Aims. The aim of this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of arthroscopic partial meniscectomy versus physical therapy plus optional delayed arthroscopic partial meniscectomy in young patients aged under 45 years with traumatic meniscal tears. Methods. We conducted a multicentre, open-labelled, randomized controlled trial in patients aged 18 to 45 years, with a recent onset, traumatic, MRI-verified, isolated meniscal tear without knee osteoarthritis. Patients were randomized to arthroscopic partial meniscectomy or standardized physical therapy with an optional delayed arthroscopic partial meniscectomy after three months of follow-up. We performed a cost-utility analysis on the randomization groups to compare both treatments over a 24-month follow-up period. Cost utility was calculated as incremental costs per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained of arthroscopic partial meniscectomy compared to physical therapy. Calculations were performed from a healthcare system perspective and a societal perspective. Results. A total of 100 patients were included: 49 were randomized to arthroscopic partial meniscectomy and 51 to physical therapy. In the physical therapy group, 21 patients (41%) received delayed arthroscopic partial meniscectomy during follow-up. Over 24 months, patients in the arthroscopic partial meniscectomy group had a mean 0.005 QALYs lower quality of life (95% confidence interval -0.13 to 0.14). The cost-utility ratio was €-160,000/QALY from the healthcare perspective and €-223,372/QALY from the societal perspective, indicating that arthroscopic partial meniscectomy incurs additional costs without any added health benefit. Conclusion. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy is arthroscopic partial meniscectomy is unlikely to be cost-effective in treating young patients with isolated traumatic meniscal tears compared to physical therapy as a primary health intervention. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy leads to a similar quality of life, but higher costs, compared to physical therapy plus optional delayed arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2023;105-B(11):1177–1183

Partial meniscectomy patients have a greater likelihood for the development of early osteoarthritis (OA). To prevent the onset of early OA, patient-specific treatment algorithms need to be created that predict patient risk to early OA after meniscectomy. The aim of this work was to identify patient-specific risk factors in partial meniscectomy patients that could potentially lead to early OA.

Partial meniscectomy patients operated between 01/2017 and 12/2019 were evaluated in the study (n=317). Exclusion criteria were other pathologies or surgeries for the evaluated knee and meniscus (n = 114). Following informed consent, an online questionnaire containing demographics and the “Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score” (KOOS) questionnaire was sent to the patient. Based on the KOOS pain score, patients were classified into “low” (> 75) and “high” (< 75) risk patients, indicating risk to symptomatic OA. The “high risk” patients also underwent a follow-up including an MRI scan to understand whether they have developed early OA.

From 203 participants, 96 patients responded to the questionnaire (116 did not respond) with 61 patients considered “low-risk” and 35 “high-risk” patients. Groups that showed a significant increased risk for OA were patients aged > 40 years, females, overweight (BMI >25 kg/m2 ≤ 30 kg/m2), and smokers (*p < 0.05). The “high-risk”-follow-up revealed a progression of early osteoarthritic cartilage changes in seven patients, with the remaining nineteen patients showing no changes in cartilage status or pain since time of operation. Additionally, eighteen patients in the high-risk group showed a varus or valgus axis deviation.

Patient-specific factors for worse postoperative outcomes after partial meniscectomy and indicators for an “early OA” development were identified, providing the basis for a patient-specific treatment approach. Further analysis in a multicentre study and computational analysis of MRI scans is ongoing to develop a patient-specific treatment algorithm for meniscectomy patients.

