Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 20 of 311
Results per page:
Bone & Joint Research
Vol. 12, Issue 8 | Pages 497 - 503
16 Aug 2023
Lee J Koh Y Kim PS Park J Kang K

Aims. Focal knee arthroplasty is an attractive alternative to knee arthroplasty for young patients because it allows preservation of a large amount of bone for potential revisions. However, the mechanical behaviour of cartilage has not yet been investigated because it is challenging to evaluate in vivo contact areas, pressure, and deformations from metal implants. Therefore, this study aimed to determine the contact pressure in the tibiofemoral joint with a focal knee arthroplasty using a finite element model. Methods. The mechanical behaviour of the cartilage surrounding a metal implant was evaluated using finite element analysis. We modelled focal knee arthroplasty with placement flush, 0.5 mm deep, or protruding 0.5 mm with regard to the level of the surrounding cartilage. We compared contact stress and pressure for bone, implant, and cartilage under static loading conditions. Results. Contact stress on medial and lateral femoral and tibial cartilages increased and decreased, respectively, the most and the least in the protruding model compared to the intact model. The deep model exhibited the closest tibiofemoral contact stress to the intact model. In addition, the deep model demonstrated load sharing between the bone and the implant, while the protruding and flush model showed stress shielding. The data revealed that resurfacing with a focal knee arthroplasty does not cause increased contact pressure with deep implantation. However, protruding implantation leads to increased contact pressure, decreased bone stress, and biomechanical disadvantage in an in vivo application. Conclusion. These results show that it is preferable to leave an edge slightly deep rather than flush and protruding. Cite this article: Bone Joint Res 2023;12(8):497–503


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_8 | Pages 120 - 120
11 Apr 2023
Hettich G Weiß J Grupp T
Full Access

In severe cases of total knee arthroplasty which cannot be treated with off-the-shelf implants anymore custom-made knee implants may serve as one of the few remaining options to restore joint function or to prevent limb amputation. Custom-made implants are specifically designed and manufactured for one individual patient in a single-unit production, in which the surgeon is responsible for the implant design characteristics in consultation with the corresponding engineer. The mechanical performance of these custom-made implants is challenging to evaluate due to the unique design characteristics and the limited time until which the implant is needed. Nevertheless, the custom-made implant must comply with clinical and regulatory requirements. The design of custom-made implants is often based on a underlying reference implant with available biomechanical test results and well-known clinical performance. To support surgeons and engineers in their decision whether a specific implant design is suitable, a method is proposed to evaluate its mechanical performance. The method uses finite element analysis (FEA) and comprises six steps: (1) Identification of the main potential failure mechanism and its corresponding FEA quantity of interest. (2) Reproduction of the biomechanical test of the reference implant via FEA. (3) Identification of the maximum value of the corresponding FEA quantity of interest at the required load level. (4) Definition of this value as the acceptance criteria for the FEA of the custom-made implant. (5) Reproduction of the biomechanical test with the custom-made implant via FEA. (6) Conclusion whether the acceptance criteria is fulfilled or not. The method was applied to two exemplary cases of custom-made knee implants. The FEA acceptance criteria derived from the reference implants were fulfilled in both custom-made implants. Subsequent biomechanical tests verified the FEA results. This study suggests and applies a non-destructive and efficient method for pre-clinical testing of a single-unit custom-made knee implant to evaluate whether the design is mechanically suitable


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 104-B, Issue SUPP_5 | Pages 33 - 33
1 Apr 2022
Chester J Trompeter A van Arkel R
Full Access

Introduction. Non-union is debilitating, costly and affects 2–8% of intramedullary fixed fractures. Clinical data suggest that percutaneous interfragmentary screws offer a less invasive alternative to exchange nailing. This study aimed to assess their efficiency with biomechanical analyses. Materials and Methods. A tibia was prepared for finite element analysis by creating a fracture of AO classification 42A2b, prior to reaming and insertion of an intramedullary nail. A callus was modelled as granulation tissue and gait loads were applied. The model was validated against published data and with sensitivity studies. The effects of weightbearing, fracture gap and angle, percutaneous screws and exchange nailing were compared through quantification of interfragmentary motion and strain, with the latter used to gauge healing performance via mechano-regulation theory. Results. Axial interfragmentary motion increased with increasing weightbearing, however, shear decreased at 25–50% weightbearing, leading to superior healing performance. Fracture gap had minimal effect on axial motion, but larger gaps gave greater shear, compromising healing. Elevated fracture obliquity culminated in more shear and inferior healing. Exchange nailing reduced axial motion by ∼30%, but had little effect on shear. Conversely, percutaneous screws had negligible effect on axial motion, but reduced shear by ∼15%, with three screws having a similar net effect on healing as exchange nailing from 10 to 11mm. Conclusions. This study provides new insight into fracture healing biomechanics and discovered that partial weightbearing, less oblique fractures and percutaneous screws all reduce shear, enhancing healing


