The patients were scored pre operatively using Knee society score ( KSS) and Western Ontario and McMasters Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC). Patients were assessed with same scoring system post operatively at 3 months, 1 year and annually there after. Post op x rays were reviewed by Knee society Radiological Evaluation.
All surgery was performed by a single surgeon, using one prosthesis design in each group. The data were assessed for any correlation between the pre-operative MCS and post-operative PCS, Pain, Stiffness and Function scores using Spearman’s Rank Correlation.
There was a statistically significant negative correlation between pre-operative MCS and six month WOMAC Pain, Stiffness and Function scores (P=0.025, P=0.019 and P=0.011 respectively) in the primary patients. There was no significant correlation with twelve months WOMAC scores. There was no significant correlation in terms of pre-operative MCS and six months WOMAC scores in the revision patients, but there was a statistically significant negative correlation between pre-operative MCS and the twelve months pain score (P=0.039).
Twenty four operations were reviewed in 23 patients to show a modified Roux-Goldthwait operation would improve the symptoms of chronic patella instability. This retrospective study used a questionnaire to record symptoms before and after surgery. The examination assessed joint hypermobility, patella tracking and stability, the Q and valgus angles of the knee. Apprehension test and assessment of patella tilt was also assessed. All patients underwent radiographic assessment. Twenty of 23 patients were improved by this procedure. Patella subluxation was reduced by 22%. Patella dislocation was reduced by 86%. The 3 unsuccessful cases had generalised joint laxity and may have been improved by the addition of a medial reefing procedure. There were no cases of tibial tuberosity numbness post operatively, patella tilt or failure of the transposed tendon. We showed that this procedure is effective, regardless of x-ray signs. We did observe a subjective increase in patellofemoral pain post operatively.
Review of 133 cases of Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) reconstruction, showed 91 cases had been arthroscoped twice. The incidence of meniscus pathology, at first arthroscopy was 71% and this fell to 63% at the second arthroscopy and reconstruction. 21% of recurrent tears were in previously undamaged menisci. The medial meniscus, was the most commonly damaged meniscus, at the time of the first arthroscopy. The incidence of lateral and bilateral meniscus pathology increased in the time period awaiting ACL reconstruction. The mean time between the two arthroscopies were 27 months. Damaged menisci continued to tear over the time period between first and second arthroscopies or new pathology occurred. The paper concludes that if ACL reconstruction is performed by a mini open technique then it should be re-arthroscoped immediately before the ACL reconstruction. This is essential to avoid missing meniscus pathology, even in previously arthroscoped knees.
There has been speculation as to whether the outcome of revision total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is as successful as primary TKA, this study was designed to compare the outcomes of primary and revision TKA in order to address this question. The study collected data prospectively from patients operated upon by one surgeon using one prosthesis design in each group. All patients undergoing revision TKA between 1997 and 2000 were included in the study. 100 consecutive patients undergoing primary TKA between 1997 and 1999 were included in the study. All surgery was performed by the senior author. Patients completed SF-12 and WOMAC questionnaires pre-operatively and at six and twelve months post-operatively. Mean scores were calculated for the different areas within both outcome measures (WOMAC pain, stiffness and function; SF-12 – physical constant score [PCS] and mental constant score [MCS]) The results were entered into a database and analysed using a combination of two way and simple repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) and t-tests. Only if the result of the ANOVA was significant were post-hoc adjusted t-tests performed on the data values. WOMAC scores did not differ between the two groups pre-operatively. Both patient groups showed a significant improvement in WOMAC scores at six months (P<
0.0005). In the primary group the pain and function scores improved significantly between six and twelve months (P=0.0258 and P=0.0019 respectively). This was not the case in revision patients. SF-12 PCS scores were significantly better in the primary patients pre-operatively (P<
0.0005). Both groups showed a significant improvement at six months assessment (P<
0.0005). Neither group demonstrated an improvement between six and twelve months. SF-12 MCS scores did not show any difference between the two groups pre-operatively. No significant change in MCS score occurred during the study in either the primary or revision patients. The SF-12 and WOMAC health questionnaires are valid, reliable and responsive outcome measures. The study has collected data prospectively from patients operated upon by one surgeon using one prosthesis design in each group. These findings support the concept that revision TKA leads to a comparable improvement in patient perceived outcomes of physical parameters as does primary TKA in both generic health outcome measures and disease specific outcome measures.
We report the role of our advanced nurse practitioner (ANP) with particular relevance to cost effectiveness, patient satisfaction and data collection. Our nurse practitioner has been involved in arthroplasty care since 1996. Her duties include preoperative assessment, health advice, informed consent, clinical follow up and maintenance of a database for research/audit. Follow up radiographs are reviewed regularly by the entire medical team in a teaching environment. Relative costs of this service were calculated using outpatient charging data. 100 postal questionnaires were used to assess patient satisfaction. Patients answered 13 questions relating to the service they received. Knee arthroplasty follow up through the nurse led clinic was half the cost of follow up through the consultant led clinic. 80 patients returned the postal questionnaire. Responses were very supportive of the nurse practitioner service. 76 (95%) of patients were happy to be assessed by the ANP and felt that their problems were dealt with appropriately. 17 (21%) of patients felt they should be seen by a surgeon at some stage during their routine follow up. Overall, 75 (94%) of patients were very satisfied or satisfied with the service, 1 (1%) was dissatisfied and 4 (5%) did not answer this question. Increasing patient numbers and demand for high quality care combined with a decrease in doctors hours worked has lead to a shortage of time for discussion of ‘prehabilitation’ and postoperative care. Long term clinical and radiological follow up leading to adequate research and audit must not be compromised. A trained nurse practitioner working in conjunction with the surgical team is a cost effective way of improving total patient care, audit and research within a department. We have found a high degree of patient satisfaction with this approach.