Current evidence on the indications for and efficacy of non-rigid lumbar stabilisation remains unclear. The aim of this study was to review the outcome of the DYNESYS system (Zimmer, Inc.) in a consecutive series of 34 patients undergoing this procedure between 2001 and 2006. Prospectively collected outcome measure data obtained pre-operatively and at 1 year post-operatively was analysed using the Wilcoxon Signed Rank Test. Kaplan Meier survival analysis was performed using revision surgery as the end point. Cox Regression was utilised to identify variables that were related to implant survival. Pain rating on the visual analogue scale improved from a mean of 7 pre-op to 4 at 1 year (p=0.009), Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire scores from 13 to 9 (p=0.02), Modified Somatic Perception Questionnaire from 13 to 9 (p=0.03). When reporting subjective outcome, 54% of patients reported “better” or “much better” outcomes at last followup (12–69 months post op). Eight patients (25%) required removal of the implant and conversion to fusion, one of whom had deep infection. Kaplan Meier survival analysis revealed a survival of 78% at 5 years (95% CI, 60 – 96%). Previous spinal surgery was significantly related to the time of survival of the implant (p=0.008). Our study has demonstrated a high revision rate for this implant and 54% patient satisfaction. We recommend that patients be counseled regarding these risks and further use of this implant should be subject to the outcome of larger studies and randomised controlled trials.
We aim to assess the clinical and radiological outcome following cartilage repair in the knee using the TruFit plug (Smith &
Nephew). Eleven active sporting patients underwent cartilage repair using TruFit plugs between February 2006 and August 2007. Postoperatively patients were touch weight bearing for 2 weeks and partial until 4 weeks. Data was collected prospectively, patients underwent clinical review and completed Lysholm, IKDC subjective, Tegner, KOOS and SF-36 scores pre-operatively and at 6 monthly intervals. One patient has been excluded from the analysis as she emigrated and was lost to follow up. The remaining 10 patients (mean age 35 years (21–49)) had defects on the medial femoral condyle (n=6), lateral femoral condyle (n=3), and lateral trochlea (n=1). Patients received one (n=5), two (n=3) or three (n=2) plugs and four were primary procedures, and six revision procedures (1 failed OATS, 5 failed microfracture). Eight implantations were performed arthroscopically and, and two were mini-open. All patients were reviewed at 12 months, five were reviewed at 18 months and four have also been reviewed at 24 months. Statistically significant improvements from mean pre-operative scores are seen at 12 months; Lysholm (48.3 to 71), IKDC Subjective (37.7 to 65.1), Tegner (2.4 to 4.6), SF36 physical (39.5 to 50.3) and all components of KOOS. These improvements are maintained at the latest follow up. MRI evaluation including T2 mapping demonstrates reformation of the subchondral lamina, resorption of the graft and a similar signal from neo-cartilage as that of adjacent native cartilage. TruFit plugs offer an exciting novel solution for cartilage repair in the knee with advantages of low morbidity and rapid recovery without the need for prolonged non-weight bearing. The implant may be suitable for small lesions only and further prospective study is required to establish long-term outcome.
Peri-prosthetic fracture after joint replacement in the lower limb is associated with significant morbidity. The primary aim of this study was to investigate the incidence of peri-prosthetic fracture after total hip replacement (THR) and total knee replacement (TKR) over a ten-year period using a population-based linked dataset. Between 1 April 1997 and 31 March 2008, 52 136 primary THRs, 8726 revision THRs, 44 511 primary TKRs, and 3222 revision TKRs were performed. Five years post-operatively, the rate of fracture was 0.9% after primary THR, 4.2% after revision THR, 0.6% after primary TKR and 1.7% after revision TKR. Comparison of survival analysis for all primary and revision arthroplasties showed peri-prosthetic fractures were more likely in females, patients aged >
70 and after revision arthroplasty. Female patients aged >
70 should be warned of a significantly increased risk of peri-prosthetic fracture after hip or knee replacement. The use of adjuvant medical treatment to reduce the effect of peri-prosthetic osteoporosis may be a direction of research for these patients.