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_9 | Pages 75 - 75
1 May 2017
Koris J Blunn G Coathup M
Full Access

Background. Children suffering from primary bone cancer necessitating resection of growth plates, may suffer progressive leg length discrepancy, which can be attenuated with extendable prostheses. A serious complication is catastrophic implant failure. Over time, bone will remodel, altering the stress pattern in the implant. By using finite element analysis we can model different bone remodeling conditions to ascertain the effect that this will have on stress distribution and magnitude. A finite element analysis was performed. Simplified computer generated models were designed of a cemented femoral Stanmore growing massive endoprosthesis. Three scenarios were designed, modelled on post-operative radiographs. Scenario 1 had a gap between the end of the femur and the implant collar, scenario 2 had no gap, but with no bone attachment into the collar, and scenario 3 had growth of the bone over the length of the collar with attachment. Physiological loading conditions were applied. The resultant stress in the implant for each scenario was measured, and compared to the strength of the material. Peak stresses were recorded at the stem-collar junction. The maximum stress recorded in the implant in scenario 1 was 3104.2Mpa, compared to 1054.4Mpa in scenario 2, and 321.2Mpa in scenario 3. Conclusions. Both accurate reduction and bone growth with attachment to the stem of a massive endoprosthesis will greatly reduce the resultant stress in the implant under loading conditions. The load is redistributed throughout the length of the bone. This may help to prevent catastrophic failure in the implant under loading conditions. Further investigations of patient findings are needed to ensure the model findings are verified. Level of Evidence. IIb (Theoretical)


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_12 | Pages 66 - 66
23 Jun 2023
Chosa E Zhao X
Full Access

Finite element analysis (FEA) has been applied for the biomechanical analysis of acetabular dysplasia, but not for biomechanical studies of periacetabular osteotomy (PAO) or those performing analysis taking into consideration the severity of acetabular dysplasia. This study aimed to perform biomechanical evaluation of changes in stress distribution following PAO and to determine the effect of the severity of developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) using three-dimensional FEA. A normal model was designed with a 25° center-edge (CE) angle and a 25° vertical-center-anterior margin (VCA) angle. DDH models were designed with CE and VCA angles each of 10, 0, or −10°. Post-PAO models were created by separating each DDH model and rotating the acetabular bone fragment in the anterolateral direction so that the femoral head was covered by the acetabular bone fragment, with CE and VCA angles each at 25°. Compared to the normal hip joint model, the DDH models showed stress concentration in the acetabular edge and contacting femoral head, and higher stress values; stress increased with decreasing CE and VCA angles. Compared to the DDH models, the post-PAO models showed near-normal patterns of stress distribution in the acetabulum and femoral head, with stress concentration areas shifted from the lateral to medial sides. Stress dispersion was especially apparent in the severe acetabular dysplasia models. PAO provided greater decreases in the maximum values of von Mises stress in the load-bearing area of the acetabulum and femoral head when applied to the DDH models of higher degrees of severity, although the values increased with increasing severity of DDH. PAO is expected to provide biomechanical improvement of the hip joint, although the results also suggest a limitation in the applicability of PAO for the patients with severe acetabular dysplasia


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 88-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 326 - 326
1 May 2006
Roca D Proubasta I Lacroix D Planell J
Full Access

Purpose: We carried out a biomechanical study by finite element analysis to compare treatment with a plate and treatment with a nail in pseudoarthrosis of the humeral shaft. Materials and methods: We used a cadaver humerus and the two fixation devices to generate the geometry with design software (CATIA® v4.2). We then modelled the shapes with finite element analysis software (MSC.Patran®) and created three experimental models: healthy humerus, humerus with shaft pseudoarthrosis stabilised with AO plate and humerus with shaft pseudoarthrosis stabilised with locking nail. Both implants were titanium. The three models were subjected to nine different load conditions and the results compared. Results: The nail model is stiffer than the plate in compression (3002.80 vs 789.68 N/mm), traction (6576.73 vs 1559.90 N/mm) and torsion (4.67 vs 2.73 N/mm). However, the plate model is biomechanically superior to the nail under other load conditions (mediolateral flexion, anteroposterior flexion, anteroposterior shear and mediolateral shear). Conclusions: Although we can understand and compare the stability of the plate model with the nail, joint clinical and biomechanical studies are needed to determine the minimum stiffness required so that it will not interfere with the process of union under different load conditions


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 106-B, Issue SUPP_18 | Pages 127 - 127
14 Nov 2024
Strack D Rayudu NM Kirschke J Baum T Subburaj K
Full Access