Abstract. Background. Meniscal tears affect 222 per 100,000 of the population and can be managed non-operatively or operatively with an arthroscopic partial meniscectomy (APM), meniscal repair or meniscal transplantation. The purpose of this review is to summarise the outcomes following treatment with a meniscal tear and explore correlations between outcomes. Methodology. A systematic review was performed of MEDLINE, EMBASE, AMED and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials to identify prospective studies describing the outcomes of patients with a meniscal tear. Comparisons were made of outcomes between APM and non-operative groups. Outcomes were graphically presented over time for all treatment interventions. Pearson's correlations were calculated between outcome timepoints. Results. 35 studies were included, 28 reported outcomes following APM; four following meniscal repair and three following meniscal transplant. Graphical plots demonstrated a sustained improvement for all treatment interventions. A moderate to very strong correlation was reported between baseline and three-month outcomes. In the medium term, there was small significant difference in outcome between APM and non-operative measures (SMD 0.17; 95 % CI 0.04, 0.29), however, this was not clinically significant. Conclusions. Patients with a meniscal tear demonstrated a sustained initial improvement in function scores, which was true of all treatments examined. APM may have little benefit in older people, however, previous trials did not include patients who meet the current indications for surgery as a result the findings should not be generalised to all patients with a meniscal tear. Further trials are required in patients who meet current operative indications

Abstract. Objective. Meta-analysis of clinical trials highlights that non-operative management of degenerative knee meniscal tears is as effective as surgical management. Surgical guidelines though support arthroscopic partial meniscectomy which remains common in NHS practice. Physiotherapists are playing an increasing role in triage of such patients though it is unclear how this influences clinical management and patient outcomes. Methods. A 1-year cohort (July 2019–June 2020) of patients presenting with MRI confirmed degenerative meniscal tears to a regional orthopaedic referral centre (3× ESP physiotherapists) was identified. Initial clinical management was obtained from medical records alongside subsequent secondary care management and routinely collected outcome scores in the following 2-years. Management options included referral for surgery, conservative (steroid injection and rehabilitation), and no active treatment. Outcome scores collected at 1- and 2-years included the Forgotten Joint Score-12 (FJS-12) questionnaire and 0–10 numerical rating scales for worst and average pain. Treatment allocation is presented as absolute and proportional figures. Change in outcomes across the cohort was evaluated with repeated measures ANOVA, with Bonferroni correction for multiple testing, and post-hoc Tukey pair-wise comparisons. As treatment decision is discrete, no direct contrast is made between outcomes of differing interventions but additional explorative outcome change over time evaluated by group. Significance was accepted at p=0.05 and effect size as per Cohen's values. Results. 81 patients, 50 (61.7%) male, mean age 46.5 years (SD13.13) presented in the study timeframe. 32 (40.3%) received conservative management and 49 (59.7%) were listed for surgery. Six (18.8%) of the 32 underwent subsequent surgery and nine of the 49 (18.4%) patients switched from planned surgery to receiving non-operative care. Two post-operative complications were noted, one cerebrovascular accident and one deep vein thrombosis. The cohort improved over the course of 2-years in all outcome measures with improved mean FJS-12 (34.36 points), mean worst pain (3.74 points) average pain (2.42 points) scores. Overall change (all patients) was statistically significant for all outcomes (p<0.001), with sequential year-on-year change also significant (p<0.001). Effect size of these changes were large with all Cohen-d values over 1. Controlling for age and BMI, males reported superior change in FJS-12 (p=0.04) but worse pain outcomes (p<0.03). Further explorative analysis highlighted positive outcomes across all surgical, conservative and no active treatment groups (p<0.05). The 15 (18%) patients that switched between surgical and non-surgical management also reported positive outcome scores (p<0.05). Conclusion(s). In a regional specialist physiotherapy-led soft tissue knee clinic around 60% of degenerative meniscal tears assessed were referred for surgery. Over 2-years, surgical, non-operative and no treatment management approaches in this cohort all resulted in clinical improvement suggesting that no single strategy is effective in directly treating the meniscal pathology, and that perhaps none do. Clinical intervention rather is directed at individual symptom management based on clinical preferences. Declaration of Interest. (b) declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research reported:I declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research project

