Introduction: We have devised a new technique of lesser tuberosity osteotomy with double row fixation of the subscapularis using suture anchors.

Aim: To evaluate the biomechanical properties of this novel technique against two established methods of subscapularis repair including tendon to tendon and transosseous repairs.

Method: Matched pairs of human cadaveric shoulders were allocated into 3 groups. Group 1 consisted of the double row technique with incision of the subscapularis along the bicipital groove with a lesser tuberosity osteotomy. A double loaded suture anchor was placed along the medial border of the osteotomy site and sutures were passed through subscapularis medial to the bone island in a horizontal mattress manner. A second anchor was inserted along the lateral border of the osteotomy site and the two sutures were tied onto the subscapularis holding sutures. In group 2, the subscapularis was divided 1cm medial to the bicipital groove and repaired with tendon to tendon suturing. In group 3, the subscapularis was repaired to the cut humeral neck through transosseous tunnels. The cyclic elongation, load to failure, displacement and mode of failure were analysed.

Results: All specimens in Group 1 and 40% of Group 2 and 3 passed the cyclic loading test. The ultimate tensile strength in Group 1 was found to be 2.8 times that of Group 2 and 2.4 times that of Group 3 (p< 0.05). Simple suturing failed by suture cutting out of soft tissue and tranosseous repair failed by a combination of the suture cutting out through bone and soft tissue.

Conclusion: This novel technique is simple to perform and biomechanically stronger than established methods of repair. A stronger fixation may allow early mobilization without the risk of tendon rupture and is much less likely to loosen with gap formation and subsequent fibrous tissue interposition. Additional advantages include bone to bone healing without violation of the subscapularis tendon.

Introduction: We have described nine clinical features to aid the clinical diagnosis of frozen shoulder. These include symptoms of pain and pins and needles radiating down the arm to the hand, feeling of lameness in the arm, tenderness over medial border of scapula, tenderness over the rotator interval, tenderness over the brachial plexus in the supraclavicular fossa, reduction of pain with passive abduction and forward flexion of the shoulder, asymmetry of the arm position at rest with an increase in elbow to waist distance and apparent winging of the scapula.

Methods: We prospectively evaluate the sensitivity, specificity, predictive values and diagnostic accuracy of each clinical test in a consecutive series of 110 patients with idiopathic frozen shoulder. An equal number of patients with shoulder pathology other than frozen shoulder were used as controls matched to the study group for sex and age. We also discuss the probable causes and clinical relevance of these features.

Results The most sensitive test was pain over the brachial p:lexus in the supraclavicular fossa (0.98) and the most specific test was apparent winging of the scapula (0.84). The single most accurate diagnostic test was relief of symptoms with abduction and flexion (85%). The incidence of positive accessory features was positively correlated with the visual analogue pain score (p< 0.0001, Spearman rank correlation coefficient) and negatively correlated with the length of duration of symptoms (p< 0.0001, Spearman rank correlation coefficient).

Conclusion: These accessory tests are intended to supplement the original description made by Codman. They are most useful in the acute painful stage of the disease when symptoms have been present for less than 6 months. In the diagnosis of a patient with a painful stiff shoulder, if six of the tests with the highest correlation are positive, the diagnosis of frozen shoulder is likely.

Introduction: A secure repair of the subscapularis represents an integral part of any surgery involving the anterior approach to the shoulder. Dysfunction of the subscapularis leads not only to poor functional results but also to anterior joint instability which is potentially untreatable. We have devised a new technique of double row fixation of the subscapularis using two suture anchors.

Aim: To evaluate the biomechanical strength of this double row technique against the established methods of simple suturing and transosseous repair techniques.

Method: Twenty matched pairs of human cadaveric shoulders were allocated into 3 groups. Group 1 consisted of 10 shoulders repaired with the double row technique. This involved incising the subscapularis along the bicipital groove and a lesser tuberosity osteotomy carried out leaving the subscapularis attached to a thin island of bone. A suture anchor (Twinfix) was then inserted just medial to the osteotomy site and the tendon repaired to bone using two horizontal mattress sutures. A second anchor was inserted laterally to supplement the repair with two simple suture knots. The remaining 10 contralateral shoulders were allocated equally between groups 2 and 3. In group 2, the subscapularis was divided longitudinally 1cm medial to the bicipital groove and repaired with simple interrupted suture knots. In group 3, the subscapularis was incised at its insertion to lesser tuberosity and the tendon repaired to the osteotomy site by multiple transosseous sutures through drill holes in the anterior humeral cortex.