Introduction. Patient-specific biomechanical modeling using Finite Element Analysis (FEA) is pivotal for understanding the structural health of bones, optimizing surgical procedures, assessing outcomes, and validating medical devices, aligning with guidance issued by standards and regulatory bodies. Accurate mapping of image-to-mesh-material is crucial given bone's heterogeneous composition. This study aims to rigorously assess mesh convergence and evaluate the sensitivity of material grouping strategies in quantifying bone strength. Method. Subject-specific geometry and nonlinear material properties were derived from computed tomography (CT) scan data of one cadaveric human vertebral body. Linear tetrahedral elements with varying edge lengths between 2mm and 0.9mm were then generated to study the mesh convergence. To compare the effectiveness of different grouping strategies, three approaches were used: Modulus Gaping (a user-defined absolute threshold of Young's modulus ranging from 500 MPa to 1 MPa), Percentual Thresholding (relative parameter thresholds ranging from 50% to 1%), and Adaptive clustering (unsupervised k-means-based clustering ranging from 10 to 200 clusters). Adaptive clustering enables a constant number of unique material properties in cross-specimen studies, improving the validity of results. Result. Mesh convergence was evaluated via fracture load and reached at a 1mm mesh size across grouping strategies. All strategies exhibit minimal deviation (within 5%) from individually assigned material parameters, except Modulus Gaping, with a 500 MPa threshold (32% difference). Computational efficiency, measured by runtime, significantly improved with grouping strategies, reducing computational cost by 82 to 94% and unique material count by up to 99%. Conclusion. Different grouping strategies offer comparable mesh convergence, highlighting their potential to reduce computational complexity while maintaining accuracy in the biomechanical modeling of bones and suggesting a more efficient approach than individual element materials. The higher efficiency of FEA may increase its applicability in clinical settings with limited computational resources. Further studies are needed to refine grouping parameters and assess their suitability across different subjects


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XVIII | Pages 83 - 83
1 May 2012
Noor MS Pridham MC Fawcett MT Feng PY Hassan PO Pallister MI
Full Access

Introduction and aims. Biomechanical testing has been a cornerstone of the development of surgical implants for fracture stabilisation. To date most fracture surgery implant design and testing has been dominated by the use of standard bench top biomechanical testing. Although such methods have been used to successfully reproduce certain clinical observations, there are very clear limitations. More recently however, computerised engineering technology using finite element analysis (FEA) has been used to research orthopaedic biomechanical testing. This study aims to use FEA technology to further understand proximal femoral fractures, simulating falls, recreating fracture patterns and analyse fracture fixation devices for such fractures. Study design and results. In a multi-disciplinary collaboration, novel clinically relevant models were developed at Swansea University using advanced computational engineering. In-house software (developed initially for commercial aerospace engineering), allowed accurate finite element analysis (FEA) models of the whole femur to be created, including the internal architecture of the bone, by means of linear interpolation of Greyscale images from multiaxial CT scans. This allowed for modeling the changing trabecular structure & bone mineral density in progressive osteoporosis. Falls from standing were modeled in a variety of directions, (with & without muscle action) using analysis programs which resulted in fractures consistent with those seen in clinical practice. By meshing implants into these models and repeating the mechanism of injury in simulation, periprosthetic fractures have been successfully recreated. Discussion. The results highlight significant progress in FEA simulation and biomechanical testing of fractures. Further development with simulated physiological activities (e.g. walking and rising from sitting) along with attrition in the bone (in the boundary zones where stress concentration occurs) will allow further known the modes of failure of tried and tested implants to be reproduced. Robust simulation of macro and micro-scale events will allow the testing of novel new designs in simulations far more complex than conventional biomechanical testing will allow


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 102-B, Issue SUPP_11 | Pages 93 - 93
1 Dec 2020
Unal OK Dagtas MZ Demir C Najafov T Ugutmen E
Full Access

