In this cohort study, we compare the functional outcome of Dynesys in patients with degenerative spondylolisthesis categorised in three subgroups.
Patients with Dynesys alone had initial good improvement in ODI &
VAS but this was not maintained. Secondary surgery was needed in 32% at 28.2 months. Dynesys with adjunct PLIF showed clinically &
statistically maintained ODI &
VAS outcome. Secondary surgery rate was 11.7% at 26 months. Dynesys with adjunct decompression group was favoured by clinically &
statistically improved functional outcome. Second surgery was necessary in 7.6%.
Dynesys was designed to offer physiological motion at the lumbar spine. An advantage which is superior to abolishing movements through spinal fusion.
In our cohort, clinical indications were:
t-test was used for comparison between preoperative and postoperative scores and p-value was used to show the significance.
Patients with stenosis performed better when the procedure involved adjunct decompression. Similarly, results of decompression and fusion were better than Dynesys alone in patients with spondylolisthesis.
Dynesys was successfully controlled symptoms of DDD in the intermediate term. Dynesys can be used as surgical treatment for symptomatic ASD. Dynesys alone in the treatment of spondylolysthesis resulted in a 45% re-operation rate, and we believe it should not be recommended as an indication. Dynesys alone is not recommended as a treatment for symptomatic spinal stenosis.
• Degenerative Disc Disease (DDD)
271 patients
• Spondylolisthesis
55 patients
• Adjacent segment disease (ASD)
30 patients
• Spinal canal stenosis
18 patients
Modic changes(M) have been described in association to Degenerative Disc Disease(DDD). Type-I represents the inflammatory phase whereas Type-II describes fatty changes within the vertebral marrow and endplate. Type-III is more advanced degeneration and it indicates marked sclerosis adjacent to endplates.
Adjacent endplate levels showed worsening of M0 to M2 in 11 patients while no change was seen in 35 levels. Only 4 levels with M2 were seen, of which 3 levels did not change and 1 level continued to M3. 2 M3 improved to M2.
Adjacent segment degeneration with new, symptomatic radiculopathy occurs after ACDF in 2–3% of patients per year on cumulative basis. An estimated 15% of patients ultimately require a secondary procedure at an adjacent level. An alternative to fusion is total disc arthroplasty (TDA). The key advantage of this promising technology is restoration and maintenance of normal physiological motion rather than elimination of motion. We describe 4 patients with a serious complication observed following implantation of the Bryan disc prosthesis in our cohort of 48 patients.
Patient #1: 43 M, with neck pain &
left brachalgia, with left C6 dermatome signs, with MRI findings of C5/6 disc prolapse with left C6 root impingement, undergoing C5/6 Bryan TDA in April 2004, with treatment recommendation of C3/4 and C6/7 Bryan TDA in January 2006. Patient #2: 47 M, with worsening gait over 2 years with right brachalgia, with findings of progressive cervical myelopathy with right C5 radiculopathy, with MRI findings of severe C5/6 disc degeneration with spinal cord compression, undergoing C5/6 Bryan TDA in January 2003, with MRI FU findings after 16/12 with new left C6/7 disc prolapse and left C6 radiculopathy, with treatment recommendation of C6/7 Bryan TDA, on waiting list. Patient #3: 45 F, 6 years of neck pain with right brachialgia, with right C5 dermatome signs, with MRI findings of C5/6 central disc herniation with cord compression, undergoing C5/6 Bryan TDA in December 2000, with FU MRI showing after 5 years and 7/12 (67/12) new C6/7 canal narrowing with right C6 radiculopathy, and treatment recommendation of C6/7 Bryan TDA. Patient #4: 38 M, worsening gait over 5 years and exam findings of progressive cervical myelopathy, with MRI findings of severe C5/6 disc degeneration with spinal cord compression, undergoing C5/6 Bryan TDA in August 2003, with FU MRI showing after 3 years new C4/5 disc prolapse with C5 radiculopathy, followed by treatment recommendation of C4/5 Bryan TDA.
Despite the MRI images preoperatively, it is difficult to exclude the natural progression of degeneration as a reason for ASD.
