufficiently to allow them to see ahead and their posture was improved. There were no fatal complications, but in two cases there was failure of the instrumentation and one patient needed reoperation for nerve compression. Two deep wound infections required removal of the implant and six patients had superficial skin infections under the plaster. The use of a circoelectric bed and intermittent prone lying eliminated this problem.