Abstract. Background. Proximal fibular osteotomy (PFO) was defined to provide a treatment option for knee pain caused by gonarthrosis(1). Minor surgical procedure, low complication rate and dramatic pain relief were the main reasons for popularization of this procedure(2, 3). However, changes at the knee and ankle joint after PFO were not clarified objectively in the literature. Questions/purposes. We asked: 1) Does PFO change the maximum and average pressures at the medial and lateral chondral surface of the tibia plateau? 2) Are chondral surface stresses redistributed at the knee and ankle joint after PFO? 3)Does PFO change the distribution of total load on the knee joint? 4) Can PFO lead to change in alignment of lower limb?. Methods. This study was conducted at Maltepe University Faculty of Medicine Hospital, Orthopedics and Traumatology Department and Yildiz Technical University Mechanical Engineering Department in Istanbul, Turkey, between September 2019 and February 2020. Finite element analysis (FEA) was used to evaluate effects of PFO(4). One 62 years old, female volunteer's X-ray, computer tomography and magnetic resonance imaging images were used for creating right lower limb model. Two different lower limb models were created. One of them was osteotomized model (OM) which was created according to definition of PFO and the other was non-osteotomized model (NOM). To obtain a stress distribution comparison between the two models, 350 N of axial force was applied to the femoral heads of the models. Results. After PFO, the maximum contact pressures at the medial and lateral tibial cartilages decreased 83.2% and 66.9%, respectively at the knee joint. The average contact pressure decreased 26.1% at the medial tibial cartilage and increased 42.4% at the lateral tibial cartilage. The Von Mises stresses decreased 57.1% at the femoral cartilage and decreased 79.1% at tibial cartilage. The stress on the tibial cartilage increased 44.6%, and stress on the talar cartilage increased 7.1% at the ankle joint. Under a 350 N axial force, distribution of the total load at the knee joint was changed and become more homogenous in OM compared to NOM. Change in lower extremity alignment after PFO could not be evaluated with FEA. Conclusion. FEA revealed that PFO causes some changes in knee and ankle joint kinematics. Main loading at the knee joint shifted from medial tibial cartilage to the lateral tibial cartilage after PFO. Additionally, the stresses on each cartilage were redistributed across a wider and more peripheral area. These changes could be the main reason for pain relief at the knee joint. FEA also demonstrated that the Von Mises stresses of the tibial and talar cartilages of the ankle joint increased after PFO. This stress increase may cause long-term arthritic changes in the ankle joint. Level IV; in silico study


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_9 | Pages 25 - 25
1 May 2017
Hurley R Concannon J Lally N McCabe J
Full Access

Background. Comminuted fractures involving the tibia are associated with a high level of complications including delayed healing and non-union, in conjunction with dramatically increased healthcare costs. Certain clinicians utilise a Pixel Value Ratio (PRV) of 1 to indicate such fracture healing. The subjectivity of this method has led to mixed outcomes including regenerate fracture. The poor prognosis of complex load bearing fractures is accentuated by the fact that no quantitative gold standard currently exists to which clinicians can reference regarding the definition of a healed fracture. The aim of the current study is to use patient specific finite element analysis of complex tibial fractures treated with Ilizarov frames to demonstrate callus maturation and to determine the optimum frame removal time. Methods. 3 patients (2 males, 1 female) were analysed following presentation with complex tibial fractures treated with Ilizarov frames. Patient specific computational analysis was performed according to radiographic data, incorporating maturing material properties to analyse the callus response to weight bearing over the healing timeframe. Computational results were compared to the PVR method to evaluate its efficacy in determining the optimum Ilizarov frame removal time. Results. All fractures were observed to clinically heal at a mean of 25.4 (±2.404) weeks. Following computational analysis however, the mean optimum Ilizarov frame removal time was seen to be 23.5 (±2.323) weeks. When compared with the PVR method, the suggested removal time presented a mean PVR of 1.025 (±0.017). Conclusion. Computational models of patient specific tibial fractures has shown promising correlations with the PVR method and has shown efficacy in predicting callus strength and subsequent optimum frame removal time. Level of Evidence. Level 4


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 103-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 12 - 12
1 Feb 2021
Pianigiani S Verga R
Full Access

