Abstract
Introduction
According to proposal of Noble, the femoral bone marrow cavity form of patients who underwent Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) can be classified under 3 categories; those are Stovepipe, Normal and Champagne-fluted. We developed typical sodium chloride femoral model was created by 3D prototyping technique. The purpose was to identify the relationship of pressure zone of the surrounding areas between femoral bone marrow cavity form and hip stem.
Materials and Method
As opponent clarified stem design concept Zweymüller type model was used. According to CT data with the patients who underwent THA, the sodium chloride femoral model was custom-made and selected as the representative model based on Noble's 3 categories. Eight models of each category were used to performed mechanical test.
Result
In mechanics test, the result of comparison between the contact pressure zones of zone 1–7, significant differences of contact pressure zones were identified between the Stovepipe group and Normal group in zone 3, 4 and 5. In zone 3 and 5, such significant differences were also identified between Champagne-fluted group and Normal group. In Stovepipe group, a significant difference of the contact pressure zone was observed at the proximal and distal. In Champagne-fluted group and the Normal group, a significant difference was observed in the contact pressure in distal femur (3, 4, 5 Zone) and (Zone1, 2, 6, 7) proximal femur.
Discussion
Although in most studies Sawbone® is used for femoral models, the focus of this research is of those who possess a characteristic femur with marrow cavity form. Therefore, sodium chloride bone model was used instead. In comparison in terms of applicability between sodium chloride bone model and regular model, the failure of all 24 joints of sodium chloride bone model were unconfirmed in mechanics test. Moreover, the possibility that its performance in mechanics test is equivalent to Sawbone®is considered.
The design concept for Zweymüller type achieves the ability to load distribute within a wide range of cortical bone across the middle position to distal femur. It's determined by the concept that a wide range of contact pressure was admitted at middle position and distal femur in the Champagne-fluted group and the Normal group. On the other hand, the contact pressure zone of Stovepipe was not able to meet the expected level at distal femur. The method of this research is control its stress condition within the stem design. By this point, it is considered possible that the stability of various stem design was able to be forecasted and the assessment of stableness was positive.
Conclusion
On the basis of Noble's categories, 3 types of bone models were created by 3D prototyping technique, and pressure distribution measurement were performed. The result from the pressure distribution indicated that even in Zweymüller stem had anxiety of securing force in Champagne-fluted type and Stovepipe type canal. We believe the method of in vivo study can develop to assess the stability of implant preoperatively.
