The mechanical disadvantage and detrimental effect to articular cartilage following meniscectomy has been well documented in the literature. Meniscal repair in the avascular (white on white zone) is controversial and would be deemed inappropriate by many. Prospective data collection on all meniscal repairs between 1999 and 2008. 423 patients underwent meniscal repair at our unit during this time. We identified 88 patients who underwent a meniscal repair of a non peripheral tear (white on white zone) where there was no co-existent ACL injury or instability. There were 74 males and 14 females with a mean age of 26 years (13-54). There were 50 medial meniscal tears and 38 lateral tears, all in the non peripheral area of the meniscus. The criterion for failure was any reoperation on the same meniscus requiring excision or re fixation.Background
Methods
Avascular meniscal tears can be repaired with good clinical outcomes. The mechanical disadvantage and detrimental effect to articular cartilage following meniscectomy has been well documented in the literature. Meniscal repair in the avascular (white on white zone) is controversial and would be deemed inappropriate by many.Hypothesis
Background
The details of 320 consecutive patients undergoing knee microfracture, with a minimum follow up of 6 months, were taken from the Sports Injury Database at the Robert Jones and Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic Hospital, Oswestry. All had same phsyiotherapy regime post operatively. Two rounds of postal questionnaires were administered to assess patient satisfaction along with Lysholm, Tegner, VAS for pain and a modified IKDC scores. 196 patients responded (61.25%). The mean age of our patients was 40.64 years and the mean follow up 37.02 months (range 6–78 months). There were 35 smokers and 161 non-smokers. 64 patients had surgery in the medial compartment, 35 in lateral, 50 in patella-femoral and 47 belonged to the combined category. 93 patients had other surgeries (partial meniscectomies, ACL reconstruction etc) along with microfracture(47.45%). Seventy two percent of patients were satisfied with their outcome and 18.95% weren’t. 51.43% of smokers were satisfied with their outcome and 76.88% of non smokers (p=0.021). Patients more than 50 years of age were less satisfied (p=0.023) than younger patients. Having concomitant knee surgery, including ACL reconstruction, made no difference to patient satisfaction or functional scores. The location of the lesion in the knee did not affect patient satisfaction. However, all five post op score levels were statistically different among them. The Lysholm post op scores were significantly better in lateral and PFJ compartments than medial. Lateral and combined groups were significantly better than medial for Tegner post op scores. Lateral and PFJ groups were significantly better than medial for VAS and modified IKDC scores. Smoking and age significantly affect patient satisfaction after knee microfracture. Having concomitant knee surgeries doesn’t make a difference to either satisfaction or functional outcome. Our results suggest that the medial compartment doesn’t do as well in functional scores as previously thought.
Radiofrequency thermal shrinkage of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) laxity or partial injury is a relatively recent treatment. Studies have shown varied results with this technique but have had small study numbers and mixtures of both primary and reconstructed ACLs. We present our series of 109 patients. Between 1999 and 2008 our department performed radiofrequency thermal tightening on 109 patients with partial native ACL injury or ACL laxity. Fifty three patients completed both pre and post-operative evaluations at a mean follow-up of 20.5 months. Evaluation consisted of visual analogue pain scores, Tegner activity and Lysholm scoring. From the 110 patients that underwent thermal shrinkage for ACL instability 21 (19%) went on to require full ACL reconstruction. The decision to convert to full ACL reconstruction was made at a mean of 13 months (sd=12) following thermal shrinkage surgery. Comparing those who required ACL reconstruction with those who did not, we found those requiring reconstruction to be significantly younger. Mean = 25yrs vs. 31.5yrs. (p≤ 0.002) Fifty three patients completed both pre and post-operative evaluations at a mean follow-up of 20.5 months. Following treatment there was a significant improvement in mean Lysholm scores from 64.4 to 79.5 (p<
8.42x10-7) and pain scores 3.7 to 2.0 (p<
3.06x10-6); however there was a reduction in patients’ activity levels as assessed by Tegner score, from 6.65 to 6.0 (p<
0.019). Comparing those who required ACL reconstruction with those who did not, we found those requiring reconstruction to be have higher pre-operative level of activity (mean Tegner score = 7.3 vs. 6.5. (p<
0.047)). Radiofrequency thermal shrinkage of anterior cruciate ligament significantly improves knee function but may not be appropriate for younger patients or patients with high activity levels.