A common location for radius fracture is the proximal radial head. With the arm in neutral position, the fracture usually happens in the anterolateral quadrant (Lacheta et al., 2019). If traditional surgeries are not enough to induce bone stabilization and vascularization, or the fracture can be defined grade III or grade IV (Mason classification), a radial head prosthesis can be the optimal compromise between bone saving and recovering the “terrible triad”. A commercially available design of radial head prosthesis such as Antea (Adler Ortho, Milan, Italy) is characterized by flexibility in selecting the best matching size for patients and induced osteointegration thanks to the Ti-Por. ®. radial stem realized by 3D printing with laser technique (Figure 1). As demonstrated, Ti-Por. ®. push-out resistance increased 45% between 8 −12 weeks after implantation, hence confirming the ideal bone-osteointegration. Additional features of Antea are: bipolarity, modularity, TiN coating, radiolucency, hypoallergenic, 10° self-aligning. The osteointegration is of paramount importance for radius, in fact the literature is unfortunately reporting several clinical cases for which the fracture of the prosthesis happened after bone-resorption. Even if related to an uncommon activity, the combination of mechanical resistance provided by the prosthesis and the stabilization due to the osteointegration should cover also accidental movements. Based upon Lacheta et al. (2019), after axial compression-load until radii failure, all native specimens survived a compression-load of 500N, while the failure happened for a mean compression force of 2560N. The aim of this research study was to test the mechanical resistance of a radial head prosthesis obtained by 3D printing. In detail, a finite element analysis (FEA) was used to understand the mechanical resistance of the core of the prosthesis and the potential bone fracture induced in the radius with simulated bone- resorption (Figure 2a). The critical level was estimated at the height for which the thickness of the core is the minimum (Figure 2b). Considered boundary conditions:. - Full-length prosthesis plus radius out of the cement block equal to 60mm (Figure 2a);. - Bone inside the cement equal to 60mm (Figure 2b);. - Load inclined 10° epiphysiary component (Figure 2c);. - Radius with physiological or osteoporotic bone conditions;. - Load (concentrated in the sphere simulating full transmission from the articulation) of 500N or 1300N or 2560N. Figure 3 shows the results in terms of maximum stress on the core of the prosthesis and the risk of fracture (Schileo et al., 2008). According to the obtained results, the radial head prosthesis shows promising mechanical resistance despite of the simulated bone-resorption for all applied loads except for 2560N. The estimated mechanical limit for the material in use is 200MPa. The risk of fracture is in agreement with the experimental findings (Lacheta et al. (2019)), in fact bone starts to fail for the minimum reported failure load, but only for osteoporotic conditions. The presented FEA aimed at investigating the behavior of a femoral head prostheses made by 3D printing with simulated bone-resorption. The prosthesis shows to be a skilled solution even during accidental loads. For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 102-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 42 - 42
1 Feb 2020
Ismaily S Parekh J Han S Jones H Noble P
Full Access

INTRODUCTION. In theory, Finite Element Analysis (FEA) is an attractive method for elucidating the mechanics of modular implant junctions, including variations in materials, designs, and modes of loading. However, the credence of any computational model can only be established through validation using experimental data. In this study we examine the validity of such a simulation validated by comparing values of interface motion predicted using FEA with values measured during experimental simulation of stair-climbing. MATERIALS and METHODS. Two finite element models (FEM) of a modular implant assembly were created for use in this study, consisting of a 36mm CoCr femoral head attached to a TiAlV rod with a 14/12 trunnion. Two head materials were modelled: CoCr alloy (118,706 10-noded tetrahedral elements), and alumina ceramic (124,710 10-noded tetrahedral elements). The quasi-static coefficients of friction (µ. s. ) of the CoCr-TiAlV and Ceramic-TiAlV interfaces were calculated from uniaxial assembly (2000N) and dis-assembly experiments performed in a mechanical testing machine (Bionix, MTS). Interface displacements during taper assembly and disassembly were measured using digital image correlation (DIC; Dantec Dynamics). The assembly process was also simulated using the computational model with the friction coefficient set to µ. s. and solved using the Siemens Nastran NX 11.0 Solver. The frictional conditions were then varied iteratively to find the value of µ providing the closest estimate to the experimental value of head displacement during assembly. To validate the FEA model, the relative motion between the head and the trunnion was measured during dynamic loading simulating stair-climbing. Each modular junction was assembled in a drop tower apparatus and then cyclically loaded from 230–4300N at 1 Hz for a total of 2,000 cycles. The applied load was oriented at 25° to the trunnion axis in the frontal plane and 10° in the sagittal plane. The displacement of the head relative to the trunnion during cyclic loading was measured by a three-camera digital image correlation (DIC) system. The same loading conditions were simulated using the FEA model using the optimal value of µ derived from the initial head assembly trials. RESULTS. For both head materials, the predicted values of axial displacement of the head on the trunnion closely approximated the measured values derived from DIC measurements, with differences of −0.17% to +6.5%, respectively. Larger differences were calculated for individual components of motion for the stair climbing activity. However, the predicted magnitude of interface motion was still within 10% of the observed values, ranging from −7% to −5%. CONCLUSIONS. Our simulations closely approximated physical testing using complex loading, coming within 7% of the target values. By generating a validated computational model of a modular junctions with varying head materials, we will be able to simulate additional activities of daily living to determine micromotion and areas of peak pressure and contact stresses generated. For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 85-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 144 - 144
1 Feb 2003
van der Jagt D Schepers A
Full Access

Resorption of the calcar below the collar of a titanium femoral prosthesis was observed. Biopsies of these lesions showed concentrations of polyethylene. We assessed the size of the resorption, correlating it with the size of the femoral prosthesis and the time since implantation. The age and the weight of the patient was also linked to the size of the prosthesis. We conducted a finite element analysis (FEA) of the femoral component-femur complex in both the loaded and unloaded situation. FEA demonstrated changing pressure under the collar. This can be translated into micro-bending, with the degree of movement dependent on the size of the prosthesis, the material of the prosthesis and the weight of the patient. We postulate the existence of a ‘polyethylene pump’ owing to the bending motion of the collared prosthesis, and that calcar resorption is due to the resultant polyethylene granulomatous lesions


