Arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs now yield a similar footprint as open procedures with several advantages, including reduced tissue trauma, post-operative pain, swelling, and concern about the deltoid attachment. We present a new simple and reproducible technique for arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. Sutures are placed through the full thickness of the rotator cuff. The suture is tied in the following manner: Traction is released, the assistant maintaining the arm in abduction and applying tension on the anterior cuff sutures while the posterior cuff sutures are tied. The procedure is repeated for the anterior cuff suture; and One suture strand from the anterior cuff and one suture strand from the posterior cuff are tied. The procedure is then repeated using the second strand from the anterior cuff and second suture strand from the posterior cuff. This suture and knot tying technique snugs the cuff down to the prepared tuberosity and restores the articular footprint of the cuff. This study retrospectively evaluated the clinical outcome of 170 patients who underwent arthroscopic cuff repair using this technique.Objective
Methods
The purpose of this study is to report the 1 to 5 year results of arthroscopic Rotator Cuff repairs. Between November 2001 to May 2003, 115 consecutive patients were operated (73 males and 42 females) with arthroscopic repair. 13 patients were lost to follow up, leaving 102 patients available for follow up. Patients were evaluated using the Constant score, satisfaction levels and ultrasound scan to evaluate cuff integrity. Failures were defined as dissatisfied patients and those who had had a re-operation. Re-tear rate was recorded. The mean follow up time was 23.8 months (range 12–61). Mean age was 57.3 years (range 23–78). 47% had a history of trauma. There were 107 patients (95.5%) with full thickness tears and 5 (4.5%) had partial thickness tears. Of the full thickness tears, 8 (7.6%) were massive in size, 36 (34%) large, 44 (41.5%) medium and 18(17%) small. Isolated Supraspinatus (SSP) tear was recorded in 83.5% and subscapularis tear in 7 %. A combination of SSP tear with infraspinatus and teres minor was found in 9.6%. 86% had Acromioplasty (ASD) with or without an AC joint excision arthroplasty. Two patients had Bankart repairs in addition at the time of cuff repair. The mean pre op Constant score was 40.9 points (95% CI 37.3 to 44.5), which had improved to 84.8 (CI 82.2 to 86.9) at last follow-up. 78% returned to same work and 82% returned to pre injury leisure activity. There were 20 re-tears (19.6%). eight of the 102 patients were not satisfied. Five of these patients had revision operation. Arthroscopic cuff repair shows high satisfaction rate (92%) and good functional results with 20% re-tear rate, while offering all the advantages of arthroscopic surgery.
Considerable controversy remains in the literature as to whether hemiarthroplasty or total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) is the better treatment option for patients with shoulder arthritis. Several cohort studies have compared the outcomes of stemmed hemiarthroplasty with those of stemmed TSA and had inconsistent conclusions as to which procedure is best. However, these studies suggest that stemmed TSA provided better functional outcome. 340 CSRA cases were performed between 1987–2003, 218 Hemiarthroplasty – Humeral Surface Arthroplasty (HSA) and 122 TSA. There was very little difference in the functional outcome and pain in patients with and without a glenoid implant early, as well as, later after surgery. Mean post-operative Constant score for TSA was 85.0% (59.8 points) and for HSA patients 86.8% (62.3 points) with no statistically significant differences (t-test, p=0.4821). A highly significant difference between the overall proportions of revised cases was observed, with (21/122) 17.2% and (6/218) 2.8% of TSA and HSA cases revised, respectively (p<
0.0001). Further, HSA prostheses survive significantly longer than TSA prostheses. The difference between the survival curves was highly significant, both in the earlier post-operative period (Wilcoxon’s test, p=0.0053) as well as the later on (Log-rank test, p=0.0028). Long-term survival of total joint replacement is related to polyethylene wear debris, and therefore its use should be avoided if possible. The difference between our series and those with stemmed prostheses may be due to the fact that with surface replacement the normal anatomy for each patient can be mimicked better than with the stemmed prostheses and there is substantially less place for error as in stem positioning, head sizing or wrong version that may lead to glenoid erosion and less favourable result. Our current practice is and we suggest performing Copeland humeral surface replacement without insertion of glenoid prosthesis.
Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair has evolved significantly in the last decade and has become a standard treatment. Satisfactory results of arthroscopic subacromial decompression (ASD) in the treatment of rotator cuff tears have also been reported (
Introduction The value of collecting continuous prospective patient data, including operation records and outcome scores, is well known. In 1994, a systematic prospective patient data collection was initiated on all patients attending the Reading Shoulder Unit (RSU). Initially this was done with hand written records. In 1995 a Windows Access ® database was formulated on a portable laptop. This was used continuously through until September 2005 when an Internet web-based database was introduced. We present this collective data and trends in practice from a busy shoulder unit over this decade. Results Between 1995 and 2005, 10005 entries were made to the Reading Shoulder Unit database. 3233 patient visits to outpatient clinics were recorded. 6772 operations were recorded – this includes: arthroscopic decompressions (ASD) + AC joint excisions − 3514, MUA for frozen shoulder 842, shoulder arthroplasty 432, open stabilisation 356, arthroscopic stabilisation 192, arthroscopic rotator cuff repair (RCR) 402, open cuff repair 290, arthroscopic capsular release 78 and 248 trauma cases. Changes in the unit practice include the move from open to arthroscopic reconstructive surgery (RC and stabilisation), RCR rather than ASD alone in elderly patients with impingement and cuff weakness, and repairing partial rotator cuff tears when previously we did not. Conclusions With over 10000 continuous and prospective entries – the RSU database is invaluable for continuous audit of practice and assessment of outcomes of the different procedures. Several practices have changed through the decade; most notably from predominately open reconstructive surgery through to arthroscopic reconstructive surgery. We would recommend to every surgeon and unit to collect his own data prospectively to enable him to analyse and assess his results.
Arthroscopic Rotator cuff repair is gaining popularity in recent years; however, the results of arthroscopic repairs are yet to be reported. Between November 2001 to May 2003, 115 consecutive patients were operated (73 males and 42 females) with arthroscopic repair. 13 patients were lost to follow up, leaving 102 patients available for follow up. The mean follow up time was 23.8 months (range 12–61). There were 107 patients (95.5%) with full thickness tears and 5 (4.5%) had partial thickness tears. Of the full thickness tears, 8 (7.6%) were massive in size, 36 (34%) large, 44 (41.5%) medium and 18(17%) small. Mean age was 57.3 years (range 23–78). 47% had a history of trauma. Mainly Supraspinatus (SSP) tear was recorded in 83.5% and isolated subscapularis tear in 7%. A combination of SSP tear with infraspinatus and teres minor minor (posterior tear) was found in 9.6%. 86% had Acromioplasty (ASD) with or without an AC joint excision arthroplasty. Two patients had Bankart repairs in addition at the time of cuff repair. Patients were evaluated using the Constant score, satisfaction levels and ultrasound scan to evaluate cuff integrity. Failures were defined as dissatisfied patients and those who had had a re-operation. Re-tear rate was recorded. The mean pre op Constant score was 40.9 points (95% CI 37.3 to 44.5), which had improved to 84.8 (CI 82.2 to 86.9) at last follow-up. 78% returned to same work and 82% returned to pre injury leisure activity. There were 20 ultrasound demonstrated re-tears (19.6%). However, the majority of patients with radiological re-tears had good function, pain relief and were satisfied. Eight of the 102 patients were not satisfied. Five of these patients had revision operation. Arthroscopic cuff repair shows high satisfaction rate (92%) and good functional results while offering all the advantages of arthroscopic surgery.
Copeland Surface replacement arthroplasty provides a good outcome in cases of arthritis. However, the limitation of use of this prosthesis is severe bone loss of the humeral head. We describe the use of Copeland Surface Replacement Shoulder Arthroplasty in cases of severe humeral head destruction extending more than 50% of the humeral head. The bone deficiency was reconstructed with the autograft from the reaming and reshaping of the humeral head and a synthetic bone graft substitute (Tricalcium phosphate granules (Biosorb)) mixed with the patient’s blood. We report preliminary results in 8 cases. 3 males and 4 females (One patient bilateral). The average age was 48 years ( 22–76 years). 5 cases had Posttraumatic avascular necrosis of humeral head, two patients had locked posterior fracture dislocation with loss of more than 50% of the humeral head and one patient with severe juvenile rheumatoid arthritis. In this series the remaining bone of humeral head was less than 50% ranging between 30–50% (average 38%). The patients were followed clinically and radiographically. The average follow–up was 10.6 months (range: 5 to 15 months). All patients had substantial improvement in there shoulder function and pain. All the patients were very satisfied. Average pre-op constant score was 9.3 points (range: 9–14). At the latest follow-up the average constant score was 59 (range: 36–74). Age and sex adjusted constant score was 68.6 (range: 37– 87). Radiographically we observed good incorporation of the Bone graft substitute with no signs of loosening or any lucencies under the prosthesis. These are early and encouraging results in this group of young patients with severe destruction of the humeral head. It seems like it may provide a good bone preserving solution in these cases and extend the frontiers for the surface replacement of the shoulder.
