Calcium phosphate cements (CPC) are used as biocompatible and bioactive bone void fillers. Ideally, the mechanical properties of these cements should match those of the surrounding bone. The knowledge of the real mechanical properties of the material is important in the decision-making process regarding possible use of the CPCs in different anatomical sites. Although it is generally recognized that these cements are stiffer and more brittle than desired, there is a limited amount of data about the possible deformation of this class of material before failure. The focus of this study was to determine these properties of injectable CPCs. Two different types of self-setting CPCs were investigated in this study: i) hydroxyapatite (HA), that historically has been the most widely studied CPC; ii) brushite, that recently has attracted attention due to its faster resorption than that of HA in vivo. Specimens of both cement types were prepared by mixing a powder phase with a liquid phase that were left to harden in phosphate buffered saline at 37°C. Once set, the specimens underwent a quasi-static compressive test to determine the compressive strength, the elastic modulus and the maximum deformation of the two materials. The material testing machine was equipped with a digital image correlation system, which allows accurate measurement of material deformation directly on the specimen surface. Brushite was found to be significantly more stiff (+80%) and resistant (+84%) than HA. Similar findings were found for the energy needed to create a first crack on the specimen surface. However, the first crack appeared on the specimen surface at the same low deformation level (∼0.15%) independently of the type of material tested. Complete failure of both materials occurred, on average, before reaching 0.25%. It has been demonstrated that the compressive behaviour of CPCs depends on their composition and porosity [1]. One of the main reasons for the high strength and stiffness of the brushite studied here was its low porosity (∼12%). However, the maximum deformation is not positively affected by this decrease in porosity. In fact, both materials show the same brittle behaviour, i.e. they undergo comparably little deformation before they break. Under these conditions, increasing the compressive strength may not always be beneficial clinically, e.g. in the treatment of vertebral compression fractures, where the high stiffness of the bone cements used has been identified as a risk factor for adjacent-level fractures [2]. However, it is not clear whether a 20-fold higher stiffness than the trabecular bone would give a different clinical outcome than a 10-fold higher stiffness. These high-strength, high-stiffness cements may also be used as a basis for further biomaterial development, e.g. in the creation of macro-porous scaffolds, which is usually challenging due to the commonly low mechanical properties of the base CPC material.
The chemistry, amount, morphology, and size distribution of wear debris from silicon nitride coatings generated in the bearing surface can potentially reduce the negative biological response and increase the longevity compared to conventional materials in joint replacements. Total hip implants have a high success rate at 15 years of implantation, but few survive over 25 years. At present, revisions are mostly due to aseptic loosening, believed to mainly be caused by the biological response to wear debris generated in the joint bearing. For the polymer liners the size of the wear debris determines the biological response, while for metal bearing surfaces a limitation is the metal ion release. When ceramics are used, the wear debris is in general small and mechanical factors may be the main cause for failure. A more recent, experimental alternative is to let the well-known metallic substrate serve as the soft, tough bulk, and additionally apply a hard and smooth ceramic coating. In this way a lower wear rate and reduced metal ion release could be obtained. Furthermore, the chosen composition, silicon nitride (SixNy), contains no detrimental ions, and silicon nitride debris has been shown to slowly dissolve in aqueous medium. Altogether, it can potentially increase the longevity of the implant. However, the debris from SixNy coatings has not yet been characterised. In this study, a wear model test was performed to generate wear debris from SixNy coatings. The debris was characterised using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) in combination with computational calculations.Summary Statement
Introduction
Interbody fusion aims to treat painful disc disease by demobilising the spinal segment through the use of an interbody fusion device (IFD). Diminished contact area at the endplate interface raises the risk of device subsidence, particularly in osteoporosis patients. The aim of the study was to ascertain whether vertebral body (VB) cement augmentation would reduce IFD subsidence following dynamic loading. Twenty-four human two-vertebra motion segments (T6–T11) were implanted with an IFD and distributed into three groups; a control with no cement augmentation; a second with PMMA augmentation; and a third group with calcium phosphate (CP) cement augmentation. Dynamic cyclic compression was applied at 1Hz for 24 hours in a specimen specific manner. Subsidence magnitude was calculated from pre and post-test micro-CT scans. The inferior VB analysis showed significantly increased subsidence in the control group (5.0±3.7mm) over both PMMA (1.6±1.5mm, p=.034) and CP (1.0±1.1mm, p=.010) cohorts. Subsidence in the superior VB to the index level showed no significant differences (control 1.6±3.0mm, PMMA 2.1±1.5mm, CP 2.2±1.2mm, p=.811). In the control group, the majority of subsidence occurred in the lower VB with the upper VB displaying little or no subsidence, which reflects the weaker nature of the superior endplate. Subsidence was significantly reduced in the lower VB when both levels were reinforced regardless of cement type. Both PMMA and CP cement augmentation significantly affected IFD subsidence by increasing VB strength within the motion segment, indicating that this may be a useful method for widening indications for surgical interventions in osteoporotic patients.
