Abstract
Background
Hard-on-hard bearings showed advantages of reduction of wear rates, osteolysis and aseptic loosening in total hip arthroplasty (THA). A new combination of ceramic-on-metal (COM) was developed to compensate the disadvantages of MOM and COC. COM showed good short-term results in vitro and in vivo studies. There was no report of stripe wear and metal ion level elevation. Our study was designed to evaluate the wear pattern of this bearing in early loosening THA.
Methods
During January 2009 to December 2010, 121 primary THAs were performed at our institution by single-surgeon, using the same acetabular component and same uncemented femoral stem with a 32-mm modular head. All patients received the information of the bearing couples and made their own decision to choose one of the following bearings: COM, MOP and MOM. The functional outcomes (Harris Hip Score), Serum Co and Cr levels and survival rates were compared between groups at 5 years. The retrievals were tested by optical microscopy and Raman spectroscopy to evaluate the wear pattern in the cases those need revision.
Results
At the follow-up 5 years ago, 2 in 10 patients of the COM group received revision due to bearing related complications and loosening although MOP and MOM groups have good clinical follow-up without revision. Metal ion levels were higher in the revision cases. The retrieval analyses revealed metal transfer at weight-bearing area of ceramic femoral head and large wear located on the center of acetabular liner. Spectral shift and broadening of Raman bands demonstrated incorporation of metal ions into the ceramic lattices.
Conclusion
Wear pattern in COM was the same as MOM. Severe metal contamination at the ceramic surface might be affected from frictional heating. While the actual causes and contributing factors of high failure rate in COM were not clearly identified, it is important to take precautions in using COM THA.
