To discover whether orthopaedic surgeons follow the BOA guidelines for secondary prevention of fragility fractures, a retrospective audit on neck of femur fractures treated in our hospital in October/November 2003 was carried out. There were 27 patients. Twenty-six patients (96%) had full blood count measured. LFT and bone-profile were measured in 18 patients (66%). Only nine patients (30%) had treatment for osteoporosis (calcium and vitamin D). Only one patient was referred for DEXA scan. Steps were taken to create better awareness of the BOA guidelines among junior doctors and nurse practitioners. In patients above 80 years of age it was decided to use abbreviated mental score above 7 as a clinical criterion for DEXA referral. A hospital protocol based on BOA guidelines was made. A re-audit was conducted during the period August-October 2004, with 37 patients. All of them had their full blood count and renal profile checked (100%). The bone-profile was measured in 28 (75.7%) and LFT in 34 (91.9%) patients. Twenty-four patients (65%) received treatment in the form of calcium + Vit D (20) and bisphosphonate (4). DEXA scan referral was not indicated in 14 patients as 4 of them were already on bisphosphonates and 10 patients had an abbreviated mental score of less than 7. Among the remaining 23 patients, nine (40%) were referred for DEXA scan. This improvement is statistically significant (p=0.03, chi square test). The re-audit shows that, although there is an improvement in the situation, we are still below the standards of secondary prevention of fragility fractures with 60% of femoral fragility fracture patients not being referred for DEXA scan. A pathway lead by a fracture liaison nurse dedicated to osteoporotic fracture patients should improve the situation.
We analysed the outcome of the Coonrad-Morrey total elbow replacement used for fracture of the distal humerus in elderly patients with no evidence of inflammatory arthritis and compared the results for early versus delayed treatment. We studied a total of 32 patients with 15 in the early treatment group and 17 in the delayed treatment group. The mean follow-up was 56.1 months (18 to 88). The percentage of excellent to good results based on the Mayo elbow performance score was not significantly different, 84% in the early group and 79% in the delayed group. Subjective satisfaction was 92% in both the groups. One patient in the early group developed chronic regional pain syndrome and another type 4 aseptic loosening. Two elbows in the early group also showed type 1 radiological loosening. Two patients in the delayed group had an infection, two an ulnar nerve palsy, one developed heterotopic ossification and one type 4 aseptic loosening. Two elbows in this group also showed type 1 radiological loosening. The complication rates in the early and delayed treatment group were 13% and 29% respectively. The Kaplan-Meier survivorship analysis for the early and delayed treatment groups was 93% at 88 months and 76% at 84 months, respectively. No statistically significant difference was found between the two groups. We conclude that total elbow replacement provides a preditable and reproducible outcome in terms of pain relief and functional range of movement in elderly osteoporotic patients with difficult distal humerus fractures.
At the latest follow-up, none of the patients had recurrence of the infection nor did they need any further surgical procedure. There was no radiographic evidence of loosening of the prosthesis. The OKS had improved from a mean of 17 pre-operative to 41 at the latest follow-up. All the patients were extremely satisfied with the outcome.
We looked at the re-displacement rate amongst these children that required a second procedure. We also sought predictive factors for redisplacement if any.
Redisplacement of fracture after initial satisfactory reduction was seen in 9 cases (12.7%) &
required a second procedure. The secondary procedure involved closed reduction and percutaneous K wire fixation in 4 patients and open reduction in 2 cases. 3 cases had closed remanipulation &
change of plaster. We reviewed the factors responsible for re-displacement after a closed reduction such as initial displacement, angulation, adequacy of initial reduction, associated ulna fracture, type of plaster, and initial post-operative images. Average age has been 12.7 years. 3 out of 5 (60 %) completely displaced fractures treated by closed reduction and manipulation required a second procedure. Only 1 in 16 cases of incompletely displaced fracture required a second procedure. Volar angulated fractures tend to redisplace after closed reduction, 3 out of 7cases (42 %) required a second procedure. Associated ulna fracture (22.7%) increased the risks of redisplacement. 5 out of 24 epiphyseal injuries redisplaced but these were either severely displacement or had volar angulation. 3 out of 4 cases (75 %)that were severely displaced had inadequate primary closed reduction &
underwent a second procedure.
In management of paediatric distal radius fractures, primary reduction with percutaneous Kirschner wire has better outcome and lower incidence of redisplacement in selected cases with features of complete displacement and volar angulation especially in the older age group (>
11 years).