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 86-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 448 - 448
1 Apr 2004
van der Jagt D Schepers A
Full Access

Resorption of the calcar below the collar of a titanium femoral prosthesis was observed. Biopsies of these lesions showed concentrations of polyethylene. We assessed the size of the resorption and correlated this with the size of the femoral prosthesis and the time since implantation. The age and the weight of the patient were also linked to the size of the prosthesis. We conducted a finite element analysis (FEA) of the femoral component-femur complex in both the loaded and unloaded situation. The FEA study demonstrated changing pressure under the collar that can be translated into microbending motions, with the degree of the movement dependent on the size of the prosthesis, the material of the prosthesis and the weight of the patient. We hypothesise that the existence of a ‘polyethylene pump’ due to the bending movements of the collared prosthesis concentrates polyethylene particles under the collar. We therefore postulated that the calcar resorption is due to the polyethylene granulomatous lesions, resulting from the micromotion of the collar of the prosthesis


Objectives. Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is an alternative to total knee arthroplasty for patients who require treatment of single-compartment osteoarthritis, especially for young patients. To satisfy this requirement, new patient-specific prosthetic designs have been introduced. The patient-specific UKA is designed on the basis of data from preoperative medical images. In general, knee implant design with increased conformity has been developed to provide lower contact stress and reduced wear on the tibial insert compared with flat knee designs. The different tibiofemoral conformity may provide designers the opportunity to address both wear and kinematic design goals simultaneously. The aim of this study was to evaluate wear prediction with respect to tibiofemoral conformity design in patient-specific UKA under gait loading conditions by using a previously validated computational wear method. Methods. Three designs with different conformities were developed with the same femoral component: a flat design normally used in fixed-bearing UKA, a tibia plateau anatomy mimetic (AM) design, and an increased conforming design. We investigated the kinematics, contact stress, contact area, wear rate, and volumetric wear of the three different tibial insert designs. Results. Conforming increased design showed a lower contact stress and increased contact area. In addition, increased conformity resulted in a reduction of the wear rate and volumetric wear. However, the increased conformity design showed limited kinematics. Conclusion. Our results indicated that increased conformity provided improvements in wear but resulted in limited kinematics. Therefore, increased conformity should be avoided in fixed-bearing patient-specific UKA design. We recommend a flat or plateau AM tibial insert design in patient-specific UKA. Cite this article: Y-G. Koh, K-M. Park, H-Y. Lee, K-T. Kang. Influence of tibiofemoral congruency design on the wear of patient-specific unicompartmental knee arthroplasty using finite element analysis. Bone Joint Res 2019;8:156–164. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.83.BJR-2018-0193.R1


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_13 | Pages 49 - 49
7 Aug 2023
Murray J Murray E Readioff R Gill H
Full Access

Abstract. INTRODUCTION. To preserve knee function and reduce degenerative, meniscal tears should be repaired where possible. Meniscal wrapping with collagen matrices has shown promising clinical outcome (AAOS meniscal algorithm), however there is limited basic science to support this. AIM. to model the contact pressures on the human tibial plateau beneath a (1) a repaired radial meniscal tear and (2) a wrapped and repaired radial meniscal tear. METHODOLOGY. Complete anterolateral radial tears were formed across 4 lateral human menisci, before repairing with ‘rip-stop’ H sutures using 2mm Arthrex Meniscal Suture tape. This was then repeated with the addition of a ChondroGide collagen matrix wrapping. From this experimental setup a finite element (FE) analysis model was construted. FE models of the two techniques (i) suture alone and (ii) suture and collagen-matrix wrap, were then modelled; bone was linear elastic, articular cartilage was a hyperelastic Yeoh model, and a linear elastic and transversely isotropic material model for the meniscus. The contact areas of the articulating surfaces, meniscus kinematics, and stress distribution around the repair were compared between the two systems. RESULTS. Meniscal suture-tape repair had higher local stresses and strains (σ_max=51 MPa ε_max=25%) around the repair compared to with Collagen wrapping (σ_max=36.6MPa ε_max=15%). Radial displacement and pressure on the meniscal contact surfaces were higher in the suture only repair. CONCLUSION. Collagen-matrix wrapping strengthens the repair, reducing local peak stresses and strains around the suture-tape. This could reduce the chance of suture-tape pull-out and subsequent repair failure


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 95-B, Issue SUPP_15 | Pages 200 - 200
1 Mar 2013
Iguchi H Yamamoto S Arachi T Hasegawa S Watanabe N Murakami S Tawada K Kobayashi M Nagaya Y Otsuka T
Full Access

