The purpose of the present investigation was to evaluate muscle damage one year after anterior minimally invasive THA by MRI and to compare these findings with MRI investigations performed in asymptomatic patients one year after THA using a conventional direct lateral approach. Institutional review board approved this study and patients gave signed informed consent. The minimally invasive group consisted of a consecutive series of 25 patients 1 year after anterior minimally invasive THA. The historic control group consisted of a consecutive series of 25 asymptomatic patients (no pain, no limb, full abduction strength) 1 year after conventional THA. Excluded were patients having prior hip surgery or suffering lumbar spine pathology. Tendon defects and degenerations within the insertion of the Gluteus medius and minimus muscles as well as fatty atrophy within these muscles were recorded according to the protocol of Pfirrmann et al. A Mann-Whitney U Test, two sided t-test and Chi-square test were used for appropriate comparison of quantitative and qualitative variables, respectively. In terms of gender, age, BMI and side no significant differences were shown between the two groups. When compared to the conventional group, tendon defects, diameter changes and signal alterations of the Gluteus medius and minimus insertion were significantly less frequent in the minimally invasive group (p= 0.001–0.03). Fatty atrophy within the gluteus minimus and gluteus medius musculature was significantly less in the minimally-invasive group (p=0.001–0.04). In terms of structural damage to muscles and tendons of the hip abductors, the anterior minimally invasive approach proves to be less invasive than the direct lateral approach.
After THR, trochanteric soft tissue abnormalities may be associated with residual trochanteric pain and limping. However, normal MR appearance of the trochanteric region after THR is not known. The aim was to evaluate MR imagings in asymptomatic and symptomatic patients after THR through a transgluteal approach. Triplanar MR images of 25 asymptomatic (14 men, mean age 60.4 years, 11 women, mean age 60.2) and 49 symptomatic patients (19 men, mean age 62.7 years, 20 women, mean age 64.3) at least 1 year after THR were analyzed by two blinded radiologists. In 14 symptomatic patients MR imaging was correlated to surgical findings. Tendon defects were uncommon in asymptomatic and significantly more frequent in symptomatic patients (gluteus minimus 8% vs. 56%, p<
0.001; lateral gluteus medius 16% vs 62%, p<
0.001; posterior gluteus medius 0% vs18%, p<
0.025). Signal changes within tendons were very frequent in both groups except for the posterior gluteus medius tendon which demonstrated this finding more frequently in symptomatic patients (20% vs 59%, p=0.002). Changes in tendon diameter were very frequent in both groups but significantly (p=0.001–009) more frequent in symptomatic patients. Fatty atrophy was evident in the anterior two thirds of the gluteus minimus muscle in both asymptomatic and symptomatic patients. In the posterior superior third of the gluteus minimus muscle differences of fatty degeneration were significant. Fatty atrophy of the gluteus medius muscle was only present in symptomatic patients. Bursal fluid collections were more frequent in asymptomatic (32% vs 62%, p=0.021). MR diagnosis was confirmed in all 14 patients undergoing revision surgery. Although more frequent in symptomatic patients many MR findings are frequently found in asymptomatic patients. However, defects of the abductor tendons and fatty atrophy of the gluteus medius and the posterior part of the gluteus minimus muscle are rare in asymptomatic patients.