The suture material used in all three groups was identical and consisted of an ultra high molecular weight poly-ethylene suture (Ultrabraid). To simulate the direction of pull of the subscapularis, the testing block was tilted 45 degrees while a vertically applied distraction force was applied. A custom made jig was used to measure the amount of displacement in response to a gradually applied load. All specimens were tested to failure. The mode of failure of each fixational construct was recorded.

Results: The load to failure was found to be significantly higher in the double row repair technique compared to simple suturing and transosseous methods. Simple suturing failed by suture cutting out of soft tissue and tranosseous repair failed by a combination of the suture cutting out through bone and soft tissue.

Conclusion: This new double row technique is simple to perform and preliminary biomechanical testing has shown this to be superior in terms of fixational strength compared to established methods. Additional advantages of this technique which have not been taken into account in this in vitro study include non violation of the subscapularis tendon with bone to bone healing.

The management of bony lesions associated with glenohumeral instability has been open to debate. Invariably a significant period of time elapses between injury and surgery during which the bony fragment may atrophy and reduce both in size and in quality. Histomorphometric bone analyses were prospectively performed on the glenoid bone fragments harvested during the modified Latarjet operation. The main purpose of the study was to assess the viability of the bone. Biopsies were obtained from 21 patients that had given informed consent. Median age was 21 years (range 16–50). All were male patients. The most important sports identified were rugby (64%) and water sports (surfing, water polo, water skiing, surfing (21%)). Mean glenoid bone loss on CT scan was 17% (range 10–50%). Thirty-three percent had bone loss greater than 20%. Gross morphology of glenolabral fragments identified a single large fragment (11/21); dominant large fragment plus smaller fragments (7/21); multiple fragments (4/21). Single large fragments comprised 52% of the study. Mean volume and mass of bony fragments were 2.18 ml (range 1–3 ml) and 1.64 gms (range 0.43–2.8 g), respectively. Histology of the specimens revealed no bone in three of the 21 specimens. Bony necrosis was present in 8/18 (44%) of the specimens. From a histopathological point of view, reattachment of these devitalized bone fragments by screws or anchors may result in predictable operative failure and recurrent instability. We can therefore not support the practice of “repair” of bony Bankart lesions based on the above findings.

Treatment of OA of the shoulder in young and active patients remains a problem. Present treatment options are debridement, microfracturing, arthrodesis or shoulder replacement. We report the preliminary results of soft-tissue interposition arthroplasty with an acellular allograft skin-derived collagen matrix (Graft Jacket®, Wright Medical).

Between July and December 2003 five men and one woman with severe glenohumeral OA had a soft-tissue interposition arthroplasty of the shoulder. The mean age of the patients was 47 years (34 to 58). In four patients the procedure was done arthroscopically. The Graft Jacket® was sutured to the labrum with a minimum of five sutures. The mean postoperative follow-up was 6.2 months.

Four patients experienced notable pain relief after the operation. Preoperatively the mean visual analogue pain score was 7.2 and postoperatively it was 2.6. One patient had no improvement and elected to wait before having further treatment. One patient needed a hemi-arthroplasty. The range of motion improved in only one patient. The mean Constant score improved 14 points, from 45 to 59. There were no complications peroperatively or postoperatively.

While the long-term results are still unknown, soft-tissue interposition arthroplasty with the Graft Jacket® shows promising results.

External rotation of the shoulder is commonly measured in two ways, with the arm adducted or with the arm abducted to 90°. The measurement forms an important part of the assessment of shoulder function, but has been shown to be unreliable. Following the observation that, with the arm adducted, the range of external rotation alters according to the exact position of the arm in the sagittal plane, we conducted a study to quantify the effect on the range of external rotation of a small increment in forward flexion (15°).

With the arm first in a vertical position and then in 15° of forward flexion, external rotation was measured in 40 asymptomatic and 20 ‘frozen’ shoulders. With forward flexion, the range of external rotation decreased by a mean of 16.9° in the asymptomatic and 13.5° in the ‘frozen’ shoulders.

