Abstract
Background
Shoulder impingement syndrome (SIS) is a common debilitating condition, treated across multiple health disciplines including Orthopaedics, Physiotherapy, and Rheumatology. There is little consistency in diagnostic criteria with ‘Shoulder impingement syndrome’ being used for a broad spectrum of complex pathologies. We assessed patterns in diagnostic procedures for SIS across multiple disciplines.
Methods
This is a systematic review of electronic databases MEDLINE, PubMed, The Cochrane Library, Embase, Scopus and CINAHL five years of publications, January 2009 - January 2014. Search terms for SIS included subacromial impingement syndrome, subacromial bursitis. Searches were delimited to articles written in English. The PRISMA guidelines were followed. Two reviewers independently screened all articles, data was then extracted by one reviewer and twenty percent of the extraction was independently assessed by the co-reviewer. Studies included were intervention studies examining individuals diagnosed with SIS and we were interested in the process and method used for the diagnosis.
Results
The search strategy yielded 3339 articles of which 1931 were duplicates. A further 1260 were excluded based on relevance obtained from title/abstract. A total of 148 articles were identified investigating SIS across thirty different journals internationally. Fourteen different health disciplines have investigated twenty-five different surgical and conservative treatments. Studies document their diagnostic approach, reporting on duration of symptoms, medical history, physical examination tests and radiological investigations. Duration of symptoms for inclusion ranged from a minimum of 2 weeks to 18 months where the median duration of symptoms is 3 months observed in 46 percent of the studies. Commonly used physical tests were Neer's test, Hawkins-Kennedy test, Jobe and Yocum, and a further eight tests identified. Neer's test or Hawkins-Kennedy tests were individually used in 72 percent of studies. Thirty of the studies used more than one and up to six physical tests per study to determine the presence of impingement. Radiological investigations were reported in twenty-eight studies, sixteen of these required more than one radiological investigation to confirm the diagnosis of SIS. Comparisons between disciplines identify important differences in diagnostic criteria used by different health professionals.
Conclusions
This study highlights the variety of diagnostic methods which are currently used between health disciplines and will be a useful comparative tool for clinicians. Diagnostic transparency is pertinent for shoulder impingement syndrome to ensure all disciplines are treating the same pathology and importantly to contribute to our understanding of the common pathology.
