Abstract
Background
Both minimally invasive surgery(MIS) and computer-assisted surgery(CAS) in total knee arthroplasty have been scientifically linked with surgical benefits. However, the long-term results of these techniques are still controversial. Most surgeons assessed the surgical outcomes with regard to knee alignment and range of motion, but these factors may not reflect subjective variables, namely patient satisfaction
Purpose
To compare satisfaction and functional outcomes between two technical procedures in MIS total knee arthroplasty, namely computer-assisted MIS and conventional MIS procedure, operated on a sample group of patients after 10 years.
Methods
Seventy cases of posterior-stabilized total knee prostheses were implanted using a computer-assisted system and were compared to seventy-four cases of matched total knee prostheses of the same implant using conventional technique. Both groups underwent arthrotomy by 2 centimeter limited quadriceps exposure minimally invasive surgery (2 cm Quad MIS). At an average of ten years after surgery, self-administered patient satisfaction and WOMAC scales were administered and analyzed.
Results
Demographic data of both groups including sex, age, preoperative WOMAC and post-operative duration were not statistically different. Post-operative WOMAC for the computer-assisted group was 38.94±5.68, while the conventional one stood at 37.89±6.22. The median of self-administered patient satisfaction scales of the computer-assisted group was 100 (min37.5-max100), while the conventional one was 100 (min25-max100). P-value was 0.889. There was 1 re-operative case in the conventional MIS group due to peri-prosthetic infection which was treated with debridement, polyethylene exchanged and intravenous antibiotics.
Conclusion
The long-term outcomes of computer-assisted MIS total knee arthroplasty are not superior to that of the conventional MIS technique. Computer assisted MIS total knee arthroplasty is one of the treatment options for osteoarthritis of the knee that has comparable levels of satisfaction to the conventional MIS technique.
