For many years, achieving a neutral coronal Hip-Knee-Ankle angle (HKA) measured on radiographs has been considered a factor of success for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Lower limb HKA is influenced by the acquisition conditions, and static HKA (sHKA) may not be representative of the dynamic loading that occurs during gait. The primary aim of the study was to see if the sHKA is predictive of the dynamic HKA (dHKA). A secondary aim was to document to what degree the dHKA changes throughout gait.

We analysed the 3-D knee kinematics during gait of a cohort of 90 healthy individuals (165 knees) with the KneeKG™ system. dHKA was calculated and compared with sHKA values. Knees were considered “Stable” if the dHKA remained positive or negative – i.e. in valgus or varus – for greater than 95% of the corresponding phase and “Changer” otherwise. Patient characteristics of the Stable and Changer knees were compared to find contributing factors.

The dHKA absolute variation during gait was 10.9±5.3° [2 .4° – 28.3°] for the whole cohort. The variation was greater for the varus knees (10.3±4.8° [2.4° – 26.3°]), than for the valgus knees (12.8±6.1° [2.9° – 28.3°], p=0.008). We found a low to moderate correlation (r = 0.266 to 0.553, p < 0 .001) between sHKA and the dHKA values for varus knees and no correlation valgus knees. Twenty two percent (36/165) of the knees demonstrated a switch in the dHKA (Changer). Proportion of Changer knees was 15% for varus sHKA versus 39% for valgus sHKA (p < 0.001).

Lower limb radiographic measures of coronal alignment have limited value for predicting dynamic measures of alignment during gait.

Background

Achieving a neutral static Hip-Knee-Ankle angle (sHKA) measured on radiographs has been considered a factor of success for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, recent studies have shown that sHKA seems to have no effect on TKA survivorship. sHKA is not representative of the dynamic loading occurring during gait, unlike the dynamic HKA (dHKA).

Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is recognised as an effective treatment for end-staged knee osteoarthritis. Up to 20% of these patients is unfortunately unsatisfied due to anterior knee pain from unknown origin (Bourne and al. 2010). The aim of this study is to compare knee 3D kinematics during gait of patients with anterior knee pain after TKA to an asymptomatic TKA group. Our hypothesis is that the painful TKA group would exhibit known kinematics characteristics during gait that increase patellofemoral (PF) stresses (i.e. dynamic flexion contracture, valgus alignment, valgus collapse or a quick internal tibial rotation movement) compared to the TKA asymptomatic group.

Thirty-eight patients (45 knees) were recruited 12–24 months post-surgery done by one of three experienced orthopaedic surgeons (31 unilateral TKA and seven bilateral TKA, all using the same knee implant). Patients were divided according to their KOOS pain score (with a cut-off at 6/20 to be included in the painful group). The KOOS questionnaire was also used to assess activities of daily living, symptoms, sports and quality of life. A complete clinical and radiological work up was done on the painful group to exclude those with known explanation for pain (i.e. loosening, malrotation, infection and clinical instability). 3D knee kinematics during treadmill walking was captured and computed using the KneeKGTM system.

For the painful and asymptomatic groups, demographic results show respectively: age of 64.4 ± 7.6 and 69.8 ± 8.3 years, BMI of 31.9 ± 5.0 and 28.1 ± 3.6 kg.m−2, speed of 1.8 ± 0.6 and 1.67 ± 0.5 miles/h., and 50% of women in each group. Only age and BMI showed to be statistically different between groups. The painful TKA group exhibited a valgus alignment when walking (at initial contact and during stance, p<0.001). No significant difference has been put forward for the flexion/extension and internal/external tibial rotation.

Since a higher valgus alignment increases the Q angle, which lateralise the patella and increases PF stresses, results provide new insight on origin of symptoms. Conservative treatments for PF pain syndrome have shown to address the valgus alignment and improve symptoms, therefore the next step will be to assess the impact on pain level and alignment during gait of a personalised conservative management for the painful TKA group. Additionally, a study assessing the change in the radiological and dynamic alignment from pre to post surgery could bring valuable insight on the impact of surgical procedure on anterior knee pain.

Accurate and reproducible measurement of three-dimensional shoulder kinematics would contribute to better understanding shoulder mechanics, and therefore to better diagnosing and treating shoulder pathologies. Current techniques of 3D kinematics analysis use external markers (acromial cluster or scapula locator) or medical imaging (MRI or CT-Scan). However those methods present some drawbacks such as skin movements for external markers or cost and irradiation for imaging techniques. The EOS low dose biplanar X-Rays system can be used to track the scapula, humerus and thorax for different arm elevation positions. The aim of this study is to propose a novel method to study scapulo-thoracic kinematics from biplanar X-rays and to assess its reliability during abduction in the scapular plane.

This study is based on the EOS™ system (EOS Imaging, Paris, France), which allows acquisition of 2 calibrated, low dose, orthogonal radiographs with the subject standing at 30 to 40° angle of coronal rotation to the plane of one of the X-ray beams, in order to limit superimposition with the ribcage and spine. Seven abduction positions in the scapular plane were maintained by the subjects for 10 seconds, during X-ray acquisition. Between two positions, the subjects returned at rest position. Arm elevations were approximately 0, 10, 20, 30, 60, 90 and 150° (position 1 to 7). Six subjects were enrolled to perform a reproducibility study based on the 3D reconstructions of 2 experienced observers three times each. For each subject, a personalised 3D reconstruction of the scapula was created. The observer digitises clearly visible anatomical landmarks on both stereoradiographs for each arm position. These landmarks are used to make a first adjustment of a parameterised 3D model of the scapula. This provides a pre-personalised model of the subject's scapula which is then rigidly registered on each pair of X-rays until its retroprojection fits best on the contours that are visible on the X-rays. The thorax coordinate system (CS) was built following the ISB (International Society of Biomechanics) recommendations. The CS associated to the scapula was a glenoid centred CS based on the ellipse which fit on the glenoid rim on the 3D model of scapula. Scapular CS orientation and translation in the thorax CS was calculated following a Y,X,Z angle sequence for each position.

Each 3D reconstruction of the scapula was performed in approximately 30 minutes. The most reproducible rotation was upward/downward rotation (along X axis) with a 95% confidence interval (95% CI) from 2.71° to 3.61°. Internal/external rotation and anterior/posterior tilting were comprised respectively between 5.18° to 8.01° and 5.50° to 7.23° (CI 95%). The most reproducible translation was superior-inferior translation (along Y axis) with a 95% CI from 1.22mm to 2.46mm. Translation along X axis (antero-posterior) and Z axis (medio-lateral) were comprised respectively between 2.49mm to 4.26mm and 2.47mm to 3.30mm (CI 95%).

We presented a new technique for 3D functional quantitative analysis of the scapulo-thoracic joint. This technique can be used with confidence; uncertainty of the measures seems acceptable compared to the literature. Main advantages of this technique are the very low dose irradiation compared to the CT-Scan and the possibility to study arm elevation above 120°.