Introduction: In general a loose-balanced total knee arthroplasty (TKA) are believed to gain good postoperative range of motion (ROM), however, too much laxity is thought to be a cause for persistent pain and catastrophic long-term results.
Materials and methods: We measured the antero-posterior and medio-lateral laxity to evaluate the influence of stability after cruciate-retaining TKA on ROM, pain score in Knee Society score and Functional score at 4–7 years after the operation. Twenty-one knees in 15 patients with an average age of 68 years (range, 58–78) who had a PCL retaining TKA for osteoarthrosis were examined (YS-4, 16 knees; AGC-S, 5 knees). There were 12 women and 3 men. Anteroposterior laxity was examined using a KT 2000 arthrometer at 30-degree knee flexion. Mediolateral laxity was examined at full extension with manual stress x-rays.
Results: Average ROM was 112 degrees (range, 90–140 degrees), antero-posterior laxity was 9.7 mm (range, 2–27 mm) and mediolateral laxity was 10.6 degrees (range, 5–22 degrees). Knee Society pain score was 47 (range, 10–50) and Functional score was 82 (range, 40–100). No significant difference in ROM and clinical scores were noted between the lax and the stable knees. Correlations between ROM and anteroposterior or medio-lateral laxity were not significant (P = 0.55, P = 0.05, respectively; Spearman’s correlation efficient).
Discussion and conclusion: A loose-balanced TKA did not gain good post-operative ROM. No parameters suggested that lax knees got better flexion angle, worse pain score and functional score than stable knees.