336 measurements were recorded. The observed mean LDFf was 32.8 (27.4–38.1; 95% CI) , 25.4 (22.4–28.5) and 43.1 (37.8–48.4; 95% CI) For Normal, Impingement and Tear cases, respectively (p<
0.0001, One-way ANOVA). The LDFf was lowest in the Impingement without tear grade (B2) with a statistically significant increase at the edges of a cuff tear.
The diagnosis of a Massive irreparable rotator cuff tear was confirmed by diagnostic ultrasound scan. The shoulder function was evaluated using the Constant Score. Patients’ active shoulder ranges of motion were recorded and video-recorded as well. Each participant was taught the initial 6-week of self Deltoid muscle exercise, executed in supine, at least three times a day. They were instructed that when they felt better control on their active shoulder movements to gradually recline up the head of the bed and continue with the same simple exercise. They were reviewed at 6 weeks re-assessed and re-taught the same exercise, with a 2kg weight in their hand. At the 12th week they were reassessed using the constant score, and their active range of motion was video recorded again.
The Constant-Murley score has gained wide acceptance for evaluation of shoulder function. The strength component of the Constant score accounts for 25 out of 100 points. It has been criticized for lack of consistency in defined measurement method. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of various variables on the strength component measurement of the Constant score.
The readings of the EZ force and the Isobex myometer were comparable.
No influence was found as well to the device being either fixed to an immobile platform or fixed to the floor by the examiner’s foot. These make these measurements easy to perform and reproducible using the newly designed digital force gauge (EZ force).
Diseased RC were sub grouped into mild (B1), moderate (B2) and severe (*B3 – cuff tear) impingement grades (Copeland – Levy Classification). The arthroscopy, grading, and probe placement were made by the senior authors. LDF flux (LDFf) was recorded over 30 seconds at each measurement point. The mean of these readings was then calculated (LDF flux – an arbitrary unit of measurement of the perfusion).
The LDFf was lowest in the moderate grade with a significant increase at the edges of a cuff tear.
Thermal capsular shrinkage presents the prospect of reducing redundant capsule, and therefore may be a suitable method of treating capsular-type instability. A prospective study of fifty-four consecutive patients (58 shoulders) treated exclusively with radiofrequency capsular shrinkage for atraumatic instability. The mean Rowe score improved from 33.1 to 74.1 points at followup of up to 48 months. Twenty of the fifty-eight shoulders had recurrence instability. Recurrent instability was related to the type of instability: 76.9% for voluntary instability, 30.3% for involuntary instability and none of 12 shoulders for instability/impingement pain. Recurrence was related as well to previous instability surgery (70%). The outcome was not related to the direction of instability, type of radiofrequency probe used, age of patient or ligamentous laxity. Twenty-two (57.9%) of thirty-eight patients returned to their pre-instability level of sporting activity. By using repeated RF treatments for the failed thermal shrinkage cases the failure rate was reduced from (20/58) 34.5% to (13/58) 22.4% and cumulative changes were seen on electron microscopy. These results are comparable to some of the results for open inferior capsular shift for patients with multidirectional instability with substantial less morbidity. The application of the minimal effective energy is controlled according to the tissue response without any charring or burning effect to the tissue. No scar was seen in repeated arthroscopies, or in electron microscopy studies. Thermal shrinkage does not negatively affect a later open stabilisation, but rather may provide better conditions for secure open surgery. We have found significant improvement in proprioception following thermal shrinkage treatment. We believe that by re-tensioning the proprioceptors they begin to fire off at lesser degrees of movement, and that there is a greater dynamic muscular contribution to shoulder stability. When using the correct technique for the right indications, Radiofrequency thermal shrinkage is a viable alternative to open inferior capsular shift in patients with capsular type of instability.
