Abstract

Purpose

Assess and report the functional and post-operative outcomes of complex acute radial head fractures with elbow instability treated by arthroplasty using an uncemented modular anatomic prosthesis.

Distal radius fractures are very common and they often require surgical intervention to prevent long-term complications. We noticed that several patients were being managed non-operatively for prolonged periods of time, when ultimately surgical fixation was inevitable. Delayed fixation of these injuries results in prolonged immobilisation, repeat fracture clinic attendances, callous formation, poor soft tissues, stiffness and union. Our aim was to analyse the time to fixation of distal radius fractures at our hospital using a standard volar locking plate. Between December 2010 and September 2011, our study population included all patients who underwent surgical fixation for a distal radius fracture at Royal Derby Hospital. All fractures were fixed using a volar locking plate. Data collected included date of injury, fracture clinic attendances, date listed for surgery and date of surgery. There were 100 patients who underwent surgical fixation, with a mean age of 63.6 years (17 to 91). The mean date from injury to fixation was 7.7 days (range 0 to 23). 82% of fractures were operated on within 14 days, and 98% were fixed within 21 days. We accept that our study does have some limitations; this includes patients who are unwilling to accept surgery at their initial consultation. Distal radius fractures have a strong tendency to revert back to their original configuration; hence we suggest that a decision to operate should ideally be made at the one-week fracture clinic appointment. This avoids the difficulties and complications associated with delayed surgical intervention. Stability, displacement, reduction and patient factors should all be taken into account.

Recurrent shoulder instability in those with bony defects is a difficult surgical problem to resolve. Burkhart and De Beer described an unacceptably high recurrence rate for arthroscopic Bankart repair in the presence of an inverted-pear glenoid with or without an engaging Hill-Sachs lesion, with suggestions that an open modified Latarjet procedure should be recommended in such patients. The Congruent-Arc Latarjet is a modification of the Latarjet open bony stabilisation for shoulder instability developed by Burkhart and De Beer. It involves rotation of the coracoid so the curved under-surface lies congruent with the glenoid. At the Royal Derby Hospital, UK, this procedure has been adopted by our four shoulder surgeons, two of whom undertook fellowship training with De Beer, we studied the outcomes of the patients who had undergone the modified Congruent-Arc Latarjet procedure in our department.

Fifty-two consecutive patients were identified over a five-year period at the Royal Derby Hospital or Derbyshire Royal Infirmary between 2006 and 2010 inclusive. With the approval of the clinical audit department, the data was collected using theatre records and clinical coding information to identify the patient group. A review of the case notes and local PACS system was undertaken to establish pre and post-operative examination findings, radiology findings regarding Hill-Sachs defects and glenoid bone loss, re-dislocation rates and post-operative function with return to normal activity. The endpoints of this study were aimed at finding out whether patients did return to normal function, were able to continue doing activity that would have provoked dislocation prior to surgery, and how many of the cases re-dislocated.

No surgeon consultant had a patient who re-dislocated after this procedure. The follow-up period was from 1 year to 6 years post-operatively. The complications of this procedure were found to be the dislodgement of bone anchors in 2 patients, who required further arthroscopy to remove the suture anchor from the gleno-humeral joint. One patient had prolonged functionally limiting loss of external rotation, which resolved after intensive physiotherapy at 7 months follow up. We will provide graphical representation of the pre and post operative functional scores.

We have demonstrated that the Congruent-Arc Latarjet is a reproducible procedure in the hands of surgeons other than the original authors, particularly when comparing our current 0% re-dislocation rate with the published literature, which suggests that 3.9% of patients undergoing this procedure with greater than 25% bone loss of the glenoid or an engaging Hill-Sachs will re-dislocate post-operatively, and this is better than the 6% re-dislocation rate of the standard Bristow-Latarjet procedure.

The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of a pre-contoured anatomic plate in the treatment of midshaft clavicle fractures.

We treated thirty patients consecutively for middle third clavicle fractures between March 2001 to March 2006. Surgery was performed for acute fractures, non-unions and malunions by a senior surgeon.

Fifteen patients were treated by open reduction and internal fixation with a precontoured small fragment clavicle plate (mean age of thirty-eight years).

Our control group consisted of a consecutive series of fifteen patients treated by internal fixation with conventional plates (mean age of forty-one years). Ten patients had fixation of their clavicles with a reconstruction plate whilst five patients had fixation with a dynamic compression plate (DCP).

Outcomes assessed for both groups were; complications, need for removal of plate, post-operative outcome, and time to union.

All patients were followed up for an average of eighteen months (range eight to thirty months). In the pre-contoured plate group none required removal of hardware. Five patients had complications. Three of these patients complained of numbness around the caudal aspect of the wound which subsequently resolved within six to eight weeks of the operation. The remaining two patients suffered from adhesive capsulitis postoperatively. Their symptoms resolved completely after four months. All patients regained full range of motion. All patients went on to clinical and radiological union with average time to union being 4.7 months (range three to ten months).

In the conventional plate group, nine patients required removal of their plate. Average time to removal of plate from index operation was 7.7 months (range four to thirteen months). Of the nine plate removals there were two plate breakages, five removals for local soft tissue irritation and two persistent painful non-unions. Three patients required subsequent re-plating for non-unions. All fractures united in this group with mean time to union of 5.4 months (range 2 to 14 months).

