It has been suggested that transient osteoporosis or the bone marrow oedema syndrome (BMOS) may be the initial phase of osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ONFH) and that there may be a common pathophysiology. In this study, we have assessed the MR images of 200 consecutive patients with ONFH in respect of the BMO pattern in order to test this hypothesis.

This pattern was not observed in the early stage of ONFH. The initial abnormal finding detected on the MR images was an abnormal band of intensity at the junction between the necrotic area and the normal bone. Structural damage of the head seems to result in the appearance of the BMO pattern and the development of pain in ONFH. There was no finding to support the existence of a continuum between BMOS and ONFH.

The extent of necrosis is the main determining factor in the outcome of osteonecrosis of the femoral head and is best measured by MRI.

Using statistical analyses, we have evaluated the accuracy and repeatability of seven different methods of measuring the extent of necrosis, of which three demonstrate good or acceptable accuracy. For the general observer their repeatability is poor; only for experienced observers were they reasonable. We conclude that within an institution or for personal use, the accuracy of some methods is acceptable, and repeatability reasonable. None is appropriate for international use.