25 cases of closed fractures around the distal femoral growth plate were analysed prospectively over a one-year period. There were 22 males and 3 females. Mean age was 16 years (range 7 to 22). According to the classification of Salter and Harris there were 6 cases (24%) of type 1 fracture, 12 (48%) type 2 fractures, 3 (12%) type 3, and 4 (16%) type 4. Mechanism of injury was football in 13 (59%), simple fall in 4 (18%), crush in 2 (9%), RTA in 2 (9%), and fall from height in 1 (5%); in 3, the mechanism was not recorded. The average time from injury to hospital admission was 5 days (range 0 to 17 days). Management was conservative in 4 and operative in 21. The medial parapatellar approach was used in 16. Post-surgically plaster cylinders were used for a mean of 3 weeks (range 0 to 6 weeks). No patient received physiotherapy. In the operative cases, sepsis was observed in 1 case (5%). This was a crash injury with a skin ulcer that became septic postoperatively and later required knee fusion. Of the remaining 20 operative cases, 17 cases were reviewed, 4 to one year, 9 to six months, and 4 to three months. There were no cases of deformity, nor wound complications. Those reviewed at one year had an excellent range of movement averaging 0 to 117 degrees (range 0–100 to 0–140). At six months the average range of movement was 1–98 degrees (range 5–70 to 0–140) and at three months 2–62 degrees (range 10–50 to 0–95). In conclusion, we believe that these difficult fractures should usually be managed operatively where expertise allows. Preliminary results suggest that the medial parapatellar approach provides excellent access but may inhibit initial rehabilitation.
A prospective study was undertaken of wound healing in HIV positive patients undergoing orthopaedic implant surgery. 175 implant operations were assessed. 40 operations (23%) were in HIV positive individuals. Wounds were scored using the Asepsis scoring system. Closed fractures in HIV positive patients had 1 (3. 5%) major infection. No correlation was seen between CD4 count and risk of wound infection. With regards to early wound sepsis, implant surgery can be undertaken safely in HIV positive individuals with closed injuries regardless of CD4 count. The risk of wound sepsis rises dramatically in implant surgery for HIV positive patients with open fractures.
Accepted treatment for acute septic arthritis in children involves drainage of the pus and systematic antibiotics. Review of published studies show that there is a tendency for paediatricians and physicians to drain pus by aspiration and for surgeons to drain the pus by arthrotomy and surgical lavage. There is however no published prospective study comparing the two methods of drainage. 201 consecutive children under 13 (134 boys and 67 girls) presenting to our hospital with acute septic arthritis were entered into a prospective study and randomised to either aspiration of the joint with a 14g needle or arthrotomy and lavage. Both groups had systematic antibiotics for six weeks. All patients were followed up with clinical examination and x-rays at 2, 6, 12, 24 and 52 weeks. There were 102 patients in the aspiration group and 99 in the lavage group. Both groups were similar in respect to mean age (2 yrs 5m and 2 yrs 10m respectively) and both groups had had symptoms for a mean of 6. 5 days. The commonest joint involved in both groups was the knee, followed by the shoulder, and the commonest organism involved was salmonella, followed by staphylococcus aureus. Aspiration failed in 9/102 patients who then underwent arthrotomy. Aspirated cases were discharged at a mean of 7. 9 days compared to 9. 8 days in the lavage group. There is no published method of measuring clinical improvement in septic arthritis so we devised the Blantyre septic joint score (BSJS) which measures pain, swelling, range of motion and function. Using the BSJS we found significant difference in scores between the aspirated and the lavage groups at any stage of follow up. We could not demonstrate any difference in clinical outcome between aspiration and arthrotomy with lavage in the treatment of septic arthritis.