Purpose: Post-traumatic instability of the elbow is defined as a subluxation of the humeroulnar joint at least three weeks after trauma. Treatment is based on restitution of the three elements essential for stability: the coronoid process, the height of the head of the radius, repair of the lateral ligaments. The purpose of this study was to analyse treatment modalities for these unstable elbows and assess mid-term results.
Material and methods: This consecutive series included all patients who underwent surgery between 1992 and 2000. There were 22 patients (twelve men and ten women, mean age, 46 years, age range 26–74 years). The left elbow was involved in 16 cases (two dominant) and the right elbow in six cases (six dominant). The initial trauma was isolated dislocation in six patients, dislocation with fracture of the coronoid process and the head of the radius in nine, trans-olecranon fracture-dislocation in seven. Mean time from trauma to revision for instability was four months. A dynamic external fixator was used for stabilisation in all cases, with or without restoration of the height of the radius with a radial head prosthesis (n=12), and reconstruction of the coronoid process (n=7). Reinsertion of the lateral ligaments was necessary in 17 patients.
Results: Mean follow-up was 33 months. Six patients required a second procedure for transposition of the ulnar nerve in three and arthrolysis of the elbow joint in three. There was one failure requiring total elbow arthroplasty less than one year after revision. At last follow-up, outcome according to the Mayo Clinic classification was excellent in ten patients, good in five, fair in one, and poor in five (four trans-olecranon fracture-dislocations). Twenty patients had a stable elbow. Mean flexion-extension was 113° with a 19° mean extension deficit. At last follow-up, six patients had radiographic signs of osteoarthritis.
Discussion and conclusion: The results were directly correlated with the nature of the initial trauma and the quality of the restoration of he stabilising elements. The poorest results were observed after trans-olecranon fracture-dislocation, which led to osteoarthritic degradation in three out of four cases. In our experience, treatment of sequelae of elbow dislocation, or the terrible triade, can give satisfactory results with an appropriate treatment strategy.