We investigated the excess mortality risk associated with fractures of the hip. Data related to 29 134 patients who underwent surgery following a fracture of the hip were obtained from the Scottish Hip Fracture Audit database. Fractures due to primary or metastatic malignancy were excluded. An independent database (General Register Office (Scotland)) was used to validate dates of death. The observed deaths per 100 000 of the population were then calculated for each group (gender, age and fracture type) at various time intervals up to eight years. A second database (Interim Life Tables for Scotland, Scottish Government) was then used to create standardised mortality ratios. Analysis showed that mortality in patients aged >
85 years with a fracture of the hip tended to return to the level of the background population between two and five years after the fracture. In those patients aged <
85 years excess mortality associated with hip fracture persisted beyond eight years. Extracapsular hip fractures and male gender also conferred increased risk.
We have investigated how medical postponement, the time to surgery and the correction of medical abnormalities, according to McLaughlin criteria, before operation affected peri-operative mortality after fracture of the hip. From February to December 2007, in addition to core data, the Scottish Hip Fracture Audit collected information relating to surgical delay. Data were available for 4284 patients which allowed 30-day survival analysis to be performed. Multivariable logistic regression models were used to control for differences in case-mix. Patients with major clinical abnormalities were more likely to have a postponement and had a lower unadjusted 30-day survival. The time to operation and postponement were not associated with higher mortality after adjustment for case-mix. Correction of major clinical abnormalities before surgery improved the adjusted survival, but this improvement was not significant (p = 0.10). Postponement without correction of a medical abnormality before surgery was associated with a significantly lower (p = 0.006) 30-day adjusted survival. The possible benefits of postponement need to be weighed against prolonged discomfort for the patient and the possibility of the development of other complications.
We have conducted a prospective, observational clinical trial of 34 patients with dual compartment osteoarthritis of the knee treated with a 2/3 Knee.
Exclusion criteria included obesity, inflammatory arthritis and a fixed flexion deformity >
10 degrees. Subjective outcome measures included Oxford Knee Scores (OKS) and EQ-5D Scores. RSA beads were implanted at surgery to detect loosening, micro-motion and prosthesis wear. Gait analysis was conducted at 1 year post op in a subgroup of patients.
The patients have recorded Significant improvement in their Oxford Knee Scores at 6 months (mean reduction all patients: 17.3, resurfaced 20). Early RSA results have not detected Significant migration to indicate early loosening. Gait analysis has shown that patients return to approximate normal rather than pre-operative gait.
It is essential that patients undergo primary patella resurfacing to prevent crepitus and associated anterior knee pain. A study comparing clinical outcomes of 2/3 Knee vs TKA is underway at our institution.
The purpose of this study was to assess the accuracy of a modified version of the pivot shift test in detecting ruptures of the anterior cruciate (ACL) ligament.
Midvastus vs Medial Parapatellar approach: Quadriceps function in the early post operative period was better preserved in the MV group. Post operative pain, blood loss and the need for LRR tended to be lower in the MV group. There was no difference in ROM, hospital stay, knee scores, complications or radiological alignment. Subvastus vs Medial Parapatellar approach: Quadriceps function was better preserved in the SV group up to 3 months post operatively. ROM was generally greater up to the 4 week time point. Post operative pain and blood loss was lower in the SV group. There was no difference in operative/tourniquet time, hospital stay, rate of LRR, or complications. Modified “Quadriceps sparing” Medial Parapatellar vs Mini-Subvastus (MSV) approach: A tendency for earlier restoration of SLR and better early ROM was noted in the MSV group. Midvastus vs Subvastus approach: The SV group suffered with significantly more pain at six months post operatively.
We investigated the relationship between a number of patient and management variables and mortality after surgery for fracture of the hip. Data relating to 18 817 patients were obtained from the Scottish Hip Fracture Audit database. We divided variables into two categories, depending on whether they were case-mix (age; gender; fracture type; pre-fracture residence; pre-fracture mobility and ASA scores) or management variables (time from fracture to surgery; time from admission to surgery; grade of surgical and anaesthetic staff undertaking the procedure and anaesthetic technique). Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that all case-mix variables were strongly associated with post-operative mortality, even when controlling for the effects of the remaining variables. Inclusion of the management variables into the case-mix base regression model provided no significant improvement to the model. Patient case-mix variables have the most significant effect on post-operative mortality and unfortunately such variables cannot be modified by pre-operative medical interventions.
