We compared function in two groups of high demand patients who had undergone total knee arthroplasty (TKA), one group using a posterior cruciate sacrificing (PCS) prosthesis and the other a posterior cruciate retaining (PCR) prosthesis of similar design. Patients were eligible for the study if surgery had been performed more than two years ago and they were under 65 years of age and had no coexisting morbidity that markedly decreased their physical activities. One surgeon operated on 28 patients in group A (20 TKAs), routinely retaining the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL). A second surgery operated on 19 patients in group B (25 TKAs) and routinely sacrificed the PCL. A mobile bearing prosthesis of similar design was used in each group. Patients were independently selected and assessed using a questionnaire specifically developed to assess higher levels of activity not usually assessed by other knee scores. Patients in the two groups were matched in terms of age, range of motion and follow-up The gross activity score was 3.36 in group A and 3.12 in group B. The combined walking, running and stair-climbing score was in group A (7.68) than in group B (6.64). Patients in group B had decreased anterior knee pain and perceived their TKA closer to a normal knee (2.00 compared to 2.32). We conclude that retaining the PCL in TKA results in better patient function without obvious complications.
In 66 patients with back pain and suspected spondylolysis, the results of bone scintigraphy have been correlated with operative findings and clinical follow-up. Although bone scintigraphy is of little value for primary diagnosis, it helps to distinguish between those patients with established non-union of the defect, and those in whom healing is still progressing and who may benefit from immobilisation. We also found that increased uptake on the contralateral side to a unilateral spondylolysis is suggestive of impending fracture.
A method of stabilising spondylolisthesis using Dwyer instrumentation is described and the results in seven patients are presented. The operation is straightforward, has few complications and also succeeds in reducing the angle of slip.
A radiographic suvey has been carried out of 147 first-degree relatives of forty-seven patients treated in Edinburgh for spondylolisthesis of the fifth lumbar vertebra; twelve patients had the dysplastic (congenital) type and thirty-five an isthmic defect. The survey identified 19 per cent of relatives with spondylolysis, and index patients with each type of spondylolisthesis had relatives with the opposite type. Index patients with the dysplastic form had a higher proportion of affected relatives (33 per cent) than had those with the isthmic type (15 per cent), but both figures were significantly in excess of the estimated frequency for the general population of under 1 per cent and 5 per cent respectively. Spina bifida occulta at the fifth lumbar or first sacral level or both, and lumbosacral segmental defects were commoner amongst all individuals with spondylolysis than amongst unaffected relatives (dysplastic form 94 per cent, isthmic type 32 per cent, unaffected relatives 7 per cent). However, there was no single instance of a neural tube defect (anencephaly, spina bifida with or without meningocele, other generalised vertebral anomalies or spinal dysraphism) amongst 826 first-, second- or third-degree relatives. It is concluded that the developmental defects of the vertebrae associated with spondylolysis are not aetiologically related to the neural tube defects. The one in three risk of spondylolysis to near relatives of patients with the dysplastic form of spondylolisthesis is emphasised in order that the deformity in their sibs and children can be recognised at any early age.
Twelve closely related members of one family were found to have small or absent patellae. Seven of these patients also had abnormalities of the pelvic girdle and upper femora. There was a resemblance to the nail--patella syndrome in the patellar abnormalities but not in the associated conditions, and it would therefore appear that the syndrome described is a new variety of congenital abnormality of the knee.