The value of arthroscopic partial meniscectomy in the severely arthritic knee has been questioned. Some authors suggest that it may result in progression of osteoarthritis precipitating the need for joint replacement and that symptomatic improvement may occur from lavage alone. 126 patients with a torn meniscus and Outerbridge grade IV changes in the same compartment underwent arthroscopic partial meniscectomy and limited debridement of unstable articular cartilage. The indication for surgery was a symptomatic meniscal tear not osteoarthritis. A control group consisted of 13 patients with grade IV changes and intact but frayed menisci who underwent washout alone. Mean age and follow up were similar in the two groups. Initially meniscectomy improved symptoms in 82 cases (65%). Symptoms were unchanged in 26 cases (21%) and were made worse in 18 cases (14%). At a mean follow up of 55 months, 50 patients (40%) felt their knees were better than they were preoperatively. Their mean Lysholm score was 75. 5. 35 knees (28%) were not improved (mean Lysholm socre 59). 41 patients (32%) had undergone further surgery: 39 total knee replacements, 1 unicompartmental knee replacement and 1 tibial osteotomy. Older patients, those with varus/ valgus malalignment, and those with exposed bone on both articular surfaces fared worse. Outcome following meniscectomy was better than outcome following washout alone: more patients reported an improvement after meniscectomy and fewer had undergone further surgery on their knees (p=0. 04). The median time between arthroscopy and the decisions for joint replacement was the same in both groups (8 months in the meniscectomy group and 7. 5 months in the washout group) indicating meniscectomy did not precipitate joint replacement. These results suggest that arthroscopic partial men-iscectomy in the presence of Outerbridge grade IV changes can result in satisfactory long term outcomes for many patients, is more effective than washout alone and does not precipitate the need for joint replacement

Objectives: Partial meniscectomy is the current standard of care for torn menisci not suitable for repair. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy is the most commonly performed orthopaedic surgical procedure. The purpose of this study was to determine what specific factors influence longevity of improvements in function and activity levels following arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. Methods: Six hundred forty (640) knees which had undergone isolated partial meniscectomy were identified from a clinical database. One hundred ninety-three (193) knees had partial lateral meniscectomy, 342 had partial medial meniscectomy, and 105 had partial medial and lateral meniscectomy. Average age was 52 years (range, 15 to 79) with 207 females and 433 males. Patients were excluded if they had concurrent ACL reconstructions or microfracture for chondral defects. Lysholm function and Tegner activity scores were collected for a minimum of 8 years after the index partial meniscectomy. Results: For all knees, Lysholm scores improved significantly from preoperative (54) to 1 year postoperative (76) (p< 0.001). Lysholm scores did not change from year 1 to year 5. At year 6, average Lysholm score decreased to 69, and by year 8, the score decreased further to 63. When comparing degenerative knees to non-degenerative knees, the non-degenerative group had greater improvement and maintained it longer. Medial meniscus patients maintained their improvement at 6 and 7 years while the lateral meniscus group showed less improvement and decreased at years 6 and 7. Anatomic location of meniscus tear (anterior, middle or posterior thirds) was not associated with changes in improvement of Lysholm or Tegner scores. Tegner activity levels improved significantly from preoperative (3.6) to 1 year postoperative (4.7) (p< 0.001). This improvement was maintained at years 2, 3, and 4. There was no significant difference between preoperative Tegner and year-5 Tegner scores (4.0) (p> 0.05). This same finding was also seen at years 6, 7, and 8. In degenerative knees, there was less improvement, and levels declined at years 6, 7, and 8. Conclusions: Patients who undergo partial meniscectomy can expect 4 to 5 years of improved function and activity levels. Knee function continues to improve up to 5 years, but it decreases as activity levels decrease. Patients who delay treatment or have degenerative changes experience a decrease in function and activity levels sooner. Meniscectomy provides a short term improvement in function and activity levels, but long term improvement seems unlikely. Our findings confirm that specific factors such as which meniscus (medial or lateral) undergoes meniscectomy, chronicity of the tear, and preexisting degenerative changes might be expected to influence longevity of improvements after partial meniscectomy