Introduction. A Finite Element Analysis (FEA) is often used to examine load transfer between prosthesis and canal. Ordinary, bone elements' type is defined as elastic material. But using this element type for FEA on stem load transfer, the stems will jump out and fly away when the load is removed even friction between the stem and the canal was defined. This is remarkably different from the reality. It happens because the canal elements return to the original shape without the load. But actually, the bone is impacted by the load without returning to the original shape. Meshing the trabecular bone with a collapsible element type, it can collapse and be hardened by the stem pressure. We have been using Revelation (DJO, USA) with lateral flare for the primary cases whom we can expect high proximal load transfer. We were going to shorten its length to secure proximal load. We have been using Modulus (Lima Corporate, Italy) with conical fixation for the cases we expect mid stem load transfer and neck modification. We were going to extend its length for wider load transfer area. To examine load transfer of the designs the collapsible FEA was used. Objectives. Our objectives are to examine load transfer between stems with different length and canal by collapsible FEA. Materials and Methods. CAT scan data performed before Hip Arthroplasty were used. Each case has different preferable size. Data conversion was done by Mimics® then LS Dina was used for FEA. For cortical bone and stems conventional elements were used. For trabecular bone, collapsible elements were used. Results. With lateral flare stem, more stable proximal load transfer was obtained (Fig. 1). With conical stems, contact pressure on the boundary between stem and bone was widely distributed and no local stress concentration was observed. During stem insertion, trabecular bone was gradually collapsed up to a stable end point. After removing the load, stems were slightly elevated then settled as observed in realty. Conclusions. 1. Stem modification for each purpose, load transfer we had expected was obtained. 2. FEA with Collapsible elements has shown results which are closer to the realty


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 88-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 155 - 156
1 Mar 2006
Salo G Caceres E Lacroix D Planell J Llado A Ramirez M
Full Access

Aim: Investigate the influence of various types of allograft (from the tibia, femur, and fibula) through finite element analysis to evaluate the best clinical configuration. Methods: A non-linear 3D finite element model of a lumbar spine L3–L5 was used as a physiologic model (Noailly, 2003). The model was modified with the insertion of a transpedicular instrumentation (Surgival SA, Spain) and the removal of the L4 body and two adjacent discs. CT scans of a femur, tibia and fibula from the same patient were performed. Fragments of each bone were reconstructed and inserted within the model. Four configurations of allografts were investigated: one femur fragment, one tibial fragment, three fragments of fibula, six fragments of fibula. Four types of loadings were applied: compression (1000N), flexion, extension, and rotation (15Nm). Strain and stresses were calculated in large displacement (MARC, MSC Software). Results: Von Mises stresses within the internal fixator are well below the Yield stress and the fatigue limit and therefore no fracture of the fixator is foreseen. The use of a fixator to create fusion of the two vertebras makes the lumbar spine much stiffer. The geometry and configuration of the allografts have a large influence on the strain and stresses within the adjacent vertebrae with a reduction of strains and stresses. The use of fragments of fibula gives the most stable configuration. However, this is also the configuration that changes most the maximal principal strains within the vertebrae. Results obtained with the femur or the tibia are very similar between each other. However, due to its ellipsoidal geometry, the allograft in tibia gives more asymmetric deformations than the femur. Conclusion: Allografts harvested from the femur seems to be more reliable and change least the strain and stress distributions within the lumbar spine compared to allografts from the tibia or fibula


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_5 | Pages 81 - 81
1 Apr 2018
Sabesan V Whaley J Lima D Villa J Pathak V Zhang L
Full Access