We postulate that some of the variation is a function of scapular positioning. With arm flexion, the scapula protracts, resulting in alteration in glenoid version. However, some difference is due also to alteration in soft tissue tension in the two arm positions.

The sagittal position of the arm affects the range of external rotation of the adducted shoulder. This variation in measurement may affect the scores of certain outcome measures.

Little has been written about the results of isolated acromioclavicular joint (ACJ) resection using the superior approach. We report the results of our large series.

Between June 1994 and October 2003, a single surgeon performed 155 isolated ACJ resections, using the direct superior approach. Exclusion criteria were previous ipsilateral shoulder surgery, simultaneous arthroscopic procedures and OA. We asked 90 of the patients (94 shoulders) to complete the Simple Shoulder Test questionnaire by telephone. The median age of the 72 males and 18 females was 38 years (16 to 62). The dominant shoulder was involved in 54 patients. There was a history of trauma in 44 patients, with 11 rugby injuries. The median follow-up period was 29 months (6 to 118).

One portal infection resolved with debridement and antibiotics. Five revision procedures were done, four open revision Mumfords and one subacromial decompression. The mean postoperative Simple Shoulder score was 11.5 (6 to 12). Patients rated outcome as excellent in 63 shoulders, good in 22, moderate in five and poor in four.

The technique provides consistently good or excellent results (90%) and allows rapid return to normal function. There was complete resolution of pain in 73 of the 94 shoulders. All rugby players returned to the same level of play.

The shape of the glenoid can vary between pear and oval, depending on the presence of a glenoid notch. We measured the glenoid notch angle (the angle between the superior and inferior part of the anterior glenoid rim) in 53 embalmed cadavers and investigated its relationship with the labral attachment to the glenoid at that point.

The attachment of the anterosuperior labrum at the site of the glenoid notch was classified as tight or loose or, in some cases, there was a sublabral foramen. The anterior labrum was then removed and digital images perpendicular to the glenoid notch were taken. Using a digital image analysis program, the angle of the glenoid notch was measured.

In 37 shoulders (70%) the attachment of the labrum at the site of the glenoid notch was assessed as tight and in eight (15%) as loose. In eight shoulders (15%) a sublabral foramen was found. The mean glenoid notch angle was 153° in the loosely attached group, 159° in the sublabral foramen group and 168° in the group with a tight attachment. The presence of a glenoid notch was noted only when the glenoid notch angle was less than 170°.

The glenoid notch angle is related to the attachment of the labrum. In the presence of a glenoid notch, there is more likely to be a loosely attached labrum or sublabral foramen. The loose attachment of the anterosuperior labrum may be a predisposing factor in traumatic anterior instability.

The management of bony lesions associated with glenohumeral instability is the subject of debate. Invariably some time elapses between injury and surgery, during which atrophy may reduce both size and quality of the bone.

The main purpose of our study was to assess the viability of the bone. Histomorphometric bone analyses were prospectively performed on glenoid fragments harvested from 21 male patients during modified Latarjet operations. Their median age was 21 years (16 to 50). Rugby was the main sport of 64% and water sports (surfing, water polo, water skiing) of 21%.

The mean glenoid bone loss on CT scan was 17% (10% to 50%). In 33% of patients, bone loss exceeded 20%. Gross morphology of glenolabral fragments identified a single large fragment in 11 patients, a dominant large fragment with smaller fragments in seven, and multiple fragments in the remaining patients. The mean volume of bony fragments was 2.18 ml (1 to 3) and the mean mass was 1.64 gm (0.43 to 2.8). Histological examination revealed that there was no bone in three of the 21 specimens. Bony necrosis was present in eight of the 18 specimens that contained bone (44%).

Given the histopathological findings, attempts to reattach these devitalised bone fragments by screws or anchors may fail and lead to recurrent instability.

Calcific tendinitis of the shoulder is a common cause of shoulder pain and is usually treated conservatively initially. We evaluated the ultrasound-guided needling procedure for calcium deposits in the rotator cuff.

Between 2002 and 2003 eight men and 18 women (mean age 49 years) with calcific tendinitis of the shoulder were treated this way. The mean duration of symptoms was 29 months. Before the procedure, the skin and subacromial bursa were infiltrated with local anaesthetic. The calcium deposit was perforated and aspirated when possible. With saline, a lavage was done to wash out the calcium.

Eleven patients (42.3%) had marked improvement in pain and needed no further treatment. Four patients required a reneedling procedure, and four patients needed repeated subacromial injections during the absorption phase of the calcium. In six patients arthroscopic calcium removal was needed. The mean visual analogue pain score during the procedure was 2.63. There were no complications.

The ultrasound-guided needling procedure is an effective and well-tolerated method of treatment of calcific tendinitis of the shoulder and in 77% of our cases there was no need for surgical removal. Where there is incomplete dissolution, the procedure can be repeated.

The research question was: can ex-vivo chondrocyte cultures be established in shoulder cartilage biopsies?

Arthroscopic or open biopsies were obtained, with informed consent and institution-approved review protocol, from patients undergoing total shoulder replacement or orthopaedic interventions for end-stage rotator cuff deficiency or arthropathy. Chondrocytes were isolated from eight biopsies and cells cultured over 4-weeks.

In the first week post-digestion, validation studies showed cell counts varying from 30 000 to 400 000 (mean 126 666) and viability ranging from 30% to 100% (mean 75.2%). No primary culture failures were observed. One of the eight had an unexplained lower cell count and viability. Viability exceeded 80% in six of the eight cultures (75%). Alcian Blue stains and flow cytometry (Facscan) confirmed stable cultures with matrix formation. Aggrecan studies are in progress.

The fact that ex-vivo chondrocyte cultures can be established in biopsied shoulder cartilage may prove encouraging for autologous chondrocyte transplant in selected patients meeting stringent inclusion criteria.

With widely reported co-existence of impingement syndrome and acromioclavicular joint (ACJ) disease, some surgeons recommend that ACJ resection be combined with subacromial decompression.

From 1998 to 2003, 201 patients with symptomatic ACJs were taken to theatre. Bursoscopy was performed on 129 males and 54 females, those patients who had previously undergone ipsilateral shoulder surgery or had sonographically-proven rotator cuff tears being excluded. The mean age was 41 years (16 to 72). The preoperative diagnosis was isolated ACJ disease in 136 patients and combined ACJ disease and impingement in 47. Bursoscopy revealed no abnormalities in 124 of the 136 patients in whom isolated ACJ disease was diagnosed. In two patients, minimal bursal fraying was noted but no decompression was performed. Significant ‘impingement lesions’ were seen in 10 patients, all of whom were over age 35 years.

Symptomatic ACJ disease coexisted with impingement (lesion or signs) in only 57 of 183 patients (31%) patients. With careful preoperative evaluation, unnecessary surgery is avoidable.

The capsular shift procedure is done to treat instability due to ligamentous laxity. Usually there is no traumatic avulsion of the labroligamentous tissues.

In surgical repair the anterior labrum is separated from the glenoid. The labrum and attached ligaments are shifted superiorly and attached with bone anchors to the decorticated glenoid. The labrum and ligaments are rolled into a soft tissue ‘bumper’ (we refer to this as labroplasty). Arthroscopic rotator interval plication is added to the procedure.

For six months to six years we followed up 67 patients treated between 1994 and 2000. There were two cases of recurrent subluxation (3%). Patient satisfaction was high.

The acromion is a bony process that juts out from the lateral end of the scapular spine. It is continuous with the blade and the spinous process. The process is rectangular, and carries a facet for the clavicle. Inferiorly is sited the subacromial bursa. Inferior encroachment or displacement of the acromion can result in impingement.

The aim of this osteological study was to assess the presence of acromial displacement and variations predisposing to compaction of the subacromial space. Using the method described by Morrison and Bigliana, we assessed the scapulae of 128 men and women ranging from 35 to 92 years of age. We found a flat acromion in 30%, no hook in 48%, a small hook in 18% and a large hook in 4%. The presence of a hook was associated with a subacromial facet and a large hook with glenoid erosion.

This study confirms the presence of four types of acromion.

We discuss aspects of glenohumeral instability and rotator cuff tears in a clinically orientated approach, presenting a new way of quantifying structural bone loss from the anterior glenoid and defining the Glenoid Index as an indicator of the appropriate surgical approach to address anterior instability.

