Our purpose was to understand if clinical outcomes after revision surgery are influenced by the first surgical procedure performed to fix the fracture.
Constant score, Flexion, VAS scale and Dash questionnaire were evaluated preoperatively and at 1 year after revision surgery,
Although dynamic hip screw (DHS) is considered the treatment of choice for pertrochanteric fractures, we theorized that external fixation would produce clinical outcomes equal to, if not better than, outcomes obtained with conventional treatment. As external fixation is minimally-invasive, we expected a lower rate of morbidity and a reduced need for blood transfusions. We compared fixation with DHS vs. Orthofix pertrochanteric fixator (OPF) in elderly pertrochanteric fracture patients. Forty consecutive pertrochanteric fracture patients were randomized to receive either 135A1 4-hole DHS (Group A) or OPF with 4 HA-coated pins (Group B). Inclusion criteria were: female, age B3 65 years, AO type A1 or A2 and BMD less than −2.5 T score. There were no differences in patient age, fracture type, BMD, ASA, hospital stay or quality of reduction. Operative time was 64 B1 6 minutes in Group A and 34 B1 5 minutes in Group B (p <
0.005). Average number of post-operative blood transfusions was 2.0 B1 0.1 in Group A, and none in Group B (p <
0.0001). Pain was measured 5 days post-operatively and was lower in Group B (p <
0.005). Fracture varization at 6 months was 6 B1 8A1 in Group A and 2 B1 1A1 in Group B (p = 0.002). In Group B, no pin-tract infections occurred. Pin fixation improved over time, as shown by pin extraction torque (2770 B1 1710 N/mm) greater than insertion torque (1967 B1 1254 N/mm), (p= 0.001). Harris hip score at 2 years was 62 B1 20 in Group A and 63 B1 17 in Group B. This study shows that OPF with HA-coated pins is an effective treatment for this patient population. Operative time is brief, blood loss is minimal, fixation is adequate and the reduction is maintained over time.