Abstract
Open fractures of the long bones of the limbs are associated with an increased risk of osteomyelitis and few studies investigate this complication in circular frames. We reviewed the incidence of and contributory factors toward infection-related outcomes in Grade 3 open fractures, managed with a circular frame, at a single centre.
We performed a retrospective study of consecutive adult patients presenting with a Grade 3 open fracture, who required a circular frame for definitive skeletal fixation from 2005 to 2014. Patient case notes, microbiology results and radiological studies were reviewed for demographic details and surgical management. Infection-related outcomes were classified as ‘possible’ and ‘definitive’, based on clinical findings, microbiology and imaging features at follow-up at 6 and 12 months.
74 patients were identified with an average age of 43 years. There were 70 unilateral and 4 bilateral limb injuries. Most treated limbs had a tibial fracture (97%). There were 24 Gustillo-Anderson grade 3A, 37 grade 3B, 4 grade 3C and 9 not sub-classified. 33% of patients were debrided on the day of injury. Average time to circular frame installation was 14 days. 27 Ilizarov, 44 Taylor spatial and 3 other circular frames were used. A variety of plastic surgery reconstruction was used to provide wound coverage: skin grafts, local and free flaps. Circular frames were in place for 259 days on average. 10 patients (1 bilateral limb fracture) still have their frames in-situ. Additional bone grafting to the fracture site was carried out in 13 patients and 15 limbs (1 patient had 2 episodes of bone grafting to the same limb). 8 limbs in 8 patients were excluded from infection-related outcome analysis: 4 patients lost to follow-up, 2 patients who went on to below knee amputation and 2 patients had <6 months’ follow-up. 13 patients (14 limbs) had only 6 months’ follow-up and 53 patients (56 limbs) had 12 months’ follow-up. There were 5 patients (5 limbs) with ‘possible’ infection (7%): 1 screw infection and 4 soft tissue infections. 1 patient (1 limb) had a tissue-confirmed ‘definitive’ infected non-union (1.4%).
Patients managed with circular frames typically have complex fracture configurations less amenable to other methods of definitive fixation. Our patient cohort has a limb salvage rate (97%) and a soft tissue infection rate (‘possible’ infection) comparable to other reported series. We report a low rate of osteomyelitis (‘definitive’ infection) in consecutive patients managed using our protocol.