The coraco-acromial ligament (CAL) is partially resected during a subacromial decompression. Clinical studies have reported the regeneration of a structure which appears to be a new CAL. Histological studies of regenerated CAL have demonstrated an abundance of relatively acellular collagen fibrils orientated in the line of a ligament and mechanical testing of the regenerated tissue has properties similar to those of normal CAL. However it is still not clear whether this structure represents scar tissue or truly reformed ligament. Defining the major collagen constituent of this regenerated tissue would allow the distinction between ligament and scar tissue. Therefore the aim of this study was to examine the level of expression of types I and III collagen in regenerated coraco-acromial ligaments (CAL) in humans. Samples of regenerated CAL were obtained during open surgery for repair of small rotator cuff tears at an average of 24 months (range 14 to 52) after arthroscopic subacromial decompression from 4 men and 3 women with an average age of 58 years (range 44 to 68). A standard protocol radio-active in-situ immunolocalisation technique was used to quantify the ratios of mRNA collagen I to collagen III in the samples. The results demonstrated that the average ratio of collagen I to collagen III was 6.5. This ratio is similar to the value for normal hip capsule (5–6:1) and human posterior cruciate ligament (8:1). We conclude that the reformed CALs are ligamentous structures, not scar tissue, and therefore represent truly regenerated ligaments.
Arthroscopic shoulder surgery is evolving rapidly and several methods of stabilisation have been described. We present a simple new technique which addresses both the Bankart lesion and the capsular stretching together with the short-term results. The technique can be performed using just one anterior working portal and one posterior viewing portal. The labrum and capsule are elevated from the anterior glenoid neck by sharp dissection. One suture anchor is placed at the half past four position. One suture limb is passed under the labrum at 6 o’clock, the other limb is passed under the labrum at 2 o’clock and the two ends are tied. This has a purse string effect, tightening the capsule in only the superior/inferior plane, which also creates a bumper of labrum at the anterior glenoid rim. This technique was used in 35 patients (36 shoulders) with recurrent antero-inferior instability due to a traumatic Bankart lesion. The patient group included 33 men and 2 women with mean age 25 years (16–49). They had sustained an average of 5 dislocations per shoulder (1 to 11). The cohort included 4 professional and 6 semi-professional sportsmen all of whom were involved in collision or overhead sports. All the patients were assessed by an independent investigator at an average of 14 months (6–48) post surgery. Only one patient developed recurrent instability. This occurred without sustaining trauma. The average postoperative Rowe score was 93 (55–100), Walch-Duplay score was 93 (70–100), and Constant score was 97 (77–100). 65% of patients returned to the same level of sports and all the professional athletes were able to resume full activities. In conclusion, this technique is simple in concept, straightforward to perform, and demonstrates excellent short-term results.
Use of shoulder manipulation in the treatment of frozen shoulder (FS) remains controversial. One of the purported risks associated with the procedure is the development of a rotator cuff tear. However the incidence of iatrogenic rotator cuff tears has not been reported. The purpose of the study was to assess the effect of manipulation of the shoulder on the integrity of the rotator cuff. In a prospective study 20 consecutive patients (21 shoulders) with FS underwent manipulation of the shoulder under anaesthesia (MUA). The average duration of symptoms was 7.3 months (4–18 months). Patients were assessed pre and post manipulation using the Constant score. An ultrasound scan of the rotator cuff was performed before and at 3 weeks after manipulation. In all patients, pre and post manipulation ultrasound scans showed the rotator cuff to be intact. At 12 weeks after manipulation all patients indicated that they had none or only occasional pain. The mean improvement in motion was 83 degrees (range, 20 – 100°) for flexion, 95 degrees (range, 20 – 120°) for abduction, 58 degrees (range, 0 – 80°) for external rotation and 3 levels of internal rotation (range 3–5 levels). These gains in motion were all significant (p <
0.01). No fractures, dislocations or nerve palsies were observed. In conclusion manipulation under anaesthesia for treatment of frozen shoulder resulted in significant improvements in shoulder function and pain relief as early as 3 weeks after surgery and was not associated with rotator cuff tears. When performed carefully this procedure is safe and leads to early improvements in pain relief, range of movement and shoulder function.
