Abstract
Introduction
Modular hip replacement systems use Morse tapers as an interlocking mechanism to connect ball heads to femoral stems. Even though this interlocking mechanism generally performs successfully for decades, failures due to disassociation of the ball head from the stem are reported in the literature. Therefore, this failure mechanism of a possible loosening is usually evaluated in the course of the development of femoral stems. The disassembly force is a possible parameter to characterize the strength of the interlocking mechanism. Thus, the aim of the current study was to examine the impact of different taper parameters on the disassembly force of ceramic ball heads from titanium stem tapers by finite element studies.
Materials and Methods
A 2D axisymmetric finite element model was developed to simulate the disassembly procedure. First ball head and taper were assembled with a force of 4 kN. Afterwards the system was unloaded to simulate the settlement. Disassembly was simulated displacement controlled until no more adhesion between ball head and taper occurred. Isotropic elastic material behavior was modelled for the ceramic ball head while elastic-plastic material behavior was modelled for the titanium taper. Different angular gaps (0.2°, 0.15°, 0.1°, 0.05°, 0°, −0.05°, −0.1°) and different taper topography parameters regarding groove depth (12, 15 µm), groove distance (210, 310 µm) and plateau width (1, 5, 10, 20 µm) were examined. Frictional contact between ball head and taper was modelled.
Results
The topography of the taper (groove depth, distance and plateau width) within the investigated range had only a small impact on the disassembly force (Fig. 1) while the varying angular gaps had a large effect (Fig. 2). Decreasing disassembly forces were found for decreasing angular gaps. For the negative angular gaps (i.e. male taper angle > female taper angle) the forces increased. The same trends were found for the sliding distance (sliding along the tangential direction in the taper region), deformation of the grooves and contact stresses. Reciprocal behavior was found for the contacting area.
Discussion
Surface topography seems to have only minor influence, while macro-geometry seems to have major impact on the disassembly force. Higher disassembly forces are associated with smaller contacting areas, higher contact stresses, larger deformations of the grooves and larger sliding distances. For a negative angular gap the maximum stresses of the ceramic component were found at the taper mouth. This could be disadvantageous since the wall thickness in this region of the ball heads decreases and critical hoop stresses could increase the risk of a fracture. The decrease in contacting areas due to the extreme angular gaps could promote corrosive effects since a larger taper area is exposed to fluid. Furthermore, the higher contact stresses and groove deformations could increase taper wear. Therefore, a general examination of possible influencing factors and cross effects on the in vivo performance have to be conducted during the development of femoral stems. Future studies will include a wear model and include 3D calculations to examine more realistic loading scenarios.
To view tables/figures, please contact authors directly.
