Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee (SONK) mainly affects the medial femoral condyle, would be a good indication for UKA. The primary aim of this study was to assess the clinical, functional and radiographic outcomes at middle to long-term follow-up, of a consecutive series of fifty UKA used for the treatment of SONK. The secondary aim was to assess the volume of necrotic bone and determine if this influenced the outcome. We reviewed 50 knees who were treated for SONK. Patients included ten males and 38 females. The mean age was 73 years (range, 57 to 83 years). The mean height and body weight were, respectively 153 cm (141 ∼171 cm) and 57 kg (35 ∼75kg). All had been operated on using the Oxford mobile-bearing UKA (Zimmer-Biomet, Swindon, United Kingdom) with cement fixation. The mean follow-up period was 8.4 years (range, 4 to 15years). We measured the size (width, length and depth) and the volume to be estimated (width x length x depth) of the necrotic bone mass using MRI in T1-weighted images. The clinical results were evaluated using the Knee Society Scoring System (KSS) and Oxford Knee Score (OKS). The flexion angle of the knee was evaluated using lateral X-ray images in maximum flexion.Aims
Patients and Methods
Good mid-term results of Oxford UKA (OxUNI) for anteromedial osteoarthritis (OA) were reported. The designers of prosthesis reported a 98% 10-year survival rate for a combined series of phase I and II, and these findings were supported by published results from other series, with 10-year survival ranging from 91% to 98%. In order to obtain good results, the designers of this prosthesis mentioned the importance of adhering to strict indication for OxUNI, especially only for OA cases with intact anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). OxUNI combined with ACL reconstruction (ACLR) is a viable treatment option for only young active patients, in whom the ACL has been primarily ruptured. On the other hand, it was not clear whether the result of OxUNI combined with ACLR for OA with secondary ruptured ACL was good. In this study we compare the short-term results of OxUNI combined with ACLR for OA with secondary ruptured ACL with that for usual OA with intact ACL. 382 OxUNI were performed at two hospitals by one surgeon between January 2002 and August 2005. Among those, 367 cases, followed over two years postoperatively (272 patients, women: 283, men: 84) were assessed. Follow up ratio was 96.1%. The mean patient age at the time of surgery was 72.0 (47~93) years. The mean follow-up period was 39.3 (24~67) months. Thirty three knees of OA were treated with OxUNI combined with ACLR, by using synthetic graft. Clinical results were assessed by the Oxford Knee Score (OKS) and active range of motion (ROM). Patients are asked a series of 12 questions, and their response scores range from 0 (worse) to 4 (best) for each, yielding an overall score range of 0–48. All living patients were contacted, and the status of the implant was established at the time of last follow from hospital records. We evaluate the survival rate for OxUNI with or without ACLR, using the endpoint of revision for any reason. The pre-and postoperative clinical scores were compared using the paired Student’s t-test. Survivor-ship curves were constructed using the Kaplan-Meier method, and survivorship between groups was compared using logrank and Wilcoxon methods. All analyses were performed using 95% confidence intervals and a P value of <
0.05 was considered significant. The mean OKS at final follow-up was 42.1 (preoperative; 21.7), and the mean active ROM was 125.2° (preoperative; 113.4°). OKS and active ROM were significantly improved. There were no significant differences in OKS and active ROM between OxUNI with ACLR and OxUNI with intact ACL. Fourteen knees among 367 knees were revised; nine for loosening of tibial component, four for dislocation of bearing and one for progression of lateral OA. Overall 5-year survival rate was 95.6%. When survival rate was assessed separately with or without ACLR, that of OxUNI with intact ACL was 96.7% and that of OxUNI with ACLR was 83.8%. There was significant worse survival rate between the two groups (P=0.0071). The 5-year survival rate for OxUNI with intact ACL was 96.7%, which was equivalent to those of original series from Oxford. However, 5-year survival rate for Oxford UKA with ACLR was 83.8% in our series. Four knees in nine of loosening of tibial component were replaced by OxUNI combined with ACLR. Therefore, even if ACL was reconstructed, the results of OxUNI for OA with secondary ruptured ACL was proved to be pessimistic. There was significantly worse survival rate for OxUNI with ACLR, compared with OxUNI with intact ACL. So we conclude that combined ACL reconstruction and OxUNI for anteromedial OA with secondary ruptured ACL is not recommended, which must be treated with TKA.
The range of motion (ROM) after total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is one of the most important factors for patient satisfaction, especially in Asian countries. To enhance the knee flexion angle, “high-flexion” designs have been introduced in total knee prostheses. One of such design was a new design of femoral prosthesis, which increased the posterior cut on the bone by 2 mm and thickened the posterior condyle, allowing the posterior condylar radius to continue further. There were several reports on postoperative ROM of such “high-flexion” posterior-stabilized (PS) total knee prosthesis. However, there was no report on the postoperative ROM of “high-flexion” cruciate ligament retaining (CR) total knee prosthesis. The purpose of this study was to compare the ROM associated with standard and high-flexion posterior CR total knee prostheses. One hundred and fifty-one consecutive patients (176 knees) had CR total knee prosthesis. 89 knees had standard CR TKA (NexGen CR, Zimmer, Warsaw, IL), and 87 knees had high-flexion CR knee prostheses (NexGen CR-Flex, Zimmer, Warsaw, IL). Differences in the age, diagnosis, preoperative Knee Society Score (KSS), and preoperative ROM of the knee between two groups were not significant. At one year postoperatively, the patients were assessed clinically and radiographically. The mean postoperative KSS knee score was 96.2 points for the standard CR prosthesis group and 96.7 points for the high-flexion CR prosthesis group (p=0.464). The mean postoperative KSS function score was 83.4 points for the standard CR prosthesis group and 84.8 points for the high-flexion CR prosthesis group (p=0.446). The mean postoperative ROM was 110.8 degrees in the standard CR prosthesis group, and 114.0 degrees in high-flexion prosthesis group (p=0.236). No knee had aseptic loosening, revision, or osteolysis. Previous report showed that “high-flexion” PS design did not increase postoperative ROM compared to standard design. However, there was no report on the postoperative ROM of “high-flexion” CR total knee prosthesis. We found no significant differences between the standard CR group and “high-flexion” CR group with regard to ROM or clinical and radiographic parameters. However, in the cases which achieved high flexion, “high-flexion” design, which chamfered posterior femoral edge, can reduce the possibility of deformation from posterior contacts under lord. Therefore, the results of the current study suggested that “high-flexion” CR design is not the design that increase ROM significantly, but might be the safe design even when the knee achieved deep flexion.