Introduction. Meniscal tears in middle-aged patients are common. There is a lack of consensus regarding the optimum management of these injuries. Although arthroscopic partial meniscectomy (APM) is a frequently performed surgical option, literature has failed to prove its effectiveness over conservative approaches. Materials and Methods. We retrospectively reviewed 102 middle-aged (age > 40 years) patients who had been treated for meniscal tears between January 2010 and December 2012. We followed these patients up telephonically to assess knee outcome satisfaction rates, any early (6 weeks) improvements in pain and knee function and their pre-morbid and post-treatment activity levels (Tegner Activity Scale). Results. There were 65 male and 37 female patients with an average age of 58 years (range 40–79). After their first consultation 72 patients were treated conservatively and 30 patients were treated with an APM. There were no reported complications following surgery. We managed to contact 87 patients who were followed up at an average of 17.5 months (range 5–34 months). Overall, 72.4% of patients managed were satisfied with their knee outcomes. APM had a 78.9% satisfaction rate and 67.3% of patients treated conservatively were satisfied. There were no significant differences in early or long term pain or knee function improvements between APM or conservative modalities. 89.7% of patients returned to the same or better activity levels after treatment. There was a 1.5 times greater risk of worse activity level following APM. There was a 79.3% satisfaction rate in patients who remained at the same activity level (p=0.00). Analysis showed 21 of the 72 conservatively treated patients failed this approach. APM was performed on 18 of them resulting in a 75% satisfaction rate for this group. Conclusion. APM and conservative management produce equivalently good results for meniscal tears in middle-aged patients. Delayed surgery does not negatively influence the outcome of these patients. NO DISCLOSURES

The aim of the present study was to compare the mechanical properties of the torn menisci between stable and ACL unstable knees. Material and method: Ten medial menisci from isolated bucket handle tears and ten from ACL deþcient knees (injury < 3 months) during ACL reconstruction were obtained after an arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. They were þxed and tested mechanically in tension. The modulus of elasticity (E), maximum stress σmax, maximum load, and stress-strain curves were evaluated. Results: In the isolated tears E was 56.35 Mpa (median values) and in the ACL deþcient knees was 163.0 MPa and it was signiþcant (P=0,023). The maximum failure stress σmax was 9,22 Mpa for the þrst group and 17,26 Mpa for the latter and this was also signiþcant (P=0.04) Conclusions: The bucket handle torn menisci from the stable knees had inferior mechanical characteristics compared to the ACL deþcient knees. In other words isolated meniscal tears seem to be an inferior material compared to those of the ACL deþcient knees. The authors believe that it is worth considering a low cost and morbidity partial meniscectomy in isolated bucket handle tears, instead of a more demanding and long lasting meniscal repair operation followed by an also longer rehabilitation time

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to review the clinical results of a series of 108 children treated artroscopically for symptomatic discoid lateral menisci. Methods: The medical records of more than 100 consecutive patients who underwent arthroscopic treatment for symptomatic discoid meniscus between 1990 and 2005 were reviewed. Results: The mean patient age was 8.7 years (range, 2,5 to 14 years), with 55% female and 45% male patients. The mean duration of symptoms before surgery was 20 months (range, 2 to 48 months), with 95% having pain and 38% having mechanical impingment. All patients were treated arthroscopically. Partial or subtotal arthroscopic meniscectomy was performed. Operative classification of the menisci revealed 64 complete, 18 Wrisberg type and 26 incomplete discoid menisci, with meniscal tears being present in 48 knees (45%). At final follow-up, all patients exhibited full knee flexion beyond 135 degrees. Three patients reported residual knee pain, and four reported intermittent mechanical symptoms. At final follow-up, 3 years minimum, according to Ikeuchi clinical score more than 50 % of the patients were considered very good and 25 % good. Only 8 patients felt that their activity level remained partially limited. Conclusions: Our results show the middle-term efficacy of arthroscopic partial or subtotal meniscectomy in cases of symptomatic lateral discoid menisci. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy is preferrable only when the posterior attachment of the discoid meniscus is stable. A total meniscectomy is indicated for the Wrisberg-ligament type of discoid meniscus and when the meniscus is completely degenerated. This to our knowledge is the largest series of discoid lateral menisci arthroscopically treated. Level of evidence: Level IV, therapeutic case series

Aims

The aim of the British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK) Meniscal Consensus Project was to develop an evidence-based treatment guideline for patients with meniscal lesions of the knee.