header advert
Results 1 - 4 of 4
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXIII | Pages 115 - 115
1 May 2012
Stubbs G
Full Access

The suggestion of a meniscal tear produces a pavlovian response in the orthopaedic surgeon. However, meniscal signal anomalies and associated changes become common with age in symptom free knees. T he issue for the IME requested to assess workers with painful knees is to determine if the MRI changes represent a painful injury and if the treatment planned (usually arthroscopy) may, in fact, be harmful.

MRI signal changes are assessed on the likelihood they predict for unstable meniscal tears. Some patterns of meniscal tears are benign. Associated changes such as baker's cyst and ligament thickening are also common but are poor predictors of symptomatic tears. Preclinical osteoarthritis has a high incidence of associated meniscal change and arthroscopic menisectomy may accelerate osteoarthritis progression.

Clinical tests have variable specificity and sensitivity but in combination with an understanding of the patterns of MRI signal can be combined to predict which meniscal tears would benefit from arthroscopic surgery, which injuries would do as well with non-operative treatment and which patterns predict deterioration after surgery.

As the views of the IME are often contrary to the surgeon, a comprehensive bibliography is provided for any who need to argue their case. As the topic is information and image dense, a CD ROM will be distributed.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 86-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 468 - 468
1 Apr 2004
Stubbs G Tewari S Rogers J Costello L Crowe B Smith N
Full Access

Introduction Bilateral total knee replacement under one anaesthetic is a common procedure. Claimed benefits include: shorter hospital stays, fewer complications of some kinds, lower over all cost and more efficient use of staff time. In general the literature supports these concepts though some writers caution against the procedure. Most studies come from large university hospitals but most joint replacements are done in smaller hospitals. At Calvary Hospital we instituted a quality assessment review of our experience to determine patient safety and cost savings.

Methods A medical records review between 1997 and 2001 showed 63 patients had bilateral total knee replacement (126 knees). We further identified 38 patients who had both knees replaced at separate admissions within one year (76 knees), these were the staged knee replacements. We selected a matched subset of the patients who had only one joint replaced in this period (125 knees). A review was carried out over a wide variety of parameters on a relation database.

Results The incidence of infection, unplanned return to theatre and DVT was too low for this study to have statistical power and little difference was noted. Amongst the more common post-operative respiratory, cardiovascular and gastrointestinal complications no significant difference was noted per hospital admission. Post-operative confusion was not more common in bilateral replacements and we felt that fat embolism syndrome was not increased. Neither, type of anaesthesia, previous medical history nor post-operative care predicted for confusion but we did note a strikingly increased incidence in patients of low BMI. Contrary to common views obese patients did not have more complications or longer hospital stays. Mobilisation in heavy patients is not prolonged provided they have good upper limb strength. Blood transfusion is more likely in bilateral cases but our review has allowed us to formulate a nomogram based on weight and pre-operative haemoglobin to improve blood management. High admission rates to ICU were noted but mostly for precautionary reasons, the unplanned admission rate was not greater. Pre-operative urinary tract infection and use of an IDC were not associated with any infective events.

Conclusions Bilateral total knee replacement was found to be a safe proceedure with complication rates equivalent to single knee replacement. For the patient who has severe arthritis in both knees it is prefered to repeated single knee replacement as the exposure to complications is halved. A nomogram to predict blood transfusion requirements has allowed a reduction in the transfusion rate for all groups. Twenty-three hour recovery admission covers the needs of bilateral replacement patients in the immediate post-opertaive setting. Cost savings are identified allowing four knees to be replaced, if done bilaterally, for each three knees replaced as seperate admissions.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 86-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 494 - 494
1 Apr 2004
Nabavi-Tabrizi A Stubbs G McKewin S
Full Access

Introduction The AO/ASIF 3.5 mm STS is increasingly used for internal fixation of large bones with the recent introduction of the 3.5 mm periarticular plating system. Our study aims to compare the insertion torque and mechanical properties of the screw after insertion into bovine femora using non tapped and pretapped methods.

Methods Three groups of ten 3.5 mm AO/ASIF STSs of variable lengths were used. One group was put aside as the control. One group was inserted into fresh bovine femora using pre-tapped drill holes and the final group using non-tapped drill holes. The insetion torques were measured and compared using an analogue torque screw driver. All screws were removed. The three groups were then tested for mechanical strength. The results of the groups were compared we found the insertion torque to be six times greater in the non tapped group compared to the pre tapped group. We noted the non tapped group failed later than the pre-tapped group, this was statistically not significant however. The mechanical strength of the screw was not statistically altered.

Conclusions We conclude that the 3.5 mm STS is easier to insert when pre tapped. However pre tapping is not necessary to preserve the mechanical strength of the screw.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 84-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 261 - 261
1 Nov 2002
Stubbs G Gordiev C Lyle I
Full Access

Distal biceps tendon avulsion requires surgical treatment but is uncommon. The average orthopedic surgeon will come across a case only occasionally. The two-incision technique of Boyd is technically difficult. One-incision methods are easier for the occasional surgeon. Methods using Mitek Bone Anchors and Endobuttons have been described in the literature. This presentation compares those techniques and a technique using anterior cruciate interference screws against the Two Incision Technique in a model consisting of sheep bone and sash cord.

The models were then tested on a dynamometer to failure to assess the ultimate strength of the various methods of fixation. In this model Mitek Anchors and Endobuttons gave comparable fail points to the two Incision Technique. The Interference Screw Technique was stronger.