Anterior knee instability associated with rupture of ACL is a disabling clinical problem, especially in the athletic individual. The gracilis and semitendinosus tendon (T4) represent an alternative autograft donor material for reconstruction of the ACL. The aim of our study was to elaborate a CPG to assist physiotherapists in decision making and to improve the efficacy and uniformity of care for patients with ACL reconstruction with T4. The CPG was developed according to international methods of guideline development. To identify “best evidence” a structured search was performed. When no evidence was available, consensus between experts (physiotherapist and orthopaedic surgeons) was achieved to develop the guideline. To identify “best clinical experience” and “physiopathology reasoning” focus group of practicing physiotherapists was used. They reviewed the clinical applicability and feasibility of the guideline, and their comments were used to improve it. CPG include three phases determined from the evidence, physiopathology reasoning and the biological process of autograft (weeks after the surgery: 2a–6a, 6a–10a and 10a–16a). The recommendations included: In postoperative weeks (2a–6a) physiotherapy focused on early range of motion of the knee; manual therapy (passive range of motion (PROM) 0–120° and miofascial techniques), pulsed ultrasound of low intensity with a power of 0.3w/cm2 (1MHz) during 10min/day in tibial tunnel, early active hamstring beginning with static weight bearing co-contractions (closed-kinetic-chain) and adductors, partial weight bearing with crutches, exercises in the swimming pool and cryotherapy to pain control (30 mi/4 hours). In weeks 6 to 10, full weight bearing, manual therapy (PROM 0–140° and miofascial techniques), hamstring strengthening progress complexity and repetitions of co-contractions, electrotherapy hamstring and quadriceps co-contractions. Starting at week 10, progress to more dynamic activities/movements, proprioceptive work, open-kinetic-chain, stationary bike and Theraband squats. In week 12, progress jogging program and plyometric type activities. The patients performed sports-specific exercises by about 3½ months postoperative.
Results: The length of the implanted CMI ranged between 3 and 5.5 cm and required 4 to 8 stiches. The IKDC subjective evaluation was normal in 18 patients, nearly normal in 18, abnormal in 5 and severely abnormal in 1. Range of motion was normal in 28 patients and nearly normal in 14. KT 1000 examination was normal in 32 patients, nearly normal in 7, abnormal in 1 and severely abnormal in 2. The X ray findings were normal in 28 patients, nearly normal in 6 and abnormal in 8. Complications included 2 saphenous nerve neuritis, 1 ACL graft tear with CMI implant breakage and 2 knee stiffness that required mobilization. 40 patients returned to work. The average time to resume work was 5.5 months
The histological study showed normal tendinous tissue with a few areas of disorganised collagen bundles, increased proliferation of fibroblasts and formation of capillaries. After a follow-up of 14 and 17 months, both patients recovered their prior level of sports activity and their knees were stable.