Chondrocyte density was calculated from a defined site in each joint. Cartilage volume was measured by novel application of Peripheral Quantitative Computed Tomography (pQCT). Cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP), glycos-aminoglycans (GAG) and total protein (TP) concentrations were measured and then adjusted for cartilage and synovial fluid volume and compared between joints.
The DIP had higher TP, COMP and GAG concentrations, however, when values were expressed per unit cartilage volume the opposite was found, with the MCP then exhibiting significantly higher concentrations.
We aim to assess the outcome of ankle arthrodesis performed for painful osteoarthritis in the presence of a coronal plane deformity of 20 degrees or more. To our knowledge this is the first reported series of such a cohort of patients. We have a consecutive and complete series of 24 patients with 26 ankle arthrodeses which were all performed for painful osteoarthritis in the presence of large coronal plane deformity. These patients have a minimum of twelve months clinical follow up. The results showed a low non union rate of 8% (2 ankles). These have subsequently been refused satisfactorily, and were excluded from further analysis. The results of the remaining 24 ankles which united primarily show that they were very pleased with the outcome of their surgery. AOFAS scores were used to measure pain and function both pre operatively and post operatively. These scores showed large improvements for both pain and function, and had a high statistical significance (p<
0.0005). All patients improved in their walking distance and many patients reduced their need for walking aids. Stair climbing ability was also improved in some patients. It is recognised that an ankle arthrodesis usually relieves pain but does not result in a normal gait and full function. We feel that the high level of patient satisfaction in this series was due to the combination of deformity correction, restoring a functional foot position, and achieving a painless ankle. Arthroplasty of the ankle is a good procedure for relief of pain and restoration of function. However In the presence of a large coronal plane deformity ankle arthroplasty is known to fare badly with early failure. Therefore for patients with painful osteoarthritis and a coronal plane deformity of 20 degrees or more, we recommend ankle arthrodesis as the procedure of choice.
We report gender differences in the epidemiology and outcome after hip fracture from the Scottish Hip Fracture Audit, with data on admission and at 120 days follow-up from 22 orthopaedic units across the country between 1998 and 2005. Outcome measures included early mortality, length of hospital stay, 120-day residence and mobility. A multivariate logistic regression model compared outcomes between genders. The study comprised 25 649 patients of whom 5674 (22%) were men and 19 975 (78%) were women. The men were in poorer pre-operative health, despite being younger at presentation (mean 77 years (60 to 101) Multivariate analysis indicated that the men were less likely to return to their home or mobilise independently at the 120-day follow-up. Mortality at 30 and 120 days was higher for men, even after differences in case-mix variables between genders were considered.
We prospectively studied 29 patients with distal femoral fractures stabilised using the less invasive stabilisation system [LISS]. Four patients were excluded from the final follow up [3 deaths and 1 case of quadriplegia]. The mean age of the remaining 25 patients [9 males] was 60.9 years and the mean follow up 18 months [12–24]. Eleven patients were tertiary referrals from other hospitals [7 cases were referred due to failure of primary fixation]. Overall, there were 12 cases of high-energy trauma [7 open fractures]. According to the AO classification there were 5 Type 33A, 2 Type 33B and 12 Type 33C fractures and 4 Type 32A, 1 Type 32B, 1 Type 32C fractures. Functional assessment was performed using the Modified HSS and the Schatzker and Lambert scores. The average time to union in 22 cases was 3.5 months [range, 2–5]. None of the acute cases required bone grafting with a 100% union rate. There were 3/7 cases of non-union in the salvage group still undergoing treatment. The overall results in the acute cases were good and in the salvage cases fair. While this is a small series of patients, our preliminary data indicate favourable results using the LISS in stabilizing acute distal femoral fractures. However, when the LISS is used as a revision tool despite the concept of preserving the bone biology, the results seem to be less satisfactory. The system appears to be user friendly and no technical difficulties were encountered.
The application and interpretation of the impact factor of a journal is fraught with problems, some of which are explored in this editorial.
A consecutive series of 23 patients (25 ankles) with osteoarthritis of the ankle and severe varus or valgus deformity were treated by open arthrodesis using compression screws. Primary union was achieved in 24 ankles one required further surgery to obtain a solid fusion. The high level of satisfaction in this group of patients reinforces the view that open arthrodesis, as opposed to ankle replacement or arthroscopic arthrodesis, continues to be the treatment of choice when there is severe varus or valgus deformity associated with the arthritis.