Introduction. Varying degrees of posterior glenoid bone loss occurs in patients with end stage osteoarthritis and can result in increased glenoid retroversion. The excessive retroversion can affect implant stability, eccentric glenoid loading, and fixation stresses. Ultimately, the goal is to correct retroversion to restore normal biomechanics of the glenohumeral joint. The objective of this study was to identify the optimal augmented glenoid design based on finite element analysis (FEA) modeling which will provide key insights into implant loosening mechanisms and stability. Materials and Methods. Two different augmented glenoid designs, posterior wedge and posterior step- were created as a computer model by a computer aided design software (CAD). These implant CAD models were created per precise manufacturers dimensions and sizes of the augmented implant designs. These implants were virtually implanted to correct 20° glenoid retroversion and the different mechanical parameters were calculated including: the glenohumeral subluxation force, relative micromotion at the bone-cement interface the glenoid, implant and cement mantle stress levels. The FEA model was then utilized to make measurements while the simulating abduction with the different implant designs. The biomechanical response parameters were compared between the models at comparable retroversion correction. Results. The model prediction of force ratio for the augmented wedge design was 0.56 and for the augmented step design was 0.87. The step design had higher force ratio than the wedge one at similar conformity settings. Micromotion was defined as a combination of three components based on different directions. The distraction measured for the wedge design was 0.05 mm and for the step component, 0.14 mm. Both implants showed a similar pattern translation wise. The greatest difference between the two implants was from the compression standpoint, where the step component showed almost three times more movement than the wedge design implant. Overall, the step design registered greater micromotion than the wedge one during abduction physiologic loading. The level of stress generated during abduction on the glenoid vault was 1.65 MPa for the wedge design and 3.78 MPa for the step one. All stress levels were found below the determined bone failure limit for the bone and polyethylene (10–20 MPa). Concerning implant stress, the results measured on the backside of the wedge and step components were 6.62 MPa and 13.25 MPa, respectively. Both components showed high level of stress level measured on the cement mantle, which exceeded the endurance limit for cement fracture (4 MPa). Discussion. The augmented glenoid is a novel surgical implant for use in with severe glenohumeral osteoarthritis. Unlike standard glenoid prosthetics, the augmented glenoid is better suited for correcting moderate to severe retroversion. Whereas a step design might provide higher glenohumeral stability, the tradeoff is higher glenoid vault, implant and cement mantle stress levels, and micromotion, indicating higher risks of implant loosening, failure or fracture over time, leading to poorer clinical outcomes and higher revision rates


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 103-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 13 - 13
1 Feb 2021
Gardner C Karbanee N Wang L Traynor A Cracaoanu I Thompson J Hardaker C
Full Access

Introduction. Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) devices are now increasingly subjected to a progressively greater range of kinematic and loading regimes from substantially younger and more active patients. In the interest of ensuring adequate THA solutions for all patient groups, THA polyethylene acetabular liner (PE Liner) wear representative of younger, heavier, and more active patients (referred to as HA in this study) warrants further understanding. Previous studies have investigated HA joint related morbidity [1]. Current or past rugby players are more likely to report osteoarthritis, osteoporosis, and joint replacement than a general population. This investigation aimed to provide a preliminary understanding of HA patient specific PE liner tribological performance during Standard Walking (SW) gait in comparison to IS0:14242-1:2014 standardized testing. Materials and Methods. Nine healthy male subjects volunteered for a gait lab-based study to collect kinematics and loading profiles. Owing to limitations in subject selection, five subjects wore a weighted jacket to increase Body Mass Index ≥30 (BMI). An induced increase in Bodyweight was capped (<30%BW) to avoid significantly effecting gait [3] (mean=11%BW). Six subjects identified as HA per BMI≥30, but with anthropometric ratios indicative of lower body fat as previously detailed by the author [2] (Waist-to-hip circumference ratio and waist circumference-to-height ratio). Three subjects identified as Normal (BMI<25). Instrumented force plate loading profiles were scaled (≈270%BW) in agreement with instrumented hip force data [4]. A previously verified THA (Pinnacle® Marathon® 36×56mm, DePuy Synthes) Finite Element Analysis wear model based on Archard's law and modified time hardening model [5] was used to predict geometrical changes due to wear and deformation, respectively (Figure 1). Subject dependent kinematic and loading conditions were sampled to generate, for both legs, 19 SW simulation runs using a central composite design of response surface method. Results. HA group demonstrated comparable SW gait characteristics and Range of Motion (RoM) to the Normal group (p>0.1) (Figure 2) but statistically greater SW peak loads, PE liner wear rates, deformation, and penetration after 3Mc (Million cycles) of SW (p<0.01). HA group demonstrated comparable RoM (p>0.4) and peak loading to ISO-14242-1:2014 (p>0.1) although, up to 8° increase in flexion-extension angle was observed. The HA group demonstrated statistically greater wear rates (mean 7.5% increase) to ISO-14242-1:2014 (p<0.05) (Figure 3). No difference in PE liner deformation or penetration was observed (p>0.4). Discussion. This study detailed only a 19. th. percentile within a broader HA population (BW=91kg, n=485) [6] however, were statistically worst-case compared to a Normal group and ISO-14242-1:2014. A 95. th. percentile HA population (BW=127kg) may produce lower PE liner tribological performance than reported in this investigation and therefore, warrants further investigation. Further studies would be beneficial to determine whether the increase in PE liner wear rate for HA patients is predictable based on kinematics and loading alone, or whether influences exist in design inputs and surgical factors. Conclusion. The HA population detailed in this study (representative of a 19. th. percentile) demonstrated statistically greater SW PE liner wear rates compared to ISO-14242-1:2014. This study may have implications for the test methods considered appropriate to verify novel designs. For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly