Summary Statement

Using abdominal CT scans to evaluate bone mineral density following acute fractures of the thoracic and lumbar spine demonstrates significant levels of osteoporosis in older patients; this approach may help save on time and resources, and reduce unnecessary radiation exposure.

Summary Statement

It is now possible to diagnose osteoporosis using incidental abdominal CT scans; applying this approach to fractures of the cervical spine demonstrates levels of osteoporosis in patients over 65.

Purpose: Femoral neck fracture collapse and shortening has been a desired effect of parallel screw fixation to promote healing. While some degree of compression might be beneficial, it remains unknown whether the effects of uncontrolled femoral neck shortening leads to detectable functional impairment. We aimed to evaluate the effect of shortening and varus collapse after cancellous screw fixation of femoral neck fractures on patient functional status and quality of life.

Method: The databases of four University Hospitals were screened to identify patients with a healed isolated femoral neck fracture. Patients were contacted by telephone to complete Short-form 36(SF36) and Euroquol-5D(EQ5D) questionnaires (Primary outcome: SF36 physical functioning score[PF]). Femoral neck shortening and varus collapse were assessed by three independent reviewers blinded to functional outcome results based on the latest follow-up radiographs and categorized into three grades: None/Mild (within 5mm/5°), Moderate (5–10mm/5–10°), and Severe (> 10mm/> 10°). The minimal clinically important difference for SF36 PF score equals 12 points (1/2 of Standard deviation).

Results: Out of 660 patients screened at all four sites 70 met the inclusion criteria and were available for follow-up. The average follow-up was 20 months and an the average age was 71 years. Overall, there were 24/70 patients with none/mild femoral neck shortening, 25/70 with moderate shortening and 21/70 with severe shortening. Patients with severe shortening of their hip had significantly lower SF36 physical functioning scores (No/Mild vs. Severe shortening: 74 vs. 42 points, p=0.01). Similar important effects occurred with moderate shortening suggesting a gradient effect (No/Mild vs. Moderate shortening: 74 vs. 53 points). Some degree of varus collapse occurred in 39% of the patients and correlated moderately with the occurrence of shortening (r=0.66, p< 0.001).

Conclusion: A large proportion of displaced and undisplaced femoral neck fractures fixed with cancellous screws heal in a shortened position (66%) and varus (39%). The differences in function we observed represent patient important declines and suggest that uncontrolled sliding with cancellous screw fixation has limitations.