Dynamic stabilisation system for the spine relies on titanium screw purchase within the pedicle. Decision on osteointegration is important especially when the patient becomes symptomatic following initial good outcome. From our cohort of 420 Dynesys patients, over all incidence of screw loosening was 17%. Only 35% were symptomatic.
Seven observers composed of two expert orthopaedic spine consultant surgeons and one spine expert consultant radiologist and four Specialist Registrars in orthopaedics and radiology. Data gathered were distributed and presented in tables in the form of descriptive statistics. The evaluation of interobserver agreement was performed by obtaining a Kappa (K) index. For continuous variables comparison, the t test was employed, with a significance level of 0.05.
We are planning to evaluate a 3D computer reconstruction model based on 2 X-ray views at 45 degree angle to each other which might be sensitive to detect screw loosening.
Dynamic stabilisation system for the spine relies on titanium screw purchase within the pedicle. Decision on osteointegration is important especially when the patient becomes symptomatic following initial good outcome. From our cohort of 420 Dynesys patients, over all incidence of screw loosening was 17%. Only 35% were symptomatic.
Seven observers composed of two expert orthopaedic spine consultant surgeons and one spine expert consultant radiologist and four Specialist Registrars in orthopaedics and radiology. Data gathered were distributed and presented in tables in the form of descriptive statistics. The evaluation of interobserver agreement was performed by obtaining a Kappa (K) index. For continuous variables comparison, the t test was employed, with a significance level of 0.05.
We are planning to evaluate a 3D computer reconstruction model based on 2 X-ray views at 45 degree angle to each other which might be sensitive to detect screw loosening.
Spinal fusion for degenerative disc disease is known to have inconsistent outcomes. One concern is the possibility of AASDD as a result of the altered kinematics. The Dynamic Neutralisation System (Dynesys) appears to offer an advantage in that it restricts, rather than abolishes movement at the treated segment, and should thereby reduce the problem of AASDD, In the event of failure, it can in addition be removed, returning the spine to the former status quo. Various biomechanical studies confirmed flexibility of Dynesys.
Extension of Dynesys10 Dynesys combined with MIF2 Dynesys combined with PLIF2 There was no caudal ASD in our cohort.
Back pain/neck pain was the presenting complaint in 100% whereas neurological signs were found in 37% and systemic manifestations present in 38%. To control the disease, spinal surgical procedures was needed in 44% of cases. Approximately 30% of them had partial recovery and 9% had complete recovery.
Outcome assessment revealed significant improvement in SF36 even after removal of stabilising system while no worsening of ODI or VAS in comparison with preoperative status.
Tuberculosis continues to increase in England. London accounted for a substantial proportion of cases in 2005 (43%) and had the highest rate of disease. Spinal TB is the most common skeletal manifestation. The diagnostic evaluation of spinal TB is hampered by the difficulty of MRI interpretation and failing to keep a high index of suspicion. The mode of presentation of spinal tuberclosis, surgical procedures and outcome of patients were highlighted. Various dermographic parameters were evaluated. A prospective cohort study was conducted. Cross sectional sampling of patients presented with spinal TB between the years of 1999–2006 in two main hospitals covering large population of East London, Royal London Hospital and King George Hospital. One hundred and twenty three patients (mean age: 34 years) were identified. Asians represent the highest group affected (63%), then appear Afrocarribean (28%). White British represent only 6.5%. Frequency of occurence was as follows: dorsal spine 45%, lumbar spine 33%, multiple regions 11%. Delayed diagnosis was made in 34% of patients, 44% of whom were over 6/12. Backpain or neckpain was the presenting complaint in all of the patients (100%), whereas neurological signs were found in 37%. Systemic manifestations presented in 38%. Spinal surgical procedures were needed in 44% of cases. Approximately 30% of them had partial recovery and 9% had complete recovery. The incidence of spinal TB is on the increase. A high index of suspecion is required to avoid delay in the diagnosis. Knowledge of the patients’ background may help making appropriate early referral for MRI.
Outcome assessment revealed significant improvement in SF36 even after removal of stabilising system while no worsening of ODI or VAS in comparison with preoperative status.