A pre-contoured clavicle plate provides rigid fixation without compromising plate stiffness and fatigue strength. We have successfully treated patients with acute fractures, nonunions and malunions of midshaft clavicle fractures, where there was gross distortion of normal anatomy. None of our patients required the removal of their plates (minimum follow-up of 8 months). We have also found these plates to be a valuable anatomical template when reconstructing a malunion, nonunion or highly comminuted fracture.

In conclusion, this is the first reported series demonstrating the use of anatomical pre-contoured plates for clavicle fractures. They can reduce time spent on intra-operative contouring, are low-profile and thus far, plate removal has not been necessary.

Purpose of study: To evaluate the ‘Open book’ technique (described below) for the extended approach in Total Knee arthroplasty with respect to its efficacy and outcome.

Summary: Adequete exposure in revision knee arthroplasty can be technically very demanding. Various techniques have been described to aid in exposure. These include Tibial tubercle osteotomy, V–Y quadricepsplasty, rectus snip and Patellar turn-down approach.

Since 1998 the senior author (TJW) occasionally has combined a Tibial crest osteotomy and Rectus Snip-‘Open Book Approach- in revision Knee Arthroplasty where exposure was made difficult by scarring and fibrosis.

The Tibial crest osteotomy is performed as described by Whiteside and this is combined with a 3 cm oblique Rectus snip proximally. This enables the surgeon to reflect the extensor mechanism as if opening a book. This approach protects the patellar blood supply by minimising soft tissue retraction and by making the rectus snip proximal, the feeding vessels in the quadriceps are not distributed.

Methods and Materials: Eight patients requiring Revision Knee arthroplasty in whom the ‘open book’ technique for extended approach to the Knee were reviewed for an average of 4.5 years. The patients were evaluated clinically and radiologically at final follow-up.

Results: All patients made good recovery of range of motion with little evidence of an extensor lag. There was no incidence of refracture, slippage or non-union of the osteotomy.

Conclusions: We concluded that, the ‘Open-Book’ technique is useful in the extended approach of Total Knee arthroplasty resulting in improved clinical outcome with no adverse effects.

The purpose of the project was to develop a questionnaire for completion by patients with elbow pathologies which is short and practical, internally consistent, valid, responsive and sensitive to changes of clinical importance.

The first, pilot phase included 43 patients who each completed a 19 item questionnaire relating to elbow function. The 19 ADLs produced a total scale Cronbach Alpha of 0.96., two different groups of ADLs were identified by multivariate analysis. Group 1 consisted of ADLs requiring moderate to high isometric loading and Group 2 of ADLs requiring high flexion. From the 19 items the best 10 which represented both groups were selected. A summary score was used to create the Wrightington Elbow Disability Score (WEDS).

In the second phase 89 patients completed the new WEDS form, reliability studies produced a Cronbach’s alpha value of 0.91. Internal validity of the groups of ADLs all correlated at p< 0.001 level with strength (Group1) and flexion (Group 2). A sub set of 40 patients undergoing total elbow arthroplasty were assessed for sensitivity to change in disability, the WEDS indicated a significant improvement at the p< 0.001. Convergent validity was demonstrated by the correlation with the ASES-e score at p< 0.001 level. The WEDS was significantly correlated with the ASES-e but not the DASH score.

Our study confirms that the WEDS questionnaire which is short and practical, is internally consistent, valid, responsive and sensitive to changes of clinical importance.

100 pre-operative and post-operative knee and function scores were analysed to assess whether a low pre-operative score was related to a poorer outcome, ie, are we operating too late? A two tailed student “t” test was performed showing that a pre-operative “function “ score of less than 30, resulted in a lower post-operative “function” score and the difference was statistically significant. These patients also showed the greatest improvement in scores and were the most satisfied with surgery. However, a low pre-operative “knee” score could not be related to a low post-operative “knee” score. Patients who had either a “knee” or “function” score of greater than 60 made no statistically significant improvement in either score. In conclusion, the pre-operative “knee” score is not a reliable indicator for when to perform surgery. However, the “pre-operative “ function score should be given more credence, along with clinical judgement, as it would appear that operating too late adversely affects the functional outcome of total knee arthroplasty.

65 patients over the age of 80 years, who underwent a total knee arthroplasty between 1989 and 1994, were retrospectively reviewed, by means of questionnaire, phone call, clinical and radiological examination.Notes were reviewed for pre-existing medical conditions, pre-operative and post-operative Knee Society “Knee” and “Function” scores. They were then compared with 65 randomly selected patients in a different age group, 70 years and under.56 octogenarians were alive at 5 years and 50 available for full review.

Elderly patients had more pre-existing medical conditions, with hypertension a ubiquitous diagnosis, required a longer in patient stay and more social services input before discharge, than the younger age groups. All patients in the elderly group suffered from osteoarthritis, unlike the younger age groups. Valgus deformity of the knees was only seen in the younger cohort. Previous surgery was more common in the octogenarians, with more octogenarians having undergone a tibial osteotomy and more youngsters undergoing arthroscopy. A reflection of changing surgical practice.

“Knee” Scores were not significantly different between the age groups. However, the “function “ scores pre-operatively, were significantly lower in the over 80s and they made a more significant post-operative gain. Post-operatively, elderly male patients were more likely to go into retention post-operatively, than female patients and males in the younger age group.

None of the prostheses had required revision in the elderly age group and only 5 patients had died since the surgery. None of the deaths were related to the surgery.

We recommend pre-operative catheterisation of octogenarian patients, especially those with a history of prostatism. There would appear to be from this review no indication for denying elderly patients an arthroplasty on the basis of age.