All cases were biopsied. 37% of these were excisional biopsies, 29% were incisional biopsies and 17% were needle biopsies. 21 patients (88%) received definitive surgery. Of these 5 had forequarter amputations (24%), 11 cases were excised marginally (52%), and 5 cases curetted (24%). Surgical choice was highly dependent on grade (X2=4.9256, p=0.005). In all cases the intent was curative. 2 patients had metastasis disease at diagnosis, and 5 developed metastases after definitive surgery. 4 patients had local recurrence (all had undergone wide local excision). All patients with grade 1 tumours remained disease free. Cumulative survival at 5 years was 57% and at 10 years 42%. Patient age did not affect survival. 5 year survival in grade 1, 2 and 3 tumours was 100%, 83% and 20% respectively. 4 of 5 patients undergoing amputation developed metastases and survival was significantly worse in the amputation group. Local recurrence in the wide local excision group did not diminish prospects for survival.
Curettage was chosen for most grade 1 and some grade 2 tumours. Although maintenance of function is far better, our study provides no evidence that curettage results in increased local recurrence rates. Indeed, local recurrence in the wide local excision group did not depress survival figures. Because of early death in the amputation group, we would recommend avoidance of amputation in favour of wide local excision in almost all cases if possible. Age alone should not be a factor in determining surgical treatment.
Purpose: To assess the long-term outcome of Schanz subtrochanteric abduction osteotomy (SO) in patients with long-standing dislocation of the hip Patients and methods: Between 1962–1981, 11 patients were treated with a SO. Nine patients, in whom 16 SO procedures were performed, were available for follow-up. Seven hips had had failed surgery in infancy, 9 hips had not been operated on previously. The average age at the time of SO was 17.8 (12–29) years. The degree of dislocation at the time of SO was classified according to Eftekhar type B: subluxation; (4 hips); type C: dislocation with neo-acetabulum, (8 hips) patients, and type D: high dislocation, no neo-acetabulum (4 hips). The indications to perform SO were fatigue and a painful lurch in 14 hips and a flexion/adduction contracture with pain in 2 hips. Post-operatively, patients were immobilised in suspended traction for 6–8 weeks, followed by progressive weight-bearing. Follow-up averaged 21 (14–37) years. Follow-up included the Harris-Hip score and ADL-score (Barthel-index); working status, sexual problems, ROM, hip/knee instability and radiographic examination. Results: Ten secondary surgical procedures were performed at an interval of 6–19 years following SO: shelf procedure ( 5); Epiphyseodesis (3) and total hip (2). The shelf procedures were performed for residual hip pain, at an average of 12 years. The total hips were performed after 17 and 19 years following SO. Both have failed and had complicated hip-revisions. ROM was severely restricted in 4 patients. The mean Harris hips score was 76 ( 27–97). One of six bilateral cases and 2 of 4 unilateral cases had poor functional results. All patients had unlimited ADL activities; 7 patients regularly participated in cycling and swimming. Three female patients experienced minor sexual problems, due to limited abduction. Four patients had 400 excessive valgus at the knee, without clinical or radiographic symptoms. Leg-length discrepancy varied from 0–3 cm. Conclusion: 1. The results of SO in patients with Eftekhar C/D were surprisingly fair, and poor in type B, subluxation.