Avascular necrosis (AVN) of the humeral head is an extremely disabling condition (Gerber et al, JSES 1998. 7(6):586–90). The results of stemmed arthroplasty for this condition are good, with Hattrup and Cofield reporting 79% subjective improvement at nine years (JSES 2000;9:177–82). This study reports the outcomes of surface replacement shoulder arthroplasties for AVN over a 16 year period. Between 1986 and 2001 twenty-seven arthroplasties were performed in patients with advanced avascular necrosis of the humeral head. All patients had secondary degenerative changes. AVN was secondary to corticosteriods and trauma in most cases. The mean age of the patients was 60 years (range 35 to 86). These included 16 hemiarthroplasties and 7 total shoulder arthroplasties. All prostheses were of the Copeland Surface Replacement Arthroplasty (CSRA) type. The average follow up period was 6 years (range 1 to 13). The average preoperative Constant score was 17. This improved to 74 at follow-up. Forward flexion improved from 63 degrees preoperatively to 133 degrees at follow-up. Abduction improved from 49 degrees to 118 degrees. External rotation improved from −3 degrees to 61 degrees. Pain scores improved from 0 to 11.7, using a 15 point visual analogue scale. 81% of patients had slight and no difficulty performing their routine activities of daily living. The remaining 19% still had some difficulty with routine activities. Four of the patients performed regular overhead activity and recorded some difficulty in doing this, whereas they had great difficulty pre-operatively. There were no cases of loosening. No difference was seen in any of the results between the hemi-arthroplasty and total shoulder replacement patients. Surface replacement arthroplasty is a suitable procedure for degenerative disease secondary to AVN of the humeral head, with results similar to stemmed prostheses. It has the advantage of preserving bone stock.
To assess the indication and role of shoulder arthroscopy for the problem shoulder arthroplasty. Between 1995–2000, 28 patients who had excessive pain or limitation of motion following a shoulder arthroplasty underwent arthroscopy. A pre-operative diagnosis was made in 13 out of the 28 patients. Of the 13 patients who had a pre-operative diagnosis an impingement syndrome was confirmed and successfully treated by arthroscopic subacromial decompression in 10, a rotator cuff tear was confirmed and debrided in two and in one loose bodies removed. Of the 15 patients who did not have a pre-operative diagnosis a post-arthroplasty capsular fibrosis was found in seven, six undergoing a successful arthroscopic capsular release. Loose or worn components were found in four of the shoulders, a small cuff tear was identified in one, a florid synovitis was present in another, loose cement was found in a further patient and in one no abnormality could be found. During the procedures orientation within the joint was often hindered by the reflection from the prosthesis making it difficult to differentiate between the real and mirror images of both the tissues and arthroscopic instruments. Access was also often compromised. Arthroscopy following shoulder arthroplasty is useful for the diagnosis and treatment of pain and loss of motion in selected patients, but can be technically demanding. Diagnostic arthroscopy following shoulder arthroplasty should be considered for patients suffering from pain in whom no cause can be found using less invasive investigations.
To report the results of the vertical apical suture Bankart lesion repair. Fifty-nine patients (52 men and 7 women) with a mean age of twenty-seven years (range, 16 to 53 years) were studied. The mean duration of instability was 4. 1 years and mean follow-up was 42 months (range 24 to 58 months). A laterally based T-shape capsular incision was performed with the horizontal component directed towards the glenoid neck and into the Bankart lesion. A vertical apical suture through the superior and inferior flaps of the Bankart lesion, tightens the anterior structures to allow them to snug onto the convex decorticated surface of the anterior glenoid. The inferior flap of the capsule was then shifted superiorly and the superior flap shifted inferiorly to augment the anterior capsule, with the shoulder in 20 degrees of abduction and 30 degrees of external rotation. At final review, according to the system of Rowe et al., 94. 9% (56 patients) had a rating of good or excellent. Three patients had a recurrent dislocation due to further trauma. The mean loss of forward elevation was 1 degree, external rotation with the arm at the side was 2. 4 degrees and external rotation in 90 degrees abduction was 2. 2 degrees. Of forty-four patients participating in sport, thirty-five (79. 5%) returned to the same sport at the same level of activity, seven returned to the same sport at a reduced level of activity and two patients did not return to sport. The vertical apical suture repair offers a 94. 9% stability rate, a maintained range of motion and a 79. 5% return to pre-injury level of sporting activity. It is technically less demanding than the Bankart procedure. All sutures used are absorbable. Complications related to non-absorbable implants and absorbable anchors and tacks are avoided.
Where a plica was present the impingement lesion seen on the cuff side was significantly greater than the lesion seen on the acromial side (p<
0.0001). This suggests that the impingement might be due to the plica itself.