Abstract
Utilising the (ACS-NSQIP) database, we aimed to evaluate the impact of resident level of training on surgical outcome following (TKA) and to compare the US and Canadian health care training system in regards to 30 days postoperative complications and readmission rates.
Using the (CPT) codes we selected from the 2011 and 2012 NSQIP database elective primary TKA with the resident surgeon involved. Of these, all cases with a primary diagnosis code of infection, fracture, mechanical complication, or malignancy and all cases with incomplete or incongruous demographic information were excluded. We also eliminated all the cases with the Attending not present. A total of 2513 cases were included in the study. The cases were stratified into three groups according to the postgraduate level of training {PGY 1 to 3 (junior resident), PGY 4 to 5 (senior resident), and fellow}. Univariate analysis of all patient demographics, comorbidities, intra and postoperative variables, length of surgery, hospital stay and 30 days readmission rates were conducted in order to identify differences between the groups. A standard student's t test was used for continuous variables while the ChiSquared was used for categorical variables. Multivariable logistic regression models were created to assess the independent effect of the resident level of training on the 30 days major complication and re-admission rates while controlling for all other variables.
We identified, 854 (34%) TKAs with junior residents, 1013 (40%) TKAs with senior residents and 646 (26%) TKAs with fellows' participation. Junior residents had a significant (p<0.0001) longer operative time (107±36 minutes) compared with senior residents and fellows. Length of hospital stay was longer in the fellow group probably because of their involvement in more complicated cases. Additionally, an increased number of blood transfusion was observed for the cases performed with involvement of senior residents when compared with the other two groups. However, no significant difference in complications was observed across training levels. When comparing US (2074 TKAs) versus Canada (423 TKAs) cases, we found that fellow contribution to TKA surgeries is higher in Canada. The occurrence of pulmonary embolism and pneumonia was three times higher in Canada cases, while blood transfusion was more frequent in US. Increased operative time, ASA class, age, diabetes, percutaneous cardiac intervention, and steroid use were all independent risk factors for complications following primary TKA. However, no significant difference was observed between the two groups with regards to major complications suggesting no difference between Canadian and American training system in regards to post operative complication.
Our results support previous study study indicating that involvement of residents did not affect the surgical outcome within 30 days when compared to cases with no resident involvement. Our study suggests that resident level does not independently increase the risk of short term complications and support continuing involvement of junior trainees in TKA.
