Abstract
Introduction
Patient Specific Instrumentation (PSI) has the potential to allow surgeons to perform procedures more accurately, at lower cost and faster than conventional instrumentation. However, studies using PSI have failed to convincingly demonstrate any of these benefits clinically. The influence of guide design on the accuracy of placement of PSI has received no attention within the literature.
Our experience has suggested that surgeons gain greater benefit from PSI when undertaking procedures they are less familiar with. Lateral unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) is relatively infrequently performed and may be an example of an operation for which PSI would be of benefit. We aimed to investigate the impact on accuracy of PSI with respect to the area of contact, the nature of the contact (smooth or studded guide surfaces) and the effect of increasing the number of contact points in different planes.
Method
A standard anatomy tibial Sawbone was selected for use in the study and a computed tomography scan obtained to facilitate the production of PSI. Nylon PSI guides were printed on the basis of a lateral UKR plan devised by an orthopaedic surgeon. A control PSI guide with similar dimensions to the cutting block of the Oxford Phase 3 UKR tibial guide was produced, contoured to the anterior tibial surface with multiple studs on the tibial contact surface. Variants of this guide were designed to assess the impact of design features on accuracy. These were: a studded guide with a 40% reduction in tibial contact area, a non-studded version of the control guide, the control guide with a shim to provide articular contact, a guide with an extension to allow distal referencing at the ankle and a guide with a distal extension and an articular shim. All guides were designed with an appendage that facilitated direct attachment to a navigation machine (figure 1). 36 volunteers were asked to place each guide on the tibia with reference to a 3D model of the operative plan. The order of placement was varied using a counterbalanced latin square design to limit the impact of the learning effect. The navigation machine recorded deviations from the plan in respect of proximal-distal and medial-lateral translations as well as rotation around all three axes. Statistical analysis was performed on the compound translational and rotational errors for each guide using ANOVA with Bonferroni correction with statistical significance at p<0.05.
Results
Contact points in greater than one plane led to a trend for increasing accuracy and precision of PSI guide placement with respect to rotational alignment, this achieved statistical significance relative to the control guide only with the guide that included articular and distal contact points (figure 2). No significant differences were found with respect to translation. Changes in contact area within the same plane and the use of smooth or studded contact points made no significant difference to accuracy.
Conclusion
PSI guide design significantly impacts on accuracy of placement. PSI guides for UKR should endeavour to include widely separated reference points in different planes to maximise rotational accuracy.