Repair of the rotator cuff depends on viable and functional muscular tissue. We discuss the potential for repair of the supraspinatus tendon in relation to the tangent sign, fat infiltration and retraction. Comparing MRI and arthroscopic findings, we highlight pitfalls in the diagnosis and repair of the subscapularis tendon.

Painful conditions of the acromioclavicular (AC) joint are common in South Africa, particularly among sportsmen. These conditions are often treated by open excision of the distal end of the clavicle, but an arthroscopic procedure offers many advantages.

From February 1994 to February 2000, we performed 138 procedures. The mean age of patients ({71% men and 29% women) was 29 years (19 to 53). In cases of rotator cuff impingement, arthroscopic acromioplasty was followed by clavicular excision via the subacromial route. With a normal acromion and rotator cuff the AC joint was approached through two superior AC portals, avoiding removal of the AC ligaments. In all cases a standard 3.5-mm arthroscope was placed in one portal for viewing and the mechanical shaver inserted through the other. About 7 mm to 8mm of bone was removed from the clavicle. Patients were in hospital for about a day and 87% were discharged the same day.

The mean follow-up time was 34 months (2 months to 4 years). Patient satisfaction was high in 32%, fair in 60% and poor in 8%. Most patients (92%) returned to all previous sports and activities.

We concluded that the arthroscopic Mumford procedure is at least as successful as its open equivalent. It can be done as an outpatient procedure and permits a rapid return to activities. Cosmesis is excellent and stability of the AC joint is preserved.

The rotator cuff is sited on the anatomical neck of the humerus and is formed by the insertion of the supraspinatus (SP), infraspinatus (IS), teres minor (TM) and subscapularis. All play a vital role in the movement of the glenohumeral joint, and the anatomy is of critical importance in arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. We undertook an osteological and gross anatomical dissection study of the insertion mechanism of these tendons, in particular the SP .

The SP inserts by a triple or quadruple mechanism. The ‘heel’ (medial) and capsule fuse, inserting into the anatomical neck proximal to the anterior facet of the greater humeral tubercle. The ‘foot arch’ inserts as a strong, flat, fibrous tendon into the facet. This area is cuboidal, rectangular, or ellipsoid, and measures 36 mm² to 64 mm². In about 5%, the insertion is fleshy (pitted), rendering it weaker than a tendinous attachment. The ‘toe’ lips over the edge of the facet laterally and fuses with the periosteum, fibres of the inter-transverse ligament and the IS. A proximal ‘hood’ of about 4 mm stretches down inferiorly and fuses with the periosteum of the humeral shaft. The subacromial or subdeltoid synovial bursa are sited laterally.

The IS and TM insert into the middle and posterior facets (225 mm and 36 mm²) at respective angles of 80° and 115°. The inferior portion of the TM facet is not fused with the shoulder capsule. The subscapularis inserts broadly into the lesser tubercle, and the superior fibres fuse with the shoulder capsule and intertransverse ligament. The insertion of the subscapularis does not contribute directly to the formation of the ‘hood’, which belongs exclusively to the SP, IP and TM.

This study confirms the complexity of the SP insertion and suggests that an unfavourable attachment or biomechanical anatomical malalignment may lead to eventual tendon/cuff degeneration.

The supraspinatus tendon (SP) often ruptures. Gray established that the tendinous insertion always attaches to the highest facet of the greater tubercle of the humerus. Our osteological study of 124 shoulders in men and women between the ages of 35 and 94 years refocuses on the humeral insertion of the SP in relation to infraspinatus (IS) and teres minor (TM).

We found type-I SFs (cubic) in 53 shoulders (43%) and type-II SFs (rectangular or oblong) in 21 (17%). Type-III (ellipsoid) SFs were present in 20 shoulders (16%) and type-IV (angulated or sloping) in 11 (9%). SFs were type V (with tuberosity) in 12 shoulders (10%) and type VI (pitted) in three (2%). The facet area of the SP, IP and TM varied from 49 mm, 225 mm and 36mm2. Of the three muscles, the IS facet was consistently the largest (p < 0.05) and shaped rectangularly.

The SP inserted in a cubic or rectangular facet format in 75% of people. SP facet-size may relate to tendon strength, degeneration and rupture. This information may contribute to the understanding of tears of the rotator cuff.